Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Labour are hypocrites

540 replies

Labscollie · 08/05/2022 08:24

Beergate. Turns out the event was planned. To think of all the slating Starmer gave Johnson. 🤔 This site's favourite newspaper, the Dailymail, has released a leaked memo, which might mark Starmer's downfall. If Johnson could survive, can Starmer?

OP posts:
EmergencyPaintSituation · 11/05/2022 14:33

Trickle down economics doesn’t work. Social inequality has grown so much. We need a wholesale change - if we want to tackle poverty, injustice and social inequality.

Of course - we could also keep going as we are and bring back workhouses. Sod it. Let’s start hanging people in the town centre too. Bring it on.

Or let’s evolve.

Zilla1 · 11/05/2022 09:09

And only a fool would jeopardise future economic growth for short term tax cuts and tax rises and other measures that probably won't work and would jeopardise the interests of important people who make investment decisions and can easily take their wealth abroad to benefit other countries. The pie needs to get bigger even if it takes decades and if more slices of that bigger pie are taken by the really hard working then the wealth will trickle down like a warm shower running down your backs. Economic growth can take decades to build and seconds to ruin by foolish knee jerk decisions by populists like those Labour scoundrels. We are only in the place we are because of the last twelve years of Tory rule.

Zilla1 · 10/05/2022 15:55

Recent PPs have a good point. Call that a party, Labour scallywags? The average chap in the street, salt of the earth, the Daily Mail reader is having to painfully stretch to call that a party and are only doing so for the national interest to hold Labour to account. Cake, karaoke, suitcases of booze, lots of young ladies, that's a party, or a series of parties, what is the collective noun for 14 parties that obviously weren't really parties for the purpose of reports and fines? Let's say a Bozza of parties? Jo and Josephine public won't respect Labour if a beer and a curry in a room full of people then back to work constitutes a party. Then walking to a premier inn. Boris would have stayed at the Ritz. OK there might not be a Ritz in Tyneside or Teeside or wherever his might have been so a flight back to a decent hotel. Roll on the next election, Schrodinger's party will influence the results.

Notonthestairs · 10/05/2022 14:22

Ah yes. Reckon a few are being deleted/shredded?
And yes the video does make it look boring and shit! I suppose that could be another angle - Labour don't even know how to have a party (where's the karaoke and broken garden toys?)

carefullycourageous · 10/05/2022 14:18

Notonthestairs · 10/05/2022 14:12

Yes but I doubt they'll have had the benefit of a Spectator/Telegraph columnist's son filming them.

It isn't the film that would prompt the fine though, the film makes it look really boring and shit - it is the 'memo' the Mail was calling new info. There will be many memoes of many events.

carefullycourageous · 10/05/2022 14:14

in anticipation of the triumphant agenda announces in the Queen's Speech hahahaha

Notonthestairs · 10/05/2022 14:12

carefullycourageous · 10/05/2022 13:51

I think if this meal is fined, then there may be questions about a lot of campaign events across all parties.

Yes but I doubt they'll have had the benefit of a Spectator/Telegraph columnist's son filming them.

Zilla1 · 10/05/2022 14:08

I presume Keir has cynically been trying to suck the oxygen out of the room in anticipation of the triumphant agenda announces in the Queen's Speech., the Trump-esque scallywag. Just goes to show there is literally nothing more that could be done to help people before the next election than the Tories have set out as Keir had to resort to underhand tactics to distract from Boris' success rather than repeating the airy fairey impractical ideas around tax cuts, tax raises (on energy firms) and such like. The Chancellor's tax cut in a couple of years when things will probably be much more predictable looks inspired. Keir called the PM a joke. Who's laughing now?

carefullycourageous · 10/05/2022 13:51

I think if this meal is fined, then there may be questions about a lot of campaign events across all parties.

Luculentus · 10/05/2022 13:31

Sorry, I meant to put the first paragraph of that in bold to show it was a quote.

Luculentus · 10/05/2022 13:30

Whether the event was a "party" or not is irrelevant. It doesn't have to have been a "party" for it to have been illegal. All that matters is whether the gathering itself was strictly necessary for work purposes, and if not, did it break rules on the numbers attending and social distancing involved.

Not quite. What matters is whether it was reasonably necessary for the purposes of campaigning in an election. It is regarded as particularly important that there should be no more interference than is strictly necessary in the democratic process.

jcyclops · 10/05/2022 13:26

I just want to make a few points that seem to have been ignored or misinterpreted in this discussion.

  1. Durham police, just like the Met, deliberately refused to progress their investigations in the lead up to the local elections. Durham were going to reopen their investigation as soon as possible afterwards due to receiving further information at an earlier date.
  2. Durham police did not "cave in" to pressure from a local Tory MP - they have a duty to investigate all believable reports of crime.
  3. It doesn't matter at all what Starmer et al were doing before the curry & beer, and it doesn't matter what they did afterwards. It doesn't matter whether it was planned or impromptu. It is solely the gathering itself which should be (and probably is) the subject of investigation.
  4. Whether the event was a "party" or not is irrelevant. It doesn't have to have been a "party" for it to have been illegal. All that matters is whether the gathering itself was strictly necessary for work purposes, and if not, did it break rules on the numbers attending and social distancing involved.
  5. Making statements of "non equivalence" between the multiple breaches at No.10 and a single breach by Labour in Durham is ludicrous. Saying someone who murdered one person isn't really a bad guy because someone else murdered six is the same sort of warped thinking as this.
  6. As seems to be nearly always the case, discussion of Johnson, Sunak, Starmer or Rayner "resigning" misses the point that all that may happen is they will get demoted and still hold a job paying £84k. Resigning means losing your job and salary - as is the case with Neil Parish.
the80sweregreat · 10/05/2022 10:44

It makes me wonder if the Labour Party had an idea that number 10 hadn't followed all the rules to the letter the year previously and just thought it would be fine to have this in 21?
I'm not sure what the rules were last year , but they did keep on changing and it wasn't as strict as the first lockdown were (at that time. )
I'm NOT condoning any of their actions by the way and I'm glad he has made this statement about what he'll do and now he'll have to stick to it if they receive the FPNs and did break the lockdown rules.
Just some musings.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 10/05/2022 10:16

@SleeplessInEngland Oh, don't imagine I am in any way defending anyone or trying to say that anyone, politician, journalist etc, has acted differently, better, worse in any of this crap!

I am saying, as I have said for a few years now, that the behaviour by all concerned is the same, whichever party, whichever newspaper etc. And I dislike it, no matter who it is I am looking at!

That I did not know until this week that the media had sat on the Starmer video in the same way as they had sat on the Johnson info was my point. Knowing this doesn't make anyone look any better, or worse!

As you say, nature of the beast!

SleeplessInEngland · 10/05/2022 10:11

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 10/05/2022 10:00

I meant that they, the media, had had the video for longer, 9 months longer, but didn't begin to use it until January. Laurence Fox tweeted it the following day, I believe. It was ignored because Starmer wasn't politically interesting enough, The Sun printed it buried where unimportant stories go (middle of page 2 of the second print edition only, the most unread page of any paper apparently) the media was focussed on Johnson. So for months the media had that video and watched Keir the Apparently Insignificant castigate Johnson and did bugger all with the infomtation they had.

www.theguardian.com/politics/2022/may/06/media-keir-starmer-lockdown-beer-footage

This worked both ways though: partygate only broke in January but there had been lots of tittle-tattle in the months before that stuff had gone on in Downing Street - so at the time the tory shennanigans weren't deemed politically interesting enough either. Once partygate became a going concern that Starmer video was front page news pretty quickly. Nature of the beast.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 10/05/2022 10:04

Mind you that does have the advantage of me not seeing the immediately wmotive stuff. I get to see the bigger stories when there is often a bit more depth and context to them. Keeps the blood pressure down!

MarshaBradyo · 10/05/2022 10:04

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 10/05/2022 09:53

@MarshaBradyo I know. I've been trying to put that into words on many threads during covid. Been shouted down on many of them, as have you I know. But I can't work out how I can engage with olitics in a way that is meaningful. Ignoring the mainstream media hasn't been all that successful, but something has to change, hasn't it? Educating the next generations is probably a good way to go. Though given the track record of many Sec Eds, maybe not!

@newnamethanks I know! Colour me purple, but somehow I wasn't surprised.

I know it’s difficult as you just get ‘far right’ yelled at you ; or I do

or shouted down

As I’ve said a few times I’m a central floating voter - if anything Blair felt most at home for me (until the illegal war) but I’ve become more disconnected from the media game recently

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 10/05/2022 10:03

i remember a psychologist saying on radio that we should try to get off the daily media cycle and catch up once a week. I do try to limit being emotively reactive by moving to radio rather than print or images

I must have seen something similar as that is what I do now. No television news unless I am following something, no newspapers and nothing online until Saturday, when I have a couple of hours catch up over tea and toast. I feel like someone out of Agatha Christie... ageing and a tad out of touch until I get a bee in my bonnet!

MarshaBradyo · 10/05/2022 10:00

and yet we do see the impact the media and the right messaging can have

Brexit campaign was more effective - keep it simple, emotive, repetitive was a formula that worked and Cummings has used again

the petrol crisis increased demand by 400% in a weekend, supply wasn’t the bigger cause

partygate has had a big impact on public

Daily fear re Covid meant some misjudged their risk

since the media moved mostly online clickbait headlines are more important - before this you’d just pick up your usual paper regardless. Now attention and clicks matter more.

we get stuck in feedback loops. The media ham it up, the public care and demand in response and the cycle continues

I would never claim people can’t think or are thick (I’ll leave that to Labour supporters) but I do think we could learn more and be more immune

i remember a psychologist saying on radio that we should try to get off the daily media cycle and catch up once a week. I do try to limit being emotively reactive by moving to radio rather than print or images

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 10/05/2022 10:00

SleeplessInEngland · 10/05/2022 09:51

"Interestingly, it seem that the mainstream media all knew about the video whilst Starmer was castigating Johnson!"

Eh? No-one thinks the video of him in his office holding a beer is new. It isn't the reason the investigation was recently opened.

I meant that they, the media, had had the video for longer, 9 months longer, but didn't begin to use it until January. Laurence Fox tweeted it the following day, I believe. It was ignored because Starmer wasn't politically interesting enough, The Sun printed it buried where unimportant stories go (middle of page 2 of the second print edition only, the most unread page of any paper apparently) the media was focussed on Johnson. So for months the media had that video and watched Keir the Apparently Insignificant castigate Johnson and did bugger all with the infomtation they had.

www.theguardian.com/politics/2022/may/06/media-keir-starmer-lockdown-beer-footage

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 10/05/2022 09:53

@MarshaBradyo I know. I've been trying to put that into words on many threads during covid. Been shouted down on many of them, as have you I know. But I can't work out how I can engage with olitics in a way that is meaningful. Ignoring the mainstream media hasn't been all that successful, but something has to change, hasn't it? Educating the next generations is probably a good way to go. Though given the track record of many Sec Eds, maybe not!

@newnamethanks I know! Colour me purple, but somehow I wasn't surprised.

Fairisleflora · 10/05/2022 09:51

I do think you need to train people to take a critical eye at news media but I think you can go too far - if you think everything you read in the paper is nonsense and all
politicians are lying scum you can end up believing conspiracy theory clap trap.

most people are immune to the daily Mail nonsense on this story. Most people can see Boris Johnson as a lying, conniving, scheming person only out for lining his own pocket in any way he can. Most people can see Keir Starmer as someone that is trying to do the right thing even though he’s a bit dull. Most people see Anglea Raynor as coarse but trying to do good things. Most people see that it was right to lock down with Covid until the vulnerable had been immunised. Most people can think for themselves.

SleeplessInEngland · 10/05/2022 09:51

"Interestingly, it seem that the mainstream media all knew about the video whilst Starmer was castigating Johnson!"

Eh? No-one thinks the video of him in his office holding a beer is new. It isn't the reason the investigation was recently opened.

newnamethanks · 10/05/2022 09:47

Delingpoles? Oh what a surprise.

MarshaBradyo · 10/05/2022 09:43

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 10/05/2022 09:29

Interestingly, it seem that the mainstream media all knew about the video whilst Starmer was castigating Johnson!

So our mainstream media, not just the BBC, was helping shape all sorts of things, not least the elections. We are indeed being played.

www.theguardian.com/politics/2022/may/09/revealed-student-ivo-delingpole-james-breitbart-beergate-video-that-threatens-to-sink-starmer

Mind you, many of us are complicit in this, having chosen to ignore, explain away, any mentions of it, publication of the video in January etc etc.

Regardless of any outcome, we need to be more politically savvy. Our politicians, media, belief in the cult of the individual and politicking in general is becoming more and more American in tone by the day!

This is the interesting and fairly depressing part for me

The power of the media to play us, Cummings got this right with Brexit (I voted remain but he knew how to motivate people), then with partygate.

The media also found out how selling fear was profitable over a long period with Covid

I’d like to see two things introduced to a higher level in education - better economics (the amount of posts on here show low understanding) and media criticism

Better equip newer generations against media storms and decide on economic policies

Swipe left for the next trending thread