Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that televising the Amber Heard/Johnny Depp case is harmful to DV victims?

111 replies

Thorilicious · 07/05/2022 08:03

I know it's America, and it's the done thing.

However, the majority of the public have already decided that's she's lying, and we're not even halfway through the case.

Whatever you believe, there will be some DV victims who are even more afraid to come forward, due to opinions about this trial.
AIBU to think that such a high profile case should have been tried behind closed doors?

OP posts:
TheBigPeach · 08/05/2022 00:42

I’ve watched/listened to all the testimonies so far. Interested because I’m taking a basic legal studies class at the moment and we discuss it with our teacher.

both of them were raised in very abusive homes. I find the whole thing so very sad. He has a terrible addiction, something I had not heard before, I never heard of her until their marriage but she likes her substances also.
some questions I have:
why did she go ahead with the marriage when she states he was abusive from the beginning?
she allegedly told her family he was abusive yet they did nothing to remove her from the situation?
she bought him a knife as a gift, who does that when they’re terrified of their spouse?
in the audio tapes she appears to be instigating arguments. If you were being abused would you start arguments? I would imagine I’d avoid them??!

I had sympathy for her when Dr Curry the forensic psychologist diagnosed her. How humiliating to have someone diagnose you as having a disorder in front of millions. Just awful.
I find the comments online terrible and the justice for jd really annoying from people who don’t know and haven’t even properly heard all the evidence.

lilmishap · 08/05/2022 00:11

I can't imagine how horrific giving evidence in front of a sniggering abuser, cameras, judge and jury AND a live audience of HIS fans must be. Even without the global hate that she's getting that would be unbelievably traumatising.

It's like an episode of black mirror.

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 07/05/2022 15:25

araiwa · 07/05/2022 08:37

FFS. Not every instance of a woman being criticized is due to misogyny. There are plenty of legitimate, obvious and proven reasons someone might think amber Heard is a shitty person

Overuse of such terms dilutes their meaning and impact.

Yes, but this blatantly is the case with AH. I cannot look at social media without being bombarded with truly vile comments, and death threats against AH, and women in general. Seriously, check out even one chat on FB, or Twitter, it's revolting

TryingNotToReact9to5 · 07/05/2022 15:14

Can you imagine judge judy tolerating this ?!

She'd order them to each never mention the other again. Ever.

DontBlameMe79 · 07/05/2022 13:17

SmiledWtherisingsun · 07/05/2022 10:23

*I agree. The whole thing is disgraceful, an indictment on the toxicity that embodies Hollywood, the greed, the narcissism, the vanity, the shallowness, the disregard and disrespect for anyone not on their payroll, the extreme selfishness and inability to appreciate how far removed they are from reality.

This trial is a product of everything that is wrong with this world, a shit show of sexism, ageism, greed, excess, ego and dishonesty, the very picture of what the American dream looks like when opened up. All that matters is money and appearances, ethics are long lost*

Totally 💯 @50ShadesOfCatholic

So great entertainment then 😂😂😂

newnamethanks · 07/05/2022 10:31

They should have knocked up a deal with Netflix and got Judge Judy adjudicating. It's obscene.

SmiledWtherisingsun · 07/05/2022 10:23

*I agree. The whole thing is disgraceful, an indictment on the toxicity that embodies Hollywood, the greed, the narcissism, the vanity, the shallowness, the disregard and disrespect for anyone not on their payroll, the extreme selfishness and inability to appreciate how far removed they are from reality.

This trial is a product of everything that is wrong with this world, a shit show of sexism, ageism, greed, excess, ego and dishonesty, the very picture of what the American dream looks like when opened up. All that matters is money and appearances, ethics are long lost*

Totally 💯 @50ShadesOfCatholic

SmiledWtherisingsun · 07/05/2022 10:20

TheKeatingFive · 07/05/2022 09:46

Do we really think a guy who talks about 'fucking her corpse' isn't capable of sexual violence?

Burnt out corpse, remember

And I totally agree with you.

Just so disturbing.
Vile misogynists him & his mate Paul Bettany.

cobab · 07/05/2022 09:52

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 07/05/2022 08:37

Honestly I think it's vile misogyny at play. Even if they are as bad as each other, the level of vitriol aimed at AH is truly disgusting when it should be both.

I believe her and she's continuing to be abused by the justice system. Remember JD is the one bringing these cases to court not her. It makes me feel sick that so many people are cheering this on.

So it's misogyny and you believe her.

Because women never lie or act abusively.

Until the time comes to post on MN about peoples childhoods. Then just look at all the comments about how "my mother was evil or my mother never cared about me .. blah blah. Now I'm NC with her blah blah"

Sorry but both genders are capable of being abusive , fucked up or evil

TheKeatingFive · 07/05/2022 09:49

In answer to your question OP. It's appalling for everyone to see this shit show televised.

TheKeatingFive · 07/05/2022 09:46

Do we really think a guy who talks about 'fucking her corpse' isn't capable of sexual violence?

Burnt out corpse, remember

And I totally agree with you.

Midlifemusings · 07/05/2022 09:41

Neverreturntoathread · 07/05/2022 09:35

Something that makes me uncomfortable is that the enitre case is about the legal issue that if AH says JD hit her, she has to prove it. But domestic violence, like rape, rarely has witnesses. So if JD wins this, doesn’t that mean no woman can describe herself as a violence victim or a rape victim without fearing she’ll be sued and have no way to prove what she said is true?

Evidence is needed - not proof. It doesn't mean there has to be witnesses. It means you have to tell a credible recounting of events and the available evidence needs to support your position. That would be photographic, circumstantial, communications, DNA, etc. In this case Amber recounts she has punched repeatedly in the face, had her lip split open with rings, had her nose broken etc and yet in pictures taken that day, the next day and days after while she was under studio lights and in professional make-up chairs - there is no sign of these injuries. So that kind of incongruence creates a gap in the evidence chain.

50ShadesOfCatholic · 07/05/2022 09:41

TheVanguardSix · 07/05/2022 09:27

I think the whole thing stinks. It's vile. They're both just deeply immersed in the Hollywood vat of acid and I don't think this trial does ANY favours for victims of abuse. It's so damn messy, how could you even locate the helpful aspects?
I feel so sorry for their kids. Amber Heard is a mother. Johnny Depp is a father. And this shit will always come up when they google their parents. It's just all sorts of rotten. And no, I'm not implying that there is shame here or that DV shouldn't be disclosed and children should be protected from the truth. But really, this is deeply traumatic for Johnny Depp's children. You can't pretend this doesn't touch them or that their family fame immunises them from this shit. I just feel so damn sorry for them. They're young people on the cusp of fulfilling their own dreams and their dad and his ex-wife are making a hugely narcissistic display of their terrible antics. They both suck.

I agree. The whole thing is disgraceful, an indictment on the toxicity that embodies Hollywood, the greed, the narcissism, the vanity, the shallowness, the disregard and disrespect for anyone not on their payroll, the extreme selfishness and inability to appreciate how far removed they are from reality.

This trial is a product of everything that is wrong with this world, a shit show of sexism, ageism, greed, excess, ego and dishonesty, the very picture of what the American dream looks like when opened up. All that matters is money and appearances, ethics are long lost.

HRTQueen · 07/05/2022 09:36

I agree it’s become a theatre show with the baddie AD

yet his behaviour is excused time and time again in court and out of court.

I read an article from Rolling Stone published in 2018 JD discussed his financial issues along with his new lawyer who was with him constantly (issues starting long before AD was on the scene) issues due to his overspending and the mis management of his money. The spending shows you what an egotistical person he is I want I get. The interview was over a number of days. JD days start later afternoon,
is often stoned, drunk, incoherent, boasts about his spending, rambles, moods up and down what really comes across is his trying to relive the good old days and that he is surrounded by yes people he pays. I actually felt sad for him

This is what JD has become the person you would avoid at a party the guy who makes you uncomfortable because he is intense bitterness he is no longer the quirky cool slightly mysterious (or pretentious) actor he is a bitter man who has been indulged and spoilt for years and years

Why I believe many people don’t believe her is because they want to believe nice guys don’t become horrible.

we were ok believing about Harvey Weinstein (even that was defended and the questions were why didn’t she rather that why did he) because he doesn’t come across as particularly nice, OJ Simpson was a charming good looking hero to many and many refused to believe he could possibly be a bad guy too

JD doesn’t fit the mould of a bad guy and foe many she doesn’t fit the mould of a victim

Neverreturntoathread · 07/05/2022 09:35

Something that makes me uncomfortable is that the enitre case is about the legal issue that if AH says JD hit her, she has to prove it. But domestic violence, like rape, rarely has witnesses. So if JD wins this, doesn’t that mean no woman can describe herself as a violence victim or a rape victim without fearing she’ll be sued and have no way to prove what she said is true?

50ShadesOfCatholic · 07/05/2022 09:35

MajorCarolDanvers · 07/05/2022 09:17

It's a civil case about money and a magazine article.

They are suing each other.

It's not a criminal case about violence.

Even though that's how it comes across.

What difference does that make?

50ShadesOfCatholic · 07/05/2022 09:32

BonnesVacances · 07/05/2022 09:12

did you see the clip of him walking towards A and she recoils? His little smug shrug and smirk was very telling.

Did you see the clip of her walking towards him before the morning break on the same day, trying to catch his eye and him looking away and being able to walk directly past him?

There was no recoiling then from AH. That's why JD was smirking. Because he knew she was acting.

Wow so awesome of you to share your mind reading prowess 👏

50ShadesOfCatholic · 07/05/2022 09:30

BonnesVacances · 07/05/2022 09:16

Tbf that's down to the media and the people watching it as entertainment. Not the fact that it's been shown on TV.

I'm watching it all because I have time and I want to be able to form my own opinion as to whether the actor we watch and enjoy in the Pirates films is a violent abuser or not. Or whether someone else is trying to blacken his name in revenge.

Well no because if it wasn’t televised then no one would be watching it.

And frankly the blame the media trope is very tired. Media is a business, it only sells stuff that people buy. If viewers didn’t tune in then it wouldn’t be televised. But no, you want to watch it and blame “the media” for your choices.

ENoeuf · 07/05/2022 09:29

TryingNotToReact9to5 · 07/05/2022 09:23

Could he possibly win this case? If the crux of the case is that she damaged his reputation with that specific article, I guess he could. But he has revealed himself to be a thoroughly awful man. That doesn't mean that she didn't rant at him abusively but he colluded very fully in his own deteriorating reputation.

I don’t think so. He lost in the UK. From what I’ve seen the defence is saying 1. It’s true and 2. Even if it’s not true he was already being dropped and losing work (hence all the headlines being round out).

TheVanguardSix · 07/05/2022 09:27

I think the whole thing stinks. It's vile. They're both just deeply immersed in the Hollywood vat of acid and I don't think this trial does ANY favours for victims of abuse. It's so damn messy, how could you even locate the helpful aspects?
I feel so sorry for their kids. Amber Heard is a mother. Johnny Depp is a father. And this shit will always come up when they google their parents. It's just all sorts of rotten. And no, I'm not implying that there is shame here or that DV shouldn't be disclosed and children should be protected from the truth. But really, this is deeply traumatic for Johnny Depp's children. You can't pretend this doesn't touch them or that their family fame immunises them from this shit. I just feel so damn sorry for them. They're young people on the cusp of fulfilling their own dreams and their dad and his ex-wife are making a hugely narcissistic display of their terrible antics. They both suck.

TryingNotToReact9to5 · 07/05/2022 09:23

Could he possibly win this case? If the crux of the case is that she damaged his reputation with that specific article, I guess he could. But he has revealed himself to be a thoroughly awful man. That doesn't mean that she didn't rant at him abusively but he colluded very fully in his own deteriorating reputation.

Branleuse · 07/05/2022 09:20

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 07/05/2022 09:04

I think many people say things they wouldn't actually do when they're angry or annoyed by someone.

Err not stuff like this

MajorCarolDanvers · 07/05/2022 09:17

It's a civil case about money and a magazine article.

They are suing each other.

It's not a criminal case about violence.

Even though that's how it comes across.

BonnesVacances · 07/05/2022 09:16

50ShadesOfCatholic · 07/05/2022 09:11

I think there is a lot of US conflict that should not be televised. It is sick to treat distressing courtroom proceedings as entertainment.

Tbf that's down to the media and the people watching it as entertainment. Not the fact that it's been shown on TV.

I'm watching it all because I have time and I want to be able to form my own opinion as to whether the actor we watch and enjoy in the Pirates films is a violent abuser or not. Or whether someone else is trying to blacken his name in revenge.

Midlifemusings · 07/05/2022 09:15

Since both the involved parties have chosen to put their stories into the public eye - they are going to do so knowing it would be scrutinized and responded to.

I think this case is also good at showing the complexity that exists in some cases of DV. DV isn't as clean as #Believe Women #Blame Men hashtags would lead you to believe. It also adds to public discourse that men can be victims and women abusers and that behind closed doors it isn't always just men treating women badly.

The fandom issue is problematic but given they are public figures I don't know how you get aroudn that. I hope it is mostly teens who are acting besotted with Johnny as though he has done no wrong and that comes from their naive life experiences.

What is hurting Amber most (beyond the rabid fan base) is her lies - that there is evidence to show are lies. Once you show yourself to not be honest, it makes it hard for people to see you as a credible witness. And it should. I am not a fan of Johnny in any form - professionally or personally but his telling of events is more credible than hers when you look at everything available