Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To WFH while on holiday abroad so I don’t use up holiday entitlement?

261 replies

RaspberryFarfait · 08/05/2022 12:43

We have already have a big holiday booked this year and DH also wants to spend a month in his home country with his parents during the summer holidays.

He doesn’t WFH, so will use all holiday entitlement, but I do. Colleague is also on leave for some of that time so I wouldn’t normally be able to be off as need to cover.

WIBU to not book holiday, travel over there and work as normal, without telling work. I only work part time and it’s certainly doable.

Only problem is will I be able to log in remotely from abroad? Has anyone done this?

Don’t want to ask work yet as they’ll cotton on!

OP posts:
Festivecheer26 · 09/05/2022 22:22

@Mfsf there were some temporary exemptions at the start of covid to prevent people stuck overseas or companies with employees who couldn’t get back to their home countries because of “public health measures” triggering tax obligations (both income tax and corporation tax) in those overseas jurisdictions. These exemptions wouldn’t apply to the OP’s situation, travel is possible again so no one is genuinely stuck due to covid.

Mfsf · 09/05/2022 22:10

Oblomov22 · 09/05/2022 05:07

I still don't understand how anything mentioned is at all relevant.

The UK has many tax treaty's with USA (largely complicated), Singapore, India, Australia, Pakistan etc.
Eg
"Claiming Double Taxation Relief for companies and other concerns".

I simply don't see how OP's situation is relevant to @Festivecheer26 's statement : "company may suffer tax consequences under the relevant tax treaty". What tax consequences might OP's company suffer? For her 1 month?

I still don't see how any of the OP's situation is at all relevant.
How would OP's situation affect corporation tax? The answer is, it wouldn't.

A company may need tax advice if a number of their employees are travelling or working abroad for a period of time.

It doesn't apply for most normal people going for a weeks holiday to Benidorm/Malaga and needing to respond to an email.

Spanish

The Spanish Tax treaty is in respect of residency. Living in the UK or Spain for "183 days per year".
Which is exactly what I claimed right at the start. I asked anyone to link anything that had more info than the HMRC re working abroad, or residency. It needs to be for a large proportion of the tax year.
OP's 1 month does NOT count.
Even @Howmuchwood said in her second point : "1 month often fine".

So none of anything mentioned applies.

Clearly I've over invested in this thread. But I hate it, it gets my goat, when people come on sprouting false and factually incorrect technical and legal terms.

Many posters posted about tax implications. But it's nonsense. It doesn't apply to OP's situation.

Why can't I do this boss? Um, um you can't. Why? I don't know. Er maybe there are ...,. Tax implications.....
(Er. No. There aren't. They don't apply)

spot on . My office was scattered all over the world during the covid lockdown , all we got was a form from HR asking us to confirm how long we spend abroad and where . We all knew about the tax implications anyway so did not came as a shock to anyone to be questioned about it .
I think as always people like to create a storm in a glass of water .

Mfsf · 09/05/2022 22:01

IcedPurple · 09/05/2022 21:11

You don't 'see an issue' with 'swindling' your employers for months?

And working remotely doesn't necessarily mean you can 'work anywhere'. Many employers will insist you be based in the UK, for reasons explained above.

It was actually supposed to say spending nit swindling lol but just too say my employee doesn’t care , I work from home anyway over 500 miles away from my office .
we had people working from all over the world during Covid , including one of the partners for over 4 months in Italy and another in India .
as long as work is ok with it why not

Hmm1234 · 09/05/2022 21:40

It depends if you need the internet or company can track IP addresses it could be a security breach and you’ll be in trouble. The only reason why I wouldn’t take the work computer on holiday otherwise go for it but be sure not to let colleagues know about your fab holiday!

MdNdD · 09/05/2022 21:12

Some companies have a policy on this, for different reasons. Just ask HR. My company allows it for something like four weeks, for tax reasons.

IcedPurple · 09/05/2022 21:11

Mfsf · 09/05/2022 20:11

I can log in from anywhere and I have done this myself . I don’t see a issue , just make sure you have reliable internet access .
I used to spend over a month with my parents abroad. Even though I had to work the having a pool and the beachfront made it so much easier .In fact just discussing jobs with DP we came to the conclusion he will be trying to find a job that is remote , as we have family in 2 different countries and swindling a few months abroad at a time might work for us really well . As I work remotely I can work anywhere

You don't 'see an issue' with 'swindling' your employers for months?

And working remotely doesn't necessarily mean you can 'work anywhere'. Many employers will insist you be based in the UK, for reasons explained above.

SnozPoz · 09/05/2022 21:08

Your company might have issues with this from a tax point of view, and you almost certainly will have problems from an IT point of view... a firewall will very likely stop you from logging in from a "strange" location. You're going to have to be open and honest about it

HRsam33 · 09/05/2022 20:41

I put YABU but only because you said you wouldn’t tell your work.

I guess it depends what company you work for, but I would always try to accommodate an employee’s request especially if it were short term. What I wouldn’t appreciate is an employee lying to us / keeping something from us.

Depending on your role, there could be security risks if you are on unsecured / public wifi networks too.

Ws have a number of employees who are hoping to travel to see family in other countries and they have all been honest with us and we've worked out individual arrangements, e.g. 4 weeks away, 2 weeks working, 2 weeks holiday.

So my advice is be honest with your employer.

Hutchy16 · 09/05/2022 20:38

As long as work are ok with it I don’t see the problem. At the end of the day you aren’t holidaying, you are staying with family. If your family lived in London and you were in the north it wouldn’t be an issue to work from theirs for a month, so why would it if you were abroad

joles12 · 09/05/2022 20:32

You absolutely must discuss with your business- this would be totally against the policy of my last place of work as it risks creating tax liabilities for the business (and you) in the foreign country . All internet traffic can be tracked and followed so it could be a real issue

Womencanlift · 09/05/2022 20:14

Spaceshiphaslanded · 09/05/2022 19:24

It’s interesting isn’t it. Ours has been fine pre covid - I mean usually when they need me (!) to dial into a call or check through something urgently. Now everyone is more
or less WFH they’ve said we cannot work abroad due to tax purposes. I suspect it’s more to stop us working on holiday/lack of trust. They’ve said “tax purposes”.

Ours, well my old work as I have left now, was the same pre covid. From what I know it is less of a trust thing and more that they turned a blind eye to it when the numbers of people working short term abroad were low and it was sporadic.

But suddenly when lockdown hit, vast numbers either got stuck abroad or flew to their home country or holiday home at the end of Feb/early March as they could see what was coming.

The longer lockdown went on that’s when they went oh shit we may be liable for tax, for the reasons explained above. The people I knew that got disciplined for working abroad were contacted in September/October time to formally discuss their working location (even though everyone had known for months where they were)

Mfsf · 09/05/2022 20:11

I can log in from anywhere and I have done this myself . I don’t see a issue , just make sure you have reliable internet access .
I used to spend over a month with my parents abroad. Even though I had to work the having a pool and the beachfront made it so much easier .In fact just discussing jobs with DP we came to the conclusion he will be trying to find a job that is remote , as we have family in 2 different countries and swindling a few months abroad at a time might work for us really well . As I work remotely I can work anywhere

cstx89 · 09/05/2022 19:30

Speak to your work. If anything hapoened to their laptop etc, it could be a sackable case (depending on info etc).
If you are caught it is a disciplinary case.

Spaceshiphaslanded · 09/05/2022 19:24

It’s interesting isn’t it. Ours has been fine pre covid - I mean usually when they need me (!) to dial into a call or check through something urgently. Now everyone is more
or less WFH they’ve said we cannot work abroad due to tax purposes. I suspect it’s more to stop us working on holiday/lack of trust. They’ve said “tax purposes”.

saltedcaramelanything · 09/05/2022 18:56

Loads of people at my company have done this. Ranging from 2wks to 6mo+

Would definitely check with your employer, but it's definitely not out of the question

Womencanlift · 09/05/2022 18:39

Festivecheer26 · 09/05/2022 09:05

@Oblomov22

As I have already said, the employing company might have to file a corporation tax return and pay corporation tax in the jurisdiction the OP travels to. These are the potential corporation tax consequences of an employee of a UK tax resident company working from another jurisdiction.

As a chartered tax advisor of 15 years specialising in corporate tax I can tell you that actually your statement “How would OP's situation affect corporation tax? The answer is, it wouldn't.” is factually incorrect. As @Howmuchwood says, there isn’t enough information in the OP to conclude one way or the other. As I said in my original post, the risk of a single trip is low but there can be circumstances in which this is enough to mean the company the employee works for has to file a tax return overseas. I’ve seen this in practice so can assure you that it does happen.

I’m not trying to scaremonger or intimidate anyone, the only reason I posted was because you started rebuffing the mention of tax implications so strongly and you aren’t correct. Maybe you mean that there won’t be any tax implications in a situation like OP’s because local tax authorities will have no way of finding out?

The OP came on to ask essentially whether she needed to ask her boss before working remotely overseas and the short answer is yes. Part of the explanation for this answer is that her employer will need to consider any potential corporation tax risks of her proposed arrangement - there may well not be any, but they need to work through the analysis to conclude.

In defence of the people who have replied with “there might be tax implications” - this is what they’ll understand from their own employers. Lots of employers had to address the issue of employees requesting to work abroad / being found to be logging on from other jurisdictions during covid and so had to either remind their staff of their employment contract terms or communicate new policies around remote working and did so in layman’s terms rather than issuing detailed tax technical arguments explaining why. These people aren’t spouting “nonsense” as you say, they are sharing their experiences.

I’d be interested to know why you think so resolutely that there are absolutely no potential tax implications of a situation like OP’s?

@RaspberryFarfait I’m sorry but without seeing the wording I’m not sure how it would apply. Is it suggesting that any amounts earned over a certain threshold would mean you have to pay some income tax?

Excellent post. And you are right I have no clue what the “tax implications” are I just know that people got disciplined during lockdown for working abroad without permission and all the comms around this topic stated that as being the reason

PurassicJark · 09/05/2022 18:16

RaspberryFarfait · 08/05/2022 18:10

Actually just checked and you need to be physically present for 6 months to be liable for income tax in the country I’m going to.

We also use a VPN to log in remotely already.

As we are going by car, I can even take my monitors with me, roof rack for clothes!

Will lay it out to boss tomorrow.

If you use a vpn to login remotely, it's probably a fairly security conscious company, so they'll likely have other measures in place that will notice instantly that you're logging in from another country, even when you use the companies vpn. It does for ours. We then ask a team if they gave permission for that. If they didn't, we disable the account instantly and remove vpn access. So you'd likely lose access if you're breaching policy and be in major trouble, not just with your boss. As you've only been there a short time and need money to live I assume, I wouldn't chance it as you may end up fired.

Definitely ask your boss. It's much safer. You might be allowed, or can get permission to do it, you never know. Worth a shot to have a holiday abroad.

Debbacat6 · 09/05/2022 18:07

You must tell them
There could be tax implications and there will be security ones
Its highly unlikely your part time job will have clearance to use international web ways or numbers.
So you must ask
And if they say No then accept that.

glitterfairy88 · 09/05/2022 18:05

I work for the NHS and we were told working abroad was a definite no. They couldn't vouch for the security of our systems and given that we access a lot of confidential information it was a non-starter.

Pootle40 · 09/05/2022 10:48

Festivecheer26 · 09/05/2022 09:05

@Oblomov22

As I have already said, the employing company might have to file a corporation tax return and pay corporation tax in the jurisdiction the OP travels to. These are the potential corporation tax consequences of an employee of a UK tax resident company working from another jurisdiction.

As a chartered tax advisor of 15 years specialising in corporate tax I can tell you that actually your statement “How would OP's situation affect corporation tax? The answer is, it wouldn't.” is factually incorrect. As @Howmuchwood says, there isn’t enough information in the OP to conclude one way or the other. As I said in my original post, the risk of a single trip is low but there can be circumstances in which this is enough to mean the company the employee works for has to file a tax return overseas. I’ve seen this in practice so can assure you that it does happen.

I’m not trying to scaremonger or intimidate anyone, the only reason I posted was because you started rebuffing the mention of tax implications so strongly and you aren’t correct. Maybe you mean that there won’t be any tax implications in a situation like OP’s because local tax authorities will have no way of finding out?

The OP came on to ask essentially whether she needed to ask her boss before working remotely overseas and the short answer is yes. Part of the explanation for this answer is that her employer will need to consider any potential corporation tax risks of her proposed arrangement - there may well not be any, but they need to work through the analysis to conclude.

In defence of the people who have replied with “there might be tax implications” - this is what they’ll understand from their own employers. Lots of employers had to address the issue of employees requesting to work abroad / being found to be logging on from other jurisdictions during covid and so had to either remind their staff of their employment contract terms or communicate new policies around remote working and did so in layman’s terms rather than issuing detailed tax technical arguments explaining why. These people aren’t spouting “nonsense” as you say, they are sharing their experiences.

I’d be interested to know why you think so resolutely that there are absolutely no potential tax implications of a situation like OP’s?

@RaspberryFarfait I’m sorry but without seeing the wording I’m not sure how it would apply. Is it suggesting that any amounts earned over a certain threshold would mean you have to pay some income tax?

100% this.

applecrumbler · 09/05/2022 10:37

Someone on my team tried this recently, when I had said she couldn't do it and should take holiday. I got a call from IT to ask why she was in [country] and using a vpn to conceal her location!! If your employer has sophisticated IT security in place and there is a requirement to let them know, you likely won't get away with it. We had to fire her unfortunately as it was a significant breach of policy, and more so trust.

notimagain · 09/05/2022 09:33

I know this keeps drifting back to the UK employers position and them needing to give permission seems to be regarded as the be all and end all....

May be yet another nudge is required about the other major issue that's still in play here - the seemingly oft ignored "right to work"....

Most folks carry laptops around the world these days and officials generally don't raise eyebrows at those being carried. However there was a comment some time ago upthread about putting monitors in the car, luggage on the roof....If that is even close to what is being planned then if Border/customs get involved at any point (either cross channel or at A N other border) the conversation could get very interesting, especially if the OP is supposedly travelling for leisure purposes but carrying an IT suite in the car.....

Datgal · 09/05/2022 09:28

My partner works in cyber. You'd definitely need to check. I think a lot of employers are probably saying remote working overseas is fine, without fully knowing the rules. Data protection and GDPR is a big one. If you are dealing with people's personal data, there are legitimate security risks, pinging data between countries. You just can't risk it. I'm amazed at how many people (and I'd be surprised if NHS and civil servants are actually allowed if they really looked into it) are allowed to do this. Tax implications aside!

Irishfarmer · 09/05/2022 09:23

I would speak to your employer before doing it. Mine wouldn't mind, if possible. She plans on doing it at some point, but we do have an office in the country she wants to go to.

I really like my job though so wouldn't risk loosing it. They will hopefully be able to accommodate you. It sounds like it would be great! My job time/ days would really lend itself to something like that too.

Schulte · 09/05/2022 09:07

OP, don’t know where you’re going but DH’s company doesn’t allow working from abroad anymore since Brexit. Something to do with taxes, legal stuff. They can see where you’re logging in from and you may be blocked from accessing files etc. Talk to your employer but they may well say no!

Swipe left for the next trending thread