Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect to be examined and diagnosed by an actual nurse or doctor?

335 replies

Cravela · 07/05/2022 10:36

Stomach pain came on suddenly and worsened over 24 hrs. Telephone appt with GP who advised hospital and sent me to the surgical assessment unit. So far so good

Staff member arrives in scrubs and takes all my details and then starts examining me. Tells me the plan (CT scan) and that she will give pain killers in the meantime.

Noticed she wasn’t wearing a lanyard/badge so I asked her her name Dr?. She says oh I’m not a doctor, ok so you’re a nurse? (No issues with that always choose to see an advance nurse practitioner when I go to the GP and I have a friend who is a consultant nurse). No she says she’s not a nurse. I was getting quite frustrated at this point because she was clearly avoiding just telling me her job role. So I straight out said can you tell me your job role please. She said she was a “physicians associate”.

I’ve never heard of one before so I googled after she left and literally anyone can be one after a 2 year course. They don’t come under the GMC or the nurses governing body and aren’t able to prescribe medicine or diagnose people??

I asked the nurse in charge if I could see a doctor or a surgical nurse and they came 10 mins later. Doctor was quite apologetic and re-examined me.

AIBU to think if you aren’t a doctor or a nurse you should tell people that before you put your hands on them??

OP posts:
OssomMummy1 · 07/05/2022 17:47

707smile · 07/05/2022 16:09

I think PAs probably have more medical knowledge than most nurses. Some (not all) nurses with two-year diplomas (from the pre-degree days) really don't know a lot. I'd much rather be assessed by someone with a 3+ year science degree + a 2 year physician's associate qualification; than someone with just a 2-year diploma and perhaps without the academic achievements needed to do a science degree.

I strongly disagree. Nurses do have good knowledge and skills but they deskill themselves for unknown reasons by sticking to the routine like filling the forms, ticking the boxes on computer, routine care etc. Very few are willing to challenge the doctors; they prefer making anonymous complaints. The only nurses I have seen that stand up to the doctors of all grades are either infection control nurses or a few band 8 nurses. This is NHS culture. The same is not true in the US. I really don’t know why the nurses in the UK are so naïve? Please speak up. I am open for any criticism or comments.

OssomMummy1 · 07/05/2022 17:41

MallampatiCatty · 07/05/2022 13:52

OP I think there's been a bit of a misunderstanding here.

  1. The lack of title on ID badge is a massive issue at our trust ; we aren't allowed our title on it! It drives me mad and it's something I'm fighting to change as doctors turn up to cardiac arrests and no one knows who is who, who is senior, what department everyone is from etc. It's dangerous but not our fault as employees unfortunately.
  1. PAs are a qualified medical professional who have more freedom and diagnostic ability than the majority of nurses. They should've stated their title, I absolutely agree with that. But they work at the level of a junior doctor, they just can't order scans or prescribe without someone checking it. They will in time have the ability to prescribe, like advanced nurse practitioners and pharmacists once they've done an independent prescribing course. To say you want an actual nurse to diagnose you is no different. They're all allied health professionals and their opinions are valid. Furthermore, ALL junior doctors work under supervision, like the PAs do. As a foundation doctor, yes they can request scans but certainly for FY1s in a&e, every single patient plan needs to be discussed with a senior first. The same will be for the PA. They won't be able to diagnose you alone for many cases, like the FY1s. They need to take your history and then present it and discuss together with a senior. In A&E this is done out of earshot of the patient so you won't know all juniors are doing this. It is documented in the notes who the senior is they've discussed it with, for medicolegal reasons.

I've honestly not worked with many PAs. There just aren't many yet in my trust. I am generally on board with them as long as they do night shifts, which in my old trust they didn't and took day shifts from doctors and meant the drs ended up doing more nights. I am not on board with, however, anaesthetic associates as i find the concept unsafe. Story for another day!

Unrelated but just for anyone that hasn't met an advanced nurse practitioner before, they are absolutely fantastic in a&e and are worth their weight in gold. We need so many more!

Hope you're feeling better Smile

From your name or pseudonym, I can confidently say that you are an anaesthetic trainee. So, you feel that PAs are unsafe in your specialty but okay in others? I have seen anaesthetic consultants running double theatres in a tertiary hospitals with two AAs safely. Do you not think, you are “double standards “?

Tincat · 07/05/2022 17:15

I am in NHS

I would not mind being seen and assessed by a PA, ANP or nurse consultant, FY1, staff nurse or other. All add to the team - all are trained highly and professional.

Another great myth is the wage of doctors 😂
ANPs salary can be substantially higher than GPs

They probably should have introduced themselves though.

Crinklecuts · 07/05/2022 16:47

@olympicsrock actually the new term is “central Doctor”.

707smile · 07/05/2022 16:09

I think PAs probably have more medical knowledge than most nurses. Some (not all) nurses with two-year diplomas (from the pre-degree days) really don't know a lot. I'd much rather be assessed by someone with a 3+ year science degree + a 2 year physician's associate qualification; than someone with just a 2-year diploma and perhaps without the academic achievements needed to do a science degree.

medicmummm · 07/05/2022 15:54

@Itwillkiiilllll

PAs assist in theatre where I have worked. They are training them to assist when there aren't enough junior doctors?! They even do procedures like abscesses observed. The trust pay for their training courses too (while the doctors have to self fund)

cocktailclub · 07/05/2022 15:39

There aren't enough doctors so I guess you will have to get used to PAs as they are the future.
I wouldn't have a problem, you get rubbish sea and nurses too so it is all about the individual and how competent they are.
I do think it's wrong they didn't introduce them self as pp have said.
All you drs looking down on PAs, count yourself fortune to have been able to attend medical school.

Ireolu · 07/05/2022 15:31

I work with a PA and she is a better clinician than some of the doctors at the practice. I was a naysayer not anymore.

SoftSheen · 07/05/2022 15:30

Itwillkiiilllll · 07/05/2022 15:25

PAs should not be assisting in theatre as they are not qualified to do so. It should be an SCP or SFA assisting according to RCS guidelines.

PAs will soon be regulated by the GMC (potentially from Summer 2023).

TankFlyBossW4lk · 07/05/2022 15:27

I'm really shocked at this thread. It's probably fairly similar to having an FYI , at least.

Anyway, I hope you all get used to PAs. They are cheaper than doctors and there will be many many more of them soon. There is a massive shortage of qualified doctors which is getting worse because the working conditions are so poor. But this is what the country voted for.

Itwillkiiilllll · 07/05/2022 15:25

SullyB · 07/05/2022 13:06

Very interesting thread.

Name changed due to job role but non-clinical NHS. We have huge issues within our service between juniors and PAs. Acute surgical specialty.

PA feels they don’t get respect for their job role. Juniors feel PAs are taking away training opportunities from them.

PA stays with our service so has more knowledge of how the ward round works, specialty specific tests and conditions. Juniors have more broad knowledge overall and they are there to learn (but rotate every 4 months).

Juniors resent being told what to do by the PA who then needs to come and ask them to sign a prescription or imaging request. PA is disappointed that the role isn’t what they thought it would be (ie they want to go to theatre/clinic etc but really they are doing the grunt work of an F1 without the prospect of advancing on).

I do nothing but referee arguments between them! Secretly I’m on the side of the juniors, PA portrays themselves as SHO level and wants to do the same thing they are doing but I’m not letting a PA take a spare slot in theatre over an SHO. They need to build their portfolio and need the training opportunities especially in competitive fields.

on top of that they have no regulatory body, no guidelines as to their scope of practice. It’s far too wooly for my liking.

PAs should not be assisting in theatre as they are not qualified to do so. It should be an SCP or SFA assisting according to RCS guidelines.

endofthelinefinally · 07/05/2022 15:17

SunshineCake1 · 07/05/2022 15:09

I had a receptionist tell me my blood tests were all okay only to discovered yesterday they aren't. Then this week another receptionist told me my scan was okay then a few hours later I spoke to a doctor who said I needed referring. Not impressed.

What has that got to do with PAs?

SoftSheen · 07/05/2022 15:15

Some PAs probably did fail to get into medical school, but so what? Not everyone is capable of being a doctor. Doesn't mean that they're not capable of taking on any other responsible role. (I'm not a PA by the way!).

endofthelinefinally · 07/05/2022 15:12

The PA who did my last lumbar puncture was excellent. Working full time in a neurological specialist diagnostic unit, she does around 20 LPs a day. She had a clear name badge and introduced herself correctly before asking for my consent. She was absolutely lovely and very skilled. Just the sort of person you need in a unit like that, everything organised and no waiting about. She had been a nurse practitioner and had undergone further training. There is definitely a place for this type of HCP IMO.

SoftSheen · 07/05/2022 15:09

YABU, Physician associates are qualified medical professionals and diagnosis is part of their job. No, they're not doctors, but neither are nurses or paramedics which presumably you don't have a problem with...

They're a new role in the UK (soon to be regulated by the GMC) but PAs have been working in the US for many years.

SunshineCake1 · 07/05/2022 15:09

I had a receptionist tell me my blood tests were all okay only to discovered yesterday they aren't. Then this week another receptionist told me my scan was okay then a few hours later I spoke to a doctor who said I needed referring. Not impressed.

Badgirlriri · 07/05/2022 15:09

Pyewhacket · 07/05/2022 13:06

Don't be pedandic, it's painful, or you are.

I work on an ICU unit and they just get in the way. Also the ones I met had no previous medical experience in emergency medicine so I had to double check everything she did. It just made more work. I'm glad to say we longer have them on our unit.

Pyewhacket is a great example of the bullying and hierarchy that exists in the NHS.

Choufleurfromage · 07/05/2022 14:56

newbiename · 07/05/2022 13:31

Do you work for the NHS ? I hope not because what you've written is just not true.

This sounds very much like someone who works in the NHS - scope and role creep is a phrase being bandied about a lot at the moment. Usually by those very insecure in their own role...

ZealAndArdour · 07/05/2022 14:47

So much obsession by alleged doctors and lay people on this thread with hierarchy and who is more highly qualified than who.

And whoever the PP was who said ANP’s should do what they’re meant to do and relieve pressure off doctors by doing bloods and cannula’s 😂I’m assuming hasn’t worked in the NHS for a very long time or ever. That would be a massive underutilisation of skills. You can teach venepunture and cannulation in a day or two given enough opportunities, which begs the question on why they’re all doing a three year masters in Advanced Clinical Practice? Oh yeah, to practice in a clinically advanced role, not to do basic clinical skills which are obtained in the first six months as a newly qualified. The ACP’s/ANP’s in my trust work on the Middle Grade Doctors rota and their clinical supervisors are the Consultants rather than the Nurse in Charge. In most trusts the HCA’s/HCSW’s do the bloods, cannulae, ECG’s and catheterisations and they’re usually very bloody good at it.

vdbfamily · 07/05/2022 14:46

YANBU to have expected any healthcare professional to not only be wearing a security badge starting their name and job title, but also to have started the conversation with " hello , my name is Jo Bloggs. I am a physician's assistant( if a job patient unlikely to have heard of, followed by, that means I work alongside the doctors to help establish what is causing your symptoms etc etc) and finally to ask if patient consents to you assessing them.
I manage a team of Occupational therapists and they are expected to introduce themselves and gain consent for every intervention and have to document that this happened. It is very basic manners really.

However YABU to think a PA incapable of doing the job. They would , I hope, be liasing closely with a registrar or consultant. Maybe if they had explained their role you may have felt more comfortable and confident.

ChloeHel · 07/05/2022 14:32

Anyone in any healthcare setting should introduce themselves “Hi, I’m so and so and I’m the (job title)”

Bur yeah I do think YABU to say if you aren’t a doctor or nurse you shouldn’t put your hands on someone. A physicians associates literal job description is to support doctors with the diagnosing and management of patients, with one of their main roles to physically assess someone. They are far from uneducated HCP’s too, they have to complete a bioscience degree before hand which are usually 3 years and then 2 years training as a physician associate. Some physicians associates can already be qualified nurses, midwives, pharmacists etc who want to further their career. So maybe do a bit more research before jumping to the conclusion that they aren’t trained.

lljkk · 07/05/2022 14:32

my cousin's girlf went to & finished medical school - am fairly sure she's working as a PA in USA. It's better money, nicer job & quality of life than if she fully qualified as 'medical doctor'.

DilemmaBlah · 07/05/2022 14:27

A lot of paramedics are moving into hospitals and primary care now they can independently prescribe. It’s nice that more doors are opening for career progression. One paramedic I know is now an ACP in cardiology and they are fantastic.

They aren’t a “failed doctor” as one previous poster so rudely put it. They are simply expanding their own career now that the opportunities are there. It’s enriching their development and career pathway.

Feckingfeck · 07/05/2022 14:25

@titchy

Hard to understand 🤨 okay.

Perhaps its why there are issues between the 2 groups of staff is all.

What about those in lower grade trust jobs?

itsgettingweird · 07/05/2022 14:24

If they are recognised professionals with a role they should also have a lanyard.

It sounds like she was doing her job but to not be recognisable to patients or have the nhs recognise or advertise her role is pretty bad imo.

Hope you feel better soon. Gallstones are the pits Flowers