Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how long you think food banks should support people for?

369 replies

tartanbaker · 06/05/2022 18:28

I help to run an independent food bank, & we currently support over 100 families. We are nearing our capacity (in terms of numbers we can help) due to limited storage etc, but there are new people applying all the time. We give people food every week, and some families have been registered with us for about 2 years now. They are still needy, and we all know that things are going to continue being tough for the foreseeable future, so my question is…if you were to donate to a food bank, how would you want them to use your food/money? Continuing to help everyone for as long as they ask for help, even though it might mean turning others away? Or telling existing families who rely on you that you can’t help them any more because you are going to help new people now? It’s so hard, and an ongoing debate we are having, and I’d be really interested to hear other people’s opinions. Both options seem really tough….

OP posts:
TheWayTheLightFalls · 06/05/2022 21:02

When people are able to ‘self refer’ for access to free stuff why would anyone expect demand to be anything other than limitless?

Well, think about yourself. I can near-on promise that if you live in a town or city there is a social supermarket, gurdwara, church or community cafe doing free meals at least one day a week, on a self-referral basis. Have you looked it up? Do you go? Do you use it, as someone presumably not in food poverty? No, because you don’t need it and because it’s not something for nothing really - it’s your time (which is worth less and less the poorer you are), and because there is HUGE stigma attached to food bank use. It’s not like Waitrose flinging open their doors and shouting “Free food here today!”

I’m sure there are some chancers. We feed hundreds a week, and I can’t promise that there isn’t someone in the queue patting themselves on the back for scoring some free food. But we chat a lot with our regulars and when you get to know more you (we) always come away very clearly understanding why they are using our services.

JustLyra · 06/05/2022 20:59

Brieandcamembert · 06/05/2022 20:55

We need an absolute overhaul of the way we are functioning. We need to teach better budgeting, cooking and financial planning.

Benefits should be time limited (unless you are so sick or disabled that any form of paid employment is not possible). They should also come in the form of allocated amounts for gas/ electricity / oil and food vouchers. Good vouchers include basic but very nutritious foods (no breakfast cereals etc, but porridge, fruit, veg, meats for stewing). Recipe ideas and meal plans. Support people to get back on their feet and living well.

Yes, because vouchers worked so well for school meals...

There wasn't issues with people being stuck with vouchers for supermarkets they couldn't afford to get to or delays in them being issued.

Issuing vouchers also completely goes against teaching budgeting. Not to mention actually giving people a bit of respect and dignity.

What we actually need to do is address the cost of living and stop pretending that there is a huge issue with people scamming benefits. They've already been attacked and cut to the bone as it is.

Tilltheend99 · 06/05/2022 20:56

I think neither option is ideal. You need to be upfront with the people who donate to you long term and ask for more support/food donations/sponsorship going forward until things improve for the country.

Yes that’s tough but you absolutely cannot let down families that have been relying on you long term. If they were already in poverty before the cost of living crisis then they are in a much more precarious position that is only getting worse.

For the people who are just beginning to fall into poverty, you need to contact other community groups like mosques, churches, temples, synagogue, community Facebook groups. Explain how desperate the situation is and use your experience and expertise to guide them in opening more food banks/soup kitchens/community outreach schemes.

I know it sucks if you are already doing everything you can in awful circumstances with no help from gov to be asked to do more but I assume you are doing this in the first place because you care.

I would also contact your newly elected labour or libdem or green councillor and ask for ideas, resources, use of space etc as they will be keen to show they are getting to work etc

You said space was an issue. Would you be able to collect more donations from local businesses if you had more space? Are there unused buildings owned by the council that they could give you use of?

Is there a celebrity with connections to your area who could retweet their followers to help you?

JustLyra · 06/05/2022 20:56

I honestly think most people have absolutely no idea how the most vulnerable people in our society are being forced to live. It is shocking and it is shameful.

I think that's very clear by some of the language on the thread.

A lot of people would be shocked by things like delays in PIP appeals for example. I have a friend whose partner has lost his PIP, she's lost her carers while they wait for the appeal - the date is seven months away... It's a massive impact on their budget and the only advice she's been given by her MP is "it'll be backdated when you win" (as he very clearly will!).

Far easier to have the "well people will rely on it" attitude like it's a life choice, when for the vast majority it's not.

Feckingfeck · 06/05/2022 20:56

Allthesefolks · 06/05/2022 18:35

My instinct is as long as they need it but I really feel for you with having to deny new applications, there’s no easy answer.

This

Its a difficult one as i guess people become reliant on it but then you wont be able to help others even if some only need it as a short term fix?

I know someone who went to the food bank then got a new car delivered the next day, so i wonder how many take advantage and deprive others of the help they need?

JulesRimetStillGleaming · 06/05/2022 20:55

As long as they need it. Surely you have eligibility criteria. It's better to get more donations/ funding than to cut people off.

Brieandcamembert · 06/05/2022 20:55

We need an absolute overhaul of the way we are functioning. We need to teach better budgeting, cooking and financial planning.

Benefits should be time limited (unless you are so sick or disabled that any form of paid employment is not possible). They should also come in the form of allocated amounts for gas/ electricity / oil and food vouchers. Good vouchers include basic but very nutritious foods (no breakfast cereals etc, but porridge, fruit, veg, meats for stewing). Recipe ideas and meal plans. Support people to get back on their feet and living well.

JustLyra · 06/05/2022 20:53

Most food banks only give a maximum of three times a year. A small number do not have this rule and have differing rules.

All bar the Trussel run foodbanks round here have dropped that rule because of how dire situations have become for some people.

lameasahorse · 06/05/2022 20:52

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Mumwantingtogetitright · 06/05/2022 20:51

All the people saying that people should be limited to three food parcels in 12 months so that they don't build up a dependency on them... that's all very well if people are in a position to budget more carefully or increase their income in some way. However, I work in this area and we are increasingly seeing people with negative budgets who simply cannot make ends meet no matter how effectively they "manage" their money. You can't manage it if there just isn't enough. And while it's easy to say that they need to find ways of increasing their income, not everyone has the ability or the opportunity to do that.

The problem is this fucking government which is pushing people into the most desperate situations. It really isn't a case of cancelling Netflix and cutting back on a few fags. Or buying value brands as a government minister so helpfully suggested the other day. I honestly think most people have absolutely no idea how the most vulnerable people in our society are being forced to live. It is shocking and it is shameful.

JustLyra · 06/05/2022 20:50

Millonia · 06/05/2022 20:46

THEY SHOULDN'T NEED FOODBANKS IN THE FIRST PLACE!! WHY HAS IT BECOME SO NORMALISED - THAT'S WHAT YOU SHOULD BE ASKING YOURSELVES.

They shouldn't. That doesn't change the fact that they do.

Simply withdrawing the assistance won't change government policy or the position people are in though...

GandTfortea · 06/05/2022 20:48

I thought ,it was a one of ,like one voucher ,for one lot of shopping
id no idea people were getting their food shop weekly provided.wow ,no wonder they don’t want to stop.
do you provide vegan food ,

Millonia · 06/05/2022 20:46

THEY SHOULDN'T NEED FOODBANKS IN THE FIRST PLACE!! WHY HAS IT BECOME SO NORMALISED - THAT'S WHAT YOU SHOULD BE ASKING YOURSELVES.

ChiefInspectorParker · 06/05/2022 20:45

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Blossomtoes · 06/05/2022 20:41

Doubt a labour government would be any better though

I’d bet my house it would.

Blossomtoes · 06/05/2022 20:39

FangsForTheMemory · 06/05/2022 18:54

But this is what the government WANTS, you know! If they didn't want this, it wouldn't be happening.

This. It’s absolutely atrocious that foodbanks are needed at all. Nobody should ever be turned away from one.

duvetdayforeveryone · 06/05/2022 20:36

No answer to OP question, but this is honestly the saddest thread I have seen in a long time 😢

TyrannosaurusRegina · 06/05/2022 20:33

Perhaps people's finances should be examined to see if it's a genuine case of not having enough money or mismanagement of finances. My sister uses a food bank from time to time. I used to help her out when she was skint and down to her last penny, until I realised that she always managed to afford her 20 pack of benson and hedges every day.

Whisp3r · 06/05/2022 20:33

I think this is too much responsibility for one independent organisation trying to help people. Nobody is more deserving than somebody else of food. New people are no more deserving of help than people who have already been helped and vice versa. I would probably go with individual circumstances. So maybe give food to people who were in lots of debt and couldn't borrow anymore before giving to people who had no money but could borrow a bit. That's terrible because it will lead people onto debt but people who have already maxed out all their borrowing options are going to find obtaining food very difficult. All food banks can do is try to help. They can't solve all the problems of all the people.

LemonDrizzles · 06/05/2022 20:33

Every 6 months everyone had to re apply. Make it know how many slots there are and that there is a waitlist. Anyone can be added to the waitlist at any time. Your waitlist position could change and only the top ten in the waitlist get told "you are in the top ten".

If you are a charity, you made need to make public the details of how you determine need.

All the best and very very deep thanks for the great work you continue to do for your local community!

Blondeshavemorefun · 06/05/2022 20:30

A hard choice

you can’t turn away new people

equally 2yrs is. Very long to be solely reliant on a food bank

not sure what the solution is

a weaning off process so every other week

or everyone gets less

you say you send a list out and they choose
.
what is an average weekly list of say. Single person v a family of 2 adults and 2 kids

Foodbanksshouldbeobsolete · 06/05/2022 20:28

@Spoldge45

When I was in a refuge there were many of us with fancy false nails and new iPhones. the iPhones because if you can get a phone on credit/pay monthly its often the only way to get a new phone fast and on a new number and that the abuser has never had time to track. some people even had smart phones funded through support services. Or through catalogues like very/little woods where you can spread payments. a few of the women there were trained in hair/beauty/nails and often couldn't work or earn. Thats just one example of why somebody might have false nails and a new iPhone. Circumstances can change really fast, i have met homeless families who had a few bad luck things happen and went from middle salaries and rented houses to emergency accommodation and food banks within a surprisingly short time.

A lot of people struggle with budgeting due to impulsivity (ADHD, bipolar, BPD, spring to mind), addictions to alcohol, drugs, gambling etc. Of course there are irresponsible people, but most have challenges and difficulties that are not easy to overcome and don't any less deserve sympathy or food than anyone else. And government has systematically stripped back all the support so that all there is is self will and food banks.

MamboMambo · 06/05/2022 20:23

Woolandwonder · 06/05/2022 19:27

Could you move to fortnightly parcels after say 3 months then monthly after 6 months, then needing a re-referral/reassessment after that point or something similar, so not suddenly cutting off support but making sure you can support a lot more people.

This was going to be my suggestion! If you do every other week you essentially double the amount of people you can help.

JustLyra · 06/05/2022 20:19

Spoldge45 · 06/05/2022 20:14

I've often wondered if people have to actually referred to food banks or can they just turn up? There was a lady on the local radio the other day saying that some people turn up with fake nails and brand new phones iPhone sometimes? I hope this doesn't mean people in genuine hardship have to go without? Terrible if so😕

It totally depends on the foodbank - some are referral only, some are open and some are a mix.

The lady on the radio sounds like she was just spouting tropes about poor people tbh.

NuttyinNotts · 06/05/2022 20:19

As part of my job, I support people to go to a food bank. The no questions asked model is by far the most appropriate for the people I work with. By the time they are seeking help, they are already hungry. They also struggle with bureaucracy and even with support, seeking a referral is a barrier. We provide a lot of support around budgeting and support them to get help with other organisations for debt and benefit advice. But there are still frequently situations where they are in immediate need of food. They're also not people who rely on it for years at a time, so closing to new clients would hurt them, they frequently need support for a few weeks to months to see them through a crisis.