Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that televising the Amber Heard/Johnny Depp case is harmful to DV victims?

111 replies

Thorilicious · 07/05/2022 08:03

I know it's America, and it's the done thing.

However, the majority of the public have already decided that's she's lying, and we're not even halfway through the case.

Whatever you believe, there will be some DV victims who are even more afraid to come forward, due to opinions about this trial.
AIBU to think that such a high profile case should have been tried behind closed doors?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Midlifemusings · 08/05/2022 18:26

InFiveMins · 08/05/2022 17:17

Totally agree. The vitriol aimed towards AH is shocking to me as well - people all over social media automatically dismissing her claims because they love JD and can't possibly accept he might be abusive. It's also quite sad how people think they know he couldn't possibly be abusive by watching him in a few films 🙄The whole thing is a circus but very damaging to women who are genuine sufferers of DV and could be more hesitant to speak out because of how the woman in this case is being treated.

I am dismissing her claims because the evidence shows she is lying.

Nothing to do with Johnny. Never seen any of his movies - nothing to do with being a fan.

I am not alone in that. Many people are looking at the evidence and struggling to find any way to believe her given her accounts, the inconsistencies, and the lies.

BonnesVacances · 08/05/2022 17:41

The whole thing is a circus but very damaging to women who are genuine sufferers of DV and could be more hesitant to speak out because of how the woman in this case is being treated.

Or because of the absolute mockery AH is making of the process.

That it has got this far, having made so many horrific claims that so many intelligent & considered people judge to be unsubstantiated (not just JD fans), it will seriously and catastrophically undermine everything women have fought for to be believed in cases like this.

I cannot state how much damage AH has already done. Whatever the outcome, trust in the system has been damaged.

InFiveMins · 08/05/2022 17:17

Totally agree. The vitriol aimed towards AH is shocking to me as well - people all over social media automatically dismissing her claims because they love JD and can't possibly accept he might be abusive. It's also quite sad how people think they know he couldn't possibly be abusive by watching him in a few films 🙄The whole thing is a circus but very damaging to women who are genuine sufferers of DV and could be more hesitant to speak out because of how the woman in this case is being treated.

BonnesVacances · 08/05/2022 16:38

Yes this. Plus she's making it a million times worse by digging the hole deeper and deeper.

I only see one person continuing the abuse tbh. AH sat in the witness box, looked at JD and said he did all those things, knowing well that he didn't. And the evidence proves that.

I expect there is an element of "fuck you, I can afford to take you to court and put you on the stand to tell your bullshit to the world" on his part. I can't blame him for that. I would too if someone made up shit about me.

Midlifemusings · 08/05/2022 16:00

Xenia · 08/05/2022 15:54

He spoke to her abusively. It does not matter if she wqas 1000 times worse than he was - he is suing her because he says it was a lie that she was abused by him. In my view the recordings show he was - end of story, case proven.

The defamation includes the op ed title of him being sexually violent. This case isn't just about any incidence of abuse. It is specific to what was in the op-ed. That she became a public figure representing women who are vicitms of domestic abuse. That she spoke up against sexual violence and faced wrath for doing so.

Xenia · 08/05/2022 15:54

Case not proven I mean of course... his case for libel against her not proven.

Xenia · 08/05/2022 15:54

He spoke to her abusively. It does not matter if she wqas 1000 times worse than he was - he is suing her because he says it was a lie that she was abused by him. In my view the recordings show he was - end of story, case proven.

Midlifemusings · 08/05/2022 15:51

Enough4me · 08/05/2022 15:37

I believe they were both abusive, but the court case is all about Depp trying to keep the abuse going. She wouldn't be there except for him aiming to publicly destroy her.

It's awful for DV victims as shows that if an abuser is rich they can employ the best team and continue to abuse their ex-partner and there is no way around it. If the rich person has lots of friends, the victim is publicly hated and vilified.

The abuser turns up to court with adoring fans high fiving them and cheers, then gets to smirk and laugh through their appearance. The system allows a rich person to run a show of humiliation and many are happy to watch.

I don't get this. If you listen to the recordings, she is clearly more the physical abuser. She spent three years falsely accusing him of assaults that the evidence shows didn't happen. She released photos and recordings and stories and made sure for 3 years that the headlines were all about how evil he was and how he hurt her, a poor victim. She is the one who took it public and kept it public and he finally decided to respond to defend himself and he is the bad guy?

Is he perfect or g aood guy - far from it but the recordings and photographic and video evidence tell an entirely different story than the one Amber has been putting in the public arena for the last 3 years.

What isn't good for DV victims is Amber lying and making up stories of abuse and excusing or forgetting her own actions.

knowinglesseveryday · 08/05/2022 15:38

They're both nauseous and should shut up, and the media should stop publishing about it.

SunscreenCentral · 08/05/2022 15:38

It's a civil (and not criminal) case. Depp wanted people to see, and they have. It's a pity the inadmissible recordings (where she admits cutting him) can't be included (due to multiple voices) but there we are.
I believe him.

Enough4me · 08/05/2022 15:37

I believe they were both abusive, but the court case is all about Depp trying to keep the abuse going. She wouldn't be there except for him aiming to publicly destroy her.

It's awful for DV victims as shows that if an abuser is rich they can employ the best team and continue to abuse their ex-partner and there is no way around it. If the rich person has lots of friends, the victim is publicly hated and vilified.

The abuser turns up to court with adoring fans high fiving them and cheers, then gets to smirk and laugh through their appearance. The system allows a rich person to run a show of humiliation and many are happy to watch.

QuotetheLaw · 08/05/2022 15:27

@OnlyHippyInTheVillage Completely agree with your post. It doesn't make sense. She would have had glass embedded in her feet, there would have been bloody footprints all over the house, she would have needed the glass extracted and then stitched up, she wouldn't have been able to walk. That many blows to the head and she would have been unconscious, possibly dead.

Something else I don't understand is if it did happen, why has she not reported it to the police as a criminal matter? I understand not reporting it if she's not ready to but she's telling the whole world now so why not get a criminal case started. If someone had done that to me I would want to make sure they never did it to anyone else.

OnlyHippyInTheVillage · 08/05/2022 15:06

There is no medical evidence of the assault with the bottle in Australia. Please go back and rewatch her testimony.
Her story is ' the abuse happened', she went to the bathroom, retched, saw blood, went up to bed. Took 2 sleeping pills. Woke up, gave an extensive description of the paint and blood everywhere. Saw JD with his finger bandaged. She couldn't remember who called security and his Dr and Nurse. They came, the nurse gave her a sedative. She said she took a half or quarter. And went to sleep.

So she is claiming she experienced a horrific pyhsical and sexual assault, where her feet were "sliced up pretty good" from glass. She was beaten, choked, sexually assaulted with a bottle. And the only medical attention she was given was a sedative. There is recording of Australia, on her phone. It can't be admitted to court because Jerry Judge, JDs security died a few years ago.

As far as I can see there are 2 options.

  1. Everyone else is lying, including 2 medical professionals.
  2. She is lying.
Midlifemusings · 08/05/2022 14:57

To anyone who believes Amber.

Listen to what the recordings and what they each say. (it is an hour but gives a good sense of their dynamic)

Listen to part 1 and part 2 in this tweet.
mobile.twitter.com/bybyeblackbird/status/1285735012135034893

She is the aggressor and she admits she loses it and being violent. She doesn't disagree with him when he says he has never done x.

What makes her so angry is when he walks away when they argue. She wants him to stay and fight. He wants to leave. She panics and feels abandoned and like he isn't fighting for the relationship when he walks away. She then loses it.

And remember in these clips, she knows she is recording and he doesn't know he is being recorded.

latetothefisting · 08/05/2022 14:00

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 07/05/2022 08:34

And this is part of the problem. She DIDN'T use a movie quote in her opening statement! What people posted on social media wasn't even what she said.

you got there before me! Exactly, the poster showed themselves up by ironically proving what they were trying to disprove, i.e. people believing things that support their own viewpoint without taking a second to check if there is any actua evidence.
www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/films/news/amber-heard-talented-mr-ripley-johnny-depp-b2073688.html

Basketet · 08/05/2022 13:59

Yes, it is incredibly damaging for victims and survivors of DV. The nature and realities of DV and its fallout are still so stigmatised in the west. We like to think that with societal movement towards greater equality between the sexes that abuse against women/male violence is a now null and void subject.

I don't exactly know what to make of the whole JD/AH debacle, though so far it seems:
It was a toxic relationship. And I think they were both abusers/instigators of the abuse. Both damaged by intergenerational trauma. They are both unstable, but he used his advantage as a man and intetnational sex symbol as a means to control her. She may have been jealous of him, but so was he of her.

All this nonsense about her being the sole abuser, somehow asking, deserving or causing the abuse and JD's substance abuse, and the social media whitewashing of Depp being implicit in the toxicity, is shocking though unsurprising. Especially coming from women - internalised misogyny is real. And it shows lack of critical thinking and awareness or education around the fight for equality for women and girls.

BonnesVacances · 08/05/2022 13:52

The level of abuse AH is claiming is a pretty big story tbh. Whether she's making it up to damage him or he's guilty of it, it's massive either way. She's a big part of the #metoo movement yet the evidence is that she's guilty of IPV.

It's not just two Hollywood stars fighting it out. This has big ramifications imo.

fluffiphlox · 08/05/2022 13:44

I really don’t understand why this case is getting so much coverage in UK media. They both come across as Hollywood nutcases who are doing nothing for their careers. Cue sob story memoir from both parties.

Midlifemusings · 08/05/2022 13:39

ENoeuf · 08/05/2022 11:12

I think I’ve asked before on this thread/similar thread about this - what’s the evidence? Depp is suing because of the article and it’s not disputed she wrote that. But why hasn’t that come up then if it’s definite she’s been releasing this stuff?

The private recordings were taken on her phone. TMZ obtained the rights to play them. They can only do that from the owner of the recordings. If her phone had been hacked - TMZ wouldn't be able to get rights to those recordings. Now maybe she sold them to an third party who sold them to TMZ - so it can't be evidence as we don't know who they bought them from but since they were able to obtain the rights to them - we know they came originally from Amber.

burnoutbabe · 08/05/2022 11:29

TheBigPeach · 08/05/2022 10:19

when AH’s lawyers presented their case during the week the first thing they did was move to dismiss the whole case. The judge said she spent the evening before looking at the evidence and testimonies and ruled that there was enough evidence there to keep going. So clearly she is still on the fence herself.

that is pretty standard in every single US trial i think - motion to dismiss. Always done and mostly refused.

If this was a rape trial or an assult trial i'd like to think it would not ever be shown in the USA. but as its about defamation (lying about an assult/sexual assult) then its allowed to be shown. As its pretty nasty its being televised if what she says is True. its effecticly allowing an abuser to publicly abuse her all over again?
(and i am thinking of this and similar cases, as a legal principle - should we have potential victims of abuse have to describe it in court and be cross examined on it to a live world wide public?)

If he loses, i wonder if then the police will actually prosecute him for the abuse (though its a higher standard of proof in criminal trials)

Thorilicious · 08/05/2022 11:19

KissedintheDark · 08/05/2022 10:25

There's no way you can know what the majority of the public have or haven't decided.

You're right. I should clarify from out of what I've seen posted by people, the majority of those don't believe Amber Heard.

OP posts:
ENoeuf · 08/05/2022 11:12

Midlifemusings · 08/05/2022 10:34

Hear spent two plus years from 2016 thorugh 2018 releasing recordings, pictures and news stories into the public arena. She spent two years putting out her side of the story and evidence she felt corroborated it. Then she didn't want Depp to have any public forum to tell his side or put forward his evidence.

It wasn't that she didn't want it public, she just wanted to control the narrative. If she hadn't wanted it public, she wouldn't have released and sold pictures and recordings and stories.

I think I’ve asked before on this thread/similar thread about this - what’s the evidence? Depp is suing because of the article and it’s not disputed she wrote that. But why hasn’t that come up then if it’s definite she’s been releasing this stuff?

TheBigPeach · 08/05/2022 10:48

I also find it strange she has multiple pictures of him asleep or passed out, it’s such a violation of trust to take pictures of someone in a vulnerable position without their consent. And taping conversations with people not just Depp without prior consent, it’s odd.
police officers responding to calls have testified there was no evidence of dv. I do think it’s worth hearing all the evidence.
there was abuse on both sides I believe.

bluebell34567 · 08/05/2022 10:46

KissedintheDark · 08/05/2022 10:25

There's no way you can know what the majority of the public have or haven't decided.

true. thats just spreading misinformation.

bluebell34567 · 08/05/2022 10:42

HailAdrian · 07/05/2022 09:00

Do we really think a guy who talks about 'fucking her corpse' isn't capable of sexual violence?

TRUE