Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many people are hypocrites when it comes to housing?

234 replies

WestminsterCrabby · 07/05/2022 09:28

Got into quite a heated row discussion last night with some relatives. 🍷

They are Fuming (capital F intended) about all the new housing estates popping up in their leafy village. Apparently its ruined the views, ruined their dog walks yaddah yaddah.

These are couples in their late 50s early 60s whose children are long gone but still live in their large 4 bed detached homes. When I pointed out that perhaps so many new homes wouldnt need to be built (or smaller ones that took up less space) if people only took up the amount of space they needed rather than felt entitled to, they thought I was being very very unreasonable. I disagree!

I appreciate that people living in houses bigger than there needs is not the cause of the housing shortage HOWEVER surely you cant complain about other people needing to be housed while you yourself have 2 bedrooms per person?!?

Drives me mad and it's not the first time I've had conversations like this with people in a similar circumstances.

It makes me sad to see the countryside being converted over as well but people have got to live somewhere.

Aibu here?

OP posts:
PurassicJark · 07/05/2022 13:02

BinBandit · 07/05/2022 12:22

I don't know where I stand to be honest. We live in a 4bed detached 20 year old house that was build on former farmland towards the edge of a town. The area next to it was pretty deprived. Because of the new housing, the local school was upgraded, a new playpark built, the parent council was boosted by people who had access to resources and circles that the council estate didn't and raised enormous amounts for extra school equipment, the local shopping parade which was closing down bit by bit has been rejuvenated with new customers. there are new scout and guide groups, football field and coaching etc etc. It's really boosted the area for all children. The high school has gone up in the rankings. I come from a very rough council estate as does DH, we'd have been delighted when we were kids if "incomers" had brought these extra facilities etc.

On the other hand, our DC are currently in Uni and in the next few years we would want to downsize, and in theory a 2 bed would be fine. However there are things I have that I'd be reluctant to give up such as utility room, downstairs loo and in looking to the future, we might want the ability to have a downstairs bedroom and shower. Dh wants a dog when we retire and he doesn't want a small one so you need enough space in the house so we aren't tripping over it and then a garden of reasonable size, we'd like a new build so that the insulation is good and maintenance low....and once you start getting to that list you end up needing either a decent sized bungalow or at least a 3 bed semi....and once you reach that conclusion you wonder if it's worth moving.

I would be fine with building more houses if they did this in my council. But in the past decade, they've maybe built 2 more, if that, and I dread to think how many thousand of houses. The schools are mostly awful and falling down, shops are shutting, the roads are awful, the hospital is an actual joke, and they have the nerve to up our council tax every year!

They must provide the infrastructure to justify the extra houses. But not many places do unfortunately. Its just left to rot. God help the poor suckers that move here and pay those inflated prices for houses.

nokidshere · 07/05/2022 13:01

I moved onto a new build estate on the edge of a town 22 years ago. When we moved in it was pretty soulless, messy, just concrete and building works. Since we moved here there have been 600+ houses added.

However, 20 yrs on its lovely. Plenty of play areas, trees, landscaping, cycle paths and new roads. A new primary school was built at the beginning and 5 years ago they built another. There's a thriving community feel to it, local shops, pub etc. It's a lovely place to live.

On the down side there's still no secondary school on this side of town and no extra doctors or dentists.

My boys are grown up now but will be home for a while yet, when they do leave I have no intention of moving, however I also won't be moaning about new houses being built.

Crikeyalmighty · 07/05/2022 13:00

@Lockheart I couldn't agree with you more- you've clearly seen my'crikeyalmighty' party manifesto!!!

Crikeyalmighty · 07/05/2022 12:58

If I can say too we are coming back to UK and renting a detached non estate 4bedder in a nice town in south east and there's only 2 of us- we work /run business from home and my H has to have loudish video and music on as part of his job- and it cant all be done on headphones- plus we need a spare room, an office and a storeroom - so with people still working there are sometimes people like ourselves for whom a nice 2/3 bed semi or flat just wont work practically. As someone else said above with people working from home a lot more then a lot will ideally need 4 beds - and some 4 beds, especially modern ones often really aren't that big

Lockheart · 07/05/2022 12:56

Our housing situation in the UK is truly broken.

We do need more homes.

But new developments are cheaply built, poorly planned, low quality, identikit "executive homes". Rows and rows of monocultured asphalt and AstroTurf with little infrastructure or community, which will be riddled with problems in a couple of decades and which will likely not see out the century. They're the equivalent of the giant out of town shopping malls. And for this we are charged an exorbitant amount.

We also need to stop building on greenbelt. It's all very well to dismiss this as people wanting a pretty view or a nice walk, but the countryside feeds us and provides habitat for all the other living things that we share the planet with. You can't keep concreting over it.

Rather than building a few massive estates of tens or hundreds of identical homes on the outskirts of towns which have a disproportionate amount of pressure put on them, we should be focussing on the conversion of small brownfield sites into varied accommodation; flats, houses, bungalows, which are in keeping with the manner of the town, which integrate with the community and which are built to last. One or two extra houses in a village has little impact. An entire estate is a devastating carbuncle socially, environmentally, and from an infrastructure point of view.

We should also massively restrict holiday homes / cottages and Airbnb lettings. Housing stock should primarily be for housing.

Again, we do need more homes. But I also fully sympathise with a community who is landed with another massive soulless estate which will ruin their village.

There is a better way to do this.

darlingdodo · 07/05/2022 12:55

WhoSpottedThat, the same issues apply to older people in bigger homes - they may have lots of visitors (perhaps even more likely if they have grandchildren, and judging by the number of threads on MN, younger people with young families hate having visitors, especially grandparents 😁), they may still be working so need a home office, they may have a hobby room etc etc.

Tabitha005 · 07/05/2022 12:54

Wbeezer · 07/05/2022 09:35

I'm on our local community council, we review planning applications, one of the main issues we have is that developers don't want to build two bed bungalows which our village really needs, because they make more money from 4/5 executive homes. It's a nice place to live so local well heeled oldies carry on living in their large houses to stay part of the community.

I work for a community housing project attached to a charity that carries out housing needs surveys - mainly in rural areas. Our experience is that there are MANY older people who would love to downsize, but want to stay in the small town or village where they've lived for years and feel safe and part of the community.

Likewise, younger people, couples and young families needing more space can't often afford to buy property in new developments because they're simply too expensive - and they don't actually want to buy massive 'executive' detached houses, either that are more expensive to maintain and heat. They want decently-sized apartments and terraced/semi detached houses on small developments close to the town centre or village where they can still feel as though they're part of the community - as opposed to being stuck out in the middle of nowhere without good public transport or cycle/walking paths.

Developers, as you say, simply aren't building the type of housing that's most needed or wanted by the demographics mentioned above because they can't make large profits on it.

I too, feel similarly irritated by people who live exceptionally comfortably and complain about 'over development' and refuse to support smaller, community-minded developments that could be made available on a perpetually-affordable basis (through community led housing initiatives such as community land trusts, housing cooperatives and co-housing schemes). It totally smacks of 'I'm alright Jack, but f*ck everyone else'.

Crikeyalmighty · 07/05/2022 12:53

@EmilyBolton I don't disagree with you at all - which was why I looked at specific developments for my FIL, with huge wraparound balconies, ground floor ones with a nice patio etc - they were managed too by the leasholders- I was really impressed- insides were modern and funky and they had a bar, a library, a nice lounge and easy access to a very nice village/suburb.- plus a call button if they hit problems. My FIL I think would prefer a bungalow but a lot actually for sale needed a lot of work or were a bit run down and as others have said almost impossible to get a new one .

Chemenger · 07/05/2022 12:48

I am currently trying to sell my family home to downsize now the children are grown up. Families with young children who view it are put off by the upkeep of the big garden, the council tax, and the heating costs of a big old house. The most likely buyers seem to be people of our age who are semi retired and want a big garden to work in, space to work from home, and can afford the bills. Most people round us are active older people who garden and have family and friends to stay often and need space. When we moved in (20 odd years ago) we were the only family with children, and that hasn’t changed, even though several houses have changed hands.
I personally don’t like the amount of new houses being built on every available scrap of land round here, I think it’s a shame that productive farmland, mature trees and valuable habitat is being lost. In my opinion we should build up not out, my ideal home is a well built and managed high rise block with good amenities. I’ve lived in a city centre 36 storey apartment block in the US and loved it.

WhoSpottedThat · 07/05/2022 12:47

darlingdodo · 07/05/2022 09:46

Also, TBH, there are many families with one or two children who live in 5/6 bed houses when a 3 bed would do....

I understand your point but how do you know a 3 bed would do. What if they have regular visitors, or both work from home so use two rooms as studies. Life isn’t just about squeezing into the smallest possible space available.

Everyone should have the opportunity to have a comfortable space to live.

I also agree with the criticisms of new estates. We have several friends living on them. The roads are narrow, parking insufficient, there are no new schools, shops, pubs, doctors, etc etc. Just houses plonked in fields. There should be thought out community planning and the expectations should be legislated for.

Bunty55 · 07/05/2022 12:47

When these older couples bought their lovely big houses in pretty villages and paid a premium for them they probably thought they were safe in the knowledge that nothing would ever be built on the farmland around spoiling the view.

It seems nowhere is safe. If this were me and I had a wonderful view from my living room window for years and then a housing estate was built in the field next to me blocking the one thing I loved and wiping out my privacy I would be pissed off as well.

I see it happening all around where we live now. My daughter has a house on one of these estates. It is a lovely house and perfect. I would love to downsize from my home (not in a village) and buy a house on her estate but I can't afford it. The cost of these houses is crazy and they are all very close together with not much in the way of a garden.
She can't get my grandson into the village school because the housing estate is 0.9 miles away from the school and the catchment area is 0.5 miles.
She will have to take him to school in an area where they do not live. The estate is built on farmers fields but there is still a levy to pay on the council tax for the village even though she won't be able to send him to the school.

There is nowhere for children to kick a football around on this estate and as of yet - no shops or amenities.
It seems to me that this has not been properly thought through and the building plans rushed.
I wonder who considers the people when they build the new houses? What about the existing residents in the big houses? What about building bungalows for them to downsize to if they want to stay in their postcode?
Why would they even want to when social housing is a part of the scheme?
It's all mad.

.

HardyBuckette · 07/05/2022 12:44

RosesAndHellebores · 07/05/2022 12:10

what @Kitfish said.

I have no problem with new developments. However DH and I shall be staying in our substantial house with its substantial garden. We bought it and have paid high taxes throughout our lives and shall continue to live where we want even if it means three bedrooms each. We renovated it completely 4/5 years ago and will give it a link.of paint here and there over the next 25/30 years but will sustain no more substantial expenditure because it's worth more as a development site than the beautiful house it is - fortunately not listed.

DH and I have discussed this at length and it's more effective to put it in trust now for the dc to do what they like with when the time comes than it is for us to downsize. Meanwhile we shall keep the gardener and cleaner busy. Still working in our 60s; still paying tax.

As you've no problem with new developments, you're not one of the cohort OP is complaining about. You seem to understand that people making decisions like yours has consequences and to accept them, which is fine. I think her point is more about people who aren't doing that.

EmilyBolton · 07/05/2022 12:44

Crikeyalmighty · 07/05/2022 12:33

One problem is they build a lot of flats , but a lot of older people don't want flats as they are concerned about noise issues etc- flats need to be built to much higher specs on sound proofing, rubbish shutes, lifts etc. And be well looked after. The ones built here in Copenhagen are so much better quality .

There are some really good part buys specifically for over 55s though that are very good quality , giving them communal facilities, releasing cash and in nice areas- I was looking st this for my FIL. But obviously you have to be prepared to move areas to where they are- a lot are south coast.

I am over 55 and moved to bungalow’s . I did not look at flats. I would absolutely avoid flats. Stairs are a major issue for elderly people and one’s of reasons people have falls or go to live in nursing homes. Sure, flats may have lifts but what if there is a power cut or worse still a fire, or maintenance issues? You then become stuck and isolated . Jeez, it would scare the bejesus out of me.
it is fine that OP homes have flats as part of their buildings- they have help on hand and emergency generators. Not true in most privately owned flats
plus a flat means no garden in most cases. Why would you sell a home with nice access to outdoor space for one with space maybe 1 or 2 floors below you have to go onto a balcony to see, especially as these are folks that will be spending increasingly large proportion of time stuck at home.

Wisteriaroundthedoor · 07/05/2022 12:39

The ops point is nonsensical. There is a shortage and a need for affordable housing which means smaller family homes in thr right areas. There is no shortage of large homes. Telling people to move out doesn’t mean they become affordable for others. They don’t. It just puts pressure on the cheaper houses as more folks compete for them.

thr op clearly has issues, she says it “drives her mad” and she’s repeatedly telling people to leave their family homes. Envy? Lack of understanding of the housing market? Something is causing it, because who runs around telling folks to leave their homes?

EmilyBolton · 07/05/2022 12:38

Wbeezer · 07/05/2022 09:35

I'm on our local community council, we review planning applications, one of the main issues we have is that developers don't want to build two bed bungalows which our village really needs, because they make more money from 4/5 executive homes. It's a nice place to live so local well heeled oldies carry on living in their large houses to stay part of the community.

Absolutely this. Trying to move to a bungalow is difficult and they are disproportionately expensive given they require a proportionally bigger plot and due to short supply.
I had to move due to divorce and did find a dormer bungalow. But if we had not divorced we would have stayed put..why? Because our very large 4 bed house had space enough downstairs to make a downstairs bedroom and toilet if needed at some point in the future. My DB still lives in his big family home for precisely the same reason- he and dsil have it all figured out how to convert downstairs into a bedroom and bathroom if and when needed.
modern smaller 4 bed houses don’t have space for that. Bungalows will mean they have to spend over the odds and the cost of moving.

until there is decent housing stock to allow “ageing in place” at sensible prices and at sufficient supply then older folks most certainly will stay put. Why the hell would they move to a 2 bed property with only bedrooms being upstairs and no space downstairs to convert if needed. It just doesn’t make any sense.

NewHouseNewMe · 07/05/2022 12:36

darlingdodo · 07/05/2022 12:23

NewHouseNewMe, the houses being built in the thirties were generally lovely - substantial, decent sized rooms, well built, proper gardens, proper boundaries between them (in fact we lived in one about twenty years ago and it was the nicest house we've ever owned). There was also thought given to the infrastructure round the houses, so parks and recreational land, community centres, shops, sports clubs etc.

I had 2 maps of my suburb in 1929 and 1939, the period in which most housing sprung up.
In 1929, there are fields, a primary and a church, with very little else.
In 1939, there are roads and roads of houses and two tube stops, and not much else. The infrastructure came a bit later. Quite fascinating really.

I agree that the houses were superior by today’s standards, even if Mumsnet hates them!

Crikeyalmighty · 07/05/2022 12:33

One problem is they build a lot of flats , but a lot of older people don't want flats as they are concerned about noise issues etc- flats need to be built to much higher specs on sound proofing, rubbish shutes, lifts etc. And be well looked after. The ones built here in Copenhagen are so much better quality .

There are some really good part buys specifically for over 55s though that are very good quality , giving them communal facilities, releasing cash and in nice areas- I was looking st this for my FIL. But obviously you have to be prepared to move areas to where they are- a lot are south coast.

Ferngreen · 07/05/2022 12:30

Be sensible - everyone's a nimby if it is their life/ their children's wellbeing/ the volume of traffic noise/ airplanes flying over them.
People are magnanimous and welcoming and not nimbies because the new project is not really affecting their lives. Or more traffic, bigger school classes etc is not something they care about.

And just because it doesn't bother you to have 400 new homes along the road. The elderly person who has been there for decades and values the beautiful country walk they did every day is entitled to complain.

Criticising planners is pointless - they abide by the planning rules, (though everyone in my area claims they take back handers which I don't really believe) the developers know how to weasel their way round them - hence all the 4-5 bed homes.

TimBoothseyes · 07/05/2022 12:25

I have no problem with people living in homes that some may consider "to big" for them. What I do have an issue with is people objecting to new homes being built on fields, when, not 5 years ago their house was also was also built on green fields....yes leader of the Local Residents Action Group I'm looking at you and all your hypocritical minions.

darlingdodo · 07/05/2022 12:23

NewHouseNewMe, the houses being built in the thirties were generally lovely - substantial, decent sized rooms, well built, proper gardens, proper boundaries between them (in fact we lived in one about twenty years ago and it was the nicest house we've ever owned). There was also thought given to the infrastructure round the houses, so parks and recreational land, community centres, shops, sports clubs etc.

PenguinIce · 07/05/2022 12:23

Before forcing people to downsize maybe second homes and holidays let’s should be better regulated. In my local town there is few houses to rent long term but over 100 air b&bs. No point building more homes if they are not going to be lived in full time.

hellrabbitishere · 07/05/2022 12:22

AzazaelsFury · 07/05/2022 12:12

Why should people who buy houses and pay them off then get old be obligated to sell them to young couples who "need it more"!?

Disagree with that outlook and always have. My parents live in my childhood home. 5 bedroom for 2 people. Grandkids stay often and every room is used and they love their home. Why should they have to move because some entitled person thinks they deserve it more?
Sorry not how it works.

im not sure thats what the op quite meant though , it must be annoying to listen to a privilaged older couple living in comfort in a house thats bigger than they need moaning about new housing ,
i think she was just trying to make a point to them that whilst they are having that much space in their home they shouldnt be moaning about others needing housing and shes right .

BinBandit · 07/05/2022 12:22

I don't know where I stand to be honest. We live in a 4bed detached 20 year old house that was build on former farmland towards the edge of a town. The area next to it was pretty deprived. Because of the new housing, the local school was upgraded, a new playpark built, the parent council was boosted by people who had access to resources and circles that the council estate didn't and raised enormous amounts for extra school equipment, the local shopping parade which was closing down bit by bit has been rejuvenated with new customers. there are new scout and guide groups, football field and coaching etc etc. It's really boosted the area for all children. The high school has gone up in the rankings. I come from a very rough council estate as does DH, we'd have been delighted when we were kids if "incomers" had brought these extra facilities etc.

On the other hand, our DC are currently in Uni and in the next few years we would want to downsize, and in theory a 2 bed would be fine. However there are things I have that I'd be reluctant to give up such as utility room, downstairs loo and in looking to the future, we might want the ability to have a downstairs bedroom and shower. Dh wants a dog when we retire and he doesn't want a small one so you need enough space in the house so we aren't tripping over it and then a garden of reasonable size, we'd like a new build so that the insulation is good and maintenance low....and once you start getting to that list you end up needing either a decent sized bungalow or at least a 3 bed semi....and once you reach that conclusion you wonder if it's worth moving.

JudgeJ · 07/05/2022 12:20

NIMBYs, particularly of the boomer generation, drive me mad.

Good, glad we do!
It's not as simple as some people on here seem to think. I am now one person in a four bedroom house with a massive garden in a village, I would like to downsize but there is little on the market at the moment other than rabbit hutches for much the same price I would get for the house. I would prefer to stay put and employ help for the house and garden than move at the moment.

Booboobibles · 07/05/2022 12:18

If the new houses were attractive with big gardens full of trees then I wouldn’t object. When houses were built in the early 20th century they tended to have very large gardens and they’re mostly full of trees and great for nature. In fact they’re much better for nature than a field of wheat for example. Those gardens add up to a huge area and if animals can get through fences they’ve got a large habitat.

All the new houses/flats being built have tiny gardens - just little squares which are often paved or have fake grass….they leave absolutely no room for nature. My solution would be to spread houses out and create natural areas in between. It wouldn’t work because there’d be no land left for farming but I’m not a town planner so I don’t have any say anyway🙂