Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rwanda plan

40 replies

Lakia11 · 07/05/2022 17:38

Do you agree with it or not.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Figrolls14 · 07/05/2022 22:59

The plan is an obscenity

BewareTheLibrarians · 07/05/2022 22:53

@Justanotherlurker EA
Who’s the open border crowd? Who are you talking to? What are you reading that no one else can see?? 😂

Not any chance of having a grown up discussion with people who aren’t following or understanding what’s being discussed on the thread like, for e.g, quite basic concepts like resettlement schemes are not “open borders”, they actually allow a country to control immigration. Whereas in the current situation, boat crossings don’t allow you to control numbers, are unexpected and place a burden unfairly on one small section of the country.

As I think I may have already replied to you on a previous thread about Rwanda. If my explanation is somehow confusing, please feel free to ask for clarity, there’s no shame in that, rather than throw around words like “uneducated” when it’s not clear what relevance your comments have to this thread.

BurnDownTheDiscoHangTheDJ · 07/05/2022 22:46

thistimelastweek · 07/05/2022 20:14

The Rwanda plan is inhumane, ugly and lacking in any compassion whatsoever.

A special place in hell for everyone involved in its conception.

This.

it’s disgusting. It won’t happen but the fact they’ve used the idea as red meat for their cruel and unfeeling fans who vote Tory seemingly just to inflict pain on other human beings is vile.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 07/05/2022 22:41

Justanotherlurker · 07/05/2022 22:25

We could control immigration by actually having functional processes that allow us to keep track of overstayers and visa infringements and deal with them effectively so that we have more capacity to take in Asylum seekers.

That's the grown up discussion that is ignored, it's happening in Sweden, Norway, Italy and Germany and there isn't a lot of white middle class women storming the planes on those they do deport for not meeting the criteria.

If the UK was along the lines of the EU on extraditions of asylum seekers there would be outcry from the 'we should do more' crowd.

The ironic situation we are in is that the open boarder crowd are fully mirroring the global capitalist narrative.

border!

Justanotherlurker · 07/05/2022 22:25

We could control immigration by actually having functional processes that allow us to keep track of overstayers and visa infringements and deal with them effectively so that we have more capacity to take in Asylum seekers.

That's the grown up discussion that is ignored, it's happening in Sweden, Norway, Italy and Germany and there isn't a lot of white middle class women storming the planes on those they do deport for not meeting the criteria.

If the UK was along the lines of the EU on extraditions of asylum seekers there would be outcry from the 'we should do more' crowd.

The ironic situation we are in is that the open boarder crowd are fully mirroring the global capitalist narrative.

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 07/05/2022 22:07

In the last week or two there have been over 2000 people crossing the Channel. The plan is to send 300 to Rwanda.
Even if you subscribe to the ridiculous inhumane plan, migrants have a far greater chance of staying in the UK than being sent to Rwanda. Travel with someone who says they're your dependent and you stand a much better chance of staying. Women and children will be bought and sold or kidnapped in the camps.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 07/05/2022 21:45

We could control immigration by actually having functional processes that allow us to keep track of overstayers and visa infringements and deal with them effectively so that we have more capacity to take in Asylum seekers.
^this.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 07/05/2022 21:44

Justanotherlurker · 07/05/2022 21:23

There is a reason why Sweden are having doubts about their migrant situation, Germany is currently kicking out a lot of their recent migrants and Italy, Greece and even france are looking at solutions, until people can have a grown up discussion without resorting to the emotive angle on the subject the Rwanda deal is needed.

It's only the uneducated type who think it's a simplisitc situation of opening boarders, or we should do 'more'

People who accuse others of being uneducated might wish to check how to spell borders.

MayorDusty · 07/05/2022 21:39

@Lakia11 p
what's your take on it? Or are you just blowing the whistle?

EinsteinaGogo · 07/05/2022 21:35

Lakia11 · 07/05/2022 17:38

Do you agree with it or not.

@Lakia11

What do you think, OP? Can you summarise your view of 'the Rwanda plan' as you put it, and we can discuss?

HalfShrunkMoreToGo · 07/05/2022 21:33

Justanotherlurker · 07/05/2022 21:23

There is a reason why Sweden are having doubts about their migrant situation, Germany is currently kicking out a lot of their recent migrants and Italy, Greece and even france are looking at solutions, until people can have a grown up discussion without resorting to the emotive angle on the subject the Rwanda deal is needed.

It's only the uneducated type who think it's a simplisitc situation of opening boarders, or we should do 'more'

Wow, only uneducated people. So those of us who don't think it's humane to ship people to a country renowned for human rights violations and force them to settle there are just a bit thick??

Read up on the experiences of Australia, Israel and Denmark who've tried this plan before and tell me how successful it's likely to be.

We could allow people to apply for Asylum from outside the U.K. we could work with France and other European countries to agree safe migrant routes for asylum seekers to travel and volumes that can be accepted in each country.

We could control immigration by actually having functional processes that allow us to keep track of overstayers and visa infringements and deal with them effectively so that we have more capacity to take in Asylum seekers.

BewareTheLibrarians · 07/05/2022 21:31

@Justanotherlurker It’s not being opposed on solely an emotive angle though, it’s being opposed on an unlawful, unworkable and expensive angle.

Can’t see that anyone on this thread is proposing open borders, or doing “more”. Different strategies like safe routes and resettlement schemes do not mean open borders and increased numbers of asylum seekers. They actually mean more checks and more control on numbers. Which might be an idea to check before you call others uneducated.

Bonjovispjs · 07/05/2022 21:27

Yes!

Justanotherlurker · 07/05/2022 21:23

There is a reason why Sweden are having doubts about their migrant situation, Germany is currently kicking out a lot of their recent migrants and Italy, Greece and even france are looking at solutions, until people can have a grown up discussion without resorting to the emotive angle on the subject the Rwanda deal is needed.

It's only the uneducated type who think it's a simplisitc situation of opening boarders, or we should do 'more'

HalfShrunkMoreToGo · 07/05/2022 20:57

Lakia11 · 07/05/2022 19:57

Are these people crossing the Channel economic seekers in which case they obviously intend to work illegally.

Lots of people make this claim/assumption based on lots of the asylum seekers being young men but let's just think about it a minute.

You're a family in a country dealing with famine/war/religious persecution. Your sons are at risk of being forced to war or imprisoned, your daughters are at risk of forced marriage/rape, all are at risk of starvation. You manage to scrape together the means to send 1 person to try to get out and make a better life so they can maybe help the rest of the family.

Dependent on country/religion your daughter may have very limited education and have been raised to obey men to her own detriment.

Do you send your daughter or your son?

Lonelycrab · 07/05/2022 20:38

So it’s basically a load of old popularist bollocks designed to divide and spread hate, and perhaps pick up some votes along the wayWink

Lonelycrab · 07/05/2022 20:35

To work as a deterrent as is claimed will mean deporting thousands. The costs and legal wrangling will make it unworkable. And it goes against international law.

balalake · 07/05/2022 20:14

This is not a plan to send people to Rwanda, assess their claim, then if successful have them settle in the UK. This is a plan to send them to Rwanda and them have to settle there.

Given there will be legal appeals and probably other means that those who cross the channel in small boats will use to stop being moved to Rwanda from the UK, I don't expect it will have much if any impact in reducing the numbers crossing in small boats. People traffickers will promise they have ways of ensuring those who pay them large amounts of money believe they won't be moved to Rwanda, and frankly if they get their money do not care one bit.

If we had a sensible relationship with France, more chance of this heinous people trafficking being reduced.

thistimelastweek · 07/05/2022 20:14

The Rwanda plan is inhumane, ugly and lacking in any compassion whatsoever.

A special place in hell for everyone involved in its conception.

MrsSchrute · 07/05/2022 20:04

Lakia11 · 07/05/2022 19:57

Are these people crossing the Channel economic seekers in which case they obviously intend to work illegally.

Why obviously?

DoesItEverEnd · 07/05/2022 19:58

No

Lakia11 · 07/05/2022 19:57

Are these people crossing the Channel economic seekers in which case they obviously intend to work illegally.

OP posts:
pointythings · 07/05/2022 18:27

It's inhumane. The UK offers no alternatives. Per head of population the UK is very poor at taking asylum seekers compared to other countries. If you think the Rwanda plan is reasonable then yes, YABVU.

HalfShrunkMoreToGo · 07/05/2022 18:09

Lakia11 · 07/05/2022 17:55

HalfShrunkMoreToGo
I tend to disagree the uk asylum system is very tough with less than half of cases granted.

64% asylum claims are granted on initial application with almost half of appeals being successful.

So yes the majority of asylum requests are granted.

WoodenClock · 07/05/2022 18:07

Even if you thought it was a reasonable thing to do to people, I still don't see how it will solve the crisis of people making the treacherous crossing.

They know it could cost their lives, but they still do it in the hope/expectation that they'll be one of the lucky ones.

As I understand it only a tiny % of the number of people who arrive annually can be accommodated in Rwanda so even if the scheme is implemented, there's still a high chance that someone making the crossing will be lucky and not go to Rwanda.