Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hope Amber Heard is lying?

192 replies

roadsweep · 06/05/2022 13:31

Otherwise it's just another abused woman that's not believed.

OP posts:
Firebird83 · 06/05/2022 17:26

From what I can see, they’re both abusive, toxic people.

MarJau26 · 06/05/2022 17:20

Knittingchamp · 06/05/2022 16:16

She physically abused him, has a history of being physically abusive with at least one other and has been diagnosed with histrionic personality disorder. She's lied a lot. She secretly recorded him for evidence yet at no time was there any physical abuse recorded. Police said there was no evidence of physical abuse when they came either. Given that she's abusive herself, I don't have sympathy for her. That doesn't mean I have any positive feelings toward Depp, either.

Exactly. Yet there are people bending over backwards to disbelieve that she's an abuser. She has lied about alot and this was proven. She's vile.

Bagelsandbrie · 06/05/2022 17:11

DressingGownofDoom · 06/05/2022 17:05

'I didn’t like the way he turned up to court yesterday with Bob Marleys “war” playing full blast and stepping in with a smile. He’s enjoying the media attention and the fact people are turning against Amber H and you can see it. Very childish.'

Yeah he gives me the creeps. All that smirking and when she came down off the stand and he walked towards her it looked like he was squaring up to her! I think he doesn't even care if he wins he's just brought this case to terrorise her even more.

100%

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 06/05/2022 17:10

FourTeaFallOut · 06/05/2022 13:56

Yes. The hope that she is lying is the only thing that makes this entire circus palatable. Otherwise what we have is an abused woman being torn apart at the behest of her abuser on a world stage while the whole world shouts witch.

This, I find it beyond disgusting how much hatred there is against AH,all because people like Jack Sparrow, it's fucking despicable

DressingGownofDoom · 06/05/2022 17:05

'I didn’t like the way he turned up to court yesterday with Bob Marleys “war” playing full blast and stepping in with a smile. He’s enjoying the media attention and the fact people are turning against Amber H and you can see it. Very childish.'

Yeah he gives me the creeps. All that smirking and when she came down off the stand and he walked towards her it looked like he was squaring up to her! I think he doesn't even care if he wins he's just brought this case to terrorise her even more.

Bagelsandbrie · 06/05/2022 16:53

Ducksinthebath · 06/05/2022 16:28

Very few people seem to realise than mental health difficulties are more likely to make you the victim of abuse rather than a perpetrator or someone fabricating allegations of abuse.

A civil court has already found to a substantial degree that the allegations she has made are true. That remains the case regardless of her behaviour towards him.

His turning things into a circus is very telling. Also very telling that despite previously appearing very close with his children they seem very much estranged now. If the allegations which touch on his conduct around his daughter are even slightly accurate he’s a disgusting individual.

I agree with this.

I didn’t like the way he turned up to court yesterday with Bob Marleys “war” playing full blast and stepping in with a smile. He’s enjoying the media attention and the fact people are turning against Amber H and you can see it. Very childish.

Ducksinthebath · 06/05/2022 16:28

Very few people seem to realise than mental health difficulties are more likely to make you the victim of abuse rather than a perpetrator or someone fabricating allegations of abuse.

A civil court has already found to a substantial degree that the allegations she has made are true. That remains the case regardless of her behaviour towards him.

His turning things into a circus is very telling. Also very telling that despite previously appearing very close with his children they seem very much estranged now. If the allegations which touch on his conduct around his daughter are even slightly accurate he’s a disgusting individual.

Knittingchamp · 06/05/2022 16:16

She physically abused him, has a history of being physically abusive with at least one other and has been diagnosed with histrionic personality disorder. She's lied a lot. She secretly recorded him for evidence yet at no time was there any physical abuse recorded. Police said there was no evidence of physical abuse when they came either. Given that she's abusive herself, I don't have sympathy for her. That doesn't mean I have any positive feelings toward Depp, either.

anon2334 · 06/05/2022 16:03

Sign of the times. Narcissistic abuse can make the other one look like the abuser and they are the victims! Unless both are narcs and toxic together. So difficult . Narcissism is a toxic type of abuse and the narc is so clever at hiding their mask.

Lachimolala · 06/05/2022 16:02

@Waxonwaxoff0 Hahaa! Thank you! Big Jimin fans in our house 😂

jeaux90 · 06/05/2022 15:55

I believe her, as per the previous case shows.

Timeson · 06/05/2022 15:53

roadsweep · 06/05/2022 15:38

He didn't notice her until the last minute and she massively overacted? That's how I saw that

He was walking towards the witness box that she had just been stood on giving evidence

Indicatrice · 06/05/2022 15:45

roadsweep · 06/05/2022 15:38

He didn't notice her until the last minute and she massively overacted? That's how I saw that

I don't think he had to be stopped or that he was laughing. However, I don't think Amber 'massively overreacted' either Hmm

She recoiled after seeing the man she says abused her walking towards the dock., that is not massively reacting, she didn't scream or shout.

malificent7 · 06/05/2022 15:41

Both awful.

roadsweep · 06/05/2022 15:38

Timeson · 06/05/2022 15:25

I was a bit on the fence so far. But I’ve just seen the video of him trying to walk towards her when she came off the stand and he had to be stopped.
She seemed genuinely terrified and he was laughing, something about that clip put shivers down my spine

He didn't notice her until the last minute and she massively overacted? That's how I saw that

OP posts:
Bagelsandbrie · 06/05/2022 15:36

BeyondPurpleTulips · 06/05/2022 14:51

I sarcastically said similar to my abusive alcoholic ex, shortly after he tried to strangle me, then when I was upset and anger he tried to claim I was abusing him.

As someone who has lived through a very similar relationship to AH, her story is entirely plausible to me. Recordings and all.

Living with an abuser who messes up your view of reality has a septic effect on your sense of self and your behaviour - you become reactively abusive and goady.

I was an autistic woman (yet another form of unreliable witness, not unlike AH's alleged personality disorders), being followed around the house being shouted at as I was melting down, begging for space to calm myself down while he kept on at me. When cornered I would lash out, and he'd use that as evidence of how I was the abusive person.

I'm not trying to use my bias by saying she is definitely telling the truth - just that her version is entirely plausible to someone who has lived it

That is similar to my own experience too.

BeyondPurpleTulips · 06/05/2022 15:36

Sniffypete · 06/05/2022 15:32

But BeyondPurple you are putting your own experience on that. My experience of DV is vastly different. I wouldn't have dared to answer back or respond in that way.

I understand that not every DV victim will respond the same, I am just saying that her responding that way does not prove she is lying about him being abusive.

Responding with any of the trauma responses (ie fight, flight, freeze, fawn, flop) would be entirely natural, I am just explaining it as someone who did respond in the same manner as AH.

Sniffypete · 06/05/2022 15:32

But BeyondPurple you are putting your own experience on that. My experience of DV is vastly different. I wouldn't have dared to answer back or respond in that way.

Timeson · 06/05/2022 15:25

I was a bit on the fence so far. But I’ve just seen the video of him trying to walk towards her when she came off the stand and he had to be stopped.
She seemed genuinely terrified and he was laughing, something about that clip put shivers down my spine

Waxonwaxoff0 · 06/05/2022 15:17

@Lachimolala off topic but I love your username 😁

SunscreenCentral · 06/05/2022 15:10

Heard has form. Depp does not. The opposite is the case, in fact.

Lachimolala · 06/05/2022 15:09

BeyondPurpleTulips · 06/05/2022 14:51

I sarcastically said similar to my abusive alcoholic ex, shortly after he tried to strangle me, then when I was upset and anger he tried to claim I was abusing him.

As someone who has lived through a very similar relationship to AH, her story is entirely plausible to me. Recordings and all.

Living with an abuser who messes up your view of reality has a septic effect on your sense of self and your behaviour - you become reactively abusive and goady.

I was an autistic woman (yet another form of unreliable witness, not unlike AH's alleged personality disorders), being followed around the house being shouted at as I was melting down, begging for space to calm myself down while he kept on at me. When cornered I would lash out, and he'd use that as evidence of how I was the abusive person.

I'm not trying to use my bias by saying she is definitely telling the truth - just that her version is entirely plausible to someone who has lived it

I’ve had an almost identical experience, from the being followed whilst having a meltdown (adhd) to saying something similar (oh go on then who will believe you) while he was baiting me that he was going to tell everyone I was the abusive ‘psycho’ one.

LuaDipa · 06/05/2022 15:00

FourTeaFallOut · 06/05/2022 14:44

We see this all the time, don't we? Oh, she doesn't seem traumatised in the right kind of way to be believable. We see it with women who are rape victims, women who are victims of domestic violence, women of murdered children. Always a judgement of their performance of showing grief and trauma in the 'right' kind of way. It's sick.

It’s awful to see this is still going on. I can’t watch an abused woman being forced to relive her ordeal via live link.

And the fact that there is no protection for her in court. She’s having to testify in front of her abuser while he (and the whole world for that matter) looks on and laughs. And no one else can see how utterly wrong this is.

What sort of world are we living in?

MiseryWIthAStent · 06/05/2022 14:53

I believe her. I don't think she was perfect obviously and they was definitely a toxic relationship. But I think how sad it is when a woman is concerned about telling the police she's being abused because her husband is a charmer, a hard worker or has money. Well that's basically Jonny depp really.

Indicatrice · 06/05/2022 14:53

Sniffypete · 06/05/2022 14:43

Amber is an abuser. She actually said on a phone call: “Tell them, I, Johnny Depp, I'm a victim of domestic abuse ... and see how many people believe or side with you.”

She has previous abuse history, although her partner said that the arrest was homophobic, the officer that arrested Heard was also from the LGBT+ community.

It was clearly a fucked up relationship, goodness why it lasted as long as it did. Do I think he abused her? I don't know. None of his ex-partners have come forward to say that he behaved that way with them. Whereas she has been abusive with others. She cheated on him, there's video evidence, she claims he cheated on her. It's just all messed up. She recorded him, took photos etc, it just seems as if she was setting him up all along.

That quote doesn't prove anything. It's worrying that you think it does.