Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Labour are hypocrites

540 replies

Labscollie · 08/05/2022 08:24

Beergate. Turns out the event was planned. To think of all the slating Starmer gave Johnson. 🤔 This site's favourite newspaper, the Dailymail, has released a leaked memo, which might mark Starmer's downfall. If Johnson could survive, can Starmer?

OP posts:
Sirius3030 · 09/05/2022 16:49

Labscollie · 08/05/2022 17:28

Talking of gibberish.. All of those you've mentioned are noted in the plural, are you saying a Labour shadow cabinet is singular? In fact, I haven't the foggiest what you're saying, except to use nebulous analogies.

I’m pretty sure you said ‘Labour are hypocrites’ Yup. Yesssss, pretty nebulous and idiotic.
BTW, I’m Labour and I’m not a hypocrite.

Labscollie · 09/05/2022 16:46

SleeplessInEngland · 09/05/2022 16:19

"MPs are all the same.
Politicians are all the same."

Only people who don't pay attention to politics think this. No, not all MPs are like boris johnson.

You sound very naive

OP posts:
SleeplessInEngland · 09/05/2022 16:42

"The lies may be different, but the lack of morals remains identical."

Fine. They're all the same, nothing ever gets better, there's no point in optimism.... and the tories win again.

MaryAndHerNet · 09/05/2022 16:38

"Well, the fact that labour and tory ideology on the matter is diametrically opposed shows not all mps are the same. 🙂"

The lies may be different, but the lack of morals remains identical.

SleeplessInEngland · 09/05/2022 16:37

"If they can't tell the truth about biology, they can't tell the truth about anything, that makes them untrust worthy and without morals and it shows they'll put their careers before 52% of the population every time."

Well, the fact that labour and tory ideology on the matter is diametrically opposed shows not all mps are the same. 🙂

Zilla1 · 09/05/2022 16:35

@MaryAndHerNet to take a slightly different tone, I've heard indirectly that Alan Johnson was held in high regard and achieved relatively high office without grim self-interest. Similar feedback about Estelle Morris. Grasping at straws to add to the list though I've no direct insight for quite a few years.

MarshaBradyo · 09/05/2022 16:34

Starmer has already gone past the point where he said others should resign - on police investigation

He’s made the most of partygate but that part was just soundbite

I don’t think he should resign - although I’d welcome Rayner following through with the idea

MaryAndHerNet · 09/05/2022 16:30

SleeplessInEngland · 09/05/2022 16:23

"There isn't a single Tory MP that hasn't put themselves before the voters.
You will say that's not true."

You've rather moved the goalposts there by narrowing it down to tory mps. (Not that I disagree in the main.)

I'll include Labour too, but they're not in power right now.

I wouldn't believe any of them would put the population before their careers, not one of them.
Not even Kier or Raynor. In fact, how often have labour MPs said negative things about women, 52% of the population?
Why?
To try and mitigate wrath of ideologues that went often JKR and others.

If they can't tell the truth about biology, they can't tell the truth about anything, that makes them untrust worthy and without morals and it shows they'll put their careers before 52% of the population every time.

SleeplessInEngland · 09/05/2022 16:23

"There isn't a single Tory MP that hasn't put themselves before the voters.
You will say that's not true."

You've rather moved the goalposts there by narrowing it down to tory mps. (Not that I disagree in the main.)

MaryAndHerNet · 09/05/2022 16:22

SleeplessInEngland · 09/05/2022 16:19

"MPs are all the same.
Politicians are all the same."

Only people who don't pay attention to politics think this. No, not all MPs are like boris johnson.

I pay attention. Close attention.

There isn't a single Tory MP that hasn't put themselves before the voters.
You will say that's not true.

I will say,
If they cared about the voters, why have they done nothing to oust BoJo?
Why have they defended him or stayed silent?
Why have they continued working in a job led by BoJo?

They are complicit. They are defenders. They are supporters. Every single one.

SleeplessInEngland · 09/05/2022 16:19

"MPs are all the same.
Politicians are all the same."

Only people who don't pay attention to politics think this. No, not all MPs are like boris johnson.

Walkaround · 09/05/2022 16:17

If Keir Starmer isn’t fined, then it is obviously different and Keir Starmer not hypocritical, as it will show no rules were broken by him, but that rules were broken multiple times by Johnson. If he is fined, then he is hypocritical and should step down - which should also force Johnson to step down, as that proves it’s a resigning matter.

I found Starmer going on about partygate and Boris resigning pretty tiresome, but I think you have to be hard of thinking to believe Boris Johnson’s behaviour and Keir Starmer’s are equivalent. Starmer certainly never claimed to be surprised by his meal and beer, whereas Johnson was endlessly surprised by cakes, karaoke and suitcases of alcohol.

Zilla1 · 09/05/2022 16:14

Barristers. All opinions and assertion. Unless they agree with my opinions of course.

Like journalists. muck rakers. confrontationalists. except the ones that speak common sense.

Don't get me started on politicians. Waste of space, the lot of them. Except ...

MaryAndHerNet · 09/05/2022 16:12

MPs are all the same.
Politicians are all the same.

No one gets into politics without thinking of personal gains.

It's one huge gravy train and it's all paid for by idiots like us that argue over shit like partygate and beer gate whilst the sick are screwed, the elderly and left to rot and the poorest in society starve.

It's ridiculous how much and how easily get distracted. £2900 fuel bills coming.. NI up.. millions in poverty.. millions reliant on food banks...

But the headlines are about an MP having a takeout. FFS. We deserve Boris.

LEnferCestLesAutres · 09/05/2022 16:11

as for this barrister, all I have read is conjecture and his own conclusion as to the differences between the proven and alleged contravention of lockdown laws. There is no legal reasoning I can see

If you are referring to Adam Wagner, I suggest you look at his twitter account where he has exhaustively analysed the various rules in force at different times. His views are very much based on legal reasoning! And by the way, he has previously opined that other Tory "gatherings" - eg Johnson's cheese and wine fest in the garden (which the police did not in the end investigate), Jacob Rees Mogg travelling in restrictions, Tobias Elwood, Cummings - were not breaches.

His legal analysis is rigorous, persuasive, unbiased and well informed. Yours on the other hand....

Zilla1 · 09/05/2022 16:03

It just goes to show how poorly Keir has misjudged the PM. He's a man of principle and won't let the nation down by running away if some bureaucrat issues a fine. Keir won''t get more respect from Conservative MPs by fetishising his principles. Boris has shown he's above things like principles.

SleeplessInEngland · 09/05/2022 15:37

Journalists reporting that Starmer will announce later today he'll resign if fined. Would make the tories look even worse but it's a hit they'll probably be happy to take and will pray people forget about it all before the next election.

ChrisReasBathEggs · 09/05/2022 14:49

I think this is a load of hot air. What the Tories did was far worse. It wasn't a curry while working (or not working because it was delivered late supposedly). If they were going down the local Londis with a suitcase to fill with booze and was sending a group email to 100+ people to bring their own booze or having interior decorators over to celebrate getting rid of an aide, then fair enough. It was a curry during a work meeting.

Just another diversion tactic so the Tories can do the square root of fuck all about sorting out the cost of living crisis and the utter shit show if the local elections.

At least Starmer is considering resigning. Boris isn't, and I expect there are far more incidences of rule breaking to come.

I find it hard to understand how a work curry vs a culture of boozing and partying on multiple occasions (plus an aide going for a drive to 'test his eyesight' when he had tested positive the week before) compares.

Labscollie · 09/05/2022 11:33

Eddiesferret · 09/05/2022 10:00

Labscollie if YOU can't tell the difference between actual law breaking and spurious allegations that the police have no alternative but to investigate.. then you are just daft.

Johnson is a serial lier. Always has been and always will be. He was sacked from numerous jobs before this one for lying . He was investigated AND found guilty. A rather important difference to Starmer who has been found guilty of nothing.

I can contact the police and accuse YOU of pretty much anything. If I get enough of my mates to contact them and accuse you of the same thing . (As has been done in Durham) they are obliged to investigate.

So if I do that and accuse you of being .. let's say - a fraudster. Does that mean you are guilty of fraud ? No it doesn't. Once the case is investigated and evidence is found to support the allegations, then depending upon the nature of the offence you will either go to trial or be given a penalty notice.

Until then you are innocent.

I also don't understand all those Tories calling for Starmer to resign . Why should he resign when guilty of nothing - when the PM who HAS been found guilty refused to go. Surely that's the hypocrisy... and then , when the Sue Gray report is finally released and you find out exactly what he has been up to - what are you going to use as an excuse then ?

Starmer has been found guilty of nothing....yet. as for this barrister, all I have read is conjecture and his own conclusion as to the differences between the proven and alleged contravention of lockdown laws. There is no legal reasoning I can see. Just a puff of air around how he has interrupted work related gatherings. So johnson is a liar, aren't they all.

OP posts:
Squillerman · 09/05/2022 11:20

Honestly don’t see how they’re of the same calibre at all. One was a beer and takeaway after work whilst on the road together, could technically say they were still working while eating. The government had organised birthday parties and various other get togethers including a Christmas party. Plus the government actually formulated the rules only to break them numerous times.

RufusthefIoraImissingreindeer · 09/05/2022 11:18

The lengths some will go to, to protect their own bias

I've confused myself, are you saying that we shouldn't believe trained barristers when they talk about their understanding of the law

Or that betting your cornflake collection is a step too far

Or neither of them

derxa · 09/05/2022 11:13

Zilla1 · 08/05/2022 11:32

'you'd never know there was a war going on would you ?'

Exactly. The PM is busy helping Ukraine and saving the free world, practically on the front line, so I'd expect every patriotic person who wasn't a Russian bot to support the PM and stop going on about cost of living crises and suitcases of booze and Jennifer Accuri and bridges and parties and PPE contracts and fines, well except fines for Kier, obviously. We all know the naysayers are Kremlin Gremlins.

You need to learn to spell your leader's name correctly.

HRTQueen · 09/05/2022 11:08

Starmer isn’t seen as a huge threat the the Tories so yes keeping him as leader is better the devil you know

also many Tories are not ready for Johnsom to be replaced if Starmer resigns how does that reflect on Johnson still being PM

SleeplessInEngland · 09/05/2022 10:57

Insterestingly a new poll suggests that if Starmer is fined the majority of Lab voters think he should resign while the majority of Con voters think he shouldn't.

oldwhyno · 09/05/2022 10:50

yeah, the public aren't really that impressed Labour's "holier than thou" hypocrisy over this and Rayner "honey" 🤢 trapping feckless tories bragging about flashing her "ginger growler" (her words).