Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many people are hypocrites when it comes to housing?

234 replies

WestminsterCrabby · 07/05/2022 09:28

Got into quite a heated row discussion last night with some relatives. 🍷

They are Fuming (capital F intended) about all the new housing estates popping up in their leafy village. Apparently its ruined the views, ruined their dog walks yaddah yaddah.

These are couples in their late 50s early 60s whose children are long gone but still live in their large 4 bed detached homes. When I pointed out that perhaps so many new homes wouldnt need to be built (or smaller ones that took up less space) if people only took up the amount of space they needed rather than felt entitled to, they thought I was being very very unreasonable. I disagree!

I appreciate that people living in houses bigger than there needs is not the cause of the housing shortage HOWEVER surely you cant complain about other people needing to be housed while you yourself have 2 bedrooms per person?!?

Drives me mad and it's not the first time I've had conversations like this with people in a similar circumstances.

It makes me sad to see the countryside being converted over as well but people have got to live somewhere.

Aibu here?

OP posts:
hellrabbitishere · 07/05/2022 12:18

darlingdodo · 07/05/2022 09:37

I think the issue I would have is with the size and density of the estates and the fact that there is rarely any new infrastructure to cope with the additional people.

Town I live in has an estate of 600 new properties going up on the edge of town. It's a mixture of everything from 5 bed detached to 2 bed social housing flats, but the roads are so narrow that it's like running a slalom to drive through - no-one uses their garages to park cars because the garages aren't big enough (and many of the properties don't have garages anyway). The houses are far too close together so there's already been neighbour disputes. There has been no allowance for the numbers of children who will be attending local schools (the estate is aimed at families - imagine the number of additional children), no increase in GP provision, the road onto the estate is causing traffic problems on the main road.

Edinburgh is becoming encircled by massive new housing estates, I'm sure every single house will be someone's beloved family home, but they are soulless, heartless estates. Again, houses built too close together, no shops/cafes/amenities, no thought to schooling, medical provision, congestion.

Far more thought needs to be put into building new homes, but it won't happen, because the developers won't make enough billions.

I always wonder how many town planners, people who sit on planning boards etc live on one of these estates? My guess is none.

agree with this , there does need to be much more thought and care put into the design of new estates . in romford my hometown ,havent lived there now in 19 years everyones up in arms about a huge new development on the site of the old ice rink , the blueprint design looks lovely , but theres just one hospital serving a very large town that will now have to cope with even more people using it once these houses and flats are built, more demand on the schools and doctors .
i can kinda see why people are pissed about it , as you have said its all very well new huge builds that can house hundreds of people , but it needs more things put in place to support it , and yes sometimes the designs look awful , houses all identical and flats that look like they have all the space of a shoebox

my main issue is its never the right kind of housing , accross the country councils are spending millions putting homeless families in temp accomadation where they wait for months to be allocated either a housing assciation property or a council one , both of which are in short supply , these are normally families who are low income , cannot afford private rentals and in many cases cant get one anyway because if you have to claim housing benefit landlords dont want to touch you , we need more social housing built , yet all these new develepments up and down the country never are

NewHouseNewMe · 07/05/2022 12:18

I wonder if there were NIMBYs back in the 1930s when most of the outer London suburbs sprung up, along with their tube stations and new schools.
YANBU that we need more housing and have to accept it goes where it is needed even if locals don’t love it.
YABU to say older people need to move out to smaller properties. There are no bungalows where we live and service charges are £3K+/year.

tootiredtoocare · 07/05/2022 12:17

I live on one of the new housing estates - built on green land, which I do feel guilty about, but it was previously owned by a farmer who I think just can't exist any more and is selling up, I can't blame them for getting the most they can for their land. It's kind of in a spare bit between two established urban areas, which eases my guilt somewhat. Our first new build, though, was on a brown field site that the builders got cheap, and they were subsidised so we got a little 2 bed starter home for next to nothing (25 years ago, before house prices went stratospheric) and a neat housing estate was built on what was previously a muddy, unsafe, eyesore. Wish this was done more now, it got us onto the housing ladder, and a lot of the homes were bought by older people downsizing.

bellac11 · 07/05/2022 12:17

I also dont think its true to say there is a housing shortage, there is an affordable housing shortage.

TheHatinaCat · 07/05/2022 12:15

WestminsterCrabby · 07/05/2022 09:28

Got into quite a heated row discussion last night with some relatives. 🍷

They are Fuming (capital F intended) about all the new housing estates popping up in their leafy village. Apparently its ruined the views, ruined their dog walks yaddah yaddah.

These are couples in their late 50s early 60s whose children are long gone but still live in their large 4 bed detached homes. When I pointed out that perhaps so many new homes wouldnt need to be built (or smaller ones that took up less space) if people only took up the amount of space they needed rather than felt entitled to, they thought I was being very very unreasonable. I disagree!

I appreciate that people living in houses bigger than there needs is not the cause of the housing shortage HOWEVER surely you cant complain about other people needing to be housed while you yourself have 2 bedrooms per person?!?

Drives me mad and it's not the first time I've had conversations like this with people in a similar circumstances.

It makes me sad to see the countryside being converted over as well but people have got to live somewhere.

Aibu here?

So you are saying that they should downsize to benefit someone else not because they want to?

Is that what you would do then?

I'm not surprised it turned into a blazing row.

starlingdarling · 07/05/2022 12:15

I have no objections to new homes but do get annoyed about the lack of roads to keep up with an increasing population. I live in a village with three exits. Two go towards the town centre and are congested because they join the same road and have to pass a busy private school to get to town (30-50mins to town during term time, 10 minutes outside of school hours). The other goes in the opposite direction and doesn't have a turning for several miles so no long easy route to town. I'm dreading the 500 houses planned here. The village isn't huge so there's a good chance that even though I go in the opposite direction to get to work, I won't be able to get onto the high street because of congestion.

AzazaelsFury · 07/05/2022 12:12

Why should people who buy houses and pay them off then get old be obligated to sell them to young couples who "need it more"!?

Disagree with that outlook and always have. My parents live in my childhood home. 5 bedroom for 2 people. Grandkids stay often and every room is used and they love their home. Why should they have to move because some entitled person thinks they deserve it more?
Sorry not how it works.

JayAlfredPrufrock · 07/05/2022 12:11

What a nasty nasty thread.

midsomermurderess · 07/05/2022 12:10

As others have said, you see new housing estates marooned in dug-over fields on the edges of Edinburgh. The volume builders, who throw these shoddy estates up, have no interest in building communities, just build and run. That’s why you will have no schools, shops, medical centres, recreation facilities. It must be a dreadful way to live. Housing policy throughout the UK is woeful. It involves profligate use of land and on so many levels is environmentally disastrous.
As to turning empty shops in to homes, in most cases they aren’t suitable. The premises tend to be long so large parts of the space will be gloomy and lack natural light. And empty office blocks, well, offices and spaces for living are very different things.

RosesAndHellebores · 07/05/2022 12:10

what @Kitfish said.

I have no problem with new developments. However DH and I shall be staying in our substantial house with its substantial garden. We bought it and have paid high taxes throughout our lives and shall continue to live where we want even if it means three bedrooms each. We renovated it completely 4/5 years ago and will give it a link.of paint here and there over the next 25/30 years but will sustain no more substantial expenditure because it's worth more as a development site than the beautiful house it is - fortunately not listed.

DH and I have discussed this at length and it's more effective to put it in trust now for the dc to do what they like with when the time comes than it is for us to downsize. Meanwhile we shall keep the gardener and cleaner busy. Still working in our 60s; still paying tax.

CaptSkippy · 07/05/2022 12:09

I live in a house that's too big for me. But at the time my choices were limited. I am no longer elligible to rent below a certain amount per month, so I had to rent something pricier and larger than I had before. This how our goverment dealt with the looming housing crisis, trying to force people who earn above a certain income to move.
For a time it worked, but now all houses are a lot more expensive. If I move now I will be moving to something even more expensive, but smaller. I can't afford it anymore so now I am stuck in a house that's not exactly suitable for me.

Haircliphell · 07/05/2022 12:09

There is a massive new housing estate being built where we live. The area we live in is crap (to put it politely) and the estate was sold as bringing development into the area.

Except no new roads are being built. The local primary school has a maximum capacity of 210 and is already turning kids in catchment away. The nearest high school is five miles away. No new school is being built in the next decade. There is a Spar, chemist and a bookies. So hardly a vibrant, thriving community for people to become involved in.

What is really happening is that there are more people to pay council tax so the council have got what they wanted. House prices in the old area have shot up because it's a 'desirable area' now apparently. Most people rent because it was that sort of area but most people are being forced out now because landlords got gready. Now they're charging £1k per month for a mouldy old Victorian terrace that cost £500 per month a year ago.

LauraNicolaides · 07/05/2022 12:09

Polyethyl · 07/05/2022 12:03

There are an estimated 80,295 homes in London that are vacant. Probably because they are owned as secure capital investments, rather than for living in.
This is why we are building over our green fields! The more London properties are owned as investments, the more Londoners are pushed out to live in suburbs and satellite towns, which in turn pushes other people to live further out.

(I can't paste in the link to my source, how do you do that now. Anyway source is City AM.)

Do you know how many homes we need to build each year? If all of the empty homes you're talking about were nationalised and given free to new graduates it would cover three months of what needs building.

darlingdodo · 07/05/2022 12:09

LauraNicolaides, but that shortage could equally be caused by families with one or two children living in 4/5/6 bedroomed houses - it's not all about older people downsizing. Most of the retirees I know, those with adult children, live in 3 bedroomed houses, not mansions.

LauraNicolaides · 07/05/2022 12:05

SleeplessInEngland · 07/05/2022 12:00

NIMBYism is a huge political problem in the UK, especially for big infrastructure projects. Any government I’d damned if it does/damned if it doesn’t.

That's true of any political decision. It becomes good politics when more people will damn you for not doing it than vice versa. Demographics and the nature of the housing market are moving against the NIMBYs.

darlingdodo · 07/05/2022 12:05

Thebellagio, I totally agree with your point about houses being built with renewables incorporated - there shouldn't have been a house or business premises built in the UK in the last 10 years without solar panels and/or heat pumps.

SleeplessInEngland · 07/05/2022 12:04

“I just don’t understand why so many houses are being built”

I don’t what country you’re living in, but in the uk there sure as hell aren’t - not even close to meeting demand. But hey, I’m sure it’s all the immigrants’ fault.

Polyethyl · 07/05/2022 12:03

There are an estimated 80,295 homes in London that are vacant. Probably because they are owned as secure capital investments, rather than for living in.
This is why we are building over our green fields! The more London properties are owned as investments, the more Londoners are pushed out to live in suburbs and satellite towns, which in turn pushes other people to live further out.

(I can't paste in the link to my source, how do you do that now. Anyway source is City AM.)

lljkk · 07/05/2022 12:03

I fully agree about poor public transport and lack of pedestrian &/or cycle paths in new build areas. So annoying.

Locally, We get strident moaning about "no new homes/roads if no new infrastructure"

The local schools are under-subscribed

3 new doctor's surgeries could be built: but no doctors can be magicked up to staff them, anyway (ditto dentists)

Everyone complains about lack of local jobs: more residents would mean more local economic activity -> more local jobs

Everyone moans about lack of local social care staff: you mean the young people who can't afford to live here?

Our high street is moribund anyway, and much of it has been converted to flats

LauraNicolaides · 07/05/2022 12:02

I appreciate that people living in houses bigger than there needs is not the cause of the housing shortage

YABU - this plainly is a cause of the housing shortage!

SleeplessInEngland · 07/05/2022 12:00

NIMBYism is a huge political problem in the UK, especially for big infrastructure projects. Any government I’d damned if it does/damned if it doesn’t.

altiara · 07/05/2022 11:58

I don’t know if you’re being unreasonable or not, yes people have to live somewhere but where I live, there are huge blocks of flats going up around the town centre, then further out from the centre all green areas are being proposed to be built on. There are huge problems with traffic (been a problem for over 20 years since I’ve lived here), there aren’t enough schools, doctors surgeries etc. During previous building of new estates, there was supposed to be a new school and Gp centre, but that didn’t happen. So here, it’s not surprising that everyone wants the developing to stop now and try and keep some of the green areas green.
I feel like all the villages and towns now join up and there’s no community feel.

SecretVictoria · 07/05/2022 11:57

Meh, I’ll live in whatever house I like. I’ve paid for it. My parents would like to downsize (3 bed semi with loft conversion and large garden) but smaller properties, especially bungalows, are either the same price or more expensive. As soon as a bungalow goes for sale here it’s into a bidding war.

Quite often the smaller properties just aren’t available. I’d like to move to a bungalow in a few years but can’t see it happening. Wouldn’t mind a flat but a lot don’t let you have pets so a house that’s ‘too big’ it is.

bellac11 · 07/05/2022 11:55

You're both being unreasonable

Housing needs to be built or empty housing/offices repurposed if possible

But theres nothing wrong with people having bigger homes than they 'need'

Equally I do have some sympathy for the complaint about lack of infrastructure when new housing is built, I dont have a problem with the extra housing but with the lack of new schools and GP surgeries and public transport being supplied

Ultimately though the biggest gap in this country in terms of housing is social housing,

Choufleurfromage · 07/05/2022 11:54

wow YABU! So what if they have a house with 'too many rooms'. Theyvworked for it, so they can do what they want with it. None of your business