Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ban talk of children in the workplace?

232 replies

Kanfuzed123 · 07/05/2022 22:27

Chatted to my friend today over coffee. She’s snr leadership at quite a big company, very successful and generally v lovely. She is struggling ttc, and the ‘wrong side of 35’ (quote is from a dr she has seen not me)

She mentioned She wanted to escalate a work issue around a few specific individuals, talking about their children. She wanted to escalate this higher and ban talk of children at work and get thr repeat offenders basically ‘told off’… not a disciplinary but getting someone more snr than her (and she’s pretty snr) to talk to them as they’ve been ‘upsetting people’ over ‘repeated insensitive comments’.

To be clear this isn’t the case of people saying ‘why don’t you have kids?’ ‘When are you having them’ because I do think there could be a conversation there. It seemed more of office chit chat like hi Bob what did you do this weekend?’ ‘Well Dave I took my kids to the aquarium’ sort of thing or you know introductory calls/ getting to know each other, ‘hi I’m Dave, 45, background in computer programming, originally from New Zealand, 2 kids both are football mad and a cocker spaniel called fluffy’ sort of thing

I’ve been through infertility myself and it’s hell, but I think to raise this issue higher and actively ban your direct reports talking of their family is not the sort of precedent to set. I actually think suggesting it to people higher up will not make her look good at all and could be a HR issue. Where does the line get drawn, can people talk about or mention their parents? Someone has probably lost a parent somewhere in the wider team etc.

I could tell she was quite worked up about it today over our coffee so I didn’t say anything about it from a ‘don’t do that’ point of view but we’re going shopping tomorrow and I do feel like I should maybe say something as when she gets sometbing in her head she does plough ahead with it and I think it doesn’t make her look too good.

am I wrong?

OP posts:
Hardbackwriter · 08/05/2022 07:33

That’s my gut feeling too, that it’s really problematic that she thinks it’s ok to think she can police what’s being said in that awkward 5 minute waiting for everyone to join a meeting silence killer small talk conversation.

also given her disdain for a small group Im wondering if it’s going to inadvertently lead to targeting them in some capacity as they are the core offenders apparently.

If you think she might start targeting people she manages then I'm not sure how ethical it is to advise her to stop short of the point where it would alert more senior people... You're right that if she tries to ban talk of children it'll make her look unstable and raise doubts about whether she should be a people manager but it sounds like they would be legitimate doubts!

BoredYummyMummy · 08/05/2022 07:33

This is weird - if I haven’t seen someone for a while at work it’s
‘hey, how’re you, how’s the kids’ etc.. it’s a fantastic conversation starter

TryingNotToReact9to5 · 08/05/2022 07:30

I did used to get upset when people talked about their extensions, or their mortgages. Not only did they OWN the house they lived in but they could afford to improve it.

So. Ban the word mortgage as it can be upsetting to renters and ban the word extension as I can't afford to extend.

deplorabelle · 08/05/2022 07:26

Kanfuzed123 · 07/05/2022 23:06

How did she do this @deplorabelle like flat out ban through snr management all talk of children because she found it upsetting?

No it's not an outright ban, it was just guidance. We are still working 100 percent remotely so we have slightly stilted social catch-ups and the manager who leads them just told us all we'd have to stop talking about children when the new person starts. It's not very well adhered to tbh but I've taken it to heart a bit. I'd hate to think I was making people upset or being boring.

TryingNotToReact9to5 · 08/05/2022 07:25

ha well, good luck to her. I have DC but they're 16 and 19 so they're the people in my life rather than my cute kids. I don't show photos around, ykwim

But i'm single, how about I banned ALL TALK of partners?

I don't really mind when people tell me how Dave/Mike/Steve likes his burger done on the barbecue, I just nod and smile. If they weren't talking about Dave/Mike/Steve they'd be saying something else. What's the difference. It's all how it's told. Whatever it is, it's always how they tell 'em.

carefullycourageous · 08/05/2022 07:24

The idea you should be able to ask colleagues not to discuss any topic except where it meets a threshold of offensiveness or controversy is ridiculous.
I have two colleagues who discuss the local rugby club's performance. Boring boring boring. Allowed allowed allowed.
People are getting increasingly self-obsessed. I think part of normal, healthy life is listening to other people waffle on a bit.

MaverickSnoopy · 08/05/2022 07:24

This is ridiculous. So Bob asks me what I did at the weekend and I took my children to the park, I say what? "I went to the park Bob, it was great and i played on the swings and got an ice cream" or "Nothing Bob, I didn't do anything" or just lie? What about if a child is off sick and you have to look after them? Or leave early for a school performance or some such. There's a multitude of practical and logistical, non boasting, reasons to talk about your children at work. I don't waffle on about my children but I'd really resent working somewhere that restricted me discussing my life in normal context.

Beseen22 · 08/05/2022 07:20

TTC for 4+ years really damaged my mental health. I remember asking when couples got married if I heard they were expecting so I could decide if they 'deserved' it. I'm really still quite broken by it all.

However with hindsight I can see that it was a 'me' problem and not a 'them' problem. No one was goading me, perhaps some were unwise with words but my infertility is not their problem. And literally everyone has crappy stuff going onnbehind closed doors. If infertility is making her feel like this she should consider accessing some support.

Professionally this is a poor move. I feel she's opening herself up to potential bullying/grievances/constructive dismissal if she as a manager puts these policies in place. How approachable/supportive would she be if someone called in with a pregnant related illness compared to someone with any other call? If she's leading the call and cba with kiddie chat then just start it with 'Good morning everyone, don't want you stuck on the call for longer than we have to so let's get cracking on point 1'

Xenia · 08/05/2022 07:16

She needs to get a grip. People have children and of course they want to talk about them at work. What would be next? That people who cannot afford to buy a flat could stop flat owners talking about their first flat purchase or cars or the they have a dog (if the other person does not have a flat allowing dogs)? Or the lovely dress you bought (that the rather larger colleague could never fit into so is upset you talked about your dress)?

CounsellorTroi · 08/05/2022 07:14

Ticksallboxes · 08/05/2022 00:41

Cripes! This is next level crazy!

I had my first child at 39 and my second at 42 - she still has time and I think getting wound up about colleagues talking about their DCs will only make her less relaxed and less able to conceive.

I say this because after 18 months of ttc with my first it took a month long break in Australia for me to do so.

Your poor friend is completely wound up like a coil. You need to talk her down, but I realise with her position the stakes are high.

I sincerely hope you don’t tell people IRL who are struggling to conceive that all they need to do is relax and book a holiday.

veronicagoldberg · 08/05/2022 07:13

Absolute madness.

ToyahBattersby · 08/05/2022 07:12

No she is being ridiculous. If we banned talk about every subject that hurt us for whatever reason, nobody would ever speak.

mintybobs · 08/05/2022 07:07

She sounds like she's have a breakdown to me- thats a ridiculous thing to want to "ban". Good grief. I presume she is also willing to police her own topics of conversation then if its painful to others?- eg if someone lost a parent, I presume she will commit to never mentioning her parents?

InvincibleInvisibility · 08/05/2022 06:58

My manager is in her mid 40s, single and childless not through choice. When chatting all together we do try to limit talk about our DC (cos she just sits in a stony silence) however being able to talk about DC at work is a lifeline for many of us.

One colleague recently had a baby and has really appreciated our tips and reassurance. I have just been through both my DC being diagnosed with ADHD and dyspraxia- support from my colleagues has been invaluable. Especially when DS1 has been in crisis and tried to jump out of the window...

Several of us have dual-nationality/ bilingual DC (the nature of our work means that is far more common at work than where we live) and sharing experiences has been interesting and useful.

Following the dianosis of my 2nd DC I've had to ask for flexible hours for his various appointments. Obviously this meant a discussion about DC with my mamager. Fortunately she was lovely and understanding (which is not always the case with her - you never know how she'll react which is very stressful)

KermitlovesKeyLimePie · 08/05/2022 06:57

What next, no talk of food if you are on a diet?

She is being utterly ridiculous and you should tell her so OP.

Starlightstarbright1 · 08/05/2022 06:46

As she is senior not sure how it would be avoided- i last week requested a specific shift off for ds's appointment, another member staff off Dc in hispital.

Tbh a lot of our staffs children are teens and our conversations are more likely to put you off having kids.🤣

mathanxiety · 08/05/2022 05:45

Your colleague is a narcissist and a bully.

Someone needs to tell her to get a grip.

silentpool · 08/05/2022 05:28

She needs grief counselling to get some coping mechanisms in place. I find people talking about their children to be rather dull but it's like any small talk, it's often just to be sociable so we must endure.

doingitforthegirls · 08/05/2022 05:15

Being a parent is about selflessness and putting anothers needs before your self - sacrificing everything even when you have nothing left

If I'm being honest that doesn't sound like your friend even possesses these qualities

She sounds awful and I myself suffered years of infertility and many many losses. I'd never have been so presumptuous or arrogant to have insisted no one else talk about their children

timeisnotaline · 08/05/2022 04:33

Her career progression will be jeaopardised if she even suggests this. The execs will quite rightly think she hasn’t got what it takes to be at the top, either in resilience or understanding and support of others. You’d be doing her a favour to mention it to her. Perhaps suggest she just think about it objectively- it’s not an acceptable work place constraint given the emphasis on ‘bring your whole self to work’ and the pressure on senior leadership to foster an environment of psychological safety for employees.

3g4g5g · 08/05/2022 04:32

Well, she's trying to bully those with children isn't she really. She knows that if she tries to implement a ban on talking about children she'll be accused of discrimination/bullying , so she's trying to get someone higher than her to do it for her. She sounds awful.

timeisnotaline · 08/05/2022 04:28

Wow @deplorabelle I think I wish you could bring yourself to say ‘well they haven’t tried to commit suicide this week so it’s a good week but really talking about my parents is very upsetting and stressful and I’d much rather talk about my kids, tell me again why I have to go through this difficult conversation topic because kids upset some people?’ Have you considered talking to hr and saying the emotional upset is impacting your health?

Loopyloopy · 08/05/2022 04:19

Dinoteeth · 07/05/2022 22:49

What a bazaar thing to try and ban.
What else does she want to stop talk off, parents, grannys, goldfish? Not allowed to mention cutting the grass because Bob lives in a flat.

Nothing beyond the mundane weather?

People talk about the weather & family life because its non controversial. People tend to already avoid politics, and football already.

Even the weather is fraught, what with strong opinions on climate change...

Changechangychange · 08/05/2022 03:27

there’s apparently a specific subset of people below that always talk about their kids in the start of the week catch up

So she has a specific issue with the new mums? Let me guess, no issue with the dads?

She needs to be really careful she doesn’t end up with them complaining about maternity discrimination. It could easily look like she is bullying them for being part time/having childcare commitments.

Changechangychange · 08/05/2022 03:24

Allezvite · 08/05/2022 00:56

If she does have children herself, will the ban be upheld or relaxed at that point? Either no one is ever allowed to mention any of their personal circumstances or relationships, ever again … or she unclenches. She’s being ridiculous. Which doesn’t mean that I don’t have any compassion for her difficulties and her feelings.

Somehow I feel sure that this woman’s child will be the most perfect PFB to have ever been born, and none of her colleagues will ever hear the end of their brilliance Grin