Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect to be examined and diagnosed by an actual nurse or doctor?

335 replies

Cravela · 07/05/2022 10:36

Stomach pain came on suddenly and worsened over 24 hrs. Telephone appt with GP who advised hospital and sent me to the surgical assessment unit. So far so good

Staff member arrives in scrubs and takes all my details and then starts examining me. Tells me the plan (CT scan) and that she will give pain killers in the meantime.

Noticed she wasn’t wearing a lanyard/badge so I asked her her name Dr?. She says oh I’m not a doctor, ok so you’re a nurse? (No issues with that always choose to see an advance nurse practitioner when I go to the GP and I have a friend who is a consultant nurse). No she says she’s not a nurse. I was getting quite frustrated at this point because she was clearly avoiding just telling me her job role. So I straight out said can you tell me your job role please. She said she was a “physicians associate”.

I’ve never heard of one before so I googled after she left and literally anyone can be one after a 2 year course. They don’t come under the GMC or the nurses governing body and aren’t able to prescribe medicine or diagnose people??

I asked the nurse in charge if I could see a doctor or a surgical nurse and they came 10 mins later. Doctor was quite apologetic and re-examined me.

AIBU to think if you aren’t a doctor or a nurse you should tell people that before you put your hands on them??

OP posts:
MPharm · 07/05/2022 11:12

@Theheartandtheshape like ANPs, they can follow a strict protocol or guideline, but they don't have the intelligence and broad based medical education to think laterally

This is really rude and untrue. I can't speak for PAs as I have no experience of them (outside watching ER), but I've worked with some fabulous ANPs who outclassed a lot of the junior doctors within their own specialty. They're independent prescribers so of course they're intelligent and have gone through quite intense post-grad training.

Bookmark

TheNinny · 07/05/2022 11:11

They are highly trained and the course is extensive. I was a PA in another country and the entry requirements (after completing a 4 year bachelors degree) are extremely high. The just ‘2 years’ masters degree (U.S.) included the same classroom hours as a 4 year medical degree at that time and there was almost no time off. They are often used in roles at the same level as an ANP or nurse practitioner, the difference being the model of which they are trained.

They aren’t commonly used in the UK as the push back from doctors has been huge as they are viewed as failed doctors/job stealers but this isn’t true at all and one of the reasons I don’t work as one here. I think they would help with the significant pressures on NHS if utilised. But I do see where the confusion would be in terms of role.

Feckingfeck · 07/05/2022 11:11

Theheartandtheshape · 07/05/2022 10:53

And as for PAs having more clinical experience than FY1s - what on earth? doctors have 2 pre clinical years and 3 clinical years.

Tell me about it 🙄

In our trust they tried to improve relations by getting the PAs to present their job role to the doctors. Claimed they can manage all sorts of conditions including neurological emergencies 😂

I think the talk just made things worse. Try giving us fair pay for our skills rather than adding under skilled workers in the mix and paying them more than us!

They are basically triage as they can't prescribe and cant order radiation imaging 😂 as experienced as FY2 they claim- i think not!

titchy · 07/05/2022 11:10

The government refuses to fund medical school places

And while I agree with this to an extent, the NHS also needs to make more F1 vacancies - most years there are newly qualified medics with no job. No point the Gov funding another 1000 med school places if that leads in five years time to 1000 unemployed medicine grads.

Feckingfeck · 07/05/2022 11:08

Not sure why the GP didn't see and examine you, they may struggle to make an appropriate referral otherwise?!

A PA (physician associate) are sore point. They train for 1 year at uni after doing a science based degree then claim to be as experienced as us. They only work 9-5 and get paid more than us too! Welcome to the NhS.

Not enough doctors. So they make up a role to plug the gap.

DressingGownofDoom · 07/05/2022 11:07

@Theheartandtheshape did a PA piss on your chips or something Confused

titchy · 07/05/2022 11:05

If you're not bright enough and dedicated enough for med school, you have no business assessing and diagnosing patients. It's unsafe. Medical school is hard - that's the point.

Cheap "noctors" benefit the government and endanger patients.

That's nasty. Presumably you also look down on nurses who weren't bright enough for med school as well? How do you feel about PAs who were bright enough for med but chose something else?

Nurses are far cheaper than PAs btw.

Theheartandtheshape · 07/05/2022 11:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

titchy · 07/05/2022 11:02

According to NHS careers PAs have to have a Bioscience degree, then a further two years postgrad training, or a four year integrated masters. That sounds pretty rigorous to me! Certainly I'd say equivalent to nursing degrees.

LisaSimpson73 · 07/05/2022 11:00

Cravela · 07/05/2022 10:56

But they can’t order CT scans?? Presumably because it needs a higher level of experience to decide if you need one. So was she just going to get a doctor to sign the request?

Well yes, I assume what happened is that she was assigned to you but the doctor.
She examined you to make sure that you weren't urgent then she explained the plan for you. CT and pain relief. She was acting as part of the team to ensure that you didn't get left on your own for hours without knowing what was going on.
Her only real mistake was that she didn't have id or explain who she was properly to you and was evasive when you asked.

Theheartandtheshape · 07/05/2022 10:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

AliceW89 · 07/05/2022 10:58

Theheartandtheshape · 07/05/2022 10:53

And as for PAs having more clinical experience than FY1s - what on earth? doctors have 2 pre clinical years and 3 clinical years.

You are entirely miss quoting me. I didn’t say they generally have more clinical experience than an FY1. Take a surgical PA out of surgery and plonk them in medical admissions and they would struggle massively. But in their limited scope of practice, their experience is huge and that counts for a lot under the direction of a medic. I am a doctor so I’m hardly going to want to talk myself out of my own job!

WeAllHaveWings · 07/05/2022 10:57

Would have no problem with this assuming after triage and the appropriate test, CT scan, she decided, then a Dr would be involved/consulted.

Cravela · 07/05/2022 10:56

But they can’t order CT scans?? Presumably because it needs a higher level of experience to decide if you need one. So was she just going to get a doctor to sign the request?

OP posts:
OddBoots · 07/05/2022 10:55

Anyone examining you should introduce themselves but in terms of qualifications I don't think that should be an issue, a 2 years post graduate degree following a science honours degree is still a substantial amount of study.

I can see them becoming a bigger part of the NHS given the current pressures and I think that's a good thing.

Badgirlriri · 07/05/2022 10:54

Theheartandtheshape · 07/05/2022 10:48

PAs often try to conceal their actual role because most of them failed to get a medical school place and are trying to become doctors through the back door. The ones like in the OP should be reported for misleading patients about their qualifications.

Only doctors should diagnose. ANPs, PAs etc. should be limited to the things they were created to do: lessen the pressure on doctors by doing bloods/cannulas/reviewing chronic stable conditions and very minor illnesses.

Scope and role creep is a huge safety issue in medicine. There is no such thing as a "consultant nurse", just a nurse trying to play doctor.

That is absolutely not true. I think you’re getting confused with the role.

An AP completes a 2 year foundation degree after already doing A levels/diploma’s/NVQ 3’s.

“literally anyone can be one after a 2 year course”

well literally anyone can be a nurse after a 3 year course!

Zippy1510 · 07/05/2022 10:54

They have a 3 year BSc before their PA degree. That’s more years of education than a nurse. They were doing the job they are trained to do.

Sloth66 · 07/05/2022 10:54

The entry requirements and training for this role are pretty rigorous. She could have explained her role, but she sorted you out a scan. Given serious NHS staff shortages, I’m glad they are developing roles like this.

ittakes2 · 07/05/2022 10:54

She should have introduced herself but since she is just authorising tests sounds like people will get their tests sooner using her job role than waiting for a doctor. I think as long as the doctor reviews the test results I would prefer to see a less experienced person sooner to have my tests authorised.

RoomOfRequirement · 07/05/2022 10:53

She did her job! My only concern would be the lack of a badge for ID, but she didn't diagnose you she just ordered the (correct) test!

A lot of snobbery on this thread.

AReallyUsefulEngine · 07/05/2022 10:53

They should have introduced themselves and been wearing an ID badge. But why is a physician associate with 2 years of training who is typically band 7 but can’t prescribe not acceptable but a nurse with 2 years of training (which is what many graduate courses are) who is band 5 and also can’t prescribe is? They weren’t diagnosing you at that point that argument is irrelevant anyway.

Theheartandtheshape · 07/05/2022 10:53

And as for PAs having more clinical experience than FY1s - what on earth? doctors have 2 pre clinical years and 3 clinical years.

Theheartandtheshape · 07/05/2022 10:52

AliceW89 · 07/05/2022 10:50

She should have been wearing her ID badge and introduced herself by name and job roll. Its very unprofessional that she didn’t.

It’s not unreasonable for her to examine you though - their roll is to triage patients depending on symptoms/test results/clinical findings and then report back to the medics who will examine again if needs be, plus diagnose and treat. It’s pretty standard practice these days. As someone mentioned up stream, it’s 2 years of focussed education off the back of a science degree, so they are hardly anyone off the street. In their narrow roll of practice, they will likely have a lot more clinical experience then say the foundation doctors or newly qualified nurses.

This is wrong. Many PA courses will take graduates with non medically related degrees.

ICannotRememberAThing · 07/05/2022 10:51

I have absolutely no problem with this.
They are most definitely part of the triage team. They are educated to degree level and beyond and arrange tests, scans, do administration in behalf of other medical staff.

www.healthcareers.nhs.uk/explore-roles/medical-associate-professions/roles-medical-associate-professions/physician-associate

AliceW89 · 07/05/2022 10:50

She should have been wearing her ID badge and introduced herself by name and job roll. Its very unprofessional that she didn’t.

It’s not unreasonable for her to examine you though - their roll is to triage patients depending on symptoms/test results/clinical findings and then report back to the medics who will examine again if needs be, plus diagnose and treat. It’s pretty standard practice these days. As someone mentioned up stream, it’s 2 years of focussed education off the back of a science degree, so they are hardly anyone off the street. In their narrow roll of practice, they will likely have a lot more clinical experience then say the foundation doctors or newly qualified nurses.

Swipe left for the next trending thread