Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect to be examined and diagnosed by an actual nurse or doctor?

335 replies

Cravela · 07/05/2022 10:36

Stomach pain came on suddenly and worsened over 24 hrs. Telephone appt with GP who advised hospital and sent me to the surgical assessment unit. So far so good

Staff member arrives in scrubs and takes all my details and then starts examining me. Tells me the plan (CT scan) and that she will give pain killers in the meantime.

Noticed she wasn’t wearing a lanyard/badge so I asked her her name Dr?. She says oh I’m not a doctor, ok so you’re a nurse? (No issues with that always choose to see an advance nurse practitioner when I go to the GP and I have a friend who is a consultant nurse). No she says she’s not a nurse. I was getting quite frustrated at this point because she was clearly avoiding just telling me her job role. So I straight out said can you tell me your job role please. She said she was a “physicians associate”.

I’ve never heard of one before so I googled after she left and literally anyone can be one after a 2 year course. They don’t come under the GMC or the nurses governing body and aren’t able to prescribe medicine or diagnose people??

I asked the nurse in charge if I could see a doctor or a surgical nurse and they came 10 mins later. Doctor was quite apologetic and re-examined me.

AIBU to think if you aren’t a doctor or a nurse you should tell people that before you put your hands on them??

OP posts:
Namechanger355 · 07/05/2022 13:34

Mellowyellow222 · 07/05/2022 13:21

@Namechanger355 do you work in the healthcare sector?

I don’t. I flatter myself that I am fairly intelligent and have been quite successful in my field.

but I have never heard of a physician assistant. I have no idea where the stand in the medical profession, what qualifications they have and what they are allowed to do in respect of my care.

i am not being ‘snobby’ but I would expect someone giving me medical care to die today who they are and what their role is. I have never been treated by anyone other than a doctor or nurse and am always aware which one I am dealing with.

there is an arrogance in your response that we should just suck it up, and never question the care we are getting.

that attitude should have died out decades ago. We no longer need to show unquestioning deference to people in the medical field. It is absolutely fine, and indeed to question qualification and ensure we are comfortable with the care we receive.

clearly the medical prefssion need to understand this role is not widely understood. Theta is not the fault of the general public and to suggest it if this lady’s fault is just wrong.

I take your point that there should be more education about these roles. And of course we should question what is being done or given to us - and by whom. I definitely did that during my labour

that said, OP’s post simply stated that the diagnosis should have been given by a doctor or nurse and implied that the PA had done something wrong because she was apparently too low in the food chain

utter nonsense and incredibly insulting- she could simply have asked for further info on the PA role

many PAs are more qualified than nurses. Just because people are not aware of something, does not give them a right to judge

we will see more varying roles like this in the NHs in future - there does need to be more education to avoid confusion but they serve a vital role when our public services are becoming more and more stretched

titchy · 07/05/2022 13:34

Feckingfeck · 07/05/2022 13:22

@titchy

Yes they do earn more than the foundation doctors they compare themselves to and compete for experience with.

The point is that FYs will earn more. Not sure how that's difficult to understand. A PA who's been on the same unit for several years will, as plenty has attested to here, have far greater knowledge than an F1 freshly graduated on their first four month rotation.

Good to hear that the GMC is planning oversee PAs though. Hopefully both roles will develop some respect for each other in due course.

ZealAndArdour · 07/05/2022 13:33

I work with loads of physicians associates and they’re all absolutely fantastic clinicians. I don’t think it’s as simple as “anyone can become one after a two year course”, you need a sciences undergraduate degree with a good classification to do the PA masters. The PA Masters teaches the “medical model” of consultation/practice right from the start.

My best friend is a PA and she did three years of Medical Sciences with a First Class Honours and then straight onto the two year PA Studies Masters. It’s a lot more training than many practice nurses have.

PA’s are an established health care profession in the US, but a relatively new thing here. It’s part of the governments plan to backfill the shortage of doctors. Turn all the nurses, paramedics, physios, OT’s and ODP’s into Advanced Clincial Practitioners and train loads of PA’s. Move all the HCA’s into Nursing Associate rolls and then get them onto Nursing Apprenticeships to make more nurses and so on and so on. I don’t think they’d describe it in those terms but it’s exactly what’s happening in reality. It’s a shame they can’t just improve the contract for junior doctors and make their job attractive, as well medicine more accessible for people from all backgrounds.

olympicsrock · 07/05/2022 13:32

SockFluffInTheBath · 07/05/2022 13:27

I’m pretty sure it was a PA who finally placed the cannula in DD’s tiny vein for her surgery when the radiologist, ward doctor and nurse had failed- that was really not great to watch. He was fantastic and worth his weight in gold just got that.

Yes , being good at cannulas involves lots to practice. A P. A. doing them all the time will be very skilful.

Eucalyptusbee · 07/05/2022 13:32

I wouldn't want decisions on my health to be taken by a PA with maximum 2 years education in a very limited scope vs minimum 6 for a doctor. There is a reason they were being quiet about their actual role- its very limited and for good reason

You were absolutely right to request to be seen by an actual doctor.

Discovereads · 07/05/2022 13:31

Mellowyellow222 · 07/05/2022 13:09

I disagree. We put a huge amount of trust in medical professionals. They should extend the basic courtesy of introducing themselves.

ahe probably does Beal with a lot of people then refusing to be examined by her because they don’t understand her role and qualifications. But there is an attitude in the UK that you should just take what you are given and show deference to anyone in a medical setting. This is wrong and we need to be assertive about our health and our bodies.

Medical professionals Introducing themselves to patients is as you say a courtesy. Whether or not they adhere to such outdated rules of politeness has zero impact on their capability to provide healthcare.

I don’t give a fig if I know the name and exact job title of whoever is examining me when I’m in A&E with severe stomach pain getting triaged. I think getting me scans/tests and a diagnosis are far more important than wasting time on social pleasantries.

Im not showing deference or being unassertive, I’m merely actually prioritising my health and my body by getting straight to accessing care instead of wasting time.

newbiename · 07/05/2022 13:31

Theheartandtheshape · 07/05/2022 10:48

PAs often try to conceal their actual role because most of them failed to get a medical school place and are trying to become doctors through the back door. The ones like in the OP should be reported for misleading patients about their qualifications.

Only doctors should diagnose. ANPs, PAs etc. should be limited to the things they were created to do: lessen the pressure on doctors by doing bloods/cannulas/reviewing chronic stable conditions and very minor illnesses.

Scope and role creep is a huge safety issue in medicine. There is no such thing as a "consultant nurse", just a nurse trying to play doctor.

Do you work for the NHS ? I hope not because what you've written is just not true.

olympicsrock · 07/05/2022 13:30

CraftyGin · 07/05/2022 13:23

My friend is a PA. I think it is a higher qualification than Nurse Practioner.

It’s a different role.
many advanced care practitioners may be from a nursing or physio background. They will have done masters level training and may be an accredited prescriber and be qualified to give ultrasound guided injections. They are highly specialised and an independent practitioner .
A physician associate is there to support doctors with practical and administrative tasks within the supervision of a doctor. They are not independent prescribers or licenced to request radiation tests . The scope of their role is a grey area though and is often extended due to doctor shortages. It’s controversial.

medicmummm · 07/05/2022 13:28

This has turned into an interesting thread.

But ultimately the PA should have introduced herself appropriately, you would expect the same of anyone in a clinical setting. With everyone in scrubs it can just be so unclear.

But OP should have enough faith in the health care system to know nobody under qualified would clinically assess a patient. Attitudes towards other health care professionals can be poor, perhaps its also due to poor education of their roles. But then again thats not a patients issue.

Faith in the health care system.....Perhaps thats where the problem lies.

SockFluffInTheBath · 07/05/2022 13:27

I’m pretty sure it was a PA who finally placed the cannula in DD’s tiny vein for her surgery when the radiologist, ward doctor and nurse had failed- that was really not great to watch. He was fantastic and worth his weight in gold just got that.

Bunnycat101 · 07/05/2022 13:27

Realistically PAs are a solution to the staffing crisis but it’s not going to happen if junior drs hate them and their role isn’t defined well. The reality is the progression and earning opportunities will never be the same for a PA as a doctor but I can see how it must jar in the early stages of training when a PA might be earning more than an F2 with better hours.

olympicsrock · 07/05/2022 13:25

All health care professionals should introduce themselves by name and role. That’s indisputable.

I am a consultant. I often take phone calls from X ‘one of the doctors’ and I ask what grade they are. I have found that PAs often do not introduce themselves by role “I’m Y from the cardiology team”. It’s important to know. I also take referrals from paramedics, practice nurses and podiatrists whereas in previous years it would have been the GP. Sadly GPs who phone have all the patient history but have often not seen the patient face to face.
I do find that nurse /nurse/ podiatry referrals are inaccurate compared to medical ones as they are keen to safety net the patient and get them seen however I would rather see a patient who does not need admission rather than the opposite. This is the reality of the NHS with inadequate resources. It is all hands to the pump!

OssomMummy1 · 07/05/2022 13:24

TheVanguardSix · 07/05/2022 13:23

By the way, we've had them in the States for years. They don't replace doctors, they share the workload.

And they are well regulated in the US. Here?

LouisCatorze · 07/05/2022 13:24

@Cravela a Physician's Assistant is senior to most (other than management) nurses surely? Now even your initial assessment had been by a HCA I could understand your annoyance. YABU. But hope you are better now?

CraftyGin · 07/05/2022 13:23

My friend is a PA. I think it is a higher qualification than Nurse Practioner.

TheVanguardSix · 07/05/2022 13:23

By the way, we've had them in the States for years. They don't replace doctors, they share the workload.

Feckingfeck · 07/05/2022 13:22

@titchy

Yes they do earn more than the foundation doctors they compare themselves to and compete for experience with.

AliceW89 · 07/05/2022 13:22

The Foundation docs do need to appreciate that the Physician asssociates will have good local knowledge of protocols and how to get things done but the P.A. Need to understand that there role is not a training role, it is for service and to allow training time for the post grad doctors

This is spot on. When I’m oncall on medical admissions, the 3 or 4 PAs there have been very useful and friendly. They know how the ward works, they know how different consultants like things and they know how to get things done. I’ve never seen issue with job roll crossover - things like lumbar punctures and ascitic taps are done by the SHOs without question. I get it must be difficult for @SullyB (who’s post was also very good!) - I suspect it’s generally more difficult on surgery anyway.

TheVanguardSix · 07/05/2022 13:21

She made the right call and you're complaining??
You got diagnosed courtesy of the results of the CT scan she'd suggested, a suggestion she would have absolutely run by the duty doctor.
She did all the right things.

You were in the hands of a qualified clinician who made clinical observations and then discussed decisions with the duty doctor. She would be part of a decision-making process, not the sole person deciding on your treatment but suggesting to the doctors what she thinks might be a suitable way forward.
Was she right or was she right?

I don't understand why you're upset. Because she's too far down on the food chain in terms of qualifications? Was she holding a bucket and mop? No.
You were accurately and swiftly diagnosed and now you can have a treatment plan in place. Excellent result.

Feckingfeck · 07/05/2022 13:21

@SullyB

Spot on.

Thats the issue, but in a triage situation it may present an issue when a patient has multiple pathologies or present atypically.

Mellowyellow222 · 07/05/2022 13:21

@Namechanger355 do you work in the healthcare sector?

I don’t. I flatter myself that I am fairly intelligent and have been quite successful in my field.

but I have never heard of a physician assistant. I have no idea where the stand in the medical profession, what qualifications they have and what they are allowed to do in respect of my care.

i am not being ‘snobby’ but I would expect someone giving me medical care to die today who they are and what their role is. I have never been treated by anyone other than a doctor or nurse and am always aware which one I am dealing with.

there is an arrogance in your response that we should just suck it up, and never question the care we are getting.

that attitude should have died out decades ago. We no longer need to show unquestioning deference to people in the medical field. It is absolutely fine, and indeed to question qualification and ensure we are comfortable with the care we receive.

clearly the medical prefssion need to understand this role is not widely understood. Theta is not the fault of the general public and to suggest it if this lady’s fault is just wrong.

OssomMummy1 · 07/05/2022 13:20

SullyB · 07/05/2022 13:14

One of my registrars made a good observation

“they can tell you what needs doing and how but they can’t tell you why”.

So they know that x and y symptoms need a and b test, but any questioning as to the mechanism behind it they falter and fall apart. They don’t have the broad knowledge doctors do. That’s just a fact.

That’s because medical skills can be copied by observing but not medical knowledge. There is no end to medical knowledge. ODPs, midwives, ANPs guide and help when junior doctors do something wrong technicwise. Don’t they?

SullyB · 07/05/2022 13:20

Feckingfeck · 07/05/2022 13:16

But what would career progression for a PA look like?

Yes they are great in their roles. But then you get some that think they are above their station and do very little, handing all jobs to the foundation doctors and just wanting to enjoy going to theatre. A rota of ward vs theatre would be the only fair thing but who would prescribe on the ward and order imaging?

Career progression at the moment is zilch in acute care, they are ward monkeys.

Personally I don’t and won’t rota them for theatres. My consultants are very strict on who they will have in theatre with them and I respect that. For big cases there are often 2 consultants, an ST7/8, surgical care practitioners and 1 space for a junior to observe and maybe hold something. I’m not going to say a PA can go over a junior who intends to do surgical and is desperately trying to get a training number. Not going to happen and the consultants would hang me anyway!

Samiamnot · 07/05/2022 13:19

PakkaMakka · 07/05/2022 12:42

@Samiamnot there is no such thing as a conversion course for social work in the UK.
In England and Wales the options are a 3yr degree course, a two year MA course, a two year on the job training course (only available to people with a relevant degree at 2:1 and above) or a three year apprenticeship. After training social workers complete an assessed year in employment and as with any other profession, have to do ongoing CPD to maintain registration.

Please don't spout nonsense, it is scaremongering and unhelpful to vulnerable people who use those services.

Should have specified I was talking about teachers. Not scaremongering at all. Just sharing experience...as is the intention of a discussion forum.

My good friend is a social worker. She trained for 3 years. Her first year employed she was given double the caseload as her team was so thin on the ground and her mentor was off sick and there was no one available to support her. Not ideal.

But it's not scaremongering to state facts. Public services have been aroded to bare bones and people are suffering because of it. Who does it serve to pretend that our public services are all top notch and fit for service when everyone can see they are all on their knees and close to collapse?

I am a public servant by the way. I'm talking from in the trenches.

titchy · 07/05/2022 13:18

Feckingfeck · 07/05/2022 13:09

@titchy

It was more of a sarcastic joke... i'm more senior. But for the lack of responsibility its a good pay packet. However, who would want to still be doing junior doctor type roles in their 50s 🧐 would be exhausting!

It wasn't though. Virtually every post of yours you've pointed out how much more PAs earn compared to doctors. And it's not true. Band 7s earn between £40k and £45k. That's the same as a someone in their first year of specialty training - ie once the FYs are completed. And beyond that clearly you will earn far far more than a PA ever will. So your posts are disingenuous to say the least.