Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you exercise....please can you answer my questions :-)

107 replies

fortysomething8 · 08/05/2022 10:05

Hello,

I'm just wondering the following.....

  1. If you exercise regularly - how often? How many calories do you aim to burn over how long?
  1. If you don't use calories as a way of keeping track, what do you do?
  1. For those who don't go to the gym - how do you exercises? Running? Exercise bike etc?
  1. Do you use any aids that have really helped you with weight loss/toning up? I was thinking of getting a waist trainer but not sure if it's a waste of money
  1. How many calories do you aim to eat a day?

Thank you!

OP posts:
fortysomething8 · 08/05/2022 13:40

ExMachinaDeus · 08/05/2022 12:31

I've bought on exercise bike which I do 40 mins a day on, try push myself a little more each time.

just pedalling for 40 minutes won’t necessarily do much beyond overall mild improvement of your aerobic capacity. you need to do something that will put a certain amount of stress on your body. If you just pedal at the same rate you won’t get any significant training effect.

Interval training can really change this. That’s what Spin classes are- intervals of high intensity interspersed with intervals of active recovery.

See if you can find some routines on YouTube. You may find that a 20-30 minute HIIT session is far more effective than just pedalling without much point for 40 minutes.

Thank you! I will defo look that up!

OP posts:
BogRollBOGOF · 08/05/2022 13:19

If you exercise regularly - how often? How many calories do you aim to burn over how long?
I do some kind of exercise most days. Some "rest days" are walking or gentle exercise like yoga or just generally being active.
I don't "aim" to burn calories, but as a short woman, regular exercise helps me to maintain a healthy weight on a relatively relaxed diet

If you don't use calories as a way of keeping track, what do you do?
I record data from my Garmin watch into an exercise log (notebook/ bullet journal) this helps me check that training is balanced, seasonal patterns, training plans.
For runs I train by time/ distance. Swimming by time. Other is just recorded. I know I'm progressing at circuits if I move up a weight.
Calories are pretty meaningless for assessing exercise benefits. One hour of running/ weights/ yoga/ swimming have different benefits.

For those who don't go to the gym - how do you exercises? Running? Exercise bike etc?
I run (and tend to have a race on the horizon at any point). Running is easily measurable. I like outdoor and group exercise. Both is even better. I do some short videos at home but struggle with longer workouts in that setting.

Do you use any aids that have really helped you with weight loss/toning up? I was thinking of getting a waist trainer but not sure if it's a waste of money
Not aids in that sense.
I have fitness equipment in varying states of use. If nothing else it reminds me not to join a gym 😂
I use my Garmin watch to record sport/ general activity.
I use apps such as C25k, strava, to record/ motivate/ share. Online discussion.
If actively monitoring my diet I use MFP

How many calories do you aim to eat a day?
If I'm monitoring my diet, I'll bring it down to 1600 as it's enough to fuel an active lifestyle. If I'm being active I typically burn 1900 average. I sometimes 5:2.
Most of the time I don't pay much attention.

*

I'd say from the questions that OP's focus on exercise is a bit the wrong-way-round and highly likely to fail.
I could say that spin and running marathons are great ways to burn calories and I wouldn't be wrong, but for most people it's not sustainable.

Think about what you find practical and what you enjoy. That will work longer term because you can and will want to do it.

For most people unless they put a lot of time and training into exercise it's pretty limited in the additional calorie burning potential. If your body burned 2000 on a regular day, most of that would be burned by generally existing. If you spent an hour blitzing a 10k run, you could burn 600 extra calories... BUT you can't do that every day, or even much more than once a week if that.

Better to focus on the other benefits of exercise. General fitness/ health, how you feel, healthier body shape, stronger bones/ joints, time outside in fresh air/ vitamin D, social time, stress relief...

Don't be dominated by scales either. Muscle is more dense and can hold water retention. Using a mix of methods including a tape meaure and photos is better for seeing progress.

OnoNotagain · 08/05/2022 13:18

I walk the dog twice daily- brisk walking - across country (local woods and fields) for a total of around 2 hours. I also ride my horse 4-5 times per week, look after a biggish garden and all the usual domestic stuff.

No aims regarding calories and don't track or count them - it's far too time consuming to add them up, or calculate how many calories on a slice of bread or whatever...... I eat sensibly and well - home cooked meals/fresh veg etc as far as possible. No deserts or sugary stuff, rarely fry anything, so cook in a calorie friendly way. Limited wine - weekends only.

No fitness aids, unless you count a dog/horse/garden. Never go to a gym. Hubby bought me a Fitbit ... it's gathering dust in drawer somewhere.

My clothes keep track for me ... the day my size 10 skinny jeans are too tight, I cut down.

OneTC · 08/05/2022 13:05
  1. 3 or 4 times a week for between 2 and 4 hours a time. No counted calorie goals.
  1. I track exercise by my performance. I need to maintain my weight though.
  1. Bouldering, cycling.
  1. No.
  1. I don't do a daily total. On days when I exercise I eat what I want and on days when i rest I tend to have less of an appetite
HorribleHerstory · 08/05/2022 12:54

If you exercise regularly - how often? How many calories do you aim to burn over how long?

I exercise on purpose at least four times a week I’d say. As in, head out with the purpose of exercise. I don’t know how many calories I burn or how long I exercise for. I exercise because I am a fucker to live with if I don’t.

If you don't use calories as a way of keeping track, what do you do?

I don’t keep track particularly. I mean I have an idea of how far I run or hike or how far I swim or how long I played sport for or how long the class was. I like to get faster when running, get places when hiking and I like to get better when playing sport.

For those who don't go to the gym - how do you exercises? Running? Exercise bike etc?

Hiking. Usually up and down hills and I like to hike at least once a week (20-30km) Running, because it’s faster to get the distances I need on a weekday. Swimming occasionally and playing tennis a couple of times a month (more variable as needs a partner)

Do you use any aids that have really helped you with weight loss/toning up? I was thinking of getting a waist trainer but not sure if it's a waste of money

I don’t have any aids and I don’t know how much I weigh.

How many calories do you aim to eat a day?

I don’t know how many calories I eat or how many I should eat, I don’t know or care how much I weigh.

Redcrayons · 08/05/2022 12:47

If you exercise regularly - how often? How many calories do you aim to burn over how long?
i run 3 or 4 times a week. Try to do yoga at least twice a week and have just started strength training.

I dont monitor calories burned.

If you don't use calories as a way of keeping track, what do you do?
I use Strava for all. Running goals are based on a weekly target for miles per week. Yoga and strength I don’t have goals for but I probably should.

For those who don't go to the gym - how do you exercises? Running? Exercise bike etc?
Running. Yoga and strength are at home via YouTube videos. Like you I just never got round to going to the gym.

Do you use any aids that have really helped you with weight loss/toning up? I was thinking of getting a waist trainer but not sure if it's a waste of money
No, log calories in MFP.

How many calories do you aim to eat a day?
1700 is my lose target on MFP. I only put on weight when I fall off the MFP wagon.

my best tip is not to eat your exercise calories back. Abs are built in the kitchen, as the saying goes.

Zilla1 · 08/05/2022 12:36

At the risk of sounding complacent, I wouldn't be initially trying to push and push, rather than at the start just trying to embed exercise into your routine and not get injured or dispirited. You are trying to create sustainable habits for a lifetime. Have seen too many people go from enthusiasm to quitting rather than focusing on healthy eating and sustainable exercise. I know people like early results. Not sure about rice case as a snack or treat unless you truly prefer them. Fruit and nuts or something you enjoy eating.

Good luck.

gwenneh · 08/05/2022 12:34

I exercise 2-3 days per week. More if I’m lucky. It’s important to set actual achievable goals when it comes to habits so that was what I decided was a baseline minimum I could always meet. I ride horses. I don’t measure calorie burn, and that’s partially because I enjoy doing it so calories aren’t important AND because all fitness trackers overestimate calorie burn. The low end of that is they overestimate by about 30% and the high end is as much as 90%.

I don’t count anything. I just get out and do an active thing that I enjoy. That’s it.

As far as aids go, high intensity interval training and properly guided free weight sessions were very very beneficial.

Waist trainers have their place, but they’re not an aid to toning or weight loss. They can help in certain situations when paired with physio for specific conditions. You can certainly injure yourself with one, as a previous poster pointed out you will not correctly strengthen muscle groups while wearing one.

I stopped monitoring calories years ago. I eat only when I’m hungry, and only in portions that satisfy me. I’m not afraid to say no, to go out for a meal and leave things on the plate, or to have exactly what I want when I am really hungry.
It was hard work to heal a fractured relationship with food but the minute I did the weight dropped off and I now weigh the same as I did at 18 (am in my 40’s). When I got serious about losing weight I started with food. It’s easier to handle than finding time to exercise, the day already has time in it for eating so the focus on changing how I ate was much more crucial.

ExMachinaDeus · 08/05/2022 12:31

I've bought on exercise bike which I do 40 mins a day on, try push myself a little more each time.

just pedalling for 40 minutes won’t necessarily do much beyond overall mild improvement of your aerobic capacity. you need to do something that will put a certain amount of stress on your body. If you just pedal at the same rate you won’t get any significant training effect.

Interval training can really change this. That’s what Spin classes are- intervals of high intensity interspersed with intervals of active recovery.

See if you can find some routines on YouTube. You may find that a 20-30 minute HIIT session is far more effective than just pedalling without much point for 40 minutes.

MintyCedricRidesAgain · 08/05/2022 12:23

I started seeing a wellbeing advisor at the beginning of the year so very much a work in progress but...

Currently aiming for 3 x 30 minutes a week, ultimately working up to 5 x 30 mins or equivalent. Will likely be fewer, longer sessions.

I don't really worry about how many calories I'm burning. I've not looked after myself well in the past or done any regular exercise so anything I do is a bonus.

Lily Sabri videos on YouTube. She's great...gorgeous but very down to earth, great music and lots of options. I love that each exercise has a countdown timer, she allows 30 seconds between moves so you're not rushing to get the hang of it and doing it wrong. I find with her videos that just as I'm getting bored or struggling she moves onto something else or winds it up which is brilliant for me. Also incorporates demonstrations of simpler moves for beginners/the less fit. DD started with her videos last year and now if a fully fledged gym bunny so I use her old yoga mat, resistance bands and light weights.

I found the body analysis scales my advisor uses brilliant. They calculate my basal metabolic rate so my calorie allowance for the day is 1750 based on that. I only weight with her once a month and it's great to be able to see the invisible progress and really keeps me motivated, eg...last weigh in I had only lost 1kg overall weight, but the stats showed I'd converted 4kg of fat to muscle, improved my hydration and dropped a point on the visceral fat scale.

I will probably invest in a pair of similar scales next month for home use as I only have one more session.

Zilla1 · 08/05/2022 12:04

Have just seen your recent post and parts of that seems more sensible. Eat healthy food and not too much. Exercise as much as you can. Don't expect quick results but the eventual results will be sustainable as you are effectively training your lifestyle and body compared with what for some people may be decades of less good dietary habits. Good luck.

Zilla1 · 08/05/2022 12:01

IME, most people who exercise don't count calories. What do you think will be achieved by counting calories?

fortysomething8 · 08/05/2022 11:56

Thank you for all these fab replies!

I've started to really look after myself, I'm the biggest I've ever been due to some medication I'm taking and the weight is proving hard to shift!

Lesson learnt on the calories, I do find that very stressful anyway so I won't be so strict on myself!

Id love to join a gym but being a single mum of 3, working etc iota just not possible. I joined one in January thinking I could fit it in somehow but it's just not possible so I'm doing all my exercise from home.

I've bought on exercise bike which I do 40 mins a day on, try push myself a little more each time. I watch my steps too.

I've cut out all the crap on eating.

It varies but I eat a lot of:

I have porridge for breakfast with raspberries
Scrambled eggs on 1 thin with plum tomatoes and rocket or tuna salad.
For tea I have salad or chicken and veg.
3x cups of tea a day
2x Kallo rice cakes and maybe one of those 7cal jelly pots.

Drinking lots of water

My weight is getting me down so I'm just really trying but I need to remember I've had 3 kids! I'm not 18 anymore and the weight won't just fall off me like it has done in the past.

Thanks so much Mumsnetters!

OP posts:
Soffit · 08/05/2022 11:55

It would be a wonderful thing if the notion of exercising to lose weight was shelved by the mainstream and the focus was put entirely upon the mental health/strength/flexibility benefits. Unfortunately, there are additive ridden fake foods to sell and now menus showing the calories for every dish. This will reinforce unhealthy thinking and discourage others from trying altogether.

ExMachinaDeus · 08/05/2022 11:42

You can’t out-train a bad diet.

You need to be active every day and find ways of putting sustainable exercise into your daily routine. For example, ditch the car and walk everywhere. Aim for over 15,000 steps a day (the figure of 10,000 is a minimum not ambitious).

I have no idea what a “waist trainer” is but it sounds like a gimmick.

You also need to be aware that exercise isn’t the magic melting away of calories. I train really hard in 3 sessions per week of a mix of heavy weight lifting and HIIT, then do something like a pump class for active recovery. The heavy sessions probably only burn around 500 calories even though I’m left completely dead!

UseOfWeapons · 08/05/2022 11:31

I exercise daily, 3-4 times a week intensively, gym for weight training, running walking, cycling, stretching and toning exercises every night. No idea about how many calories burned, as don’t keep track. I don’t count calories either. The only equipment I use at home are resistance bands.

HesterShaw1 · 08/05/2022 11:09

I play badminton for 4-6 hours a week because it's fun and I enjoy the company. I've got no idea how many calories it burns to be honest, and no idea how many I eat. A lot of leisure time is spent going for walks and other active things, and have an active job. I'm lucky in that I've always been fit and slim, which is why I'm a bit laissez faire. However I do think that the primary aim of exercise is that you should enjoy it, otherwise you won't want to do it and won't get the other benefits.

To keep I just keep a mental note of the kind of things I'm eating and adjust as I go along. Everything in moderation etc. I do try and eat healthily though, and don't drink much.

Mirrorball2022 · 08/05/2022 11:02

Hi
I’m a size 12. I could be a bit lighter. But I don’t exercise for weight loss. It’s for health and my anxiety/insomnia too.

I don’t exercise to lose calories and fitness watches etc aren’t always accurate.

Exercise I do depends on my shifts I work full time on 3/4 days

12/13 hour days on a ward. It’s already active and covers a lot of steps. On a good week I do 2x30 min spin classes, 2/3 yoga practice and some form of strength: currently resistance bands or kettle bells. We also as a couple walk at least once at a weekend for ‘minimum 3 or usually much more miles We have a couple of evening
walks too on days off.
My watch tells me I burn calories but I don’t rely on them.

I don’t count calories, I’m aware of average calories in foods I eat. I’d say I eat under 1800 most days bar ones I go out for food or get a takeaway. I don’t cut out food groups or foods I enjoy. I do value nutrition and macros. Lots of colour in my diet and protein too.

Ive no idea about waist trainers but if you carry excess weight there surely they won’t work?

SquirrelFan · 08/05/2022 11:00

2x Chloe Tings a week
1x yoga session
1x live zoom session with near-personal trainer (very small class)
5x 30 mins walking (to work & back)
2x 1hr walking (on weekends)
Don't count calories spent or eaten. Too depressing when you realise that a thirty-minute walk "earns" you a jaffa cake!

  1. Samsung watch with movement goals.
  2. As above.
  3. Smallish home weights - also have a mini trampoline that I occasionally use.
  4. Don't monitor calories in-just trying to eat plenty of fruits and vegetables.

I think it depends on your goals what you do - I'm trying to stay healthy and maintain bone strength (50+). No marathon or bikini competitions!

OrangeBall · 08/05/2022 10:52

And I don't count my calories but I am mindful of what I'm eating if that makes sense

HairyBum · 08/05/2022 10:51

Fog = dog 🐶

OrangeBall · 08/05/2022 10:51

I hate exercise and work full time out the house (with a commute) so don't have a lot of time during the week at all

Having said that, I walk from the train station rather than getting the tube/bus and by doing that I speed walk 5km a day (2.5km each way) with my backpack on (which isn't light).

I try and go to gym once a week and do a run on the weekend (5-7km normally). I also walk the dog on weekends (about 5km at a time).

I have an Apple Watch so keep an eye on it via that. I thought I wouldn't use it but I must admit I enjoy seeing the stats/impact on my health etc.

HairyBum · 08/05/2022 10:51

I always walk 10k steps a day minimum with my fog. Sometimes I slow jog them instead

In addition I do one other activity daily. I either cycle or swim or do yoga or rowing or bands or walk another 10k. I often do this additional activity with friends so that it’s social

Excise calories. I stopped counting as it was all guesswork and seemed to slow my weight loss.

D0lphine · 08/05/2022 10:50

Also @fortysomething8 if you're not exercising at all at the moment then don't worry about how much, how often, how many calories etc. it's all just detail.

Aim to 1. Go to the gym and 2. Do something and 3. Eat fruit and veg. That's enough to focus on!!

People tend to be too strict and then not stick to it because it's unsustainable. Sticking to smaller goals is much easier and then you can build on it / refine.

SmurfysLaw · 08/05/2022 10:50

4 days a week. 2 reformer Pilates, 1 cycle class and 1 session at home where I use light weights, kettlebells stretch bands. The at home session comprises of squats, lunges, planks, dead lifts, etc. I chose 3 moves and do 3 sets of each. The classes last 45 minutes and my at home varies between 40-60 mins.

I love crisps and salted caramel ice cream way to much to track calories! I don’t have a strict diet but I try to aim for 7-10 fruit & veg (80 ish grams each) a day and will add a protein when I can.