Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how long you think food banks should support people for?

369 replies

tartanbaker · 06/05/2022 18:28

I help to run an independent food bank, & we currently support over 100 families. We are nearing our capacity (in terms of numbers we can help) due to limited storage etc, but there are new people applying all the time. We give people food every week, and some families have been registered with us for about 2 years now. They are still needy, and we all know that things are going to continue being tough for the foreseeable future, so my question is…if you were to donate to a food bank, how would you want them to use your food/money? Continuing to help everyone for as long as they ask for help, even though it might mean turning others away? Or telling existing families who rely on you that you can’t help them any more because you are going to help new people now? It’s so hard, and an ongoing debate we are having, and I’d be really interested to hear other people’s opinions. Both options seem really tough….

OP posts:
Absentmindedwoman · 06/05/2022 19:01

I'm uncomfortable with the talk of creating a reliance or dependancy.

I mean, there are people who have literally zero other options? They are not falling into a comfortable reliance through choices they are making. They just have no way out.

And things are on course to simply get worse, both on an individual level and on a wider scale.

Aphrael · 06/05/2022 19:01

I've been receiving Food Bank support for six months now after being forced onto Universal Credit. My Work Capability Assessment is still pending (I should be under the top bracket of being too unwell to look for work) without the FB I would be unable to eat most days. Before anyone has a go at my being on internet - I have a £10 pm mobile contract (essential as DWP can call anytime) and a household internet subsidised by my Sheltered Housing Association.

ChiefInspectorParker · 06/05/2022 19:00

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

EmergencyPaintSituation · 06/05/2022 18:59

JayAlfredPrufrock

Sorry, did you meant to use the term ‘lifestyle choice’? If so then I think it needs pointing out that you should be nowhere near vulnerable families. Do you really think anyone sits there and says, ‘I fancy a change of lifestyle. I fancy queuing to get food that I haven’t chosen so that I can eat food that I might not like. I was going to take up rowing but this just seems more ‘me’’?

if not, then please reconsider your wording.

Lipsandlashes · 06/05/2022 18:59

Lurkerlot · 06/05/2022 18:31

Wow. Just that really.

How very helpful

5128gap · 06/05/2022 18:58

TheWayTheLightFalls · 06/05/2022 18:51

I've worked for various charities and when families were referred for hardship payments or food bank vouchers we could not do more than three in a twelve month period. This was to stop a reliance building up, obviously at the same time help would be given with regards to ensuring all relevant benefits were in place etc.

while I understand this approach I don’t agree with it wrt a lot of the people we’re serving (as I said above I’m in the same circumstances as the OP) - pensioners who are short every week because of heating/gas bills for example, or families who can’t afford a decent weekly shop because of high rents even if the adult/s is in work. Debt is another biggie. For these people I think the safety net of readily available, nutritious food is a good thing. A much better thing would be government-level thinking to address the underlying issues, but (understatement of the year) it is acutely lacking.

If pensioners can't afford bills its usually because they're not getting all their entitlements. If people can't afford food because they are servicing debt, they need their debts rescheduled. I agree with you, the government has greater responsibility, but in the meantime, its better to help them to address the cause of their hardship with what is available, support them to apply for benefits, reduce debt repayments. Sew up the wound if you like, rather than continually putting a plaster on. Most FB will reissue if the client is getting support with the cause of their food poverty.

tartanbaker · 06/05/2022 18:57

Oh, we haven’t turned anyone away yet, we are just nearing the point of having to decide. Part of the decision is that we want to do the right thing for the clients, ie help them to be as independent as possible whilst at the same time letting them know that there is someone who cares and who won’t let them down…

OP posts:
Mumwantingtogetitright · 06/05/2022 18:55

You are neither being reasonable nor unreasonable. People need to eat, whether they are existing clients or new ones. Food banks are supposed to be about meeting short term needs rather than creating ling term dependencies, but if people have nowhere else to go, what are you supposed to do? Leave them to starve? And what about the new clients? How are they going to eat if all of the existing foodbanks are already at capacity simply to meet the needs of existing clients.

The foodbanks are not responsible for this situation, nor can they provide a proper solution. It is the government which is utterly unreasonable because it is not doing anything like enough to address the underlying causes of food poverty. And the situation is only going to get much, much worse. SadAngry

FangsForTheMemory · 06/05/2022 18:54

But this is what the government WANTS, you know! If they didn't want this, it wouldn't be happening.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 06/05/2022 18:52

It’s meant to be for emergencies not a lifestyle choice.

Can you expand on this with official/reputable figures or links please, I remember benefits being labelled as a lifestyle choice during the striver/skiver propaganda drive during austerity

flashbac · 06/05/2022 18:52

Newly needy come first I think. They will have throught longer and harder about seeking help. Please don't turn them away.

5128gap · 06/05/2022 18:51

Sorry, saw your additional posts. You do this already.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 06/05/2022 18:51

I've worked for various charities and when families were referred for hardship payments or food bank vouchers we could not do more than three in a twelve month period. This was to stop a reliance building up, obviously at the same time help would be given with regards to ensuring all relevant benefits were in place etc.

while I understand this approach I don’t agree with it wrt a lot of the people we’re serving (as I said above I’m in the same circumstances as the OP) - pensioners who are short every week because of heating/gas bills for example, or families who can’t afford a decent weekly shop because of high rents even if the adult/s is in work. Debt is another biggie. For these people I think the safety net of readily available, nutritious food is a good thing. A much better thing would be government-level thinking to address the underlying issues, but (understatement of the year) it is acutely lacking.

FangsForTheMemory · 06/05/2022 18:50

But the situation has now changed for the worse. This 'reliance' is what some people have no choice about. What else can they do? Where I live there's an official food bank, but there's also an unofficial one in the village which consists of a tool bin full of tins. People can come and take whatever they need from it. I dropped by to put some tins in it the other day and it was almost empty. I think there were two tins of tomatoes and a tin of beans in it. It's horrifying to think that if those had gone, there would be people without anything at all.

tartanbaker · 06/05/2022 18:50

TheWayTheLightFalls · 06/05/2022 18:38

I’d like to sign in because I am in exactly the same position - I run an independent food bank and we have the same situation. On the one hand I’m glad that we don’t follow the “three parcels a year” model and we help whoever needs help, but I also don’t feel that food banks are the correct response to chronic/ongoing need - it needs a structural solution imo.

It’s so incredibly hard, isn’t it? I wish we could help everyone, but we just can’t…

OP posts:
Mydpisgrumpierthanyours · 06/05/2022 18:50

Oh my that is one of the worst decisions ever. I have no idea how you would even begin to decide what to do for the best.
How depressing for some families though that 2 years later they STILL need food banks.

5128gap · 06/05/2022 18:50

I'd prefer that the food banks operated as most do, with vouchers issued by agencies working with vulnerable people. This then forms part of a fuller program of support, to meet their short term crisis needs, but also try to build their resilience and improve their outlook for the future, for example, by making sure they were receiving their full benefits entitlements. Obviously within this, there is some contingency for walk ins, but its good practice for the fb to signpost those people to additional sources of support as well. If your foodbank doesn't work with partners in this way, it might be something to suggest.

1990s · 06/05/2022 18:48

Ah didn’t quote a post. But no idea how you make this decision.

Pinkandpurplehairedlady · 06/05/2022 18:48

At the food bank I help run we give 4 weeks of parcels and then they have to be re-referred by the CAB, job centre etc. Any longer than that and you risk creating a dependency.

tartanbaker · 06/05/2022 18:47

And yes, I worry about having created a dependency with some clients. It’s sooooo hard! One of our trustees is a benefits expert, so we can help on that, but I just can’t help feeling that some people will never get their heads above water, no matter what we do…

OP posts:
1990s · 06/05/2022 18:47

Came on to say food banks shouldn’t support people at all, because food banks shouldn’t have to fucking exist!

Agree that the government should be ashamed and busting a gut to remove this situation.

But yeah, agree with the post I’ve quoted.

pussycatlickinglollyices · 06/05/2022 18:46

This is going to sound quite harsh...

Maybe existing users of your service should have to re-register/be newly referred every year.
They'd also have to go to the back of the queue if you have too many clients.

At least it gives the newly needy a chance.

I did say it would sound harsh.

...and before anyone jumps on me, we're on a limited budget ourselves, but add to the foodbank collection point regularly.

Acheyknees · 06/05/2022 18:45

Please don't turn away new referrals. I understand its a really awful position for you to be in but they need support.

litlealligator · 06/05/2022 18:44

Given the cost of living crisis I don't see how you could possibly stop helping existing clients but it's a horrible dilemma.

tartanbaker · 06/05/2022 18:44

Yes, we already do this, with multiple agencies, but it’s not a quick fix if you have debt, or drug or alcohol problems, so those people will then still be needy for some time…

OP posts: