Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Labour are hypocrites

540 replies

Labscollie · 08/05/2022 08:24

Beergate. Turns out the event was planned. To think of all the slating Starmer gave Johnson. 🤔 This site's favourite newspaper, the Dailymail, has released a leaked memo, which might mark Starmer's downfall. If Johnson could survive, can Starmer?

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 09/05/2022 17:43

thecatfromjapan · 09/05/2022 17:36

Marsha, Johnson misled Parliament - that was why people called in him to resign.

Not simply because he was subject to an investigation.

You did make me question whether I had misheard it so googled

25 January – After the Metropolitan Police announced an investigation into the Downing Street parties, Starmer claimed that it was grounds for the Prime Minister's removal for office. He suggested that the mere announcement of the Met probe alone – even though it had not yet found any wrongdoing – was enough for members of the Cabinet to demand Johnson's departure:

‘We need to see the report in full and frankly, some of his Cabinet now need to look themselves in the mirror and ask themselves why they’re still supporting this Prime Minister. There’s a Metropolitan Police investigation into the goings on in Downing Street. It’s time that some of those Cabinet members spoke out and said we’re not tolerating this any longer.’

The same day, Angela Rayner tweets 'Boris Johnson's Downing Street is under police investigation, how on earth can he think he can stay on as Prime Minister?'

31 January – Sir Keir Starmer argues that being under investigation alone is grounds for Boris Johnson's resignation. He tweets: 'Honesty and decency matter. After months of denials the Prime Minister is now under criminal investigations for breaking his own lockdown laws. He needs to do the decent thing and resign.'

—the idea that a police investigation should prompt resignation is from him and also Rayner

LEnferCestLesAutres · 09/05/2022 17:40

Goodness Marsha I am not suggesting anyone has paid off the Durham police! Will be watching with interest to see who might be in line for a gong tho...
They have applied their own stated policy inconsistently, that is why people (even non-labour people like me) think something is off here. And the "significant new info" - the memo - is anything but. Hardly "bold" to point out these very obvious facts.

thecatfromjapan · 09/05/2022 17:36

Marsha, Johnson misled Parliament - that was why people called in him to resign.

Not simply because he was subject to an investigation.

SleeplessInEngland · 09/05/2022 17:33

MaryAndHerNet · 09/05/2022 17:24

He did indeed.

He probably doesn't need it as he got over £100k from secondary advisory work on top of his MP wages whilst saying MPs should have second incomes.

Hypocrite.

100k over a six year period (not exactly crazy money for a top lawyer) and finished before he called for the ban. Pretty lame as hypocrisy gotchas go, but if that’s your red line I’m not going to take it away from you.

Slinkymalinky03 · 09/05/2022 17:30

So you take Durham police force investigating now as enough to conclude they’ve been leant on by the government.

Despite the papers being full of leaked information apparently from members of the Labour party and described as significant new information by Durham police force.

MaryAndHerNet · 09/05/2022 17:24

SleeplessInEngland · 09/05/2022 17:19

Starmer publicly said that payrise shouldn’t go ahead at the time. It’s decided independently by a parliamentary watchdog.

He did indeed.

He probably doesn't need it as he got over £100k from secondary advisory work on top of his MP wages whilst saying MPs should have second incomes.

Hypocrite.

itsgettingweird · 09/05/2022 17:19

Ratrick · 09/05/2022 17:13

Not a Labour supporter (am a member of another party) but this does look entirely cooked up by the press.

Starmer’s position, that he is entirely confident no rules were broken but, if fined, he will resign, seems very reasonable and shows a degree of honour and accountability that you can’t generally find in the modern Conservative party.

Agree totally with this.

I also think Starmer didn't knowingly break any laws.

His history as a lawyer and some cases he's defended show me that he's an honourable person who believe in the law and the need to follow it.

SleeplessInEngland · 09/05/2022 17:19

MaryAndHerNet · 09/05/2022 17:15

“they’re all the same” is about the most trite thing you can say about politics.

Trite, it may be, but I am yet to be proven wrong.

I believe that just recently MPs had a £2.2k a year raise whilst saying there's no money for increasing welfare more than 3%
Taking an unemployed persons welfare up to around £350 a month..

to pay:
gas
Electric
Council tax
Insurance
Fuel
Food
TV license
Travel
Clothes
Shoes
Hair cuts

Starmer publicly said that payrise shouldn’t go ahead at the time. It’s decided independently by a parliamentary watchdog.

MarshaBradyo · 09/05/2022 17:17

LEnferCestLesAutres · 09/05/2022 17:09

Excuses will come from Labour supporters why this police investigation should be viewed differently, it’s not based on anything
(i) I am not a Labour supporter (ii) it is based on the inconsistent application of Durham force's stated policy of not taking action retrospectively.

Starmer is hypocritical for asking others to resign due to an investigation
(i) Starmer is not the PM, chancellor or a member of govt (ii) Starmer has not lied to parliament (iii) Starmer has clearly not breached any rules

So whilst he should stay he’s not without the ability to do politics and say whatever at the time and not mean it
Sounds like a sanitised version of "politicians are all the same, move on"

So you take Durham police force investigating now as enough to conclude they’ve been leant on by the government.. and someone has got something in return.. what money?

bold claims from someone who is not a Labour supporter

SleeplessInEngland · 09/05/2022 17:16

Whatever happens, this story seems to have had a zero effect on Starmer’s polling, in fact it’s improved in a few areas:

”Fieldwork done yesterday, changes in approval ratings from last week:

Starmer: -2 (no change)
Sunak: -15 (+3)
Johnson: -22 (+2)

On best PM Starmer makes a big improvement against Johnson:

Starmer vs Johnson
Starmer: 39% (+4)
Johnson: 32% (-1)”

MaryAndHerNet · 09/05/2022 17:15

“they’re all the same” is about the most trite thing you can say about politics.

Trite, it may be, but I am yet to be proven wrong.

I believe that just recently MPs had a £2.2k a year raise whilst saying there's no money for increasing welfare more than 3%
Taking an unemployed persons welfare up to around £350 a month..

to pay:
gas
Electric
Council tax
Insurance
Fuel
Food
TV license
Travel
Clothes
Shoes
Hair cuts

Ratrick · 09/05/2022 17:13

Not a Labour supporter (am a member of another party) but this does look entirely cooked up by the press.

Starmer’s position, that he is entirely confident no rules were broken but, if fined, he will resign, seems very reasonable and shows a degree of honour and accountability that you can’t generally find in the modern Conservative party.

MarshaBradyo · 09/05/2022 17:13

LEnferCestLesAutres · 09/05/2022 17:09

Excuses will come from Labour supporters why this police investigation should be viewed differently, it’s not based on anything
(i) I am not a Labour supporter (ii) it is based on the inconsistent application of Durham force's stated policy of not taking action retrospectively.

Starmer is hypocritical for asking others to resign due to an investigation
(i) Starmer is not the PM, chancellor or a member of govt (ii) Starmer has not lied to parliament (iii) Starmer has clearly not breached any rules

So whilst he should stay he’s not without the ability to do politics and say whatever at the time and not mean it
Sounds like a sanitised version of "politicians are all the same, move on"

You can rephrase the last part if it makes you feel good, in this instance he asked others to resign at this stage and hasn’t.

An MP supporter then claimed he holds himself to his own high standards but that is not the case.

so yes he has been hypocritical.

LEnferCestLesAutres · 09/05/2022 17:09

Excuses will come from Labour supporters why this police investigation should be viewed differently, it’s not based on anything
(i) I am not a Labour supporter (ii) it is based on the inconsistent application of Durham force's stated policy of not taking action retrospectively.

Starmer is hypocritical for asking others to resign due to an investigation
(i) Starmer is not the PM, chancellor or a member of govt (ii) Starmer has not lied to parliament (iii) Starmer has clearly not breached any rules

So whilst he should stay he’s not without the ability to do politics and say whatever at the time and not mean it
Sounds like a sanitised version of "politicians are all the same, move on"

SleeplessInEngland · 09/05/2022 17:05

Labscollie · 09/05/2022 17:03

Of course, because Labour MPs never lie to their constituents do they? They are all cut from the same cloth. I'm sure you will find another attempt at posing with language for that metaphor.

Where did I say Labour MPs never lied? Are we already at the strawman stage of the argument?

Labscollie · 09/05/2022 17:05

MarshaBradyo · 09/05/2022 17:02

Excuses will come from Labour supporters why this police investigation should be viewed differently, it’s not based on anything

Starmer is hypocritical for asking others to resign due to an investigation

So whilst he should stay he’s not without the ability to do politics and say whatever at the time and not mean it

Some great debate on here. The splitting of hairs, though, has been amusing.

OP posts:
Labscollie · 09/05/2022 17:03

SleeplessInEngland · 09/05/2022 16:58

Nah, naïveté is confusing cynicism with knowingness.

“they’re all the same” is about the most trite thing you can say about politics.

Of course, because Labour MPs never lie to their constituents do they? They are all cut from the same cloth. I'm sure you will find another attempt at posing with language for that metaphor.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 09/05/2022 17:02

LEnferCestLesAutres · 09/05/2022 16:54

No, not all MPs are like boris johnson

Quite - and KS' response today is ample proof of that, were proof required for the hard of thinking.

The govt leaned on Durham police to let Cummings off, and are now leaning on them to re-investigate Starmer, who quite plainly has not breached any rules in force at the relevant time. I wonder who has been promised what in return...

Excuses will come from Labour supporters why this police investigation should be viewed differently, it’s not based on anything

Starmer is hypocritical for asking others to resign due to an investigation

So whilst he should stay he’s not without the ability to do politics and say whatever at the time and not mean it

SleeplessInEngland · 09/05/2022 16:58

Labscollie · 09/05/2022 16:46

You sound very naive

Nah, naïveté is confusing cynicism with knowingness.

“they’re all the same” is about the most trite thing you can say about politics.

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 09/05/2022 16:57

MaryAndHerNet · 09/05/2022 16:22

I pay attention. Close attention.

There isn't a single Tory MP that hasn't put themselves before the voters.
You will say that's not true.

I will say,
If they cared about the voters, why have they done nothing to oust BoJo?
Why have they defended him or stayed silent?
Why have they continued working in a job led by BoJo?

They are complicit. They are defenders. They are supporters. Every single one.

Amen. 500 of their colleagues out on their arses and still they back him. Not an atom of integrity to be found in the tory party right now.

Sirius3030 · 09/05/2022 16:55

“But if the police decide to issue me with a fixed penalty notice I would, of course, do the right thing and step down.”

LEnferCestLesAutres · 09/05/2022 16:54

No, not all MPs are like boris johnson

Quite - and KS' response today is ample proof of that, were proof required for the hard of thinking.

The govt leaned on Durham police to let Cummings off, and are now leaning on them to re-investigate Starmer, who quite plainly has not breached any rules in force at the relevant time. I wonder who has been promised what in return...

Sirius3030 · 09/05/2022 16:53

Labscollie · 09/05/2022 09:53

The lengths some will go to, to protect their own bias.

The irony..,

Labscollie · 09/05/2022 16:52

Sirius3030 · 09/05/2022 16:49

I’m pretty sure you said ‘Labour are hypocrites’ Yup. Yesssss, pretty nebulous and idiotic.
BTW, I’m Labour and I’m not a hypocrite.

Of course you're Labour. Your sneering personal attacks are aligned with your party's record on not being able to debate, rationally.

OP posts:
Labscollie · 09/05/2022 16:50

LEnferCestLesAutres · 09/05/2022 16:11

as for this barrister, all I have read is conjecture and his own conclusion as to the differences between the proven and alleged contravention of lockdown laws. There is no legal reasoning I can see

If you are referring to Adam Wagner, I suggest you look at his twitter account where he has exhaustively analysed the various rules in force at different times. His views are very much based on legal reasoning! And by the way, he has previously opined that other Tory "gatherings" - eg Johnson's cheese and wine fest in the garden (which the police did not in the end investigate), Jacob Rees Mogg travelling in restrictions, Tobias Elwood, Cummings - were not breaches.

His legal analysis is rigorous, persuasive, unbiased and well informed. Yours on the other hand....

What legal analysis? He assesses the potential differences between both parties' indiscretions. Most of his analysis is based on intervening in party politics vis a vis respective work schedules. Some take it with a pinch of salt. You on the other hand ...

OP posts: