Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hope Amber Heard is lying?

192 replies

roadsweep · 06/05/2022 13:31

Otherwise it's just another abused woman that's not believed.

OP posts:
P00rKids · 11/05/2022 20:18

oh except it’s not funny

P00rKids · 11/05/2022 20:16

It’s like I said - I’ve been there. You don’t understand my logic because you haven’t. Fair enough. I can recognise what he is doing. And his ‘laughing’ yea I got that small detail. And all this talk of, “poo on the bed” “it’s her poo, it’s this big etc”. Classic disgusting humiliation to drag it out in court and media. It’s all disgusting. The most disgusting thing to shut her up. I see Amber Heard as being honest. I don’t think honesty always goes very far when you’re fighting men like this. Maybe time to take a leaf out of their book and just bullshit and laugh your way out. Tbh I don’t like talking about this case at all, so I’m bowing out.

stopwaitingforpermissiontobeyou · 11/05/2022 20:12

MattDamon · 06/05/2022 13:58

She's already proven her case. Depp is an abuser. His appeal failed. This judgement changes nothing.

Erm ..no.

misssatan · 11/05/2022 20:01

P00rKids · 11/05/2022 16:26

"I found myself in a similar position once. Can’t stress enough how a simple recording could have ironed out so much confusion. However, in my case, every device I used got smashed up as it escalated. It’s too horrible and I wouldn’t wish it on anyone. That’s why I believe her."

I fail to follow your logic. I think the decision to record each other was largely mutual. And how do you explain the recordings of her mocking him and saying he wasn't punched, merely hit?

I understand how you could believe the violence was mutual but not how you can ignore her admitted violence and endless lies, not to mention her terrible acting on the stand. More and more evidence is coming out in and around this trial showing what a liar she is. There's even a recording of the bottle throwing/finger cutting incident in which she admits it was her.

misssatan · 11/05/2022 19:52

My replies seem to be going missing. I don't know if I'm being censored.

P00rKids · 11/05/2022 16:26

I believe her and agree with most of the comments on here. I loved Johnny Depp, I literally thought, “No! Not him, not Johnny Depp!!” Instantly had a strong urge not to believe her. And that’s after having experienced how crazy abuse actually is!

I think when someone goes to the trouble of repeatedly trying to record conversations - then that’s pretty desperate. Why would u actually want to record conversations? It’s because those conversations are all going completely and totally wrong. Whether it’s blatant lies, denials, gaslighting, verbal abuse - there is something - some strong reason to want to record it. A strong urge to want to identify/establish/prove what is causing problems in the marriage - in the heat of the moment. Problems that could be rectified and things could move forward (if both parties wanted to). I assume Johnny Depp didn’t want to address/rectify these problems and Amber did.

I found myself in a similar position once. Can’t stress enough how a simple recording could have ironed out so much confusion. However, in my case, every device I used got smashed up as it escalated. It’s too horrible and I wouldn’t wish it on anyone. That’s why I believe her.

Indicatrice · 11/05/2022 15:40

@misssatan

Actually the onus is on you to prove your argument and back it up with statistics.

So you've made the four statements below and the onus is on me to prove my argument, and none on you to back up your made up crap? You are cute in your delirium. Grin

  • 40% of domestic abuse is suffered by men and
  • women are more frequently the instigators of violence in the home.
  • They are also more violent as a group to children
  • and violent to other women as well. I
misssatan · 11/05/2022 14:19

Indicatrice · 10/05/2022 23:59

"hahaha, you’re the one 2
writing bullshit statistics, the onus is on YOU to post the research links. I know you won’t because they’re all bullshit, as I’ve actually read the ONS statistics."

Actually the onus is on you to prove your argument and back it up with statistics. You and the others like you are making the claim that Depp is the abuser and Heard the abused based on the assertion that men are almost always the abuser and women almost always the abused, something which simply isn't true.

Even if that were true such an identitarian approach doesn't prove anything as people are individuals not merely parts of a group who all think and act alike. We already know Heard is abusive and an habitual abuser. All that remains is to decide whether Depp was violent in that relationship or not.

Sqeebling · 11/05/2022 01:20

She's probably telling some kind of truth about being abused only it's not by him, JD.

It's how people pass lie detector tests.

They tell a truth just not the real truth about the current matter in hand

Indicatrice · 10/05/2022 23:59

@misssatan hahaha, you’re the one 2
writing bullshit statistics, the onus is on YOU to post the research links.

I know you won’t because they’re all bullshit, as I’ve actually read the ONS statistics.

misssatan · 10/05/2022 23:12

@misssatan

If you bothered to have an open mind and looked at the statistics you will find around 40% of domestic abuse is suffered by men and women are more frequently the instigators of violence in the home. They are also more violent as a group to children and violent to other women as well. I know this from personal experience.

"What a load of made-up bollocks."

Wow, what a devastating argument.

Why not actually research the subject? Afraid to learn something you don't like?

Indicatrice · 10/05/2022 19:39

@misssatan

If you bothered to have an open mind and looked at the statistics you will find around 40% of domestic abuse is suffered by men and women are more frequently the instigators of violence in the home. They are also more violent as a group to children and violent to other women as well. I know this from personal experience.

What a load of made-up bollocks.

misssatan · 10/05/2022 19:35

BeyondPurpleTulips · 10/05/2022 12:30

"Ah yes, the 40% stat that includes "nagging" (women>men) on the same level as choking someone (guess what men>women)... 🙄

Check your sources, they're highly dodgy."

Given that quite a few delicate souls on here think that slamming kitchen doors counts as serious abuse it wouldn't be very hard to re-frame 'nagging' as verbal abuse.

However, I'm talking about physical abuse and only physical abuse in which women play a significant part as instigators and primary/soul abusers.

You should get out of feminist echo chambers and into the real world sometime. Those of us who have experienced violent abuse from women know that not all women should be believed simply because they are women and not all women are poor, oppressed, downtrodden angels.

BeyondPurpleTulips · 10/05/2022 16:29

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 10/05/2022 15:34

Exactly, but nothing will convince the president of the Johnny Depp fanclub @misssatan of even considering this.

Oh I know - I'm replying purely for the benefit of the lurkers who are less... indoctrinated 😄

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 10/05/2022 15:34

BeyondPurpleTulips · 10/05/2022 12:30

Ah yes, the 40% stat that includes "nagging" (women>men) on the same level as choking someone (guess what men>women)... 🙄

Check your sources, they're highly dodgy.

Exactly, but nothing will convince the president of the Johnny Depp fanclub @misssatan of even considering this.

BeyondPurpleTulips · 10/05/2022 12:30

Ah yes, the 40% stat that includes "nagging" (women>men) on the same level as choking someone (guess what men>women)... 🙄

Check your sources, they're highly dodgy.

misssatan · 10/05/2022 12:18

"You keep trying to force the narrative that as many men are abused as women, this is patently not true, however many posts you hijack with this nonsense"

Spoken like a true feminist.

There is no hijack. Feminists like yourself and Queen Camilla are making the case that Depp must be the abuser because he has more 'male power' or some such ideological nonsense. That false position needs to be corrected.

If you bothered to have an open mind and looked at the statistics you will find around 40% of domestic abuse is suffered by men and women are more frequently the instigators of violence in the home. They are also more violent as a group to children and violent to other women as well. I know this from personal experience.

Whatever you think about Depp and the likelihood that he was abusive as well there is more than enough evidence to show that Heard is an abuser and Depp was abused by her.

Why do you choose to pretend otherwise?

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 09/05/2022 16:40

misssatan · 08/05/2022 18:37

QueenCamilla · 08/05/2022 15:15

"However (like in this case) when there's a man and a woman in the room and we're talking about who habitually beat up / raped whom, you'd be dim to not see the odds.

I have never been in any sustained way beaten, raped, bullied or tormented by someone weaker (and not solely in physical sense) than me. Have you?"

I generally don't like the phrase but it is very apt here: you really need to educate yourself. You need to learn about female abusers and male victims of female abuse. Both are common enough.

Often men feel unable to fight back because they don't think they will be believed, a realistic belief given the existence of people like you. Often they become demoralised and don't fight back or even come to believe they deserve violence. The difference in sizes doesn't necessarily determine who is the abused and who the abuser.

You should start with the Jordan Worth case. It might help correct your bias and enlighten your ignorance. He was close to death and saved by policeman who was intelligent enough to see something was wrong despite his denials and persistent enough to get him alone and get the truth from him. Her sentence was fairly lenient given the severity of her abuse, as is usually the case with women who get much shorter sentences than men for the same crimes.

You keep trying to force the narrative that as many men are abused as women, this is patently not true, however many posts you hijack with this nonsense

misssatan · 08/05/2022 18:37

QueenCamilla · 08/05/2022 15:15

"However (like in this case) when there's a man and a woman in the room and we're talking about who habitually beat up / raped whom, you'd be dim to not see the odds.

I have never been in any sustained way beaten, raped, bullied or tormented by someone weaker (and not solely in physical sense) than me. Have you?"

I generally don't like the phrase but it is very apt here: you really need to educate yourself. You need to learn about female abusers and male victims of female abuse. Both are common enough.

Often men feel unable to fight back because they don't think they will be believed, a realistic belief given the existence of people like you. Often they become demoralised and don't fight back or even come to believe they deserve violence. The difference in sizes doesn't necessarily determine who is the abused and who the abuser.

You should start with the Jordan Worth case. It might help correct your bias and enlighten your ignorance. He was close to death and saved by policeman who was intelligent enough to see something was wrong despite his denials and persistent enough to get him alone and get the truth from him. Her sentence was fairly lenient given the severity of her abuse, as is usually the case with women who get much shorter sentences than men for the same crimes.

QueenCamilla · 08/05/2022 15:15

@QueenCamilla is essentially saying white men will never be able to be a victim of anything.

A narrative that's widely accepted on MN

Errrmmm.. You are factually wrong of course. Also really not sure what the race has got to do with this!

However (like in this case) when there's a man and a woman in the room and we're talking about who habitually beat up / raped whom, you'd be dim to not see the odds.

I have never been in any sustained way beaten, raped, bullied or tormented by someone weaker (and not solely in physical sense) than me. Have you?

newnamethanks · 08/05/2022 13:25

what power does Depp have that Heard doesn't? that's not a serious question is it? If it is then I suggest you give yourself a very stern talking-to until you are able to see things more clearly. Asking such a question is embarassing. For you.

BeyondPurpleTulips · 08/05/2022 12:25

DressingPafe · 08/05/2022 11:28

I was a victim of DV and very severe emotional abuse. It turned me into someone I hated. I developed a drink problem. I ended up shouting and screaming at him. And yes I even hit him. I’ve never before acted like that with anyone else and I never will again. But he made me lose my mind. I genuinely look back and don’t recognise myself. Is someone only a victim if they sit there passively and take everything the abuser dishes out?

Had someone seen a snapshot of our relationship in the latter stages, they would also have said it was “toxic” (I don’t disagree with that). They would have also said we were as bad as each other. They wouldn’t have seen how he took a nice, kind woman and destroyed her to that point where she became someone else.

Is that what happened here? I don’t know. I don’t follow it and I don’t want to. But in general people need to understand that someone can still be a victim even if they don’t always behave well themselves.

Absolutely. I'm sorry you have endured a shite man too Flowers

DressingPafe · 08/05/2022 11:28

I was a victim of DV and very severe emotional abuse. It turned me into someone I hated. I developed a drink problem. I ended up shouting and screaming at him. And yes I even hit him. I’ve never before acted like that with anyone else and I never will again. But he made me lose my mind. I genuinely look back and don’t recognise myself. Is someone only a victim if they sit there passively and take everything the abuser dishes out?

Had someone seen a snapshot of our relationship in the latter stages, they would also have said it was “toxic” (I don’t disagree with that). They would have also said we were as bad as each other. They wouldn’t have seen how he took a nice, kind woman and destroyed her to that point where she became someone else.

Is that what happened here? I don’t know. I don’t follow it and I don’t want to. But in general people need to understand that someone can still be a victim even if they don’t always behave well themselves.

Agrudge · 08/05/2022 11:05

misssatan · 08/05/2022 09:05

QueenCamilla · 07/05/2022 18:15

"Well you asked me Why I think the way I do! Hence why.

One needs to have some sort of power to abuse it.

Does it exclude two psychos? Of course not. It, however, excludes Johnny for being an only poor victim in this and Amber being the witch. He had all the power to abuse and all the power to quit."

What on earth are you talking about? What power? Are you one of those people who analyse everything in terms of power (race, sex, class etc.) and neatly slots people into categories of victim and perpetrator based on that ludicrously inaccurate and oversimplistic way of looking at the word?

What power does Depp have which Heard doesn't?

@QueenCamilla is essentially saying white men will never be able to be a victim of anything.

A narrative that's widely accepted on MN

misssatan · 08/05/2022 09:05

QueenCamilla · 07/05/2022 18:15

"Well you asked me Why I think the way I do! Hence why.

One needs to have some sort of power to abuse it.

Does it exclude two psychos? Of course not. It, however, excludes Johnny for being an only poor victim in this and Amber being the witch. He had all the power to abuse and all the power to quit."

What on earth are you talking about? What power? Are you one of those people who analyse everything in terms of power (race, sex, class etc.) and neatly slots people into categories of victim and perpetrator based on that ludicrously inaccurate and oversimplistic way of looking at the word?

What power does Depp have which Heard doesn't?