Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how long you think food banks should support people for?

369 replies

tartanbaker · 06/05/2022 18:28

I help to run an independent food bank, & we currently support over 100 families. We are nearing our capacity (in terms of numbers we can help) due to limited storage etc, but there are new people applying all the time. We give people food every week, and some families have been registered with us for about 2 years now. They are still needy, and we all know that things are going to continue being tough for the foreseeable future, so my question is…if you were to donate to a food bank, how would you want them to use your food/money? Continuing to help everyone for as long as they ask for help, even though it might mean turning others away? Or telling existing families who rely on you that you can’t help them any more because you are going to help new people now? It’s so hard, and an ongoing debate we are having, and I’d be really interested to hear other people’s opinions. Both options seem really tough….

OP posts:
tartanbaker · 07/05/2022 07:48

Good morning everyone, and thank you all so much for taking the time to post - I will ask all of the trustees to read this as all of your opinions are so useful. Food Banks are inevitably an emotive subject and, honestly, I respect and appreciate everyone’s input on it. We are all on the same side, wanting to help those who are genuinely struggling - wanting to avoid giving to those who are taking advantage whilst not scaring off or guilt-tripping those who genuinely need help. It is clearly a dilemma that everyone shares, with the voting literally at 50/50! We will continue to help as many as we can, not turn anyone away, direct them to help with other issues and just do our best to be non-judgmental and kind to those who need a helping hand at life, for whatever reason - that’s all any of us can do, isn’t it?

OP posts:
HTH1 · 07/05/2022 07:43

I think you need to streamline the offering rather than letting them choose the food donated to them individually. Honestly, I am not surprised that the bank is too much in demand if you let people refer themselves and then they basically get the same items/service as if they paid for them (who wouldn’t put buying food to the bottom of their priority list in those circs?)

You could do a family box and individual boxes containing X number of proteins, Y number of carbs and Z number of fruit and veg (depending upon what’s been donated, topped up by items you buy in bulk to reduce costs eg tinned meat/fish).

BaaMoon · 07/05/2022 07:35

Bednobsbroomsticks · 07/05/2022 07:16

I work with client groups who use foodbanks. It pains me to see little old ladies on very little money donating and to see how the foodbanks get abused. A lot of clients will get paid, use their money for drugs drink etc then apply for foodbank to keep them going. We have dropped off foodbanks to people who ring up and say they don't want this crap. I've turned up when they've been unloading their car full of shopping. People lie and say they don't live with their partner come in and apply for foodbank each saying they have kids (same kids) and others who apply and give the foodbanks away for money. Its being abused personally I think it should be a foodbank shop. Where you pay for the goods but only a few pence per item.
Foodbanks catching on to the abuse now and making strict rules only so many in a period and referred on for financial support. We shouldn't be proud of our foodbanks. It's become the norm. We should be thinking how bad it is that we need them and looking for change. It's depressing. . People should have enough money to get by . 348 pound a month is just enough now to cover gas and electric etc. People are trying to claim all the extra benefits to have money to survive. Uc has created more claims not less. It's a shame that the misuse is creating limited help for the genuine customers that go there.

Oh this is awful to read. I know lots of people who are on low incomes who make an effort to put a tin or two in the food bank as they have been close to needing the help themselves.

Bednobsbroomsticks · 07/05/2022 07:33

mycatisannoying · 07/05/2022 07:26

I'm sorry, but they are fucking scumbags.

Sadly seen so much abuse of the system I no longer donate or if I do it will be nappies or baby food.

Marvellousmadness · 07/05/2022 07:26

Yanbu
It should be like 6 months and then help others.

mycatisannoying · 07/05/2022 07:26

Bednobsbroomsticks · 07/05/2022 07:16

I work with client groups who use foodbanks. It pains me to see little old ladies on very little money donating and to see how the foodbanks get abused. A lot of clients will get paid, use their money for drugs drink etc then apply for foodbank to keep them going. We have dropped off foodbanks to people who ring up and say they don't want this crap. I've turned up when they've been unloading their car full of shopping. People lie and say they don't live with their partner come in and apply for foodbank each saying they have kids (same kids) and others who apply and give the foodbanks away for money. Its being abused personally I think it should be a foodbank shop. Where you pay for the goods but only a few pence per item.
Foodbanks catching on to the abuse now and making strict rules only so many in a period and referred on for financial support. We shouldn't be proud of our foodbanks. It's become the norm. We should be thinking how bad it is that we need them and looking for change. It's depressing. . People should have enough money to get by . 348 pound a month is just enough now to cover gas and electric etc. People are trying to claim all the extra benefits to have money to survive. Uc has created more claims not less. It's a shame that the misuse is creating limited help for the genuine customers that go there.

I'm sorry, but they are fucking scumbags.

OfstedOffred · 07/05/2022 07:23

what a lot of people criticising long term food bank users fail to grasp is that many of these families work.

I'm sorry but this isnt true. Read the trussell trust report on this. Lack of employment is a big factor in foodbank use.

The biggest group using foodbanks is single men (39%), not families.

They are followed by single mothers with children (this one to me points to epic epic failure of the child maintenance system), then single women.

The report flags that full time employment is the a key factor preventing food bank use.

Bednobsbroomsticks · 07/05/2022 07:16

I work with client groups who use foodbanks. It pains me to see little old ladies on very little money donating and to see how the foodbanks get abused. A lot of clients will get paid, use their money for drugs drink etc then apply for foodbank to keep them going. We have dropped off foodbanks to people who ring up and say they don't want this crap. I've turned up when they've been unloading their car full of shopping. People lie and say they don't live with their partner come in and apply for foodbank each saying they have kids (same kids) and others who apply and give the foodbanks away for money. Its being abused personally I think it should be a foodbank shop. Where you pay for the goods but only a few pence per item.
Foodbanks catching on to the abuse now and making strict rules only so many in a period and referred on for financial support. We shouldn't be proud of our foodbanks. It's become the norm. We should be thinking how bad it is that we need them and looking for change. It's depressing. . People should have enough money to get by . 348 pound a month is just enough now to cover gas and electric etc. People are trying to claim all the extra benefits to have money to survive. Uc has created more claims not less. It's a shame that the misuse is creating limited help for the genuine customers that go there.

DockOTheBay · 07/05/2022 07:14

Could you support both old and new customers, but give each family less to save money/storage?

mycatisannoying · 07/05/2022 07:13

My feeling is that for the sake of the new starts, there has to be a cut-off for the long-term people.
Some people may find themselves in a sudden crisis, and it would be heartbreaking if the help just wasn't there for them.
I mean, ideally it would be there for everyone, all of the time. However this simply isn't practical.

lameasahorse · 07/05/2022 07:12

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

howtomoveforwards · 07/05/2022 07:08

So why do women end up there less?

women frequently have sole care of children and therefore have recourse to greater public funding? For men on a low wage, having to pay out maintenance can have a massive impact on their living standards. I think we frequently forget that (and I say that as someone who has a very well paid ex who pays no maintenance).

lameasahorse · 07/05/2022 07:04

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Lunar27 · 07/05/2022 07:00

An impossible situation but IMO food banks should be a short term thing. That way you can help a much broader range of people. Help should be on the basis that people must find ways to wean themselves off the support, however difficult.

Also, helping someone for 2 years only serves to let this government off the hook. People shouldn't be in this position if they're genuinely needy as that's what we pay taxes for.

OfstedOffred · 07/05/2022 07:00

One of the things I've never understood - there was a trussell trust report couple of years back on foodbank users, saying 39% are single men (I think its something like 11% single women).

So why do women end up there less?

Are there better services available to women? Are women less prone to some chronic health conditions etc?

Babigurl88 · 07/05/2022 06:47

Also I want to add this is happening in Australia

Babigurl88 · 07/05/2022 06:45

I knew so many low income earners who abuse the food banks. They would go through their pay from Centrelink and buy alcohol, smokes, actual drugs like ice, meth etc. Their pay check was/close to $1000 per fortnight and most didn't have accommodation as they liked the idea of not paying rent so they surfed around to people's houses, no animals, no responsibility. They chose to spend and live like this as they knew after so long they could reach out and get another food package from Anglicare and also St Vinnie's did/do them too. They didn't do food shopping as Anglicare/St Vinnie's had that covered every day giving out free meals, cordial, tea, coffee to everyone. Their clothes came from St Vinnie's. They did all this as a choice, they didn't really need help and nor was it to survive but always a choice of living. They knew each other's pay day so when it was that person's pay day they would go around to that person's house to take what they could until they had nothing left then move on to the next person who had money. I was about 21yo when I witnessed all this. I was the complete the opposite to them but the only thing we had in common was our pays. I didn't go on about life the way they did and still don't and they all still live the way they were. I am now 33yo.

P.S. my advice is to set a timeframe up so we can only help for 3yrs etc that way everyone gets assistance. Everyone can only help so many people, not everyone. I would say if they really need the help then they would accept financial counselling asap given the chance. When you give out stuff to people who you believe truly need the help it only creates more and more people coming and being like I said above and it's only going to get worse

Autienotnaughtie · 07/05/2022 04:16

Categories of means tested need? People in highest category get weekly food, second category get fortnightly so essentially split with another person. Awful that you have to have this debate.

JustLyra · 07/05/2022 01:57

There shouldn’t be any food banks at all. Will it take rioting , protests etc to change this??

That won’t happen while so many people are convinced that people are just not trying or choosing to be reliant on food banks.

Until people realise that it’s not just addicts or people with problems that need food banks, it’s every day people who work and just can’t get by there won’t be the appetite to properly hold the government to account.

JustLyra · 07/05/2022 01:54

Classica · 07/05/2022 01:23

the whole point is that many people have run out of cloth to cut. that's why they're at a food bank.

Exactly this.

This isn’t feckless scroungers taking the piss out of people.

it’s people - many of them people who have jobs - being unable to afford the basics to live.

Classica · 07/05/2022 01:23

the whole point is that many people have run out of cloth to cut. that's why they're at a food bank.

StScholastica · 07/05/2022 01:08

SuperFlyWoman · 07/05/2022 00:04

I think using a food bank continuously for 2 years is an outrageous pisstake quite frankly. They should be for short term emergency use only.

It takes around 6 weeks to get a Universal Credit payment doesn’t it? So that should be the maximum amount of time.

People shouldn’t be taking food from a charity so they can pay debts! They need to get an IVA, bankruptcy etc if they’re struggling that much. As for drug and alcohol addiction, they shouldn’t be taking food from charity so they can use their cash for their addiction. If there are children involved, there should be an SS referral.

Everybody is struggling with the cost of living, you have to cut your cloth and people are signposted to lots of services from food banks so there is no excuse.

People who are really in an emergency situation should starve so others who’ve already had the benefit of long term support but can’t be bothered to get their lives together can continue to eat?

Good Lord, you are all heart aren't you?
I really dont think it's a case of "can't be bothered " and "cutting your cloth".

MountainDewer · 07/05/2022 01:05

Fifteentoes · 06/05/2022 23:22

Obviously you need to watch out for the feckless undeserving poor and their tendency to develop a "dependancy" on things like food. 😞

Back in the real world though, my feeling would be to keep supporting your current clients to the fullest extent possible, and if new people apply beyond your capacity to help, say "sorry, we can't help". You know your current clients, you have structures in place that are working with them, you're doing what you can to improve a shitty situation. There's no way you're going to be able to go that for ALL the hardship of society, so there's going to be a line that appears somewhere, and that will be determined by circumstances.

If you really can't accept that, you could maybe put some resources into launching a major fundraising drive to expand your capacity, or set up another foodbank to take new applicants.

Foodbanks may have started out intending to be temporary, but they're now an accepted part of society and have become permanent and normalised. Enough people accept that as a feature of the kind of society they want to live in, that it's not going to change any time soon. So all you can do is work out the scope and limits of what your particular organisation can do within that.

You have my deepest respect.

I really don’t accept it but there’s no choice - can’t sit on our hands and theorise about what the government ‘should’ be doing at this point!

There shouldn’t be any food banks at all. Will it take rioting , protests etc to change this??

MountainDewer · 07/05/2022 01:01

It’s a difficult choice to make but I would put in a max period of a year… and then a cooling off period of a couple of months?

It depends on the reason as well.
Ongoing food bank use makes sense for the Ill/disabled. Not for people with drug and debt issues. If they haven’t sorted it in a year they’re unlikely to ever do so. You can’t feed them for the rest of their lives.

You’ll also face the double sting of donations dropping as cost of living soars

Theytrytomakmego · 07/05/2022 00:53

tartanbaker May be of no use but if there are any self storage companies near you, pre-pandemic some offered free /cheap unused storage to charities in exchange for publicity. I no longer know what the story is now, other than many are loosing customers hand over fist as most have put up prices just as the cost of living crisis bites. Just a thought.