Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that televising the Amber Heard/Johnny Depp case is harmful to DV victims?

111 replies

Thorilicious · 07/05/2022 08:03

I know it's America, and it's the done thing.

However, the majority of the public have already decided that's she's lying, and we're not even halfway through the case.

Whatever you believe, there will be some DV victims who are even more afraid to come forward, due to opinions about this trial.
AIBU to think that such a high profile case should have been tried behind closed doors?

OP posts:
FrippEnos · 08/05/2022 10:41

*Midlifemusings&
If not being believed when you say you are a victim is upsetting, why weren't more people upset when Johnny wasn't believed?

The answer is easy, but various posters are happier to call misogyny etc. than reflect on their own bias.

Midlifemusings · 08/05/2022 10:38

It is interesting that when Johnny tried to dispute the allegations in 2016-2018 and said that he was a victim - no one believed him. People don't seem to be upset that he wasn't believed or supported as a victim of abuse for years.

If not being believed when you say you are a victim is upsetting, why weren't more people upset when Johnny wasn't believed?

Midlifemusings · 08/05/2022 10:34

ENoeuf · 08/05/2022 09:56

Only Depp wanted in televised. Heard tried to stop that.

Hear spent two plus years from 2016 thorugh 2018 releasing recordings, pictures and news stories into the public arena. She spent two years putting out her side of the story and evidence she felt corroborated it. Then she didn't want Depp to have any public forum to tell his side or put forward his evidence.

It wasn't that she didn't want it public, she just wanted to control the narrative. If she hadn't wanted it public, she wouldn't have released and sold pictures and recordings and stories.

FixitJesus · 08/05/2022 10:28

Fishwishy · 07/05/2022 09:04

This is Mumsnet everything that happens to women is misogyny. So much the word has lost its meaning now.

Absolutely.

KissedintheDark · 08/05/2022 10:25

Thorilicious · 07/05/2022 08:03

I know it's America, and it's the done thing.

However, the majority of the public have already decided that's she's lying, and we're not even halfway through the case.

Whatever you believe, there will be some DV victims who are even more afraid to come forward, due to opinions about this trial.
AIBU to think that such a high profile case should have been tried behind closed doors?

There's no way you can know what the majority of the public have or haven't decided.

TheBigPeach · 08/05/2022 10:19

when AH’s lawyers presented their case during the week the first thing they did was move to dismiss the whole case. The judge said she spent the evening before looking at the evidence and testimonies and ruled that there was enough evidence there to keep going. So clearly she is still on the fence herself.

lilmishap · 08/05/2022 10:13

Apparently there is medical evidence to support the sexual assault with a bottle allegation. In the British courts that evidence was closed, that was at Ambers request. She didn't write the headline she just wrote the article.
This time that medical evidence is going to be public I dread to think what the internet is going to do with it, I've already seen tiktoks came in that it was her idea and she wanted it which is pretty standard victim blaming for any allegation of sexual assault.

Watching the way the whole world is hating her has really affected me quite badly, I thought I was imagining that people hated me when I came out about being abused in my last relationship now I know I wasn't.

ENoeuf · 08/05/2022 09:56

lljkk · 08/05/2022 09:39

Maybe for them both this is desired as a trial in the court of public opinion. They both have careers as high profile actors: they sell their services based on their fame. They both want to salvage reputations.

They wouldn't want a private trial in that case, because this is about their public reputations, not truth.

More reasons not to find either of them relatable.

Only Depp wanted in televised. Heard tried to stop that.

lilmishap · 08/05/2022 09:55

lljkk · 08/05/2022 09:39

Maybe for them both this is desired as a trial in the court of public opinion. They both have careers as high profile actors: they sell their services based on their fame. They both want to salvage reputations.

They wouldn't want a private trial in that case, because this is about their public reputations, not truth.

More reasons not to find either of them relatable.

Nope. JD wanted it televised. She didn't want this at all he recorded her pleading with him not to drag it to court because neither of them would come out looking good.

But he seems to be surrounded by yes men who don't want to tell him the truth about shitty he is already looking and it's going to get worse for him.
Who decided it's a good idea to tell the world that you are regularly so drunk and high that you vomit on yourself and regularly black out and behave appallingly but he's quite open about these things because he thinks people will forgive him as he believes they always have. That's the effect of being surrounded by people who don't tell you the truth.

He was willy wonka as well as jack sparrow, finding out how serious his drug problems means he is never going to get any role like that ever again he hasn't thought this through at all.

Trixiefirecracker · 08/05/2022 09:45

This will do nothing to ‘salvage their reputations’, quite the opposite. I don’t think their careers will ever be the same after this shitshow.

lljkk · 08/05/2022 09:39

Maybe for them both this is desired as a trial in the court of public opinion. They both have careers as high profile actors: they sell their services based on their fame. They both want to salvage reputations.

They wouldn't want a private trial in that case, because this is about their public reputations, not truth.

More reasons not to find either of them relatable.

BonnesVacances · 08/05/2022 08:27

This is why I believe there's value in having the court case streamed. Because it gives people the opportunity to watch the actual testimony and form an opinion based on that alone.

I've seen all the stuff on Twitter. Including a photo of Elon Musk with AH looking like he had a bruised cheek. If you Google the other photos in that set, his other cheek is also red and he looks flushed rather than bruised.

I accept that many people are erroneously basing their opinion on falsehoods and doctored photos etc. Or some blind loyalty to Captain Jack or Edward Scissorhands. But having watched all the testimony and seen the evidence presented to date, plus all the documents and transcripts from the UK trial, if I was on the jury, I'd find in favour of JD.

SickAndTiredAgain · 08/05/2022 07:54

The movie quotes thing - she never said the quote from The Talented Mr Ripley that she was accused of copying verbatim. And the other films that have been referenced are very generic sentences eg "he made me feel like the most beautiful woman in the world". Yes, you can find it in a film but you can probably find it in dozens of films, it's a fairly common thing to say about the start of a relationship. The other ones are even more tenuous - "what happened here?" and "drink lots of tea".

The closest quote I think is the Mildred Pierce one where in the film he says "I'd cut off my hand before I reach for you again" and AH said that Depp had said "I'd rather cut off my hand than ever lay it on you again". This is pretty similar, and isn't really a generic thing to say.

But I think if you're going to start searching the entire history of Hollywood, it's not really surprising that you can find a few similar sentences. Plus there is of course the possibility that it was Depp quoting the film in the first place.

YouHaveYourFathersBreasts · 08/05/2022 07:52

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 07/05/2022 08:34

And this is part of the problem. She DIDN'T use a movie quote in her opening statement! What people posted on social media wasn't even what she said.

It’s frustrating and upsetting to see how easy it is to lie about someone’s actual testimony in court and have it accepted as fact so readily because it fits the narrative. How ironic that Amber Heard is routinely called a liar and yet those calling her that are lying about what she’s said in court.

I left my abusive ex and my kids and I escaped to a refuge. I didn’t report any of
it to the police as I was terrified no one would believe me and the thought of that was overwhelming. I couldn’t even go through with a finding the facts hearing in family court. The person I am now would have agreed to the hearing at least I think, but at the time I was so too fragile. And I didn’t have what seems to be most the worlds population hating my guts and calling me a liar and laughing at me.

Amber Heard might not be telling the truth, that’s what the court is for. But what if she is telling the truth and she’s being subjected to all of this? A literal baying mob of millions seem to be intent on destroying a woman who has already gone through a huge trauma. It’s like that black mirror episode “hated by the nation”, only nothing will happen to the people being evil shits, they will just move on to the next big craze of who to hate.

BonnesVacances · 08/05/2022 07:26

Xenia · 08/05/2022 07:21

I don't agree with televising court although the UK Supreme Court (which just does appeals) is live streamed in most cases.

In this case more generally all she wrote in the libel case is she was abused and clearly she was - end of story. Even just his recorded swearing at her meets that bar in my view. The fact she might be lying or hit him is not relevant to if she libelled him in the one sentence in the op ed piece.

Part of this case is that the headline to the article online referenced sexual abuse and that AH shared it with that headline. So it's not just about the article itself.

Xenia · 08/05/2022 07:21

I don't agree with televising court although the UK Supreme Court (which just does appeals) is live streamed in most cases.

In this case more generally all she wrote in the libel case is she was abused and clearly she was - end of story. Even just his recorded swearing at her meets that bar in my view. The fact she might be lying or hit him is not relevant to if she libelled him in the one sentence in the op ed piece.

BonnesVacances · 08/05/2022 07:18

jurgenkloppmas · 08/05/2022 02:58

I can't believe how horrible the whole thing has been - I've muted every conceivable variation on Twitter and still it's getting through - it's a DV case, not a fan spectator sport - at this stage, I don't care who is guilty, they're as bad as each other

It is ostensibly a defamation case. JD is suing AH for writing an op-ed about being a victim of DV and it being clearly about him (and it has been testified that it was about her marriage to him).

It's a case about whether a vengeful person can damage someone's reputation by making up claims about being abused. Obviously part of that case is whether she made them up.

If she'd just stuck to what life was like being married to someone with significant substance abuse, she'd have been ok. But fabricating being repeatedly beaten and the sexual abuse she's claiming is defamation.

ParkingPermitWoes · 08/05/2022 05:59

lemonsugar125 · 07/05/2022 08:07

Maybe it should have been kept private but most people have agreed shes lying because there is tons of evidence of her lying. Shes even been quoting movies as part of her testimony like people wouldn't notice. Shes insane

Which movies has she been quoting? I thought that had found to be be false (snopes)

DaSilvaP · 08/05/2022 04:36

Notlabeled · 07/05/2022 08:25

I think what your saying is the trial should not be televised because AH is coming across badly, making a fool of herself and damaging the "believe all women" narrative.

Personally, I think the UK should follow and go even further than USA and make all the trials available to be viewed online, from magistrates dealing with speeding tickets to crown court murder cases.

How can seeing the process of justice be a bad thing?

Well if the vast majority of trials are open to the public (anyone with time to spend can go there, same as with local council meetings), where is the logic of not extending "the public" to a TV audience?

RonaldMcDonald · 08/05/2022 03:24

Midlifemusings · 07/05/2022 09:41

Evidence is needed - not proof. It doesn't mean there has to be witnesses. It means you have to tell a credible recounting of events and the available evidence needs to support your position. That would be photographic, circumstantial, communications, DNA, etc. In this case Amber recounts she has punched repeatedly in the face, had her lip split open with rings, had her nose broken etc and yet in pictures taken that day, the next day and days after while she was under studio lights and in professional make-up chairs - there is no sign of these injuries. So that kind of incongruence creates a gap in the evidence chain.

However here is evidence. As provided to the court in Depp v NGN.
Enough evidence to find that of the 14 accounts of violence described by Ms Heard that 12 were found to be substantiated
That Depp had also made Ms Heard fear for her life.

His kicking her on the plane was substantiated by text messages from his employee to her post the abuse. Read the transcripts from the first trial - it is wrong to say there is no evidence.
She has every right to speak as a victim of domestic and sexual violence if she experienced it. According to his staff - she did.
The court found the evidence compelling.

RonaldMcDonald · 08/05/2022 03:16

I think the way Amber Heard is being treated by utterly loony fans and social media is insane. I believe her and support the ruling of the Court in Depp v NGN
They forget she won’t see it but their mates who are being bashed by the charming whatever will and fear they won’t be believed

Also he is far from what male victims of domestic abuse need for a poster boy.
I believe he is quite clearly an abuse and evidence corroborated the same.

jurgenkloppmas · 08/05/2022 02:58

I can't believe how horrible the whole thing has been - I've muted every conceivable variation on Twitter and still it's getting through - it's a DV case, not a fan spectator sport - at this stage, I don't care who is guilty, they're as bad as each other

MangyInseam · 08/05/2022 02:31

I don't really like televised trials at all.

That being said, it seems to me OP that you are saying that it's necessary to maintain a perception that people never lie about such things. And the possibility that AH is dishonest has threatened that.

I don't think that's a possible or even really desirable way of thinking about it. We all know, that sometimes people are not honest, even when we'd most like them to be. We need to be able to accept that while there is really women affected by DV, there are also women who will exploit others in any way they can, just like people in general.

ForgedInFire · 08/05/2022 00:49

I have not been following the case very closely but I find the coverage alarming. It is everywhere. I see women that I personally know attacking Amber on social media because she isn't acting the way that a DV survivor "should" act. She is looking at him, she isn't stuttering, she doesnt look scared enough. But if she does any of those things, then she is acting. It all makes me uncomfortable.

TheBigPeach · 08/05/2022 00:44

I’m not a JD fan, don’t like Pirates, actually I can’t think of anything he’s been in that I’ve enjoyed. 🤔