Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Labour are hypocrites

540 replies

Labscollie · 08/05/2022 08:24

Beergate. Turns out the event was planned. To think of all the slating Starmer gave Johnson. 🤔 This site's favourite newspaper, the Dailymail, has released a leaked memo, which might mark Starmer's downfall. If Johnson could survive, can Starmer?

OP posts:
luckylavender · 08/05/2022 09:23

Blone · 08/05/2022 09:21

@luckylavender how so?

They did want that did they not?

Nope

Youaremysunshine14 · 08/05/2022 09:22

Yes, they are, OP, if it was the case it was pre planned. The difference between them and the Tories, however, is that Starmer will stay true to his word and do the honourable thing and resign if he gets a fine. He has no choice, as former legal professional. Which should hopefully shame Johnson into doing the same.

Blone · 08/05/2022 09:21

@luckylavender how so?

They did want that did they not?

MarshaBradyo · 08/05/2022 09:20

Luculentus · 08/05/2022 09:15

The rules were substantially different in 2021 compared to those in force at the time of all the No 10 parties. I would suspend judgment till we find out whether any were actually broken.

It's obvious that the Mail dragged all this up because they were in a panic about the local elections, and some of their information sources seem to be dodgy in the extreme. The fact that a working meal was factored into a working day doesn't seem to be in any way comparable to the birthday shenanigans, let alone the Abba party.

The police started the investigation that’s why it was picked up again and the rules at the time were no indoor socialising

on timing Starmer is lucky it was the day after local elections. Many people voted on this issue and will find it hypocritical

I always found it ridiculous but he moralised and used it heavily to his advantage so it will come back on him

Toplurcher · 08/05/2022 09:18

MarshaBraydo

I think the police have been heavily leant on, which I find extremely troubling. Funny how the same police force didn't see any issue with Cummings and his sight-testing excursion at the heart of lockdown but now they're looking into this....

If he is fined he should resign, yes, and I believe he will. That will be very tricky for Johnson.

Mumwantingtogetitright · 08/05/2022 09:18

MarshaBradyo · 08/05/2022 09:11

Do you think a police investigation is worth coverage?

if he is fined should he go?

Some of his party think so

I'm a Labour supporter, and if he is fined, I absolutely think he should go. His position would be untenable.

I think Boris should go too, but that's not going to happen.

Prettypussy · 08/05/2022 09:17

The whole thing is ridiculous!

For people who had to go to work and couldn't work from home, then the rules about sharing a drink and food at lunch-time or at the end of the working day with colleagues who they have been in meetings with all day was arbitrary. The memo on Kier's plan for the day even specifies they need to social distance where possible so cannot see a problem at all.

I worked throughout the pandemic as I work in a school, and we ate our lunches in the school hall, socially distanced.

What a waste of tax-payers money investigating this!

Mumwantingtogetitright · 08/05/2022 09:16

sashagabadon · 08/05/2022 09:06

Why would Boris need to resign even if Keir does? Keir is being held to Keir’s own ridiculous standards. It’s a hole he has dug for himself only. I don’t think Boris or rishi has called for anyone to resign over something? If they had and then yes done the same thing then they would be hypocritical too and have to resign.
It’s the hypocrisy Starmer has to resign over not the curry.

I disagree. It isn't just about hypocrisy, though that is a factor. It's about taking responsibility. If KS is fined and resigns, Labour can at least argue that he has taken responsibility. The Tories cannot.

As for Keir holding Boris to ridiculous standards... really? Is it ridiculous to expect a prime minister to uphold the laws that he himself has introduced? And to tell the truth about his actions to Parliament?

No. Starmer's standards are not the problem here. If he has fallen short of the reasonable expectation that lawmakers should obey the law, then he needs to go, but that doesn't make Boris any less culpable.

Luculentus · 08/05/2022 09:15

The rules were substantially different in 2021 compared to those in force at the time of all the No 10 parties. I would suspend judgment till we find out whether any were actually broken.

It's obvious that the Mail dragged all this up because they were in a panic about the local elections, and some of their information sources seem to be dodgy in the extreme. The fact that a working meal was factored into a working day doesn't seem to be in any way comparable to the birthday shenanigans, let alone the Abba party.

Labscollie · 08/05/2022 09:11

User7493268965 · 08/05/2022 09:07

Rules were obviously just meant for the little people and not something that would get in the way of government work take outs. DH took sandwiches to work and had to keep 2m distance at work but of course we wouldn't expect them to do that would we.

This.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 08/05/2022 09:11

Toplurcher · 08/05/2022 09:10

The Tories and their servants in the press are obviously terrified of him and have expertly used this crap to divert attention from the disaster the Tories had at the polls on Thursday.

Anyone who sees much of a connection between this event and the plethora of events at downing Street is either utterly stupid or kidding themselves.

The so-called smoking gun in the mail today just proves it was a meal for staff at the end of a long working day, as claimed.

Do you think a police investigation is worth coverage?

if he is fined should he go?

Some of his party think so

Toplurcher · 08/05/2022 09:10

The Tories and their servants in the press are obviously terrified of him and have expertly used this crap to divert attention from the disaster the Tories had at the polls on Thursday.

Anyone who sees much of a connection between this event and the plethora of events at downing Street is either utterly stupid or kidding themselves.

The so-called smoking gun in the mail today just proves it was a meal for staff at the end of a long working day, as claimed.

ThettaReddast · 08/05/2022 09:08

We don’t have all the facts yet, but as things stand they look very different situations. A culture of repeated parties, alcohol and associated rule/law breaking at the heart of government vs a drink and some food for a group of people whilst working together. Time will of course tell if the Starmer thing is more than that, and if he is fined he should (and I think will) resign, but it does not in any way negate what went on in Downing Street. Roll on the Sue Grey report.

User7493268965 · 08/05/2022 09:07

Rules were obviously just meant for the little people and not something that would get in the way of government work take outs. DH took sandwiches to work and had to keep 2m distance at work but of course we wouldn't expect them to do that would we.

sashagabadon · 08/05/2022 09:06

Why would Boris need to resign even if Keir does? Keir is being held to Keir’s own ridiculous standards. It’s a hole he has dug for himself only. I don’t think Boris or rishi has called for anyone to resign over something? If they had and then yes done the same thing then they would be hypocritical too and have to resign.
It’s the hypocrisy Starmer has to resign over not the curry.

SickAndTiredAgain · 08/05/2022 09:03

If people are working together all day in an office, for weeks on end, I don't see how having food and drinks together at the middle or end of the day makes the tiniest bit of a difference to the risk of infection. No one seems to talk about how likely one of these "parties" was to increase the chance of someone spreading Covid, which was the whole point of the rules!

That's not really the point though, when they came up with & voted for the rules. If the rules were ridiculous (and arguably saying that people working in the same office all day can't eat together is ridiculous) then they should have changed them/argued for them to be changed. Not kept them in place for the rest of us while breaking them themselves. The rules were no social gatherings at work, of course there's no actual additional risk once you add a plate of food to an office (although that doesn't explain the presence of Carrie, the baby and the interior designer) but that wasn't the rule.

No matter how ridiculous a rule may or may not have been, if you brought it in, you should stick to it. If Boris insisted a 30mph speed limit on the motorway was essential, and was then caught doing 35mph, that would be wrong even though the rule itself would be absurd.

EngTech · 08/05/2022 09:02

Pot, kettle, black are a few words that come to mind here😳😳

Gosh, I never thought this would happen after Boris being slated for PartyGate

The powers to be wonder why people don’t trust politicians 😳😳

Mumwantingtogetitright · 08/05/2022 08:59

I'm also unsure. It doesn't look good but we don't have all the facts yet. There is obviously a lot of political pressure to investigate but that doesn't necessarily mean that any rules have been broken.

If he is fined, then I think he will absolutely have to resign, no question. It would be incredibly hypocritical to stay in post, and if he doesn't go of his own accord, then the Labour Party needs to sack him. There is no room for any flexibility on this.

If the police conclude their investigation and confirm that no rules were broken, then obviously, he can continue. I don't know enough of the detail to know whether or not this is likely to be the case.

Personally, I would be quite surprised if he was found to have broken the rules given what he said about Boris. If there was ever any shadow of a doubt that he might get caught out himself, you'd think he might have been a bit more circumspect in his response. He doesn't strike me as a stupid man, or as a massive risk taker, but who knows?

If he is fined and he does step down, I guess that will make Boris's position rather difficult, especially if there are more fines for number 10. Labour could at least say that Starmer had taken responsibility and fallen on his sword. If Starmer is fined and stays in post, though, the Labour Party clearly won't have a leg to stand on with regard to any further comments on partygate. And the electorate will understandably conclude that they're all as bad as each other.

donquixotedelamancha · 08/05/2022 08:56

The most interesting thing will be if Starmer does resign. There's no way out for Johnson after that. He either has to say Starmer was wrong to resign because parties are fine or say Starmer is the better person for resigning for lawbreaking.

I really think he'll just ignore it like he's done for numerous other things which would have sunk other politicians.

He doesn't care about being known as corrupt and hypocritical and, for whatever reason, the Tories back him.

MarshaBradyo · 08/05/2022 08:55

Jedsnewstar · 08/05/2022 08:52

I'm not sure. If he has been found to be breaking the rules then I'll be disappointed & he'll have to go. But it was a very different time in the pandemic from the Downing Street transgressions & I'm not sure he has. He is guilty of handling it badly. Whatever happens it's not on the scale of what happened in the No 10 'inner circle' & the Right Wing Press launched a targeted attack to coincide with the Local Elections. It's been shameless & relentless

Its nice to see a lick of sense in a sea of Tory apologists.

You don’t mind Starmer under police investigation.. Why do you feel differently

would you want him to go if fined?

I think it’s all ridiculous and other than the high level of hypocritical moralising he has used he shouldn’t resign

but even his own party shuffle around and say he should go if he is. Do you agree with them?

sashagabadon · 08/05/2022 08:55

katienana · 08/05/2022 08:49

The circumstances are very different
Planned to get a takeaway delivered and drink a beer when working away from home - they did need to eat.
May 2020 sending aides with suitcases to fill up with wine to drink in downing Street when they had made the rules and the police were visiting elderly people who drank coffee in a communal garden, and questioning someone who went for a walk wearing jeans.
Context is everything

Starmer called for Rishi to resign over cake during a meeting in June 2020. If that is a resigning matter ( according to Starmer anyway) then curry for 30 after work with extra people joining them and not working afterward is too. What’s the material difference between what Rishi did ( and got a fine) and what Starmer did?
Both are stupid reasons to resign but Rishi is not calling for Starmer’s resignation ( wisely)

lisa Nandy told them to shut up about cake and party gate and was ignored. She has a better political antennae than Keir does.
But I also blame the twitterati and media too who were not equally stupid.

Labscollie · 08/05/2022 08:54

What a mess the last 2 years have been. The pandemic has tested many people and their principles.

OP posts:
Jedsnewstar · 08/05/2022 08:52

I'm not sure. If he has been found to be breaking the rules then I'll be disappointed & he'll have to go. But it was a very different time in the pandemic from the Downing Street transgressions & I'm not sure he has. He is guilty of handling it badly. Whatever happens it's not on the scale of what happened in the No 10 'inner circle' & the Right Wing Press launched a targeted attack to coincide with the Local Elections. It's been shameless & relentless

Its nice to see a lick of sense in a sea of Tory apologists.

luckylavender · 08/05/2022 08:52

sashagabadon · 08/05/2022 08:46

The difference to me is that Starmer spent 4 months calling for the resignation of Boris and rishi for stopping for cake in a meeting and yet has arguably done something worse. Yes it is hypocritical but the sanctimonious preaching is worse.
Neither event is a resignation matter, it’s all stupid but Keir is now going to have to resign if issued with a ftpn which is his own stupidity and lack of forethought and desire to get one over Boris. That’s on him. Angela too.
Boris should say nothing but if asked say he doesn’t think it’s a resigning matter ( as it isn’t) but that Keir should make his own decision. Egg also on faces of all the equally idiotic media that encouraged Keir to keep going on about it. They are all as bad as each other. It’s embarrassing for all of them.

You don't think that if you make rules you should stick to them yourself? That publicly praising a 7 year old for cancelling her birthday party while doing it himself is disgraceful? And let's not forget that the fine he has received is for the most minor of events we know he attended. And while he was doing it people couldn't attend loved ones funerals or hold their hands when they died. It may be that these laws were draconian but Johnson set them.

itsgettingweird · 08/05/2022 08:50

I'll wait until the police report.

But they weren't the same in regards so many things.

Johnson's birthday party was during the first heavy LD of 2020. It wasn't a work meal or event as he had his spouse, interior designer and official photographer there.

I wouldn't have had an issue if they were genuinely having food as they were working hard. Even in the garden. They were working long hours and food is needed to function. Alcohol after work to enjoy the sunshine as a planned social event with email invites is not.

Again - I will say the same re labours Durham gathering. If it's deemed to have been a party with people from outside the campaign invited to socialise it's very different form people who had been working all day and the food was planned as part of needing to eat.

As much as I'm neutral on the outcome and agree Starmer should resign after saying the same to Johnson - I'm also pretty sure that Starmer wouldn't have knowingly broke the law because he's so loyal to his lawyer status.

The most interesting thing will be if Starmer does resign. There's no way out for Johnson after that. He either has to say Starmer was wrong to resign because parties are fine or say Starmer is the better person for resigning for lawbreaking.

Either way I think the fallout for our PM Johnson will be bigger than the Starmers.

Swipe left for the next trending thread