Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Baby still has formula milk at 12 months

80 replies

Sofielou · 07/05/2022 08:39

DD turned 1 a couple weeks ago. I am struggling to let go of formula milk - she still has a 4/5oz bottle first thing in the morning, a smaller bottle in the morning or afternoon (we have replaced the 2nd day time bottle with cow's milk), and a large 8oz bottle before bed. So she's having 3 a day still.

She's picky with her meals, will eat bits but mostly throws it on the floor. This is the reason I'm still holding onto the formula because I'm worried she won't have a full tummy from the small amounts of solids she's eating.

Can I keep up with the formula until she's eating better? Or do I need to let it go? I'm so worried about her calorie intake and nutrition, it really consumes my mind. 😢

OP posts:
ldontWanna · 07/05/2022 09:27

@Sofielou stopping formula at 1 isn't the done thing. The recommendation is to stop using bottles when they're 1 and use cups or beakers instead.

  • You should continue to breastfeed or give your baby first infant formula until they're at least 1 year old. Breastfeeding will continue to benefit you and your baby for as long as you carry on. As your baby eats more solid foods, the amount of milk they want will decrease. Once your baby is eating plenty of solids several times a day, they may even drop a milk feed altogether.*

That's from the NHS website . Your husband is right. She will cry when she's crying or show you in other ways.

You can start dropping the morning bottle as there will be plenty of other opportunities for her to eat during the day. Either formula, or actual food. At 7 try a banana,a yogurt, a cup of milk, a yogurt, a slice of toast (even if she just nibbles at it). She will have breakfast at CM only an hour after so she won't starve.

I know it's hard figuring all out on your own,especially if you have no support . It was the same for me and DD was a lowish weight too with very small or no weigh gain. No one gave a crap, but I was massively told off for her being short at her 2 year review. 🙄

EmeraldShamrock1 · 07/05/2022 09:27

I was in a similar position with a fussy eater and continued using formula, the 12 month plus brand.

I'm not sure it helped, he continued to be a fussy eater and still is today though he became an obese fussy eater.

I'm not sure if the formula or sensory issues caused weight gain, he seeks plain bland food to comfort a lot.

Formula will stop hunger and she won't be encouraged to try more foods.

changeis · 07/05/2022 09:21

Yes I was worried about food with my first child. I kept the formula until he was 2 which wasn’t the right thing to do thinking back as he was reluctant to eat as he was full with the formula. He never drank milk cow and at 6 still doesn’t. With my second and third, I completely stopped the formula the day they turned one and gradually they started eating more and more. I understand the worry having been there but honestly I am on my third child now and things are a lot more different as I have become more chilled out.

stillsleeptraining · 07/05/2022 09:21

Sofielou · 07/05/2022 09:18

This is probably going to sound insane but... I worry that she has no way of "telling" me if she felt hungry. So I just keep giving milk to make sure she doesn't have an empty tummy and no way of telling me. DP keeps saying she'll cry if shes hungry. Not sure why this is so anxiety provoking for me tbh. Do other mums worry about this stuff?

I'd worry more about creating a snacker (which is very healthy) than I would her being a bit hungry. If you have a routine with food with one snack in between the meals, she'll know it's coming and look forward to it

Sofielou · 07/05/2022 09:20

ImustLearn2Cook · 07/05/2022 09:17

When I was weaning my dd , I found giving her a banana smoothie (I make it with frozen banana and milk) helped a lot.

Does your 1yr old like banana?

She loves banana, it's one of her favourite foods. I mean, she's pretty much being fussy with everything I give her at the moment (possible teething as she was a good eater up until recently). But I think she will eat this, I'm try it. Thank you.

OP posts:
stillsleeptraining · 07/05/2022 09:18

I was told off by the hospital dietician for keeping DC on formula after 1. Apparently it's the protein from cows milk they need, not the extra vitamins from formula.

We've settled on this stuff - whole milk with extra vitamins and iron for kids.

Baby still has formula milk at 12 months
Sofielou · 07/05/2022 09:18

This is probably going to sound insane but... I worry that she has no way of "telling" me if she felt hungry. So I just keep giving milk to make sure she doesn't have an empty tummy and no way of telling me. DP keeps saying she'll cry if shes hungry. Not sure why this is so anxiety provoking for me tbh. Do other mums worry about this stuff?

OP posts:
SheWoreYellow · 07/05/2022 09:18

As others have mentioned, it doesn’t really matter whether she’s on formula or cow’s milk.
You need to work out if you want to cut down some milk to encourage her to eat solids.

As she’s on the higher side weight wise you’ve got a bit of a buffer if she doesn’t eat brilliantly to begin with, so I’d start to gently cut down the milk.

I’d probably remove the daytime bottle and reduce the bedtime one to begin with.

ImustLearn2Cook · 07/05/2022 09:17

When I was weaning my dd , I found giving her a banana smoothie (I make it with frozen banana and milk) helped a lot.

Does your 1yr old like banana?

Bluebellsinthemistywood · 07/05/2022 09:15

Mine has the toddler formula milk at 17 months. He isn’t keen on cows milk. He only has it at night so I’m not stressing about it Smile

changeis · 07/05/2022 09:14

stop the formula and continue with the normal milk. I have done this with all 3 of my kids. The formula is taking the space of the food so she won’t be hungry but with normal milk she will start gradually eating more and more. You just have to be patient and don’t get stressed. Give water with every meal.

Sofielou · 07/05/2022 09:12

ldontWanna · 07/05/2022 09:01

Do you have any weigh in clinics nearby that are operating as usual?
Take your DD to be weighed, and talk to one of the HV/nurses there.

She's still little. It's quite normal to eat bits and pieces and get most of her calories from milk .

If you were breastfeeding, I bet you wouldn't have had so many replies that you must stop now and swap for cow's milk or water.

Why do you want to swap? Cost, practicalities?

Is she active,happy,playing,babbling? Is her weight ok?

I did breastfeed for 7 months (alongside formula). She stopped feeding by herself after I weaned her, which broke my heart 😢

I want to stop partly for cost reasons, and partly because I feel like it's what I'm supposed to do now she's 1, if that makes sense? But I've had no support with it so I feel like everything is just guesswork, which I find really stressful!

Yes she's a content happy playful baby in general. Weight is fine from what I can work out according to the online stuff. She actually seems to be in the higher percentiles for her age so she's definitely not underweight.

OP posts:
Howaboutnope · 07/05/2022 09:07

You've said in your posts it consumes your mind and you're really worried etc. This is not normal please see your GP about your anxiety urgently.

ldontWanna · 07/05/2022 09:01

Do you have any weigh in clinics nearby that are operating as usual?
Take your DD to be weighed, and talk to one of the HV/nurses there.

She's still little. It's quite normal to eat bits and pieces and get most of her calories from milk .

If you were breastfeeding, I bet you wouldn't have had so many replies that you must stop now and swap for cow's milk or water.

Why do you want to swap? Cost, practicalities?

Is she active,happy,playing,babbling? Is her weight ok?

dementedpixie · 07/05/2022 09:01

Yes cows milk should be fine to give first thing and then breakfast later

Mrsjayy · 07/05/2022 09:00

Reduce her formula and start introducing cows milk . Also get her a sippy cup to start practicing and then take away the bottles.

Sofielou · 07/05/2022 08:59

@Regenbogen22

Thank you, that's a good idea.

OP posts:
Regenbogen22 · 07/05/2022 08:55

Sofielou · 07/05/2022 08:51

Do you think it will be OK to give her cows milk first thing on a morning then, instead of her formula bottle? On a week day I normally give her formula around 7am and then she has her breakfast with the childminder at about 8/8.30am. 7am feels a bit too early to give her actual breakfast. So if I do cows milk instead before we leave the house, this will be enough for her until she has breakfast at 8/8.30??

(Sorry if this sounds stupid. I honestly have so much worry that she is getting what she needs)

Just give her water and half a banana or a little yogurt first thing.

Sofielou · 07/05/2022 08:51

Do you think it will be OK to give her cows milk first thing on a morning then, instead of her formula bottle? On a week day I normally give her formula around 7am and then she has her breakfast with the childminder at about 8/8.30am. 7am feels a bit too early to give her actual breakfast. So if I do cows milk instead before we leave the house, this will be enough for her until she has breakfast at 8/8.30??

(Sorry if this sounds stupid. I honestly have so much worry that she is getting what she needs)

OP posts:
SunnyShiner · 07/05/2022 08:47

Your childminder is chatting dogshit

Regenbogen22 · 07/05/2022 08:46

Summerholidayorcovidagain · 07/05/2022 08:42

Reduce the milk and she will be hungry for solid food! Keep with the milk and she will stay with milk!

This ☝
Switch to cow's milk and start reducing. Check out baby lead weaning sites for help with solids if it's a problem

SW1amp · 07/05/2022 08:46

And children don’t need ‘a full tummy’

An inability to regulate their appetite and to only know a feeling of being stuffed is why we have horrific childhood obesity

as pp said, reduce the bottles, let her eat more food until her appetite is satisfied and it will teach her to eat well

MissLC · 07/05/2022 08:46

My LO is 13 months and still has formula.
She has up to 6oz in the morning, then I've switched to cows milk in the afternoon, 7oz at bed and then 4oz overnight. She eats well in the main too.
Once she's used to her afternoon bottle I'll change her morning bottle but my main reason for not just swapping all quickly is I want to use the formula we have in the house! I think we have around 5 tubs left.
I've not noticed any difference in her hunger levels since swapping her afternoon bottles so think it probably does fill her up the same? I also give vitamins now, especially on days she doesn't have as much formula

TheOccupier · 07/05/2022 08:45

Sofielou · 07/05/2022 08:39

DD turned 1 a couple weeks ago. I am struggling to let go of formula milk - she still has a 4/5oz bottle first thing in the morning, a smaller bottle in the morning or afternoon (we have replaced the 2nd day time bottle with cow's milk), and a large 8oz bottle before bed. So she's having 3 a day still.

She's picky with her meals, will eat bits but mostly throws it on the floor. This is the reason I'm still holding onto the formula because I'm worried she won't have a full tummy from the small amounts of solids she's eating.

Can I keep up with the formula until she's eating better? Or do I need to let it go? I'm so worried about her calorie intake and nutrition, it really consumes my mind. 😢

Have you considered that if DD wasn't full/getting so many easy calories from formula she might want to eat more solids? It's also a texture thing - babies need to get used to different food textures, chewing etc. so if you keep giving her formula that won't happen. Assuming she's not seriously underweight (in which case you should have support from your GP/HV), switch to cow's milk and hold your nerve. She won't starve.

SW1amp · 07/05/2022 08:44

Your childminder is talking absolute nonsense!

the calories in formula and whole cows milk are pretty much identical

cows milk doesn’t have the added vitamins that formula has, but she will be getting that from whatever she eats