Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect to be examined and diagnosed by an actual nurse or doctor?

335 replies

Cravela · 07/05/2022 10:36

Stomach pain came on suddenly and worsened over 24 hrs. Telephone appt with GP who advised hospital and sent me to the surgical assessment unit. So far so good

Staff member arrives in scrubs and takes all my details and then starts examining me. Tells me the plan (CT scan) and that she will give pain killers in the meantime.

Noticed she wasn’t wearing a lanyard/badge so I asked her her name Dr?. She says oh I’m not a doctor, ok so you’re a nurse? (No issues with that always choose to see an advance nurse practitioner when I go to the GP and I have a friend who is a consultant nurse). No she says she’s not a nurse. I was getting quite frustrated at this point because she was clearly avoiding just telling me her job role. So I straight out said can you tell me your job role please. She said she was a “physicians associate”.

I’ve never heard of one before so I googled after she left and literally anyone can be one after a 2 year course. They don’t come under the GMC or the nurses governing body and aren’t able to prescribe medicine or diagnose people??

I asked the nurse in charge if I could see a doctor or a surgical nurse and they came 10 mins later. Doctor was quite apologetic and re-examined me.

AIBU to think if you aren’t a doctor or a nurse you should tell people that before you put your hands on them??

OP posts:
EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 08/05/2022 11:56

My NHS physio ordered one, it seems a bit weird that a physio can but a GP can't. (Not dissing physios, by the way, I've had really excellent treatment from them.)

Well, we're getting Integrated Care Systems as a replacement for Clinical Commissioning Groups later this year so we'll see what shakes out. There will plausibly still be substantial variation from one region to another.

Crinklecuts · 08/05/2022 11:47

lljkk · 08/05/2022 09:36

hmmm
8209 FY1 places allocated, 791 newly qualified doctors were placed on wait list for FY1 places. But "everyone on the reserve list will be allocated their foundation school in April, moving into their Foundation Year 1 posts from August 2022".

How many unemployed UK-trained doctors are there who have at least 5 years experience?

@lljkk

The last couple of years they have “created more jobs”, but there was a year they didn’t and the anxiety associated with that for fresh Graduates is immense. I think the increase is do to RTLM with Doctors added to the shortage occupation list so they can apply from all over the world and are on an equal footing with U.K. grads. That’s only for Foundation, when you get into specialty training there are literally not enough spots and they don’t create more instead people go to Australia/get stuck in non-training jobs/locum.

In addition, changing hospitals every 4/6/12 months mean quite long commutes for some. It’s not that unusual of to have one hospital for Foundation/GP/ speciality training and another with an hour and half commute which forces juniors to move every year.

Anecdotally, from scouring social media there are many Drs from abroad with 5 years experience + that cannot find jobs.

Honestly, I think that PA job sounds great. Conditions seem much better than those that Doctors get. Imagine not knowing if you got the annual leave you requested until 3 weeks before ? Imagine not being able to book more than 3 days of annual leave in succession. It’s no wonder that our Doctors are contemplating leaving/career changes.

They have also created a GP apprenticeships that don’t require you to go to university and complete a traditional medical degree you can read about it in the pulse.

The things is ….. people are getting older and living longer and we have more tests and interventions( amazing we are doing a good job), however, this increases workload in itself. It’s takes a long time to produce a Doctor so they need to plug the gaps….. viola ! The PA/ANP etc. I think we need them!

To answer the original point of the thread. There just needs to be more role definition maybe a different uniform. Tbh I think docs should be wearing a uniform too e.g colour of scrubs to indicate seniority and a picture displayed for patients so they can understand who is treating them.

titchy · 08/05/2022 11:13

mustlovegin · 08/05/2022 07:32

most years there are newly qualified medics with no job. No point the Gov funding another 1000 med school places if that leads in five years time to 1000 unemployed medicine grads

Why are we seeing so many GPs, nurses, etc coming from abroad then? I don't see the rationale here and it's unlikely that there are so many UK unemployed medicine grads

Every year there are a couple of hundred graduates who have not been able to secure an F1 position. There's threads each year!

RosesAndHellebores · 08/05/2022 11:06

So the twerp who examined me and failed to listen, failed to take on board the fact I was tanked on morphine, told me I had to trust her because she'd been to medical school and told me I needed to be mindful of the risks of radiation if I had a spine XRay and then told me that there was no new fracture was likely not to have the best profile in the junior doctor's big black bag then. I wouldn’t be surprised. It's helpful to know. I shall take an FY1 history very carefully of anything happens again and ask for someone else if I'm not satisfied. I hope someone has told her that in relation to trusting someone for going to medical school, that Harold Shipman did that too.

Sammykit · 08/05/2022 10:59

I interview for the medical
school locally and it is illuminating. ☀️🌞

Sammykit · 08/05/2022 10:52

LakieLady · 08/05/2022 10:50

One of the best diagnosticians I know is a nurse who qualified as an SRN in the early 80s and worked as a theatre sister for many years. We share the same GP, and he knows we're friends. He once asked me why I thought I might have some issue or another, and when I replied that that's what SRN friend thought, he grinned and said "Well, that's good enough for me, her diagnostic skills are remarkable".

She also realised that a friend probably had heart disease. Sadly, his GP didn't realise, despite classic symptoms and risk factors, and friend died 2 days after being admitted as an emergency.

For me, skills and ability are what matters. I'd rather be seen by a competent nurse, paramedic or PA than by a doctor who is less skilled or able. Being more highly qualified doesn't necessarily mean someone is more skilled or able.

For me, skills and ability are what matters. I'd rather be seen by a competent nurse, paramedic or PA than by a doctor who is less skilled or able. Being more highly qualified doesn't necessarily mean someone is more skilled or able.

completely agree

LakieLady · 08/05/2022 10:50

707smile · 07/05/2022 16:09

I think PAs probably have more medical knowledge than most nurses. Some (not all) nurses with two-year diplomas (from the pre-degree days) really don't know a lot. I'd much rather be assessed by someone with a 3+ year science degree + a 2 year physician's associate qualification; than someone with just a 2-year diploma and perhaps without the academic achievements needed to do a science degree.

One of the best diagnosticians I know is a nurse who qualified as an SRN in the early 80s and worked as a theatre sister for many years. We share the same GP, and he knows we're friends. He once asked me why I thought I might have some issue or another, and when I replied that that's what SRN friend thought, he grinned and said "Well, that's good enough for me, her diagnostic skills are remarkable".

She also realised that a friend probably had heart disease. Sadly, his GP didn't realise, despite classic symptoms and risk factors, and friend died 2 days after being admitted as an emergency.

For me, skills and ability are what matters. I'd rather be seen by a competent nurse, paramedic or PA than by a doctor who is less skilled or able. Being more highly qualified doesn't necessarily mean someone is more skilled or able.

Sammykit · 08/05/2022 10:49

RosesAndHellebores · 08/05/2022 10:04

@Sammykit that explains a lot- thank you. So there's little hope of a poorly performing hospital in a very expensive area just outside London ever improving then because they consistently get lumbered with the worst doctors (and nurses due to the cost of living and marginal London weighting)?

Not necessarily

I got a high score and went to another city that was a lower score than london - some people score quite high on the ranking process; some people not as lucky and had to go to some other places away from peers. It meant you could end up very isolated in a city where you knew no one whilst doing fy1.

I was met with alot of sceptisim from my peers when I arrived for fy1 because I was from another city and ‘had taken one of their highly ranked rotations’. I was not popular for a while.

the scoring system was relatively new when I qualified it was for MMC - (modernising medical careers). You were scored on - 1) marks from exams 2) if you had any audits or publications 3) extra mark if you had bsc / msc / intercalation 4) answering questions based on WWYD type questions 5) a problem solving exam

a similar process has to be gone through to get INTO general practice, core surgical training, core medical training and Accs. Then after a couple of years a similar process has to be gone through AGAIN to get a training number and become a registrar. Then after that you have to CCT (another process) to become a GP or consultant in that specialty.

they brought in modernising medical careers to stop the old boys network and try to standarise us all. Great in theory.

it is little wonder people would chose to be PAs 😂😂😂😂😂😂

LakieLady · 08/05/2022 10:10

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 07/05/2022 11:48

Depending on your CCG, GPs can't order an MRI, far less a CT scan.

It's often less to do with hierarchies and assumed competence level and more about financial sign off.

I didn't know that GPs couldn't order MRIs.

My NHS physio ordered one, it seems a bit weird that a physio can but a GP can't. (Not dissing physios, by the way, I've had really excellent treatment from them.)

RosesAndHellebores · 08/05/2022 10:04

@Sammykit that explains a lot- thank you. So there's little hope of a poorly performing hospital in a very expensive area just outside London ever improving then because they consistently get lumbered with the worst doctors (and nurses due to the cost of living and marginal London weighting)?

StScholastica · 08/05/2022 10:02

RoomOfRequirement · 07/05/2022 10:53

She did her job! My only concern would be the lack of a badge for ID, but she didn't diagnose you she just ordered the (correct) test!

A lot of snobbery on this thread.

Agreed, snobbery and ignorance.

A lot of the PA'S I work with, already have backgrounds in nursing/physio or OT.
It's awful that she didn't introduce herself properly though and appalling that she wasn't wearing a lanyard. Our Trust sends staff home if they've forgotten their lanyard, as our name badges are also smart cards that (literally) open doors and give access to the computer network.

Sammykit · 08/05/2022 09:54

RosesAndHellebores · 08/05/2022 09:48

@lljkk that's very interesting information. How does FY1 allocation work. I ask because our local hospital is dire - parts still require improvement after successive inspections. The FY1 I dealt with was so hopeless I couldn't help wondering if allocation was a bit like secondary school entry where the top students have choices re the best schools and those at the bottom if the pile get sent to poorly performing ones. It would certainly explain why even A&E services for not very complex things were so much better when we lived between St George's and Chelsea & Westminster, with Kingston (excellent hospital on the whole) as easy to get to.

Allocation works on rank system
score out of 100
the higher the score the more likely you are to get your first choice
most people want cities to stay close to friends from uni so higher score required for london, manchester, glasgow, edinburgh etc - some do not care what their score is as long as its high enough to want to go ‘home’ or closer to partners etc to

then you get your pick of rotation dependent on how high your score is

classically with my uni / peer group - everyone wanted London so the score shot up. I ‘got a london score’ but chose not to go to such a competitive place so had my pick of rotations in another area.

same cycle begins again for registrar / training numbers

RosesAndHellebores · 08/05/2022 09:48

@lljkk that's very interesting information. How does FY1 allocation work. I ask because our local hospital is dire - parts still require improvement after successive inspections. The FY1 I dealt with was so hopeless I couldn't help wondering if allocation was a bit like secondary school entry where the top students have choices re the best schools and those at the bottom if the pile get sent to poorly performing ones. It would certainly explain why even A&E services for not very complex things were so much better when we lived between St George's and Chelsea & Westminster, with Kingston (excellent hospital on the whole) as easy to get to.

lljkk · 08/05/2022 09:36

hmmm
8209 FY1 places allocated, 791 newly qualified doctors were placed on wait list for FY1 places. But "everyone on the reserve list will be allocated their foundation school in April, moving into their Foundation Year 1 posts from August 2022".

How many unemployed UK-trained doctors are there who have at least 5 years experience?

kitcat15 · 08/05/2022 09:11

Confrontayshunme · 07/05/2022 10:42

These are a lot more common in other countries. My DPs overseas love their PA, and she is easier to access than their GP. Although I agree that the lack of training and professional recognition here is problematic. They may only do a two year course, but it is pretty comprehensive I think. I am a lot more worried about teachers and social workers that do six to eight week conversion courses then are given a whole class or a whole caseload of troubled families.

Which country does this happen in???

Vikinga · 08/05/2022 09:08

Well I phoned my dentist the other week because of a concern and the receptionist was able to reassure me but she said that she will check with the dentist and call back if he said otherwise.

Although 'just' a receptionist, it is a specialised dental implant place so will have had many years of answering the question I asked. I trusted her judgement and didn't demand to see the dentist.

Theheartandtheshape · 08/05/2022 09:06

mustlovegin · 08/05/2022 07:32

most years there are newly qualified medics with no job. No point the Gov funding another 1000 med school places if that leads in five years time to 1000 unemployed medicine grads

Why are we seeing so many GPs, nurses, etc coming from abroad then? I don't see the rationale here and it's unlikely that there are so many UK unemployed medicine grads

People coming from abroad is the reason post-graduation doctors don't get jobs, because the system ranks everyone the same and doesn't prioritise UK graduates. Every year more jobs have to be created in dire corners of the UK just to have somewhere to send the rest of the UK doctors.

Imagine spending 5-6 years and £80k in loans working your arse off only to be told that you haven't got a job, having to sit around and wait for someone to create a vacancy, because the government won't prioritise its own graduates.

The absence of doctors is deliberate. There are heart and brain surgeons who will likely never become consultants because there aren't enough posts. But the NHS could easily create more consultant and registrar posts. Instead it hires from abroad and creates pseudo-doctors on the cheap.

I work with many fantastic IMGs. But our own newly qualified doctors and doctors in further training should come first, as they do in most other countries.

Sammykit · 08/05/2022 09:02

MardyBuns · 08/05/2022 08:51

Lots of mis-information and poor attitudes on this thread, particularly from my NHS colleagues I’m sorry to say. It’s entirely depressing to read.

PA’s have a managed voluntary register and are overseen by the Royal College of Physicians pending professional registration, which may come under the GMC. There is a competency framework document outlining their scope of practice. They receive two years of intense clinics training on the background of a bioscience degree so they are not at all untrained, or “wannabe doctors”.

As with any new role in the NHS there is massive resistance to change and concerns regarding role creep and overlap, which is to be expected and depends on the service and department in question.

PA’s are an absolute godsend in primary care which is facing its biggest crisis since the NHS was formed. I work and have worked with countless skilled and competent PA’s who have become invaluable in their area of work. As with any role there will be those who aren’t, but again this shouldn’t be to the detriment of the entire profession.

Give PA’s a chance and stop being so snobbish about traditional hierarchical healthcare roles. The NHS is changing and we need to adapt or die.

And @Pyewhacket - brushing off PA’s as tea-makers and store cupboard checkers …. you sound like an absolute joy to work with. What a revolting attitude towards any member of the MDT.

Totally agree. Bring the PAs in. So much snobbery and hierarchy.

Junepassing · 08/05/2022 08:57

Sorry that comment was directed at @RosesAndHellebores

Junepassing · 08/05/2022 08:56

I'm a part time HCA, leaving to start uni in September (not nursing!) I don't wear the same uniform as a nurse and I don't know any HCA that would, I always wear my name/ID badge, tell patients my job title (I tend to say healthcare assistant rather than haach-see-aaaaay) and work well within the scope of my training and role. No patient has ever had a problem seeing me to be fair. The NHS is on its knees, patients are honestly happy to have a friendly face, someone kind, who chats to them about the weather for a few minutes and who doesn't hurt them taking blood.

In my experience it's often other staff members who are deeply insecure about their own role or lives outside of work who make snarky comments about being 'just an HCA'. That's almost understandable if you're a rocket scientist, brain surgeon, splitting the atom or sequencing the human genome. Coming from a nurse though, I tend to just smile in sympathy.

MardyBuns · 08/05/2022 08:51

Lots of mis-information and poor attitudes on this thread, particularly from my NHS colleagues I’m sorry to say. It’s entirely depressing to read.

PA’s have a managed voluntary register and are overseen by the Royal College of Physicians pending professional registration, which may come under the GMC. There is a competency framework document outlining their scope of practice. They receive two years of intense clinics training on the background of a bioscience degree so they are not at all untrained, or “wannabe doctors”.

As with any new role in the NHS there is massive resistance to change and concerns regarding role creep and overlap, which is to be expected and depends on the service and department in question.

PA’s are an absolute godsend in primary care which is facing its biggest crisis since the NHS was formed. I work and have worked with countless skilled and competent PA’s who have become invaluable in their area of work. As with any role there will be those who aren’t, but again this shouldn’t be to the detriment of the entire profession.

Give PA’s a chance and stop being so snobbish about traditional hierarchical healthcare roles. The NHS is changing and we need to adapt or die.

And @Pyewhacket - brushing off PA’s as tea-makers and store cupboard checkers …. you sound like an absolute joy to work with. What a revolting attitude towards any member of the MDT.

OfstedOffred · 08/05/2022 08:28

Yanbu op in the sense that the NHS definitely struggles with role creep - these types of professions are often introduced with a relatively limited or specific scope, but then the constant desire to cost cut means more and more activities previously carried out by doctors get transferred to lower paid staff with poorer academic capability. At the end of the day it's a lower paid role for a reason.

I suspect what it will lead to, is that the more basic tasks carried out by junior doctors that will have contributed to their clinical experience, get shifted to PAs, junior doctors get forced to do more stuff currently done by more experienced higher paid doctors, and over time it will lead to fewer senior doctor roles.

Sammykit · 08/05/2022 08:25

PrawnToast5 · 07/05/2022 21:27

The only nurses I have seen that stand up to the doctors of all grades are either infection control nurses or a few band 8 nurses.

The pervasive hierarchy and culture are what leads to this. Nurses are not empowered by our training and the little empowerment we get is challenged the second we enter the workforce at band 5. Those that speak up are ostracised and pushed out.

I say this as a senior nurse who has challenged doctors from when I was a student nurse to matron. I have been lucky to not have been affected by the above because of strong managers and leaders around me.

No nurses ever had to ‘stand up to me’ because I am not a dick so far up my own arse I need an enema to get back down from it.

Any Dr I seen this attitude with I distanced myself from though; and now my two best friends are nurses so do the maths 😂

I cannot be arsed with any of the politics or hierearchies. Nurses have commented that they have never met a doctor like me because I change my own clinical orange bins and also when I was free as a junior doctor (many years ago mind you when there was free moments) I would help the HCA change the sheets / do tea rounds. I also did not go onto a power trip when I became a SpR. I do not think it is a coincedence I got further in my medical career than them far quicker - maybe NHS karma.

Sammykit · 08/05/2022 08:13

I am an NHS GP and I would not mind being examined by nurse, FY1, PA, ANP or any other professional when attending the hospital.

RosesAndHellebores · 08/05/2022 08:09

The greater creep is that of the HCA and the nurse. The former always wearing a dress that looks like a nurses' uniform and never ever a badge for clarity. There needs to be absolute clarity over who us who in hospitals. It's extraordinary really bearing in mind the hierarchical nature where the consultant is too often still revered with Dr's not far behind, even F1s with the patient bringing up the rear as little more than pond life and spoken to as sh1t.