Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how long you think food banks should support people for?

369 replies

tartanbaker · 06/05/2022 18:28

I help to run an independent food bank, & we currently support over 100 families. We are nearing our capacity (in terms of numbers we can help) due to limited storage etc, but there are new people applying all the time. We give people food every week, and some families have been registered with us for about 2 years now. They are still needy, and we all know that things are going to continue being tough for the foreseeable future, so my question is…if you were to donate to a food bank, how would you want them to use your food/money? Continuing to help everyone for as long as they ask for help, even though it might mean turning others away? Or telling existing families who rely on you that you can’t help them any more because you are going to help new people now? It’s so hard, and an ongoing debate we are having, and I’d be really interested to hear other people’s opinions. Both options seem really tough….

OP posts:
twelly · 06/05/2022 21:44

I know food banks are voluntary and volunteers are amazing.

Whilst I think the concept of the foodbank is sound I think they should be used for emergencies and I do not think they should be used long term by a family or individual. I think that it creates dependancy. Whilst I have given in the past to foodbanks I was put off seeing and hearing of people who used them but who used their income to purchase what would I would view as luxury items ie phones, computer games etc. Of course it is a matter of choice but this has put me off donating

Seraphinesupport · 06/05/2022 21:43

i remember once i had to just starve for 4 days as had no money and couldnt get a foodbank. 2 weeksater i hear someone joking about getting a foodbank so they can buy fags and beer.

Sortilege · 06/05/2022 21:43

It’s almost insoluble OP. The government should be formulating better policy but this one have deliberately thrown millions into poverty.

Could you run a compromise model that client can receive up to X weeks’ worth of help on any calendar year but once that has run out they can’t receive anything else that year? (Or some staggered policy that prevents a January stampede.)

Seraphinesupport · 06/05/2022 21:42

there should be a max times someone can use a foodbank in a timeframe like everyone can only use the bank once a month etc

Sortilege · 06/05/2022 21:39

JayAlfredPrufrock · 06/05/2022 18:39

I volunteer with a Foodbank.

recipients are referred by social workers or similar and can only have so many a year. It’s meant to be for emergencies not a lifestyle choice.

that May well Change with the cost of living crisis

That’s a worrying binary.

Lots of people are now suffering from long term poverty. Benefits no longer necessarily cover modest housing costs.

Why do you conceptualise it as short term emergencies v “lifestyle choice”?

Not everybody has the latitude to improve their circumstances.

EmergencyPaintSituation · 06/05/2022 21:37

I think we need to bear in mind the nature of addiction and some of the reasons that addictions develop and are maintained. There but by the grace of god etc… having worked with families for a very long time it’s incredibly complex. You can’t make assumptions or judgements without getting to know more about the causes of poverty, addiction etc.

Libertaire · 06/05/2022 21:31

TyrannosaurusRegina · 06/05/2022 20:33

Perhaps people's finances should be examined to see if it's a genuine case of not having enough money or mismanagement of finances. My sister uses a food bank from time to time. I used to help her out when she was skint and down to her last penny, until I realised that she always managed to afford her 20 pack of benson and hedges every day.

Crikey. B&H Silver are £12.40 for a pack of 20. Source : Tesco.com. That’s £80 a week on cigarettes. Eighty Pounds! That is actually more than we, as a comfortably off household, spend on groceries in a week. Staggering.

JayAlfredPrufrock · 06/05/2022 21:31

We regularly do kettle packs for people with no cooking facilities

JustLyra · 06/05/2022 21:30

the vast majority have a cooker, hobs and fridge and if you do t then it's more than food bank help you need.

And your one-size-fits-all system would have to take into account those that don't.

Those in temp accommodation, those without facilities, those with disabilites that can't use certain things (given how many are having to wait huge times fo disability payments), those without enough electric or gas to run all of those.

JustLyra · 06/05/2022 21:28

Brieandcamembert · 06/05/2022 21:22

People don't have the same cooking facilities so a food allowance would have to take all that into account.*

the vast majority have a cooker, hobs and fridge and if you do t then it's more than food bank help you need.

A better system would be to overhaul the benefits system in a way that doesn't leave people needing foodbanks. And preferably without stupid moves like 5 week waits, shit computer systems that make repeated errors, and the constant assumption that people are taking the piss.

It's funny, I have a full time job. I get paid once a month. If I start a new job I won't be paid for the first four weeks until my wage arrives.

We need benefits to be enough to sustain you for a time limited period until your circumstances change.

Yes - your gap for not being paid will be covered by your last wage in your previous job. That doesn't always happen when moving from one benefit to another. Or when you get made redundant unexpectedly and don't get paid.

If it was as simple as you were making out then it wouldn't be an issue. Given it is then it's clearly not so simple

Brieandcamembert · 06/05/2022 21:22

People don't have the same cooking facilities so a food allowance would have to take all that into account.*

the vast majority have a cooker, hobs and fridge and if you do t then it's more than food bank help you need.

A better system would be to overhaul the benefits system in a way that doesn't leave people needing foodbanks. And preferably without stupid moves like 5 week waits, shit computer systems that make repeated errors, and the constant assumption that people are taking the piss.

It's funny, I have a full time job. I get paid once a month. If I start a new job I won't be paid for the first four weeks until my wage arrives.

We need benefits to be enough to sustain you for a time limited period until your circumstances change.

LadyCatStark · 06/05/2022 21:21

It is a really tough decision but the first step is take is to stop sending out order forms. It’s lovely that you are giving people a choice but if they receive the form, they’ll fill it out whether they need it or not. Then I’d sadly reduce the quality of food you’re buying ie tinned fruit and veg etc. I’d rather give more people the basics. Then if that still wasn’t enough, I’d look at it on a case by case basis and prioritise those with no income which will probably be new referrals who are waiting for benefits. I’m sorry but if you have income, you need to prioritise food just like the rest of us have to regardless of what else is going on in your life.

YarnHoarder · 06/05/2022 21:20

Brieandcamembert · 06/05/2022 21:06

But vouchers could be allocated in exact basic amounts so you have just enough to live on and cover all amenities . I.e. you have a 4 person allocated food allowance per week so that you don't get to the point of needing food banks.

The school meal vouchers were hurried in. A better system would be required.

People shouldn't have 'just enough' to live on, universal basic income has been proven to improve many aspects of a person's life. They're far more likely to spend money to stimulate the economy as they know they're guaranteed an income. They're more likely to return to education as they have a stable income. They eat better, get out more and overall have better incomes than those on 'just enough' that could be taken away at any time because you missed an appointment as your bus didn't show up. 'just enough' shouldn't be the standard we're striving for when people are in need.

marvellousmaple · 06/05/2022 21:19

One idea might be to reduce the list that people choose from to only seasonal veg and whatever meat is on sale that week . In awe at your kindness OP. I'd take new applicants with children if at all possible.

Tilltheend99 · 06/05/2022 21:19

@Peppapigforlife pip stands for personal independents payments and is given to people who are disabled to the extent that without these payments they would not be able to access the outside world. So, if you are eligible for this you should use it to improve your life, if not, I don’t think you should begrudge people who do need it. The criteria for pip is notoriously hard and if you Google it you will find many examples of people who died because they were allegedly unable to access pip or has their pip stopped incorrectly.

JustLyra · 06/05/2022 21:18

Bordesleyhills · 06/05/2022 21:16

Genuinely some people will and do need help more and more. Food waste is also a huge issue. I really sympathise with the real needy cases who literally are between heat and food and real hand to mouth. However I agree that money counselling is important so that mismanagement doesn’t happen. Getting your food for free as it’s spent on booze and fags is not the idea. However I’m sure the majority of cases don’t do this.

Given that you say yourself the majority of cases don't do that why even trot out such a trope?

JustLyra · 06/05/2022 21:17

Brieandcamembert · 06/05/2022 21:06

But vouchers could be allocated in exact basic amounts so you have just enough to live on and cover all amenities . I.e. you have a 4 person allocated food allowance per week so that you don't get to the point of needing food banks.

The school meal vouchers were hurried in. A better system would be required.

How are you going to do that though? There's no amount people spend on gas and electric for starters.

People don't have the same cooking facilities so a food allowance would have to take all that into account.

A better system would be to overhaul the benefits system in a way that doesn't leave people needing foodbanks. And preferably without stupid moves like 5 week waits, shit computer systems that make repeated errors, and the constant assumption that people are taking the piss.

Especially shortly after the peak of a global pandemic where jobs went and the cost of living soared.

Bordesleyhills · 06/05/2022 21:16

Genuinely some people will and do need help more and more. Food waste is also a huge issue. I really sympathise with the real needy cases who literally are between heat and food and real hand to mouth. However I agree that money counselling is important so that mismanagement doesn’t happen. Getting your food for free as it’s spent on booze and fags is not the idea. However I’m sure the majority of cases don’t do this.

Mumwantingtogetitright · 06/05/2022 21:15

Harridan1981 · 06/05/2022 21:09

I don't know tbh. I used to work for a Trussel Trust food Bank and did support the 3 vouchers in 3/6 months rule. On the whole, if a client in genuine need appeared they wouldn't get turned away empty handed, but it did mean we could help more people and keep it as an emergency measure.

I think that was a reasonable rule with sensible intentions, but things are different from what they were. There is no way out of food poverty for some of these people. They are already managing what little money they have as effectively as they can, and there is no prospect of them increasing their income in the immediate future. So what are they supposed to do?

Mumwantingtogetitright · 06/05/2022 21:12

Peppapigforlife · 06/05/2022 21:07

I agree to prioritise those with no income at all. I'm on the lowest income for a family of two, I don't get PIP or anything like that and I manage without a food bank.

But what is the "lowest income"? Some people work and earn some income but they are in part time or irregular work and they don't have enough to get by. Their outgoings may also be different from yours, through no fault of their own. It's great that you can manage without needing a foodbank but you can't assume that others' circumstances are identical to your own.

Tilltheend99 · 06/05/2022 21:11

Brieandcamembert · 06/05/2022 20:55

We need an absolute overhaul of the way we are functioning. We need to teach better budgeting, cooking and financial planning.

Benefits should be time limited (unless you are so sick or disabled that any form of paid employment is not possible). They should also come in the form of allocated amounts for gas/ electricity / oil and food vouchers. Good vouchers include basic but very nutritious foods (no breakfast cereals etc, but porridge, fruit, veg, meats for stewing). Recipe ideas and meal plans. Support people to get back on their feet and living well.

Lol. What about the huge proportion of people on benefits who are in work. If you have a zero hour contract and your employer won’t tell you if you are working till the day before they it is very hard to get a second job to work around that.

If you have no experience of modern working practices then yes this is a great idea for getting people to ‘stop relying on benefits.’

It’s hardly something people are relying on if they are sat in the cold watching their kids eat a meal from a food bank because their benefits don’t rise in line with inflation and neither do their wages.

They would only be relying on it and therefore in need of weening off of it if it was actually enough to live on.

I agree that we need broader education in this country but it will never happen as long as conservatives are in power because the Eton set don’t want the working classes to have reasoning and problem solving skills incase it weakens their hold on their placid workforce.

Harridan1981 · 06/05/2022 21:09

I don't know tbh. I used to work for a Trussel Trust food Bank and did support the 3 vouchers in 3/6 months rule. On the whole, if a client in genuine need appeared they wouldn't get turned away empty handed, but it did mean we could help more people and keep it as an emergency measure.

Mumwantingtogetitright · 06/05/2022 21:09

There will always be chancers, of course. People who take advantage of the system. However, there are also loads of people who are really, really struggling, yet find it incredibly difficult to ask for help. Most people have reached the point of absolute desperation when they finally turn to the foodbanks. They should be met with compassion, not judgement.

Peppapigforlife · 06/05/2022 21:07

I agree to prioritise those with no income at all. I'm on the lowest income for a family of two, I don't get PIP or anything like that and I manage without a food bank.

Brieandcamembert · 06/05/2022 21:06

But vouchers could be allocated in exact basic amounts so you have just enough to live on and cover all amenities . I.e. you have a 4 person allocated food allowance per week so that you don't get to the point of needing food banks.

The school meal vouchers were hurried in. A better system would be required.