Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many people are hypocrites when it comes to housing?

234 replies

WestminsterCrabby · 07/05/2022 09:28

Got into quite a heated row discussion last night with some relatives. 🍷

They are Fuming (capital F intended) about all the new housing estates popping up in their leafy village. Apparently its ruined the views, ruined their dog walks yaddah yaddah.

These are couples in their late 50s early 60s whose children are long gone but still live in their large 4 bed detached homes. When I pointed out that perhaps so many new homes wouldnt need to be built (or smaller ones that took up less space) if people only took up the amount of space they needed rather than felt entitled to, they thought I was being very very unreasonable. I disagree!

I appreciate that people living in houses bigger than there needs is not the cause of the housing shortage HOWEVER surely you cant complain about other people needing to be housed while you yourself have 2 bedrooms per person?!?

Drives me mad and it's not the first time I've had conversations like this with people in a similar circumstances.

It makes me sad to see the countryside being converted over as well but people have got to live somewhere.

Aibu here?

OP posts:
XingMing · 07/05/2022 20:03

Almost 30 years ago, I suggested to DM that it was time to move out of her glamorous rented flat in poshest area of Sheffield and buy something she could afford outright nearer to her DM/my GM. And she did it. So she bought the cheapest most run down house in a street within walking distance of the town centre, two bedrooms, tiny courtyard, refurbished it, and it still works for her at 87, with a stairlift added recently. As it will do again for a young family when she dies and it's sold next time. It's an Edwardian terrace. She no longer has a car, and most of the houses in the street have been bought by BTL landlords, who have split up the houses horizontally to get two inadequate flats out of one property. I'd like to buy out the other person who will inherit from her, because the location is so central and it could provide a perfect starter home for DS.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 07/05/2022 20:02

Thank you for such a kind and pleasant comment, @pixie5121 . I was trying to explain why declutter it and downsizing is not the piss-easy task you think it is - and how overwhelming it could be, for an elderly person.

I’m not entirely sure that meant I deserved such unpleasantness from you.

bellac11 · 07/05/2022 19:46

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at poster's request.

Well I was specifically answering your point where you said that young families cant afford to put a roof over their heads

You're then saying its not about affordability but then also saying people are living in one beds because they cant afford to upsize. Make your mind up!

The reality is this is nothing about people downsizing or not and its a red herring.

pixie5121 · 07/05/2022 19:44

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

bellac11 · 07/05/2022 19:42

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at poster's request.

I dont understand what this would achieve for your example young family who cant afford to put a roof over their heads?

So that poster moves out, into a 2 bed bungalow lets say, or a 2 bed starter home.

And your example family then suddenly can afford to move somewhere, to what? The house the poster moved out of? How does that work?

ancientgran · 07/05/2022 19:38

I don't know if our local planners have more clout than others but when a substantial new estate is built there will be things like shops/schools/play facilities included. One local to me was built about 2 years ago and has a football pitch and club house that the builders had to include in the plans to get them passed. They also had to make a contributions to roads. Don't other areas do this?

A new development that got planning permission a few months ago, not built yet, had to include a new primary school.

pixie5121 · 07/05/2022 19:38

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

lameasahorse · 07/05/2022 19:30

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 07/05/2022 19:27

I do think that downsizing is often not as easy as it sounds. We bought this house when we had three teenage boys living at home. Now two of them have moved out, and have their own places, and the third has graduated and is living with us for a while, until he and his girlfriend get their own place - so we are not far off the point of having just two of us in a 4-bed house.

We have talked about downsizing, and I know we will have to, eventually - but bloody hell, it is a daunting task! We not only have a four-bed house, we also have enough stuff to fill a four-bed house! The thought of having to reduce it all to an amount that would fit in a smaller house/bungalow is simply overwhelming - and the older we get, the harder it will be, both physically and mentally, for us to do it.

I do try to declutter - I’ve been ruthless with my yarn stash, and even though I’m not finished, I’ve got four big bags full, to go to the charity shop. I get rid of books that I know I won’t reread.

And it’s not just the stuff - it’s the furniture. We bought furniture to fit this house and our needs - but I suspect we’d need a smaller suite, dining table, dresser, wardrobes etc, because a smaller house may well have smaller rooms, and our current stuff simply won’t fit (not if we want to walk around the rooms, that is) - and we’ve got a piano, inherited from my late MIL too - that has sentimental value.

Looking at the scale of the task we will face, I can absolutely understand why people older than me simply don’t have the energy or strength to face the declutter if and change involved in downsizing.

Elphame · 07/05/2022 19:22

I have no real beef with the new builds other than around here they are crammed in together and although the estate is not yet finished, the first phase is looking shabby as the rendering is already discolouring. They are shaping up to be the slums of the future.

What is more a problem is with an additional 3000 houses being built there have been none of the promised improvements to the infrastructure. The doctor and dentists are over subscribed and the school is full. The family pub that was promised has failed to materialise and the developer has now put in an application to build yet more houses there instead.

The roads are now constantly busy and another development application has gone in for yet another new estate. My village has been destroyed and there is no end in sight.

ShyMaryEllen · 07/05/2022 19:12

I wonder what many of the people who complain about older people living in larger houses will do when their parents die and they inherit? Will they stay where they are living at the time, or will they buy somewhere with a spare room and a kitchen big enough for entertaining?

lameasahorse · 07/05/2022 18:53

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Theoldwrinkley · 07/05/2022 18:52

I suppose we could be classified as 'boomers' (although not absolutely sure what the definition is). We have 5 bed bungalow. But do have lodgers, so feel we are making the most of the accomodation that our property offers. We don't want to downsize but couldn't afford to live here without the money coming in from our lodgers. Bungalows are marvellous, but so many people buy, then extend up into the roof, thereby negating the advantages of a bungalow.

TimBoothseyes · 07/05/2022 18:49

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Where I live HA bungalows are given to families. I've been in my 2 bed one since my divorce 22 years ago I pay just over £400 pcm and I don't receive any benefits. DD is now an adult and no longer lives here but when I enquired about 1 bed places all they had was 1 bed flats with no balcony or outside space so I'm staying put. If they were to build 1 bed houses then I'd move in a heartbeat.

lameasahorse · 07/05/2022 18:43

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

bellac11 · 07/05/2022 18:39

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Oh yes got you, I find threads difficult to follow at times.

lameasahorse · 07/05/2022 18:37

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Sleepyquest · 07/05/2022 18:32

Completely agree. There is a lot of new build developments where I live and a lot of people objecting to them also. I don't understand where they think people should live? I also think it's hypocritical when all houses were new builds once upon a time!

gwanwyn · 07/05/2022 18:32

SomewhereEast · 07/05/2022 17:34

I'm with you on this and think older couples and individuals down-sizing and freeing up family-sized homes would help a lot with housing (it certainly would in our town). Assuming our finances are ok longterm I quite like the idea of DH and I downsizing in our early sixties and giving the DC the money we make in downsizing to put towards a house deposit each. I'd rather they had homes than we had "the space to have everyone over for Christmas" or whatever reason retired people think they need four bedroom houses.

All my relatives looked at downsizing - there arent a lot of great options out there, it does cost money and it carries risks new properties can have hidden faults vs a property owned for decades is a known quanity and work may well have been done. My neighbour's late 50s are getting their house set up for their retirement years so it suits them changing the layout they had from when rising their children.

Even on radio 4 money program people come on saying down sizing hasn't freeded up the money they expected.

From what I see people even active people spend more time in their houses post retirement than before - and while they may not need the bedrooms the downstairs living spaces are more used.

Having second toilets/bathrooms downstairs or room for stair gates can be vital when ill health strikes and having a private garden you can sit in or potter in can also be very useful when you are not up for going out.

We expect to move for work before retirement so will leave family sixed home behind and may move again for retirement but our parents have lived in their locations for most of their lives - it's not that they need the bedrooms but it's where the familar things are and while change happens it's not all at once and where community they've been apart of for decades is.

I think along with not enough houses being built, developments not always putting in the much needed infrastructure there not actally the range of right type of housing being built.

My DGP built there own retiremmet house just before the hit those years it had two small bedrooms but so much downstairs space it suited them very well - decades - till last few months when they had to go into a home- when it was sold first thing done was expand the number of bedrooms- to add value to sell in on in few years - as bedroom numbers is how we sell houses in this country.

I think many glibly think oh we'll downsize but once the practicalities are looked into and it is a more immediate decision it's not such a straight forward option - at least that why no-one on our family actually managed it despite looking at doing it.

bellac11 · 07/05/2022 18:31

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Town houses come with lots of stairs and the lounge on the first floor away from the kitchen though?

How is that good for elderly people?

MintJulia · 07/05/2022 18:29

Prices are rocketing because we don't grow enough of our own food, we are dependent on Europe for much of our food and the war in Ukraine will hit hard, and yet we are building on farm land!
The environmental impact of building more homes rather than refurbish the ones we already have is huge.
And as a 58yo with a 4 bed house, and one dc who will head of to uni in a few years, trust me, finding a suitable two bed house is almost impossible because developers aren't building them.

So yea, I think yabu. Now wfh is so widespread, redeveloping commercial land for homes makes much more sense all round. But it costs more.

lameasahorse · 07/05/2022 18:24

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

lameasahorse · 07/05/2022 18:22

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

420Bruh · 07/05/2022 18:21

People will put planning objections in from their second homes. The cognitive dissonance is alarming. YANBU.

Giggorata · 07/05/2022 18:20

@lameasahorse, I agree that terraced town houses are great (if well built) housing for singles and younger families. I was thinking along these lines, since it concerns me that many young people wanting to set up on their own are priced out of the village by the huge new “executive” builds that are the norm, rather than affordable property.
But it was unusual to the point of sensational when new semis were built in the village. New terraces would be a dream come true for some of the villagers.

For older people, in the area where I live, there are LA or HA bungalows in most villages for older people plus numerous private ones for people to downsize into, if they wish.