Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Baby still has formula milk at 12 months

80 replies

Sofielou · 07/05/2022 08:39

DD turned 1 a couple weeks ago. I am struggling to let go of formula milk - she still has a 4/5oz bottle first thing in the morning, a smaller bottle in the morning or afternoon (we have replaced the 2nd day time bottle with cow's milk), and a large 8oz bottle before bed. So she's having 3 a day still.

She's picky with her meals, will eat bits but mostly throws it on the floor. This is the reason I'm still holding onto the formula because I'm worried she won't have a full tummy from the small amounts of solids she's eating.

Can I keep up with the formula until she's eating better? Or do I need to let it go? I'm so worried about her calorie intake and nutrition, it really consumes my mind. 😢

OP posts:
Sofielou · 07/05/2022 11:05

Can anyone give me ideas for healthy between meal snacks for her? I tend to rely on bananas a lot as she loves them and it's easy to give her that wherever we are, E.g. out and about. What else can she snack on?

OP posts:
Sofielou · 07/05/2022 11:04

@RedRobyn2021

She was around the 80th centile at last check a month ago.

OP posts:
Sofielou · 07/05/2022 10:59

PrincessRamone · 07/05/2022 10:13

It’s OK to start to move into the next phase OP.

At 1 year plus, your job is no longer to “make sure her tummy is full”. Your job is now to give her opportunities to sample a wide range of foods, so that going forward she can regulate her appetite.

This is helpful. I will try to keep this in mind, thank you!

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 07/05/2022 10:22

As said, the morning bottle should be reduced so she's hungry. It doesn't have to be swapped for cow's milk. Cow's milk was pushed for the sake of dairy farming, most swap because it's cheaper. There's other forms of calcium. If it makes you worry less, stick with formula. It's around 18 months when there should be a definite switch to food and not milk. The chewing helps the muscles for speech. Babies develop at different places. She's at the stage of throwing food, which is finding out about cause and effect.

RedRobyn2021 · 07/05/2022 10:14

Sofielou · 07/05/2022 09:18

This is probably going to sound insane but... I worry that she has no way of "telling" me if she felt hungry. So I just keep giving milk to make sure she doesn't have an empty tummy and no way of telling me. DP keeps saying she'll cry if shes hungry. Not sure why this is so anxiety provoking for me tbh. Do other mums worry about this stuff?

I'm sure they do, I think lots of parents worry that their child is getting enough. I make sure to offer breakfast, lunch, dinner and then snacks in between from when my DD turned 12mo (she is 14mo atm), if she doesn't want them fair enough! Sometimes she does and sometimes she doesn't. Babies are good at knowing when they've had enough.

Do you know what centile she is on? My dd is 96th and I still worry, so it just goes to show some parents will just worry regardless

Ultimately (IMO) I don't think you should put pressure on yourself or her, perhaps begin to slowly cut down on the formula and offer an additional snack with it?

PrincessRamone · 07/05/2022 10:13

It’s OK to start to move into the next phase OP.

At 1 year plus, your job is no longer to “make sure her tummy is full”. Your job is now to give her opportunities to sample a wide range of foods, so that going forward she can regulate her appetite.

MRex · 07/05/2022 10:12

Sofielou · 07/05/2022 09:18

This is probably going to sound insane but... I worry that she has no way of "telling" me if she felt hungry. So I just keep giving milk to make sure she doesn't have an empty tummy and no way of telling me. DP keeps saying she'll cry if shes hungry. Not sure why this is so anxiety provoking for me tbh. Do other mums worry about this stuff?

All mums worry about different stuff, but definitely all mums worry about something or other that they really don't need to!

She will cry if she's hungry, she'll also get some initial words soon if she doesn't have any, don't worry she will let you know!

YesitsJacqueline · 07/05/2022 10:10

Op try giving the meals first and a bottle after
You may find she doesn't want as much milk, and definitely switch to full fat cows milk
I was anxious like you and didn't go for baby led weaning
I spoon fed ds at that age with mashed and pureed food , yoghurt, porridge etc and that worked out really well for us.
He's 8 now and has a great appetite and eats a variety of foods , it worked for us.

2pinkginsplease · 07/05/2022 10:04

By the sound of it you are filling her up on formula hence why she isn’t eating much. Cut out the formula and drop the milk feeds. Give her some milk in the morning when she wakes and again before bed.

your child isn’t eating because they aren’t hungry due to being fed formula milk.

Magicfeet11 · 07/05/2022 10:01

And yes your partner is right she'll cry or grizzle if she's hungry

Magicfeet11 · 07/05/2022 10:01

Sofielou · 07/05/2022 09:18

This is probably going to sound insane but... I worry that she has no way of "telling" me if she felt hungry. So I just keep giving milk to make sure she doesn't have an empty tummy and no way of telling me. DP keeps saying she'll cry if shes hungry. Not sure why this is so anxiety provoking for me tbh. Do other mums worry about this stuff?

Honestly I never worried about this. I started ditching formula from 11 months onwards to lose the horrific cost. I gradually reduced the bottles so at 1 they were having a bottle at bedtime then sippy cup with cow's milk or water the rest of the day.

I always gave breakfast at 7 and never milk before otherwise she wouldn't eat it. Sippy cup of water with breakfast or small amount of milk in sippy cup after breakfast.

MRex · 07/05/2022 09:59

Switch to cow's milk and give her some liquid baby vitamins at breakfast time, mine always liked Haliborange. She'll eat when she's hungry, get some good food into her but just start one meal at a time on schedule so that her tummy gets used to 7am = breakfast, 12pm = lunchtime, 5pm = dinner. Mine started with lunch at 6 months and built up to having 3 meals by 18 months, little morning and afternoon snack came later but only when running about for hours (so that's most days!!).

If she isn't super excited about food and not allergic then maybe it's worth thinking about what you are feeding her and how, because most babies will get interested in munching even on a bit of toast and slices of apple. We always ate with DS (except his dinner), so he had bits of what we had and just naturally joined in. Did you do a full weaning journey of tasting bits of lots of foods from 6 months? How did she do then? If she's done samples of everything so you've checked food allergies and patrticular dislikes, then try changing what you're giving her initially to get her into the habit of eating. Easy stuff that most kids will find interesting are lasagne, savoury pancake at lunch or fruit one for breakfast, stuffed omelette, honey or nut butter in porridge, houmous or mushroom pate on toast, tortelloni with veg pesto, breaded chicken sticks, veg-loaded pizza slices, shepherds pie etc. Put the veg into dishes chopped up really small if she's rejecting that and increase size as she gets older, then she'll get used to all the textures and flavours.

Twizbe · 07/05/2022 09:55

Try to switch from a bottle to a cup as well, she doesn't NEED the milk at this age so if she drinks less it's ok. You can also give her a yoghurt at lunch or some extra cheese to give her some more dairy.

If it helps, my children (5 and 3) have a cup of soya milk first thing and before bed. It's a drink that they like and is good for them. They have their milk at 7 and then breakfast is around 7:30/8 (depending on day of the week)

I had a cup of bedtime milk until I was well into primary school because I liked milk. It was my favourite drink.

Fluffycloudland77 · 07/05/2022 09:52

When I was nhs the clinic refused to give formula to women when baby turned one, you got £4 coupons for healthy start instead.

Surely baby will cry if hungry?

lisavanderpumpscloset · 07/05/2022 09:48

If she's resisting cows milks you can slowly introduce it by mixing the 2. Add an oz at a time so she'll get used to the taste etc

If you're happy keeping her on formula just use the next one up, I'm sure they make formula for older kids, but I might be wrong here

CmonYouKnow · 07/05/2022 09:45

You should have a development review between 9-12 months. You can contact the HV team to request support if you feel it would be beneficial.

user1471538283 · 07/05/2022 09:40

My DS went onto full fat cows milk at 12 months and drank loads of it. Might your little one eat a weetabix at 7am with lots of milk? Maybe half a banana? My DS would be ravenous as soon as he woke. He has always loved milk.

I think formula is very filling.

Sofielou · 07/05/2022 09:33

Ok thank you. It looks like I need to reduce the formula and sit with the anxiety...and resist the urge to give her something to fill her tummy!

Should I have had contact with a HV by now? I haven't seen her since DD was 4 months old. I've had no help and no appointments, nothing.

OP posts:
collieresponder88 · 07/05/2022 09:33

I would suggest the reason she doesn't want food is maybe because of all the milk ! Small cup in the morning and again before bed thank will increase her appetite and start to eat proper food which should be happening now I don't think it really matters weather it's formula or cows just cut it right back though

EmeraldShamrock1 · 07/05/2022 09:33

Formula will stop hunger and she won't be encouraged to try more foods.
To counter the above, she won't be encouraged to try more foods if she has sensory issues either.
Its a minefield.
The formula helped bulk if a sensory issue.
There are lots of play therapy things you can do at home if sensory.
Sand bucket, rice bucket, slim bucket, food play.

GeminiTwin · 07/05/2022 09:32

Honestly, just switch to cows milk. You don't need to phase it just switch. She will be getting enough vitamins and nutrients from solids and babies really don't need to eat much. Their tummy shouldn't be 'full' all the time. Is adults would feel very uncomfortable if we were full all the time.

You can pick up some vitamin drops from the supermarket. I put Abidec drops in my DDs warm bottle of cows milk in the morning.

Get rid of the formula from today. It'll save you a fortune.

dollymuchymuchness · 07/05/2022 09:31

Summerholidayorcovidagain · 07/05/2022 08:42

Reduce the milk and she will be hungry for solid food! Keep with the milk and she will stay with milk!

I came on to say exactly this. ^

BusyMum47 · 07/05/2022 09:30

Idontevenknow · 07/05/2022 08:43

I would swap to cows milk too

Mine always dropped a bottle at a time, with the one at night the last one to go.

I'd focus on dropping the morning one first, and just get her straight onto her breakfast. Then drop the afternoon one and replace with a snack. I wouldn't worry about the evening one for a long time, just switch from bottle to cup

I agree with this 100%! ⬆️

Mine were exactly the same. Don't stop offering a wide variety of food at every opportunity but try not to get too stressed about it if she's not keen - it'll all work out eventually.

That bedtime milk bottle hung around for ages in our house - our eldest son stubbornly resisted all attempts at swapping an actual bottle for a sippy cup, too! Had to resort to bribery in the end!! 😆

Pinkpigs · 07/05/2022 09:29

Took both my children of formula at 9 months old and gave them cows milk and i never feed them baby food I gave them what I had with out the salt there adults now so was a long time ago

Sofielou · 07/05/2022 09:29

@changeis

Glad to see I'm not alone. I honestly don't understand where it comes from, as I was very well fed and looked after as a child myself! I was however very fussy with food and underweight most of my childhood/adolescence. I wonder if I am subconsciously trying not to create the same problems in DD by "over feeding" her?? 🙈

OP posts: