Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect to be examined and diagnosed by an actual nurse or doctor?

335 replies

Cravela · 07/05/2022 10:36

Stomach pain came on suddenly and worsened over 24 hrs. Telephone appt with GP who advised hospital and sent me to the surgical assessment unit. So far so good

Staff member arrives in scrubs and takes all my details and then starts examining me. Tells me the plan (CT scan) and that she will give pain killers in the meantime.

Noticed she wasn’t wearing a lanyard/badge so I asked her her name Dr?. She says oh I’m not a doctor, ok so you’re a nurse? (No issues with that always choose to see an advance nurse practitioner when I go to the GP and I have a friend who is a consultant nurse). No she says she’s not a nurse. I was getting quite frustrated at this point because she was clearly avoiding just telling me her job role. So I straight out said can you tell me your job role please. She said she was a “physicians associate”.

I’ve never heard of one before so I googled after she left and literally anyone can be one after a 2 year course. They don’t come under the GMC or the nurses governing body and aren’t able to prescribe medicine or diagnose people??

I asked the nurse in charge if I could see a doctor or a surgical nurse and they came 10 mins later. Doctor was quite apologetic and re-examined me.

AIBU to think if you aren’t a doctor or a nurse you should tell people that before you put your hands on them??

OP posts:
SchnitzelVonCrummsTum · 07/05/2022 11:49

(by the way, I agree with many of your reservations about PAs @Feckingfeck - not trying to be needlessly antagonistic!)

MissChanandlerBong80 · 07/05/2022 11:48

Theheartandtheshape · 07/05/2022 10:48

PAs often try to conceal their actual role because most of them failed to get a medical school place and are trying to become doctors through the back door. The ones like in the OP should be reported for misleading patients about their qualifications.

Only doctors should diagnose. ANPs, PAs etc. should be limited to the things they were created to do: lessen the pressure on doctors by doing bloods/cannulas/reviewing chronic stable conditions and very minor illnesses.

Scope and role creep is a huge safety issue in medicine. There is no such thing as a "consultant nurse", just a nurse trying to play doctor.

Reallg? I (well, my son) saw a nurse consultant in Paediatrics just a couple of weeks ago. She introduced herself as a ‘nurse consultant’ and her name badge said ‘nurse consultant’.

She also diagnosed my son correctly - the doctor who saw him a couple of hours earlier had got it wrong.

SchnitzelVonCrummsTum · 07/05/2022 11:48

It depends on the history given, clearly, and none of us knows that - so asking why the OP wasn't seen by the GP is unhelpful for this case given that it was clearly appropriate management.

Your statement that other GPs have not appropriately managed other patients is not really relevant to this case. I am fully aware, on a professional level, of what was happening in primary care during the pandemic.

Feckingfeck · 07/05/2022 11:48

@Cliftontherocks

Agree.

But they get paid more than the doctor who orders their scan and prescribes for them 🤨 and work less hours too 🧐🤨 thank you NHS 👏

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 07/05/2022 11:48

Cravela · 07/05/2022 10:56

But they can’t order CT scans?? Presumably because it needs a higher level of experience to decide if you need one. So was she just going to get a doctor to sign the request?

Depending on your CCG, GPs can't order an MRI, far less a CT scan.

It's often less to do with hierarchies and assumed competence level and more about financial sign off.

Feckingfeck · 07/05/2022 11:46

@VirginiaQ

Not entirely true..

They cant prescribe or order radiation. They have no governing body that will take this responsibility as they have only trained for 1 year and have very limited clinical exposure. The gaps in their knowledge can be shocking. However, when in a niche clinical area or as triage in a speciality they can work well. I wouldn't say they are between a nurse and a doctor though. I know they consider themselves at FY2 level 😂 this is often what causes the issues!!

Cliftontherocks · 07/05/2022 11:46

Cravela · 07/05/2022 10:56

But they can’t order CT scans?? Presumably because it needs a higher level of experience to decide if you need one. So was she just going to get a doctor to sign the request?

Yes. This is exactly this. A doctor oversees their work and they refer anything that needs to be referred on.

the only issue here is the lack of Id badge and the lack of her explaining her role. This is not acceptable

Feckingfeck · 07/05/2022 11:43

SchnitzelVonCrummsTum · 07/05/2022 11:39

@feckingfeck clearly the GP's phone triage effectively got the OP where they needed to be (hospital) for the investigations they needed and which could not be provided at the GP surgery.

We don't know what the OP said to the GP but it was self-evidently enough to suggest that an issue requiring rapid hospital care was a significant possibility - what would the GP seeing the OP have added to the situation apart from a long delay?

Because the amount of patients referred on history alone that end up being discharged from the hospital is shocking, we at time end up doing the job that a GP could have easily done.

There seems to be a massive shift to just refer, during the covid peaks this was horrendous and the amount of medical referrals was unsafe and unachievable.

I was saying it would make a better referral to. I.e is the GP found no bowel sounds the referral would then be treated differently and possibly more urgently. So it can affect patient care.

Feckingfeck · 07/05/2022 11:39

An ANP is different entirely. They are great and a huge support to junior doctors. As PPs have said they often have years of experience and I would happily be diagnosed and managed by one.

PAs have a much more limited role and in a surgical assessment role usually do the initial consultation which will be discussed with a senior who will order imaging and prescribe where necessary. To be honest they may know more in a specific area than an FY1 but not an FY2 especially this time of year. The PA isn't trying to take you to theatre so in this environment their role is appropriate. Not introducing themselves can be common to avoid "confusion" but can also be dangerous as it clouds a patient's expectations.

My grievance with PAs is more linked to pay and working conditions. You will never see a PA not take a break or stay behind to sort out a patient. (Except one I worked with in gastro- she was fab possibly because she was an ex ICU nurse) the ones with nursing backgrounds are brilliant but then again I suppose they are more like ANPs!

SchnitzelVonCrummsTum · 07/05/2022 11:39

@feckingfeck clearly the GP's phone triage effectively got the OP where they needed to be (hospital) for the investigations they needed and which could not be provided at the GP surgery.

We don't know what the OP said to the GP but it was self-evidently enough to suggest that an issue requiring rapid hospital care was a significant possibility - what would the GP seeing the OP have added to the situation apart from a long delay?

Iliketeaagain · 07/05/2022 11:38

Theheartandtheshape · 07/05/2022 10:48

PAs often try to conceal their actual role because most of them failed to get a medical school place and are trying to become doctors through the back door. The ones like in the OP should be reported for misleading patients about their qualifications.

Only doctors should diagnose. ANPs, PAs etc. should be limited to the things they were created to do: lessen the pressure on doctors by doing bloods/cannulas/reviewing chronic stable conditions and very minor illnesses.

Scope and role creep is a huge safety issue in medicine. There is no such thing as a "consultant nurse", just a nurse trying to play doctor.

This is one of the most ill-informed posts I've read in a while.

I don't know much about PA training. But I know plenty about ANPs and to be an ANP you are educated to a higher level (normally MSc) and trained and assessed to diagnose and prescribe. Scope of practice will vary for ANPs in clinical areas, but they are not failed doctors or pretending to be one.

I can diagnose and prescribe, but my scope of practice is older adults (so I would not be competent to diagnose I and prescribe for a child), but there are plenty of ANPs who work in GP surgeries and minor injuries units who are skilled and competent in diagnosis and registered prescribers for all ages. And have to evidence that competence on a regular basis.

For OP - that PA should have introduced herself, so YANBU from that point of view, and it would have also given you the option to ask about her role and whether she would be outlining a treatment plan or not.

VirginiaQ · 07/05/2022 11:34

Salutatorydrinks · 07/05/2022 11:13

A Physician's Assistant is a seriously qualified role. It's between nurse and doctor. Very common in America but just coming into being here. YA deeply U.

This. And they will be regulated by the GMC they are just setting out parameters at the minute.

Georgeskitchen · 07/05/2022 11:33

Your wrong about physicians associates. My niece is one and spent 5 years at university. To qualify as a doctor she needs a further 2 years at uni.
So get your facts right before you assume that these people have no qualifications

comealongponds · 07/05/2022 11:31

YABU they’re doing a job they’re qualified for, why is that a problem?

they should’ve had a name badge and introduced themselves though

Viviennemary · 07/05/2022 11:31

It's cheeky. Sounds more like a glorified clerk. Stomach pain can be extremely serious.

DilemmaBlah · 07/05/2022 11:29

@Theheartandtheshape Do you need some salt and vinegar to go with that massive chip on your shoulder?

Moveonward · 07/05/2022 11:28

Theheartandtheshape · 07/05/2022 10:48

PAs often try to conceal their actual role because most of them failed to get a medical school place and are trying to become doctors through the back door. The ones like in the OP should be reported for misleading patients about their qualifications.

Only doctors should diagnose. ANPs, PAs etc. should be limited to the things they were created to do: lessen the pressure on doctors by doing bloods/cannulas/reviewing chronic stable conditions and very minor illnesses.

Scope and role creep is a huge safety issue in medicine. There is no such thing as a "consultant nurse", just a nurse trying to play doctor.

I think this reply shows a lack of understanding of ANPS and nurse consultants. Usually ANPS and nurse consultants have decades of hands on clinical experience within their scope of practice . ANPS are intensively trained to MSc level and nurse consultants have a PhD! It’s not about nurses trying to ‘play doctor’ it’s about highly experienced and trained individuals developing and extending their scope of practice to fit the need of that area.

Like it or not, clinical roles will develop and change over time- PAs worry me though as they are normally young science graduates with little hands on clinical experience.

Cafetropical · 07/05/2022 11:25

I've heard of physician associates and even the students I teach have heard of it and some are considering it as a career in the future. YABU. There are so many allied health professions in a hospital that do an important job - not just doctors.

Pradababe · 07/05/2022 11:19

Physician associates are trained (with a background in health care) and are eminently capable of doing the basic assessments to provide your doctor/hopsital consultant with readings, data to monitor and triage your your condition. As are paramedics etc

ShadowoftheFall · 07/05/2022 11:15

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 07/05/2022 10:43

I think you should always introduce yourself and explain your role when you meet a patient.

This

Salutatorydrinks · 07/05/2022 11:14

they don't have the intelligence and broad based medical education to think laterally

Most obnoxious post of the day award.

Toddlerteaplease · 07/05/2022 11:14

I've been seen by one. It seems to me to be a totally pointless role. They can do less than a nurse would do!

Tinyhappypeople · 07/05/2022 11:13

Wow @Theheartandtheshape you sound seriously insecure about your role (assuming you are a doctor? If not you have no place making such sweeping statements!). And very offensive to other professionals too. Poor multidisciplinary communication, as often happens when doctors have their heads shoved up their own arse, is also a massive patient safety risk. As I’m sure you must know given your superior intelligence…

Salutatorydrinks · 07/05/2022 11:13

A Physician's Assistant is a seriously qualified role. It's between nurse and doctor. Very common in America but just coming into being here. YA deeply U.

LovelyQuiche · 07/05/2022 11:13

Some really horrible posts on here
I’m a Sonographer and I make diagnoses but I’m not a dr. Do I have no business being near patients? I’ve done years of post graduate training courses / university courses to get to my skill level. I’ve never met a PA but given the shortage or drs they can only be a good thing as a support service