Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect to be examined and diagnosed by an actual nurse or doctor?

335 replies

Cravela · 07/05/2022 10:36

Stomach pain came on suddenly and worsened over 24 hrs. Telephone appt with GP who advised hospital and sent me to the surgical assessment unit. So far so good

Staff member arrives in scrubs and takes all my details and then starts examining me. Tells me the plan (CT scan) and that she will give pain killers in the meantime.

Noticed she wasn’t wearing a lanyard/badge so I asked her her name Dr?. She says oh I’m not a doctor, ok so you’re a nurse? (No issues with that always choose to see an advance nurse practitioner when I go to the GP and I have a friend who is a consultant nurse). No she says she’s not a nurse. I was getting quite frustrated at this point because she was clearly avoiding just telling me her job role. So I straight out said can you tell me your job role please. She said she was a “physicians associate”.

I’ve never heard of one before so I googled after she left and literally anyone can be one after a 2 year course. They don’t come under the GMC or the nurses governing body and aren’t able to prescribe medicine or diagnose people??

I asked the nurse in charge if I could see a doctor or a surgical nurse and they came 10 mins later. Doctor was quite apologetic and re-examined me.

AIBU to think if you aren’t a doctor or a nurse you should tell people that before you put your hands on them??

OP posts:
lljkk · 08/05/2022 08:02

The staff shortage in NHS for many sorts of clinical staff is severe.

Junepassing · 08/05/2022 07:35

I'm not confusing GCSEs with A Levels before anyone asks, no A Levels required, no GCSEs either, that's basic numeracy and literacy, I was quite shocked - it seems like an awful lot to condense into a year!

mustlovegin · 08/05/2022 07:33

YANBU OP and I would have asked to see a doctor also in your situation

mustlovegin · 08/05/2022 07:32

most years there are newly qualified medics with no job. No point the Gov funding another 1000 med school places if that leads in five years time to 1000 unemployed medicine grads

Why are we seeing so many GPs, nurses, etc coming from abroad then? I don't see the rationale here and it's unlikely that there are so many UK unemployed medicine grads

Junepassing · 08/05/2022 07:31

As others have pointed out they are highly trained and regulated! (I'm not a PA, but I have heard of them.) I'm astonished at your insistence that you see an 'actual nurse'. Our local uni offers the nursing course with a foundation year - entry requirements - no GCSEs necessary and no prior experience needed . .

mustlovegin · 08/05/2022 07:30

But they get paid more than the doctor who orders their scan and prescribes for them 🤨 and work less hours too

How is this possible?

RosesAndHellebores · 08/05/2022 07:17

@BabyBin "She" is perfectly obvious and using it as a pronoun linked to the F1 is entirely correct usage in text. I absolutely will not be grateful for sub-optimal care delivered in a less than respectful manner. If, as an HCP, you think that's something to be grateful for and far worse happens, the NHS needs to cease immediately.

We have a home in France and I can assure you the French system is a zillion times better than here and the poor have a safety net to ensure access.

Choufleurfromage · 08/05/2022 06:50

SoftSheen · 07/05/2022 15:30

PAs will soon be regulated by the GMC (potentially from Summer 2023).

They currently regulated by the Healthvand Care Professionals Council

sashh · 08/05/2022 05:42

TheNinny · 07/05/2022 11:11

They are highly trained and the course is extensive. I was a PA in another country and the entry requirements (after completing a 4 year bachelors degree) are extremely high. The just ‘2 years’ masters degree (U.S.) included the same classroom hours as a 4 year medical degree at that time and there was almost no time off. They are often used in roles at the same level as an ANP or nurse practitioner, the difference being the model of which they are trained.

They aren’t commonly used in the UK as the push back from doctors has been huge as they are viewed as failed doctors/job stealers but this isn’t true at all and one of the reasons I don’t work as one here. I think they would help with the significant pressures on NHS if utilised. But I do see where the confusion would be in terms of role.

I think the pushback was also from nurses. As I understand things nurses in the US don't or didn't do a lot of things UK nurses do so PA's were something of a hybrid.

So a nurse in the US did not do sutures, doctors did and then PAs did as well, but it would be unusual to find a nurse in the UK who has never sutured a patient.

BabyBin · 08/05/2022 00:09

Also who is she?

OP has gallstones 🤔

BabyBin · 08/05/2022 00:08

RosesAndHellebores · 07/05/2022 22:58

@BabyBin the need for the scan arose from the failure of an F1 to diagnose a broken vertebrae in A&E. She was categorically told the pain was exactly the same as when I broke the L1 6 years previously. I was told that couldn't be the case as I couldn't feel pain when she pressed my spine (I was tanked on morphine). She insisted I didn't need an XRay. I insisted I did and was told I needed to be mindful of the risks of radiation. I said I wouldn't argue but could she please note I had requested a spine XRay and she'd refused it. So she spoke to a senior who authorised it. She categorically told me there was only an old fracture. In fact the T12 had fractured that day. She failed completely to listen or take on board the fact that I had osteoporosis and had had 5 rounds of zolendronate.

I am sick and tired of the incompetence and the rudeness.

But assuming all clinicians are incompetent is very unfair.

A blanket "the NHS are crap" response really puts down the people who work very hard to keep the cogs turning in what is a broken system.

You should really be more grateful, trust me. I have seen a whole lot worse.

DilemmaBlah · 08/05/2022 00:04

We still have grades on our epaulettes though so that’s something I suppose.

DilemmaBlah · 08/05/2022 00:04

They removed our names from our uniform too, which is a nightmare when trying to run a complex job prehospital…..ALS, polytrauma etc. It goes against all human factors teaching which encourages use of names etc.

MallampatiCatty · 07/05/2022 23:51

@Feckingfeck haha absolutely. I'm keen to audit it but apparently I won't win and they won't be changed so I'm still digging up evidence that clear ID badges with titles are needed. It's mad we don't have them already and I fully agree with the OP that clear introductions and a badge with title on are absolutely essential

MallampatiCatty · 07/05/2022 23:48

@OssomMummy1 no, I don't think it's double standards at all. Airway emergencies happen in the blink of an eye, it's different on the wards and ED there's decent supervision. I'd want an anaesthetist overseeing the progression of any deterioration from start to finish so they can accurately diagnose and manage from the offset. Whether it's a tube out, machine /monitoring error, malignant hyperthermia, wrong drug administered, whatever. Even Anaphylaxis isn't always obvious and if you as the anaesthetist administer the drugs yourself, are aware of the progression of the surgery ie latex catheter going in, it's much more straightforward and you buy precious time.

Furthermore, two emergencies happen at once in two theatres. Then what? And the consultant is responsible for both. Mad. We've had two anaphylaxes in two theatres within the hour in our theatre complex in the last 6 months. One arrested. Unrelated, different drugs.

I know it's commonplace abroad and in some tertiary centres here. I'm dual nationality and it's why I work here rather than there. It didn't work there and I don't want to work in a similar system until I can see it work safely. I've worked with PAs on the wards. They're good, hard working colleagues who are a credit to the NHS, it's nothing personal.

If AAs are so safe then why do CT1s require SO much supervision in their novice period and beyond vs f1s who are allowed to see their own patients in ED and present back remotely? Whole different ballgame, even for doctors. Same with non airway trained fellows on ICU, they're very supervised.

Would you leave a foundation doctor to manage resus with regs down in minors? I wouldn't personally. It's not fair on them. I've done my time in ED, the wards, ICU and theatres so I'm only basing off personal experiences and fully respect peoples experience vary though.

RosesAndHellebores · 07/05/2022 22:58

@BabyBin the need for the scan arose from the failure of an F1 to diagnose a broken vertebrae in A&E. She was categorically told the pain was exactly the same as when I broke the L1 6 years previously. I was told that couldn't be the case as I couldn't feel pain when she pressed my spine (I was tanked on morphine). She insisted I didn't need an XRay. I insisted I did and was told I needed to be mindful of the risks of radiation. I said I wouldn't argue but could she please note I had requested a spine XRay and she'd refused it. So she spoke to a senior who authorised it. She categorically told me there was only an old fracture. In fact the T12 had fractured that day. She failed completely to listen or take on board the fact that I had osteoporosis and had had 5 rounds of zolendronate.

I am sick and tired of the incompetence and the rudeness.

gruffnugg · 07/05/2022 22:54

Theheartandtheshape · 07/05/2022 22:42

  • Force f1s to rotate every 4 months so they can act as service provision in shit departments they have no choice over and consultants can be arsed to train as "they'll be moving on anyway". Pay them £28k and rota them for nights and weekends. Call them "Dr".
  • Pay some random people £40k to do a 9-5 Mon-Fri, with the freedom to leave a shit job if they want, give them clinic and theatre time because consultants can be arsed to train them up. Call them "PAs".

The NHS is broken

Yep this is it.

ANP2020 · 07/05/2022 22:52

Your information is wrong, a nurse does 3 years training. A nurse practitioner does an additional 2.5 years training at masters level now including prescribing and are taught diagnostics and are able to diagnose, treat and prescribe organise tests etc. 1.5 years of this training they spend with a medical mentor shadowing/teaching them so a GP/ doctor. They’re also paid B7-8 depending on area and negotiated higher than this salaries in GPS.

doggyweewee · 07/05/2022 22:49

Theheartandtheshape · 07/05/2022 22:42

  • Force f1s to rotate every 4 months so they can act as service provision in shit departments they have no choice over and consultants can be arsed to train as "they'll be moving on anyway". Pay them £28k and rota them for nights and weekends. Call them "Dr".
  • Pay some random people £40k to do a 9-5 Mon-Fri, with the freedom to leave a shit job if they want, give them clinic and theatre time because consultants can be arsed to train them up. Call them "PAs".

The NHS is broken

👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

Grumpybutfunny · 07/05/2022 22:43

YANBU she should have introduced herself.

However the NHS is a multidisciplinary team who all work together to get the best outcome for the patient.

Would you not want the HCA to be doing your obs and notice you are deteriorating from the early warming score?

The independent prescriber nurse getting you painkillers for your condition because the junior + reg is currently occupied with the lady two bays down who is bleeding?

What about the scientist waking the consultant at 3am to let them know you have an acute leukaemia whilst the F1 is still thinking about the results?

What about the pharmacist making your chemo, when the consultant wouldn't know where to start?

The clinical perfusionist keeping your brain supplied with oxygen whilst your on bypass, sure they aren't a doctor they can go aswell.

The paramedic who has prescribing rights is okay at the scene of your accident right? They aren't a nurse or a doctor so I assume they are the same as a taxi driver?

A lot of conditions are managed using set procedures which can be initiated by someone who doesn't have MBBS after there name. If we want a NHS which is free at point of use we need to use our staff more appropriately. It is likely that PA's along with a host of other allied healthcare professionals will get PGD rights in the next few years.

As a HCP (not a doctor but I can put some letters after my name ) it doesn't bother me what the persons tittle is aslong as they can treat the condition, so I can get on with my life I am happy. Unless it involves bloods in which case send in the HCA not the F1/2 please I'm begging you!!!

Theheartandtheshape · 07/05/2022 22:42
  • Force f1s to rotate every 4 months so they can act as service provision in shit departments they have no choice over and consultants can be arsed to train as "they'll be moving on anyway". Pay them £28k and rota them for nights and weekends. Call them "Dr".
  • Pay some random people £40k to do a 9-5 Mon-Fri, with the freedom to leave a shit job if they want, give them clinic and theatre time because consultants can be arsed to train them up. Call them "PAs".

The NHS is broken

justasking111 · 07/05/2022 22:38

jnh22 · 07/05/2022 22:14

This is my experience, as well.

I wish the powers that be would stop junior doctors rotating so often. No-one likes it and there are serious drawbacks to it.

Friends son medicine in Manchester Fourth year. He makes my head spin with his tearing around different hospitals spending a few weeks on each department. So much time spent commuting between them. He's overweight, pallid skin, seriously unhealthy lifestyle just now. I marvel at his stamina.

Another friends son will be a consultant next year he has been told life will be less hectic then.

There's no logical continuity for either of them yet

Feckingfeck · 07/05/2022 22:27

@titchy

Completely agree.

There are already many underrepresented specialities not covered enough by foundation rotations.

The old pure medical or surgical jobs don't exist anymore.

BabyBin · 07/05/2022 22:25

RosesAndHellebores · 07/05/2022 22:17

@Feckingfeck two things: one the NHS is not free, it is free at the point of delivery. Two, I take an expectation of optimal care, delivered kindly and expertly for granted yes.

For far too long in the UK we have been expected to put up with sub-optimal care delivered with zero respect. It isn't free; it has to change.

On Tuesday I had a hospital appointment. Someone in a white tunic called me for a scan. I have no idea of her name or her role. She then sat me down and asked for the questionnaire I'd completed and proceeded to go over every single question - I imagine because it's assumed the thicko patient receiving free care can't accurately complete a form. It was beyond patronising as was the assumption she could use my first name without asking.

My basic expectation is to deal with respectful humans who are able to treat me as their equal.

Vive la revolution.

When some have delivered care in third world countries

🙄

The system isn't perfect but we should not take it for granted. Would you rather a mistake be made with you or another patient if the list wasn't checked? Would your life be changed if she introduced herself, she is taking an image not intimately questioning or examining you nor taking responsibility for your care so this seems a bit pedantic.

titchy · 07/05/2022 22:21

jnh22 · 07/05/2022 22:14

This is my experience, as well.

I wish the powers that be would stop junior doctors rotating so often. No-one likes it and there are serious drawbacks to it.

Genuine question - if FYs don't rotate how are they supposed to make an informed decision about their speciality?