Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how long you think food banks should support people for?

369 replies

tartanbaker · 06/05/2022 18:28

I help to run an independent food bank, & we currently support over 100 families. We are nearing our capacity (in terms of numbers we can help) due to limited storage etc, but there are new people applying all the time. We give people food every week, and some families have been registered with us for about 2 years now. They are still needy, and we all know that things are going to continue being tough for the foreseeable future, so my question is…if you were to donate to a food bank, how would you want them to use your food/money? Continuing to help everyone for as long as they ask for help, even though it might mean turning others away? Or telling existing families who rely on you that you can’t help them any more because you are going to help new people now? It’s so hard, and an ongoing debate we are having, and I’d be really interested to hear other people’s opinions. Both options seem really tough….

OP posts:
Perime · 07/05/2022 00:49

Our local foodbank have had to change to being an emergency provision. Clients are then helped towards claiming benefits and other support. They are referred by social workers. Unfortunately, this will happen less and less as more people feel the pinch and there will be a huge rise in need and l suspect less state support available

Theytrytomakmego · 07/05/2022 00:44

Mumwantingtogetitright thank you, I will be ok. But yes it's perverse to try and force people to not work and not pay their way as best they can, when they want to.

Sortilege Disabled people who can’t work and their unpaid carers are in a particularly horrendous position. No hope of a job to ease the crisis, benefits periodically reviewed or suspended, and Carer’s Allowance is still less than £70 per week.

Exactly! Thanks to an unpaid carer ( just over the income to be allowed carers allowance) I can do the work I have, (proving I'm employable to others) but I don't earn enough, so the system wants me to go through making myself intentionally unemployed and all the issues that brings, in order to then live precariously and unproductively on periodically reviewed and suspended benefits instead.

If I do that and give up what I have, post pandemic I doubt I will ever get work again which is why I chose to jump rather than be pushed into make the choices the OP is having to consider making on others.

Peoniesandpeaches · 07/05/2022 00:41

At one of the drug services I work at this is a regular topic for concern. We have increasingly become concerned that this is a source of enablement for some of our clients. They will literally tell us they don’t budget for food as they’ll get it from the food bank. I know the move to remove the stigma and indignity of having to use food banks has been overwhelmingly positive but some of our clients speak of the food banks as an entitlement (someone the other day was moaning to me that they couldn’t get their “regular delivery slot” while I hear near daily moans about the quality of biscuits provided etc). We’ve even had staff threatened if they don’t just hand out vouchers without checking eligibility and have witnessed them throw half the box away because they couldn’t be bothered carrying it home or didn’t want all of it. While obviously this is a minority of food bank users and shouldn’t spoil it for all having an addiction shouldn’t make someone automatically eligible and nor should they remain eligible forever. I think you do need a set time they receive it with exceptions for certain cases and/or the ability to be re-referred.

Apricote · 07/05/2022 00:32

It worries me the idea of people needing referrals - sometimes when people need food from a food bank it's an absolute emergency, they may not already be in touch with anyone who can give them a referral or know where to get one. I've been in this position.

londonmummy1966 · 07/05/2022 00:31

Absentmindedwoman · 07/05/2022 00:22

we are likely to be "kinder" on a re referral from a family with children than a single person with alcohol issues

I really hope you would also be 'kind' on single disabled adults who often are left in complete limbo during barbaric disability benefits assessments and processes, and all other doors closed off to them.

Single disabled adults can be massively vulnerable in the current system.

Absolutely we would but we do look at circumstances and why people are coming to us for re-referrals and we have disabled people on more than basic benefits on a quick re-referral as we recognise that they often have far higher living costs than the norm due to disability etc - there are no hard and fast rules but as people have said upthread we aren't there to prevent people in heavy debt from bankruptcy we are there to help those that really need it and genuinely have no other way out.

Apricote · 07/05/2022 00:29

@Fkingfnaaarr

And how lucky are those of us who are debating this from the position of being the folk who chuck some tins into the collection, or add a few £5 fare shares into their online shop? We're living in a society where people are expected to prostate at the feet of charity to show that they are "deserving" of food. Food, for fucks sake.

Yes all your outrage is correct, but none of it changes the fact that OP's particular food bank has limited options and ways to help. She's not responsible for what the tories have done. How would you suggest her organisation make this impossible choice?

Absentmindedwoman · 07/05/2022 00:22

we are likely to be "kinder" on a re referral from a family with children than a single person with alcohol issues

I really hope you would also be 'kind' on single disabled adults who often are left in complete limbo during barbaric disability benefits assessments and processes, and all other doors closed off to them.

Single disabled adults can be massively vulnerable in the current system.

Sortilege · 07/05/2022 00:20

Mumwantingtogetitright · 06/05/2022 20:51

All the people saying that people should be limited to three food parcels in 12 months so that they don't build up a dependency on them... that's all very well if people are in a position to budget more carefully or increase their income in some way. However, I work in this area and we are increasingly seeing people with negative budgets who simply cannot make ends meet no matter how effectively they "manage" their money. You can't manage it if there just isn't enough. And while it's easy to say that they need to find ways of increasing their income, not everyone has the ability or the opportunity to do that.

The problem is this fucking government which is pushing people into the most desperate situations. It really isn't a case of cancelling Netflix and cutting back on a few fags. Or buying value brands as a government minister so helpfully suggested the other day. I honestly think most people have absolutely no idea how the most vulnerable people in our society are being forced to live. It is shocking and it is shameful.

Well said.

Those negative budgets are quite deliberate policy, BTW. This is exactly what the coalition and conservative governments intended. They slashed housing payments so that food and bill money had to be diverted to plug the shortfall. Now the inflationary crisis has been layered on top of that and people are going under.

We wrote up some case studies last year that were hair curling. Disabled people who can’t work and their unpaid carers are in a particularly horrendous position. No hope of a job to ease the crisis, benefits periodically reviewed or suspended, and Carer’s Allowance is still less than £70 per week.

Anyone talking about “lifestyle choices” or “weaning off” shouldn’t be commenting and certainly shouldn’t be working in this area.

XenoBitch · 07/05/2022 00:20

SuperFlyWoman · 07/05/2022 00:04

I think using a food bank continuously for 2 years is an outrageous pisstake quite frankly. They should be for short term emergency use only.

It takes around 6 weeks to get a Universal Credit payment doesn’t it? So that should be the maximum amount of time.

People shouldn’t be taking food from a charity so they can pay debts! They need to get an IVA, bankruptcy etc if they’re struggling that much. As for drug and alcohol addiction, they shouldn’t be taking food from charity so they can use their cash for their addiction. If there are children involved, there should be an SS referral.

Everybody is struggling with the cost of living, you have to cut your cloth and people are signposted to lots of services from food banks so there is no excuse.

People who are really in an emergency situation should starve so others who’ve already had the benefit of long term support but can’t be bothered to get their lives together can continue to eat?

Yes, 5/6 weeks to get a UC payment. And then it is about £300 a month. Who can live off of that? Seriously.

I said in a previous post about people I know who had PIP stopped so had to go to food banks... sorting PIP out can take months, even a year.

Many people with addiction issues are in denial. They are not ready to address their issues yet.

RagzRebooted · 07/05/2022 00:19

I think this becomes an emotive subject because we are talking about food. Obviously, everyone needs food to live and so giving food to people who can't afford food makes sense. But essentially, money buys food, so food has a monetary value. Now, I don't know the cost of a food bank parcel, let alone what 2 years' worth would amount to, but if you think about the question in terms of money rather than food, it makes it less emotive.

A food bank is basically providing a crisis payment, in the form of food. Would you advocate for paying certain people a weekly amount extra because they can't afford food, for years at a time. Or provide a one off amount to someone who can't afford food that week? Both are equally in need, but why should some people get extra money and not others who are struggling.

Why have food banks at all (apart from the ones that reduce food waste) when you could save all the hassle and just give people more money to live on?

LuluBlakey1 · 07/05/2022 00:13

Let's remember that, for the first time in its 70 year history, UNICEF - since last year, now feeds children in Britain. We are the 5th richest country in the world and UNICEF feeds children here because our government does not. Our government should be mortified that this is the situation they have created but they have no decency or humanity.

bridgetreilly · 07/05/2022 00:10

I don’t think foodbanks are the place to sort out poor wages or insufficient benefit payments. I think they need to offer food to whoever needs it. If people are hungry, keep helping them. And then campaign, write to your MP, do whatever you can think of to get the systemic problems sorted out so that people don’t need foodbanks.

SettingsO · 07/05/2022 00:08

I would focus on helping new people. It must take a lot to make that first contact with a food bank and you must be feeling absolutely desperate, so to be turned away in that situation would be really, really awful.

SuperFlyWoman · 07/05/2022 00:04

I think using a food bank continuously for 2 years is an outrageous pisstake quite frankly. They should be for short term emergency use only.

It takes around 6 weeks to get a Universal Credit payment doesn’t it? So that should be the maximum amount of time.

People shouldn’t be taking food from a charity so they can pay debts! They need to get an IVA, bankruptcy etc if they’re struggling that much. As for drug and alcohol addiction, they shouldn’t be taking food from charity so they can use their cash for their addiction. If there are children involved, there should be an SS referral.

Everybody is struggling with the cost of living, you have to cut your cloth and people are signposted to lots of services from food banks so there is no excuse.

People who are really in an emergency situation should starve so others who’ve already had the benefit of long term support but can’t be bothered to get their lives together can continue to eat?

Gilead · 07/05/2022 00:04

We have a rota system at one place, so many one week, and a different crowd the next so access is fortnightly, might that help?

Oceanus · 06/05/2022 23:58

OMG, that's all I can say regarding your dilemma. You really are in a difficult position! I would just like to humbly suggest that you liaise with charities that help people find a job (I want to add I'm not being ironic here). Especially for those who've being out of work for so long, it's common to feel worthless and they need help from sb who can get them going again. It's not easy after so long. Maybe set up a day for a public talk and then another for sb to be available privately?
You say you accept everybody but do you at least have some sort of list that tells you why sb needs help from you? Maybe some of those people have other options available but don't know where to go for help.
There are different places to go depending on why you can't afford food in the first place so, even though people will find it intrusive, it is important to talk to them, in a private and secluded place, offer them a cup of tea and find out that reason.
I started writing what I thougt but who how can I decide who gets fed first!? I feel too small for this kind of decision. Whatever you decide, you're doing the best you can! I would make every single person register (even the old ones) and then decide case by case, make the final list and refer others to the council and other charities. Have you considered a local kitchen sort of arrangement because maybe that would make whatever you have stretch more and it would probably give more people a warm meal a day. Give less to each person, so more can get a little bit. Goodness I sound so pety. You are the nobel one and no matter what you decide you'll choose what's best I'm sure.

Mumwantingtogetitright · 06/05/2022 23:53

@Theytrytomakmego , I am so sorry. There should be better help to support people to stay in work where they can. I hope you are OK. Flowers

Theytrytomakmego · 06/05/2022 23:48

Embarrassingly I was a food bank user for a year plus. Pushed into accepting help initially and then found myself stuck with charity as part of my life.
There is no rent or council tax help if you're in hospital, and you automatically fall into debt as a result and get ordered to use food banks so you can use money spent on food to service those debts.

I'm disabled with a restricted diet so actually all the cheap stuff, and I'm deeply grateful for the very basic food I got, (and most especially the right to choose extra loo rolls instead, which meant a lot) but after a year and everyone else seeing what I already knew; that I could neither increase my income nor lower my outgoings any further without giving up working completely and going onto benefits as everyone wanted, food bank started including letters about cutting back, and I decided morally I should remove myself.

If weight loss becomes problematic it's a medical issue not a social one, so I now get supplemented with ensure drinks at 300 calories each and vitamin D tablets by the NHS to keep things stable.

I was an early adopter of non dependance, but if you need to make dependent people do it, (which I think is your way forward) the kindest thing is to give lots of warning so they can slowly reduce intake while still supported and build up some stock and acclimatize. The body does get used to it, and can manage on less than we think, but having choice during the transition is really helpful. Dignity and some control of situations even when you're slowly loosing, really helps.

Millonia · 06/05/2022 23:33

@oviraptor21 The root cause as you put it - is that -

*Benefits were frozen for 10 years for austerity.
*Benefits were cut as well
*The introduction of the 5 week wait for payment
*Also that benefits have risen by 3% this year whilst energy and food bills have completely soared by over 54% for the gas bills.
*Long waits for disability payments and people often being denied
*Rents (private) exceeding the amount benefits will cover and the bedroom tax.

If people want to be blind to these FACTS, to not realise that this is what the government WANTS (as someone said upthread), then they will never have any empathy.

QueenOfHiraeth · 06/05/2022 23:32

I volunteered at a food bank in one of the most deprived areas in the UK. When it first set up self referrals were allowed but after a short time organisers became aware of some people using the service that local agencies knew their need was not genuine so, at that point, they agreed to work with the local council so all applications had to come through them, children's centres, schools, surgeries, etc. They had limits on how many parcels were allowed over time, partly to reduce dependency but also to be able to meet demand.

I think there are always some people who will take however much anyone will give them, whether through genuine need, through powerlessness/dependency or just through greed. No agency can support them all indefinitely

NumberTheory · 06/05/2022 23:29

Having worked with food banks for years in the US I think there are two different tacks to take and both are good things to do in the absence of a proper social safety net -

  1. You can be the go to place for urgent, stop gap help. This allows a people to not slip through the crack when one bad incident is about to send them spiralling into debt or the like. A couple of months of groceries when their benefits have been temporarily stopped or they’re just being moved to being paid in areas or something like that. You should be able to help more people, but it’s shallower help. There will be people you stop serving who will then go hungry and who will need help more than new people you take on, but it’s a good way to stop things getting worse for more people.

  2. You can commit to families and see them through until they don’t need help anymore. This is deeper help for those families you do serve. It tends to be better for the hard to serve and the more vulnerable - those with a lot of issues who find it hard to access other services, who are likely to be targeted more often for theft or assault, those with significant mental health challenges that they are unable to manage well, etc. You will serve fewer people, but more likely to be serving people who have fewer reserves or networks to draw on. It’s more challenging, but tends not to be done by as many.

What (I think) is not that great is having a mid-term arbitrary cut off (like 2 years!). Because then you are plunging families into chaos again in order to pick up more families who you will keep a float for another 2 years before dropping them. It’s not a short stop gap that lets you serve lots of families and stops many of them falling into more dire circumstances, but it also doesn’t ensure the people you do help are back on their feet.

In any case - I’d just like to say you’re fantastic for caring enough to do this and to think about what you’re doing.

JaceLancs · 06/05/2022 23:28

Most of our local food banks have a limit to length of referral
minimum is 3 parcels
maximum is 6-8 weeks
but you can re refer

londonmummy1966 · 06/05/2022 23:28

I feel embarrassed that I need to point this out to posters on this thread as I'm surprised people can't work this out for themselves but what a lot of people criticising long term food bank users fail to grasp is that many of these families work. Too often it is the case that foodbanks are a charity subsidising big companies that are paying the minimum (not the living) wage and then big dividends to shareholders or are subsidising private landlords charging rents that are unaffordable leaving their tenants in poverty and unable to feed their chidlren. Often its not the "feckless" poor but the greedy capitalists who are screwing families over and making foodbanks a necessity. I'm in London and the quadruple whammy of London rents, low pay, high childcare (as the nurseries have to pay high rents too) and cost of living increases is tipping families with 2 working parents into desperate circumstances

Dinoteeth · 06/05/2022 23:25

Op in answer to your first question it should be short term help two years definitely isn't short term. My own answer would be 3 weeks but the rules that @londonmummy1966 has described make lots of sense.

Things will get worse before they get better, increasing costs mean more people needing help and less people able to donate. Your current model isn't sustainable.

There is something seriously wrong with the wealth distribution in the UK that food banks are even a thing.

Okaaaay · 06/05/2022 23:23

As long as they need help (but with a strategy to help new families). Possibly using vouchers rather than goods if funds can be raised to support that (given no need for storage).
So so hard