Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many people are hypocrites when it comes to housing?

234 replies

WestminsterCrabby · 07/05/2022 09:28

Got into quite a heated row discussion last night with some relatives. 🍷

They are Fuming (capital F intended) about all the new housing estates popping up in their leafy village. Apparently its ruined the views, ruined their dog walks yaddah yaddah.

These are couples in their late 50s early 60s whose children are long gone but still live in their large 4 bed detached homes. When I pointed out that perhaps so many new homes wouldnt need to be built (or smaller ones that took up less space) if people only took up the amount of space they needed rather than felt entitled to, they thought I was being very very unreasonable. I disagree!

I appreciate that people living in houses bigger than there needs is not the cause of the housing shortage HOWEVER surely you cant complain about other people needing to be housed while you yourself have 2 bedrooms per person?!?

Drives me mad and it's not the first time I've had conversations like this with people in a similar circumstances.

It makes me sad to see the countryside being converted over as well but people have got to live somewhere.

Aibu here?

OP posts:
Kitfish · 07/05/2022 11:50

I live in a house that will be too big for my husband and I when the children leave home. To move house, I have calculated that I will likely have to pay about £100k in stamp duty (plus moving costs and legal fees). What's the conclusion? I'll stay put in my too big house. If the government want people to downsize then they need to stop placing a huge tax on moving. Your relatives are not unreasonable for not wanting to pay that tax.

As for building in villages - i'm all for that. My (and everyone else's) children will need to live somewhere: we need far more houses built in this country.

I think you are conflating two different issues - on one YABU and the other YANBU.

Discovereads · 07/05/2022 11:44

Why bungalows though?
When older people downsize, they have to think about becoming elderly and the lack of mobility that comes with. It’s makes no sense to downsize into a property with stairs, so that means a bungalow or ground floor flat. Otherwise they are just downsizing into a property that will only be suitable for them for a short time.

Horcruxe · 07/05/2022 11:43

The problem is the infrastructure.

No point In building 500 new homes. They need schools, GP's and health care.

But none of that is built at the same time, so existing services get stretched further.

ancientgran · 07/05/2022 11:41

WhatsHoppening · 07/05/2022 09:37

I agree OP- we at the moment are having huge campaigns in our local area (v popular suburb of a city) to prevent much needed housing being built on some wasteland that is privately owned and they want to sell. The land is mainly used by dog walkers as it’s not safe for children and it’s by a huge park with 2 kids play areas and loads of room for dogs etc. Very NIMBY- ‘there’s too many people here already’ ‘the roads are too busy’ ‘we want to maintain the messy and dangerous area as it is. Whenever they ask me to sign it I politely refuse. We live here because it’s lovely- is it such a surprise others want to live here? You can’t protect prime real estate location for the odd dog Walker. Aaaargh!!

I think there is a big difference between building on wasteland and building on large areas of farmland. Locally we are losing lots of fields that can't be replaced and we do need to grow food as well as build houses.

pixie5121 · 07/05/2022 11:40

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

Oblomov22 · 07/05/2022 11:39

I disagree. Not that we live in a large house, but if you can afford it, why not.
The real problem, as pp said infrastructure of schools and GP surgery isn't installed.

itsmeagainlol · 07/05/2022 11:36

Locally I am horrified at a building scheme that is building around 400 new homes on what was fields and walks. Its just awful but I know people need housing, so I can't argue with it. I am just sad that all that green space is now gone.

I wouldn't vote for no new housing but I do leave it to the full on NIMBYs to do it for me.

Hortensiateapot · 07/05/2022 11:33

@lameasahorse Not sure why you picked on me, did you read my post? I’m not lecturing anyone. I think what most people on this thread can agree on is that housing stock in this country is not matching need. (Which also links to wider discussions about property being snapped up by landlords, second home owners, lack of social housing, locals being out priced etc). This does require development though and there will always be a degree of nimbyism to any proposed development.

There are lots of new retirement developments going on near us (semi rural town) but as PP have outlined, these do have their issues. The people I know who live in them are active retired people and feel it has been a positive move for them. So perhaps my view is skewed.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 07/05/2022 11:33

Good to see Mumsnet’s rampant ageism is out in force by Post 3

Discovereads · 07/05/2022 11:29

YABU as the housing shortage is worse for smaller properties than larger. So even if older couples/singles want to downsize, they find that they cannot more often than families trying to upsize find they cannot.

In addition, YABU to think that just because you live in a house, you can’t complain about how new housing is being built in your community. The planning permission for these estates has been fast tracked to the point of harmfulness to communities because many are being built in small villages without the proper infrastructure upgrades (roads, water, sewage, electric, internet, etc) or allowances for necessary basic services for an increased village population (schools, GP surgeries, dentists, etc). As residents of the village, your parents have every right to complain.

Fairislefandango · 07/05/2022 11:28

Moving house is a difficult and very expensive business. YABU to think people should feel obliged to leave the house they paid for and have made their home every time a change in personal circumstances affects the number of people currently living in their house.

That's got nothing to do with complaining about necessary new houses being built. YANBU about the NIMBYism around that.

CounsellorTroi · 07/05/2022 11:28

Edinburgh is becoming encircled by massive new housing estates, I'm sure every single house will be someone's beloved family home, but they are soulless, heartless estates. Again, houses built too close together, no shops/cafes/amenities, no thought to schooling, medical provision, congestion.

Often these estates built on the outskirts of cities have poor public transport links, leading to more congestion on main routes into the city.

zafferana · 07/05/2022 11:24

Why not convert some of the empty High Street shops to flats?

This is certainly happening in our town - entire office blocks are being converted into flats.

Your relatives @WestminsterCrabby are upset, because the character of the place they've presumably lived in for years has changed. It's gone from a small place with lots of green space nearby for leisure, to a bigger place with new housing estates now built on that green space they so enjoyed as an amenity. I don't blame them tbh, I think many people are sad that the character of their villages, towns or small cities is changing in this way.

My small city, which already suffers with horrible congestion and is full of old, narrow streets, has been told it has to provide 2,400 new homes by 2038. This will have a huge impact on the quality of life of everyone who already lives here, since every new home generates probably 2 new cars on the roads. And that's before you consider that all our schools, doctor's surgeries and dentists are already oversubscribed. I wish 'new towns' were still a thing and that existing towns weren't required to constantly expand so that they lose the very things that people loved about them in the first place.

PurassicJark · 07/05/2022 11:20

darlingdodo · 07/05/2022 09:37

I think the issue I would have is with the size and density of the estates and the fact that there is rarely any new infrastructure to cope with the additional people.

Town I live in has an estate of 600 new properties going up on the edge of town. It's a mixture of everything from 5 bed detached to 2 bed social housing flats, but the roads are so narrow that it's like running a slalom to drive through - no-one uses their garages to park cars because the garages aren't big enough (and many of the properties don't have garages anyway). The houses are far too close together so there's already been neighbour disputes. There has been no allowance for the numbers of children who will be attending local schools (the estate is aimed at families - imagine the number of additional children), no increase in GP provision, the road onto the estate is causing traffic problems on the main road.

Edinburgh is becoming encircled by massive new housing estates, I'm sure every single house will be someone's beloved family home, but they are soulless, heartless estates. Again, houses built too close together, no shops/cafes/amenities, no thought to schooling, medical provision, congestion.

Far more thought needs to be put into building new homes, but it won't happen, because the developers won't make enough billions.

I always wonder how many town planners, people who sit on planning boards etc live on one of these estates? My guess is none.

This happens all over Scotland sadly. No thought given to the extra need for primary schools, secondary schools, GPs, hospitals etc. They actually advertise that the new estate has a school near it. That's full. But they keep building.

I just keep pointing out on every application that they haven't considered the infrastructure, and pointing out their stupidity. Doubtful that it will do anything, but least when things go wrong they can't say 'we didn't know' or 'no one complained'.

howtomoveforwards · 07/05/2022 11:20

if people only took up the amount of space they needed rather than felt entitled to

sigh. So simplistic a view. I live in a house that will soon be far too big for me. I would love to move. But rising housing costs, the remaining mortgage that needs paying off, the scarcity of smaller properties locally, moving costs, conveyancing, stamp duty…all mean that realistically, I wouldn’t be better off for a good number of years. Why should I cause myself financial issues?

lameasahorse · 07/05/2022 11:15

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

lameasahorse · 07/05/2022 11:13

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Giggorata · 07/05/2022 11:10

Why bungalows though? They have a larger footprint and they are characterless (in my view)
Why not build semis and terraces for singles and younger families to start off in? Well insulated and with new materials, they could fill a need in villages as well as towns.
Why not convert some of the empty High Stree shops to flats?
Why not convert some of the bigger houses to flats?

All rhetorical questions, though I suspect the answers have to do with profit.
We have just had two small developments in our village. One is huge 4+ bedroomed houses, bought by people with no links to the village, commuting to cities and whose social lives are elsewhere; the other is semis, bought by people who are local and who use the village amenities, pub, school, etc. I bet I know which one was more profitable.

lameasahorse · 07/05/2022 11:10

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

FairyCakeWings · 07/05/2022 11:07

How can you disagree with people complaining that massive building works have ruined their view and their dog walks if they’re telling the truth and just chatting about what’s going on for them in life?

It is horrible living next to building sites, even if you agree that more houses need to be built. Agreeing that more housing is needed doesn’t mean you can’t be concerned that local infrastructure won’t be able to cope adequately with many more residents living there.

It sounds like you’re being quite rude to people by insinuating that they are doing something wrong by living in their own homes.

RagzRebooted · 07/05/2022 11:04

Wbeezer · 07/05/2022 09:35

I'm on our local community council, we review planning applications, one of the main issues we have is that developers don't want to build two bed bungalows which our village really needs, because they make more money from 4/5 executive homes. It's a nice place to live so local well heeled oldies carry on living in their large houses to stay part of the community.

Same issue here. DH is chair of our Parish Council planning committee, so I get to hear all about it! We drew up a neighbourhood plan, that did actually research the housing need in the village and then determined how many and what kind of housing we needed to be developed here. As you said, it was 1 and 2 bedroom flats and homes with a smaller need for some affordable/social housing for families.

All the development applications are for 3/4 bed executive homes priced at £500k+
This is not what we need! We have people who do want to downsize, but want to stay local and there is no where for them to move to. We have families who have been here for generations, but their younger ones with their own children have to move away because they can't afford to live here.

Hortensiateapot · 07/05/2022 11:01

I do think, with our ageing population and the crisis in elderly care, by the time current working adults are in that situation, there will need to be a shift towards downsizing and moving into purpose-built accommodation at an earlier stage and before significant infirmity. Our generation may be more open to doing this, particularly if we have never been able to afford an established family home that we love or have been renting for most of our working lives. The trouble with a lot of purpose build retirement complexes is the caveats put upon them (service charges and sell-back valuations set by them) and bungalows are few and far between.

I can see both sides tbh, why should our boomer parents give up their beloved homes full of memories if they don’t want to and it is really important development planning carefully considers both access to public services and the environment (many new developments are only easily accessed by car). However, the lack of empathy and constant moaning about younger generations and their expectations (basically to be able to afford a home and decent life from full time employment) based on a few articles in the mail or telegraph can be wearing. I really struggle to avoid getting drawn in to discussing it.

AllFreeOwls · 07/05/2022 10:56

WhatsHoppening · 07/05/2022 09:37

I agree OP- we at the moment are having huge campaigns in our local area (v popular suburb of a city) to prevent much needed housing being built on some wasteland that is privately owned and they want to sell. The land is mainly used by dog walkers as it’s not safe for children and it’s by a huge park with 2 kids play areas and loads of room for dogs etc. Very NIMBY- ‘there’s too many people here already’ ‘the roads are too busy’ ‘we want to maintain the messy and dangerous area as it is. Whenever they ask me to sign it I politely refuse. We live here because it’s lovely- is it such a surprise others want to live here? You can’t protect prime real estate location for the odd dog Walker. Aaaargh!!

Not disagreeing with the sentiment, however given the reaction on MN when a dog so much as glances towards a child's playpark I can understand why the dog walkers want to go somewhere separate.

Fidodidit · 07/05/2022 10:51

My DM wanted to downsize. It was a big mental shift for her because she’d lived in the same area for 40 years and wasn’t good with change. After a lot of thought, she found a housing estate that was being developed at a location she thought would be perfect for her but there were only two bungalows being built in an area with a large population of elderly people, and they were snapped up. She died in the massive house.

Teateaandmoretea · 07/05/2022 10:50

I completely agree op.

But apparently ‘left wing’ mumsnet will go all capitalist on you and say as long as they can afford it then it’s fine.

Not that I ever intend moving when the kids move out but I haven’t objected to my views being ruined by the new houses being built locally…..