Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that televising the Amber Heard/Johnny Depp case is harmful to DV victims?

111 replies

Thorilicious · 07/05/2022 08:03

I know it's America, and it's the done thing.

However, the majority of the public have already decided that's she's lying, and we're not even halfway through the case.

Whatever you believe, there will be some DV victims who are even more afraid to come forward, due to opinions about this trial.
AIBU to think that such a high profile case should have been tried behind closed doors?

OP posts:
Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 07/05/2022 09:14

BonnesVacances · 07/05/2022 09:12

did you see the clip of him walking towards A and she recoils? His little smug shrug and smirk was very telling.

Did you see the clip of her walking towards him before the morning break on the same day, trying to catch his eye and him looking away and being able to walk directly past him?

There was no recoiling then from AH. That's why JD was smirking. Because he knew she was acting.

She's the one continuing to look in his direction, he doesn't look up to look at her.

ENoeuf · 07/05/2022 09:12

^^ in public I mean, in a filmed trial.

ENoeuf · 07/05/2022 09:12

Thorilicious · 07/05/2022 09:09

I don't mean it should be brushed under the carpet, but I feel the all the details should be made public after all the evidence has been heard, rather than it playing like a soap opera for everyone to see.

I can’t think of any reason why someone should recount in detail their experience of being penetrated by a bottle without their consent. True or not, it’s a terrible accusation and I can’t see why JD would want it made publicly against him.

BonnesVacances · 07/05/2022 09:12

did you see the clip of him walking towards A and she recoils? His little smug shrug and smirk was very telling.

Did you see the clip of her walking towards him before the morning break on the same day, trying to catch his eye and him looking away and being able to walk directly past him?

There was no recoiling then from AH. That's why JD was smirking. Because he knew she was acting.

50ShadesOfCatholic · 07/05/2022 09:11

I think there is a lot of US conflict that should not be televised. It is sick to treat distressing courtroom proceedings as entertainment.

PansyPetunia · 07/05/2022 09:11

Hasn't HE taken HER to court though?

Vsirbdo · 07/05/2022 09:10

@Notlabeled I think to televise every trial would mean a lot of victims would not testify: the experience of going to court after you’ve been abused is retraumatising enough without people picking over it. The idea of doing that to victims makes me feel a bit sick

Thorilicious · 07/05/2022 09:09

Discovereads · 07/05/2022 09:06

I don’t think it’s harmful to DV victims. It is what it is and brushing it under the carpet isn’t going to help DV victims.

I don't mean it should be brushed under the carpet, but I feel the all the details should be made public after all the evidence has been heard, rather than it playing like a soap opera for everyone to see.

OP posts:
BonnesVacances · 07/05/2022 09:08

HailAdrian · 07/05/2022 09:00

Do we really think a guy who talks about 'fucking her corpse' isn't capable of sexual violence?

In the context of quoting from Monty Python, I don't see this as an irrefutable example of the capacity for sexual violence tbh. But I can see why others would feel differently.

But at the end of the day, IMO, if the accusations were true, and he was beating her all the time, she wouldn't be having to make shit up. The clear evidence of the aftermath would be there. A bigger bruise you don't have to squint to see, ripped clothes, bloodied sheets.

She could have gone with a "I pushed him so far and he thumped me" claim, which is what my starting position was on this story, with the evidence of DV between AH & JD. And we know that a man is not allowed to fight back under any circumstances because he's bigger and stronger. So I did believe he'd hit her.

But the claims have gone way further than that and aren't just unsubstantiated but are clearly disproven. So that shows a different dynamic to the power play and who's abusing who as this trial goes on, and what's going on tbh.

And I've watched the whole trial so far and have an interest in psychology, social behaviour and trials. Hence why I'm watching it. Not as some perverse voyeur.

Discovereads · 07/05/2022 09:06

I don’t think it’s harmful to DV victims. It is what it is and brushing it under the carpet isn’t going to help DV victims.

Vsirbdo · 07/05/2022 09:06

I find the level of detail quite distressing and the obvious answer is to avoid it but somehow I still keep clicking onto it. I haven’t followed it closely enough to understand who may or may not be lying but I am really concerned about the damage this is going to do to people believing victims of abuse which is an uphill battle as it is

Pegasaurus · 07/05/2022 09:06

I haven't watched or particularly followed the case and have no idea who's telling the truth. However, it does disturb me that many victims of domestic violence struggle to leave because they fear no one will believe that their outwardly charming partner is an abuser behind closed doors. And seeing the disbelief and vitriol directed at AH can't be helping with that, regardless of the truth in this case.

Bednobsbroomsticks · 07/05/2022 09:05

ENoeuf · 07/05/2022 09:01

It’s mad. Im so surprised at all the support on SM and amongst my kids for him. Utter loser - bloated and addicted and regardless of AH what has come out about his thoughts on women is disgusting and yet people still want to support him.
did you see the clip of him walking towards A and she recoils? His little smug shrug and smirk was very telling.

I did lol. Both of their reactions were strange I thought. And he will not look at her will he?

Fishwishy · 07/05/2022 09:04

araiwa · 07/05/2022 08:37

FFS. Not every instance of a woman being criticized is due to misogyny. There are plenty of legitimate, obvious and proven reasons someone might think amber Heard is a shitty person

Overuse of such terms dilutes their meaning and impact.

This is Mumsnet everything that happens to women is misogyny. So much the word has lost its meaning now.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 07/05/2022 09:04

HailAdrian · 07/05/2022 09:00

Do we really think a guy who talks about 'fucking her corpse' isn't capable of sexual violence?

I think many people say things they wouldn't actually do when they're angry or annoyed by someone.

ENoeuf · 07/05/2022 09:01

Bednobsbroomsticks · 07/05/2022 08:57

It's extremely damaging . Taking amber heard out of it, there seems to be a movement ATM that is supporting JD regardless of his actions. The man trashes houses, refers to his women as c*s, even the mother of his children, clearly has serious drug alcohol issues, is verbally and physically abusive and yet he is held up as some kind of hero, women want him and men say well done Johnny women can be poisonous.

It's like a collective brainwashing

All of JDs staff have already been seen as lying on oath. Have you ever seen JD in a state, no . Out of control? No OUT of his head on drugs? No. Cue tape on plane of him groaning and howling like a dog sounding extremely out of it. Paid liars all of them. But everyone focuses on the other liar. There's truth in there, there also lies. He said she said, making a mockery of DA both of them. Chuck it out of court

It’s mad. Im so surprised at all the support on SM and amongst my kids for him. Utter loser - bloated and addicted and regardless of AH what has come out about his thoughts on women is disgusting and yet people still want to support him.
did you see the clip of him walking towards A and she recoils? His little smug shrug and smirk was very telling.

HailAdrian · 07/05/2022 09:00

Do we really think a guy who talks about 'fucking her corpse' isn't capable of sexual violence?

BonnesVacances · 07/05/2022 08:59

ENoeuf · 07/05/2022 08:30

I don’t think it should be televised because if she’s recounting accurately she’s had to relive abuse and sexual violence in front of a huge audience including his weirdo fans who are allowed in, and had that turned into memes and her every expression analysed.
If she isn’t (I believe her fwiw) he’s had a lot of terrible things revealed about himself (substance abuse, misogyny) as well as false accusations. However, he wanted it televised and she didn’t.
its also allowed a lot of people to
monetise it via false information/ misunderstanding and making YouTube videos to cash in.

I agree with part of this. If the accusations are true, it would be horrific for the courts in the US to permit this trial to be streamed around the world and for it to be so public.

But if the accusations are false, not so to her, but more so to genuine victims of DV.

I guess if you start with the position that JD says he knows the accusations to be false and he wants to repair his reputation, televising the trial is ok. If they are true, JD is being allowed to continue his abuse in this way.

So the process is definitely flawed as the jury hasn't yet decided if the accusations are true or not.

But the trial is whether AH defamed JD. All the defence had to do was show that there had been physical violence, so the damage to JD's reputation was justified or find some legal loophole that meant that legally the op-ed wasn't about JD because it didn't mention him by name.

The defence chose to put AH on the stand and to detail every single claim of DV in public. They only had to prove one beyond reasonable doubt.

Bednobsbroomsticks · 07/05/2022 08:57

It's extremely damaging . Taking amber heard out of it, there seems to be a movement ATM that is supporting JD regardless of his actions. The man trashes houses, refers to his women as c*s, even the mother of his children, clearly has serious drug alcohol issues, is verbally and physically abusive and yet he is held up as some kind of hero, women want him and men say well done Johnny women can be poisonous.

It's like a collective brainwashing

All of JDs staff have already been seen as lying on oath. Have you ever seen JD in a state, no . Out of control? No OUT of his head on drugs? No. Cue tape on plane of him groaning and howling like a dog sounding extremely out of it. Paid liars all of them. But everyone focuses on the other liar. There's truth in there, there also lies. He said she said, making a mockery of DA both of them. Chuck it out of court

Trixiefirecracker · 07/05/2022 08:55

Didnt she steal the story of her sexual attack from her PA?

lljkk · 07/05/2022 08:50

Lots of witnesses including the ones describing violence that AH did to them -- are recounting it in this public way.

I have no idea why people think celebrity lives are relatable to people with ordinary lives. This makes no sense to me.

BonnesVacances · 07/05/2022 08:48

The trial is immensely harmful to true victims of DV. The public seeing AH on the stand making up stories is doing a massive disservice to them.

That said, JD is well justified in wanting her to spout her nonsense in the public domain and for everyone to see how ludicrous her stories of physical abuse and sexual abuse are when there is evidence out there that disproves them (photos, recordings, TV appearances).

For someone who claims to be the poster girl for victims of IPV, she's shitting all over them and winding the clock back decades.

Branleuse · 07/05/2022 08:47

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 07/05/2022 08:37

Honestly I think it's vile misogyny at play. Even if they are as bad as each other, the level of vitriol aimed at AH is truly disgusting when it should be both.

I believe her and she's continuing to be abused by the justice system. Remember JD is the one bringing these cases to court not her. It makes me feel sick that so many people are cheering this on.

Exactly

Branleuse · 07/05/2022 08:47

lemonsugar125 · 07/05/2022 08:07

Maybe it should have been kept private but most people have agreed shes lying because there is tons of evidence of her lying. Shes even been quoting movies as part of her testimony like people wouldn't notice. Shes insane

Odd. I thought he lost the case in the UK because of all the evidence against him, and the using movie quote was shown to be untrue.
Trial by social media though. Who needs truth

TryingNotToReact9to5 · 07/05/2022 08:42

Yes, i find this very hard, i feel kike however i phrase it would invalidate their experiences which rich or poor, they also have the right to feel.

I escaped my x with one bag, two small kids and he attacked me as i left. We lived in if not "poverty" a perpetual state of worry about money for years, but SAFE.

I SEE them in court in front of the world and i cant watch. Cant bear it.