Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why parents bring out clearly ill children for days out

216 replies

squiddybear · 08/05/2022 08:29

Probably going to be shot down in flames!

This week we had a week off and took DS to lots of places - we've always been very very cautious of covid and this was sort of the first time we did lots of things although we did test twice last week to make sure we were still ok to go.

It struck me how many children were being taken out to like the farm park or ceebeebies land who were clearly very unwell. Left to cough all over things, snot dripping down their faces and a few with what looked like HFM or chicken pox. Now I understand that children get ill but to take them to a public place and let them cough and sneeze over everything especially in the wake of covid is just unfair and unnecessary.

For context there was a family we were sitting next too who were there with another mum and child who said school wouldn't have her in but she's fine (said child was pale as a ghost, hacking cough and didn't really want to move!)

I don't understand the logic, if your child is ill then stay at home! Don't spread their germs round to everyone else! AIBU to think this

OP posts:
AppleandRhubarbTart · 09/05/2022 09:33

MichelleScarn · 09/05/2022 08:19

Had to check this wasn't a zombie post with all the 2020/21 covid bingo going on!

  • selfish
-stay inside -dont go anywhere without testing -evil, germ laden infection spreading children! Have I missed anything?

Lovely! 😁

I know, and some of them coming out with this are acting like they're actually smart? It's brilliant entertainment value.

AzazaelsFury · 09/05/2022 09:10

Olivestone · 09/05/2022 08:46

@AzazaelsFury so you are allowed to build up an immune system but only if you go to childcare?

You are completely not getting it and I don't have time to break it down to a simple mode for your comprehension.... Hopefully you don't have kids you're responsible for. Have a nice day (hopefully you understand that but won't hold my breath..)

GregBrawlsInDogJail · 09/05/2022 09:08

Outdoors at a farm park off strangers' DC isn't where older people catch infections from children anyway (or vice versa). Children catch infections off other children at school and childcare. Then they share them with adults in the home. Usually before they display any symptoms.

Olivestone · 09/05/2022 08:46

AzazaelsFury · 09/05/2022 07:52

And pass it on to other older people with compromised immune systems. Sure in school/childcare situations they do but going out places with sick kids to me isn't something that should be done. But yes, people do it so thanks for showing us what kind it takes... I mean I know there's irresponsible people out there but they don't usually admit to it. So I admire your carelessness.
Have a great day (and please don't address my posts again... Thanks)

@AzazaelsFury so you are allowed to build up an immune system but only if you go to childcare?

KevinTheKoala · 09/05/2022 08:28

The thing is most children will be contagious before symptoms appear so while obviously it is sensible to keep very unwell children at home, and perhaps avoid baby groups/other enclosed spaces with bad colds, the chances are you didn't catch the virus from the snotty, rashy looking child but actually from the perfectly healthy looking one who's been at nursery all week and hadn't started showing symptoms yet. So unless you really do want all children of nursery/school age to be permanently confined indoors there will always be contagious viruses around and that's actually a good thing for our immune systems.

MichelleScarn · 09/05/2022 08:19

Had to check this wasn't a zombie post with all the 2020/21 covid bingo going on!

  • selfish
-stay inside -dont go anywhere without testing -evil, germ laden infection spreading children! Have I missed anything?

Lovely! 😁

AppleandRhubarbTart · 09/05/2022 08:12

AzazaelsFury · 09/05/2022 07:52

And pass it on to other older people with compromised immune systems. Sure in school/childcare situations they do but going out places with sick kids to me isn't something that should be done. But yes, people do it so thanks for showing us what kind it takes... I mean I know there's irresponsible people out there but they don't usually admit to it. So I admire your carelessness.
Have a great day (and please don't address my posts again... Thanks)

Your whole attitude is hilarious.

gothereagain · 09/05/2022 07:55

AzazaelsFury · 09/05/2022 02:21

YANBU. Drives me mad. But given the amount of people who think YABU then it makes sense why so many are out. Some clueless people clearly don't care about other people they spread it to or the fact their child probably could have done with some rest to get over what they have... I am actually shocked so many admit to not giving a shit though.. Good work guys :)

Thing is, there's a difference between my child being ill- lethargic, hot, tired, sleepy, clingy and them exhibiting normal behaviour and also having a snotty nose. I'm not keeping a snotty nosed child who is otherwise their usual self cooped up for weeks on end.

Covid has shown us that stopping children getting normal levels of coughs and colds is bad for them anyway.

I currently have a stuffy nose. I'm otherwise totally fine- no fever, don't feel crappy. It'd be disingenuous for me to take a day sick simply because I keep blowing my nose!

Bunnycat101 · 09/05/2022 07:52

Coughs and colds are normal in small children. My eldest had a cough between October and March every year between 2 and 5. Now she’s in primary she doesn’t seem to be as much of a snot bucket as her younger sister.

school would expect a child in with a cold. Even during covid our school sent something round to make it clear children should be in with mild colds. I would not take a child out with a fever or one with sickness but you’d be imprisoning toddlers for months on end if they had to stay in every time they were snotty.

Sirzy · 09/05/2022 07:52

I have spent 3 weeks in Itu with a baby who contracted bronchiolitis from a cold. He is nearly 13 now and we know that he has life long damage to his lungs from that time.

BUT I also know we need to be realistic - ok don’t take a baby or toddler full of a cold to a baby group or similar, and of course always use good hand hygiene but taking them out to somewhere outdoors with a bit of a cold? Not an issue.

we don’t live in a sterile bubble, and it wouldn’t do children any good if we did. They are going to come across illnesses, and when your child is vulnerable that is petrifying (we spent most of the last two years shielding).

AzazaelsFury · 09/05/2022 07:52

Olivestone · 09/05/2022 07:41

@AzazaelsFury how do you think children build up their immune systems?

....they catch stuff off other children!

And pass it on to other older people with compromised immune systems. Sure in school/childcare situations they do but going out places with sick kids to me isn't something that should be done. But yes, people do it so thanks for showing us what kind it takes... I mean I know there's irresponsible people out there but they don't usually admit to it. So I admire your carelessness.
Have a great day (and please don't address my posts again... Thanks)

Olivestone · 09/05/2022 07:41

AzazaelsFury · 09/05/2022 02:21

YANBU. Drives me mad. But given the amount of people who think YABU then it makes sense why so many are out. Some clueless people clearly don't care about other people they spread it to or the fact their child probably could have done with some rest to get over what they have... I am actually shocked so many admit to not giving a shit though.. Good work guys :)

@AzazaelsFury how do you think children build up their immune systems?

....they catch stuff off other children!

AzazaelsFury · 09/05/2022 02:21

YANBU. Drives me mad. But given the amount of people who think YABU then it makes sense why so many are out. Some clueless people clearly don't care about other people they spread it to or the fact their child probably could have done with some rest to get over what they have... I am actually shocked so many admit to not giving a shit though.. Good work guys :)

mycatisannoying · 08/05/2022 21:21

Must admit. I've never seen this!
I can't imagine why it would be in anyone's best interests to do so Confused

KevinTheKoala · 08/05/2022 21:21

On the one hand obviously parents shouldn't be taking out genuinley unwell children, that's not fair on the child or anyone else. I'm a waitress and have seen children being sick in the toilet and then coming back for the parent to finish their meal/drink! Obviously children do go downhill very quickly but if they do become unwell while out you just have to leave. It's annoying and frustrating but it's part and parcel of having children.

However, you also cannot expect parents to keep their child in for every single mild illness (e.g a cold/HFM) the symptoms of which can sometimes last weeks past the contagious stage. Building up immunity is important. You also can't tell whether a strangers child is pale if you have nothing to base that off, my daughters are both day glow white (as am I) and we always look pale. In fact I used to tell my teachers I felt unwell because I knew they would reply with 'you do look pale' and I would be sent out of lesson. You don't know which children have asthma, which often causes a cough instead of a wheeze and is a common illness, and which ones have had coughs in the last 3 weeks or which ones haven't slept well and so are now tired and miserable. None of those children will be contagious or even ill but to a passer by they might look it.

AppleandRhubarbTart · 08/05/2022 21:15

squiddybear · 08/05/2022 20:35

@AppleandRhubarbTart if both parents are working then they wouldn't be taking them out in the first place... not at school age anyway

Yes they would. People go out to places after school, plus at weekends and in the holidays. I appreciate that your OP was specifically about weekdays, but you presumably understand that children can have snotty noses on all the days of the week.

HiJenny35 · 08/05/2022 21:13

I do think you're being slightly ridiculous, on average children aged 3 - 6 have on average 12 infections a year mainly between Sept and April. You simply cannot keep children off school/at home for all of these. Children have to build up an immune system they have to catch coughs and colds. My child has asthma and several allergies, she has thick green snot constantly this time of year and a hacking cough, she can't sleep and looks tired, you definitely can't tell that it's her asthma and not a cold. I'm sure people like you say the same things about us. We've been very careful, we followed ever covid guideline and more, we stayed home for much longer than necessary after chicken pox, hand floor and mouth I kept them home when I didn't have to but colds I'm sorry I remind about tissues, we disinfect but I'm not making the whole house stay in every time. I think once your child is older and you've had a few more years of this you may feel slightly differently.

ZoyaTheDestroyer · 08/05/2022 21:11

With kindness OP, yes, it’s possible that large numbers of parents took their seriously unwell children to the same attractions as you on a relatively quiet day. Have you perhaps considered however that after (presumably) two years of extreme caution and shielding you might (understandably) be particularly alert to otherwise fairly innocuous symptoms?

Between the ages of two and three one of my children had a permanently runny nose in colder weather. It was like someone turned on a tap when the temperature dropped to single figures. Checked over by several doctors who all said that there was no underlying cause and nothing to be done. You would no doubt have been horrified to encounter us on your day out but if we had kept them home we wouldn’t have left the house from October to April.

MarvellousMay · 08/05/2022 21:05

Went out for a meal today for a treat.
Someone had their small child with them who was so clearly unwell (v red face, coughing, snotty). Cried and cried. Didn’t eat their meal. Spent a long time screaming. It was pretty awful to witness. The child got so exhausted they eventually fell asleep at the table.

YANBU.

user1496146479 · 08/05/2022 20:47

liveforsummer · 08/05/2022 14:22

If you intend to mix with others outside of the home then yes that's exactly what everyone would be doing, regardless of age. If not willing to do so, then they should be staying at home, preferably for the 10 days. That's the responsible thing to be doing

This is absolutely not what we're being told to do. Do you think you get to re write the rules based on your own opinion? Bizarre.

Couldn't agree more! Life has moved on!

Goldijobsandthe3bears · 08/05/2022 20:37

Where was your day trip to, Lourdes?? 😂

squiddybear · 08/05/2022 20:35

@AppleandRhubarbTart if both parents are working then they wouldn't be taking them out in the first place... not at school age anyway

OP posts:
shrunkenhead · 08/05/2022 20:20

You sound overly anxious about your family's health, OP.
If everyone kept their kids at home every time they had a snotty nose or a cough they'd never be at school/ nursery! It's a long old day stuck at home with kids and fresh air is good for them.

AppleandRhubarbTart · 08/05/2022 20:12

squiddybear · 08/05/2022 20:03

I had a younger brother and my DM didn't work

Right, I think the combo of a SAHP and only two DC is what made that possible then. Although even then staying in for every single cold was likely a pretty niche position. The large majority of families with children are not going to tick both of those boxes.

Giraffesandbottoms · 08/05/2022 20:08

After the winter from
hell in which my children (and I) seemed to contract every single fucking bug, virus etc known to man, I would really like them to mingle with more illnesses and build up their immune system a little.

as a rule of thumb if they are well enough for school (actually well enough, not like when people shove their children into nursery as they need the childcare) then they are well enough for activities. Clear no-nos are fevers, v&d and rashes in their contagious phase. Everything else wouldn’t really bother me.