Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there are two kinds of people when splitting the bill

166 replies

WoodenClock · 06/05/2022 11:50

And people seem to have friends that are either one if the other, never a mix?

I have a fairly wide circle and go out to eat/drink quite often with various different groups, from well off to really quite hard up. Without exception, any "argument" about money will be because someone wants to be over generous/buy an extra round/pay more than their share. As groups, a non drinker will never get stitched up for a share of the drinks bill and heavy drinkers recognise that and volunteer to pay extra, they never need to be asked.

But there are so many threads on here where people haven't paid their share or where there's awkwardness about asking them to do so. I don't meet those people.

Why is that?

OP posts:
BorderlineHappy · 06/05/2022 14:22

If I was out in a big group I wouldn't split the bill.

Me and a few friends ordering off the early bird ,we'd split it then.

rookiemere · 06/05/2022 14:17

Being a bit older, the moral of the story is never eat out in a big group, or with my BIL as he's a stingy git and eating out beings out all his anxieties and bad behaviour.

I've more or less given up eating out with some work mates since the one time a couple of the blokes ordered prawn starters, steaks and desserts.

It was tricky on holiday as we went away with friends but the DH is a teetotal vegan so naturally their part of the bill was smaller, but they insisted on paying half. I had to take my friend aside and say that I felt really uncomfortable paying the same amount and could we please pay extra for our steaks.

Thankfully I recently paid for an expensive hobby thing for the DH as my DH needed a partner to do it with, so I feel we're a bit more even now.

burnoutbabe · 06/05/2022 14:17

the issues always usually arise in big groups where people don't really know others well - less rarely in a group of 3-4 as you know what others ate and its also not much fuss to split things out between 4 easily. and you are generally close friends and either don't mind if you are "down" this month but up next time, or you can say you are broke, just having salad and its no drama.

Bigger group, no one is accountable, no one really knows who ordered what and bill too complicated to correctly split. Much more awkward - set meals are better for this type of event.

Classicblunder · 06/05/2022 14:16

see, there is an assumption that those that want to pay for what they ate are tight/anal/no fun etc

To me, it seems much more tight to ask for others to pay for part of what you had.

I don't know if this is just my social circle but I don't think it does even out - I don't think I have ever had my share of a bill been over the average because I am a relatively light drinking vegetarian. I don't mind chipping in a bit extra but sometimes an even split is me paying 3 or 4 times what my meal cost!

SirChenjins · 06/05/2022 14:12

I'm always surprised that people would actually end a friendship if someone in the group wanted to pay for what they'd eaten as opposed to splitting the bill. How shallow these friendships must be.

muppamup · 06/05/2022 14:12

Splitting bills depends on the context; in a big group where I wasn't drinking and there was an obvious massive difference then I wouldn't want to pay for others. If it were me and an old friend or two with a small bill splitting it is fine.

To assume some people are "tight" because they don't want to split is unfair. Everyone's circumstances are different. I am a single parent saving up for a deposit on a house. Unless I am super careful with cash, I will never get my own! It's basically a sink or swim situation. So while to you it might look like I'm being a bit tight it is for a good reason. No backhanders from parents, no future stability for me or my DC unless I am scrupulously careful with cash.

Before you judge others remember that their situation may be vastly different to yours and although they may look like they have cash in the bank the reality could be massively different.

burnoutbabe · 06/05/2022 14:09

see, there is an assumption that those that want to pay for what they ate are tight/anal/no fun etc

its not very nice at all to say that. people have different budgets and maybe can't afford to pay more than their one course and a coke? I can afford to just split now but don't feel inclined to split drinks if i have had 1 coke and other 5 cocktails. But don't care if its just a bit of difference on the food side.

At the start of any meal just pipe up, I'll just get my own bill, as on a budget and that is fine. Who would think badly of a friend that does that?

(and then suddently one generous person, IN FRONT OF X, says "oh we;ll all pay x's share, leaving no option to be able to say "i can't afford that" - pre agree that if you want to do it that way)

RedGazelle · 06/05/2022 14:07

Most of my friends are reasonable about it and we just split it unless there’s a massive discrepancy. So there’s one group I go out with about 3 times a year, out of the last three we’ve split it twice because everyone had roughly the same but the third time two out of the group chose dishes off a midweek bogof menu and one had something far more expensive than anything else plus wine so we each paid for our own. We don’t quibble about a pound or two but this was over £10 difference so it was fairer to pay for our own.

I used to dread it though when I was worse off and had carefully chosen cheaper options only to be met with everyone else declaring “oh let’s just split it!”.

The worst for me was when I had refused an invitation out for a friends birthday meal and been upfront about not being able to afford it and everyone pushed for me to go anyway, just come for a drink, you have to be there etc. I went towards the end of the meal as they were ordering puddings and ordered one lime and soda from the bar at a cost of £1.25 which I paid for at the bar rather than putting it on the tab. Three of my friends were sharing a bottle of wine and poured me a glass which I did accept after refusing at first. When the bill came everyone merrily agreed to split it and it was split between everyone including me. I told them I hadn’t eaten and they recalculated but then decided I’d had wine so split the full cost of the wine separately to include me. They’d had 6 bottles! I was happy to pay for the glass of wine I’d had but couldn’t afford to pay that and it was really humiliating having to insist that I paid less.

whereismybike · 06/05/2022 14:06

alltheteeshirts · 06/05/2022 12:31

Actually, I think there are three types of people.

  1. The type of people who want to only pay for exactly what they've consumed
  2. The type of people who prefer to just split the bill (on the assumption everyone's consumed a similar amount)
  3. CFers who always want to take advantage no matter which method is used

I think the people in 1) are usually on a tight budget, so a difference of a couple of quid can add up fast.

The people in 2) are financially comfortable, so are happy to potentially pay a couple of quid extra for the ease of being able to just pay the bill without someone whipping out a calculator.

The people in 3) are people I do not want to eat with. They're the ones who will have everyone else pay first, then use other people's tips to make up their share of exactly what they've consumed, or they'll suggest splitting the bill evenly when they know they've had much more expensive stuff than everyone else (typically the steak and wine brigade).

I agree with this. Like the OP, when I go out with friends the 'arguments' tend to be people wanting to make sure they don't underpay. Occasionally someone will just be staying for a drink, or on a tight budget, and they will say up-front that they want to pay separately.

However, when I've been out with people I don't know that well (work meals out etc) there always seems to be someone who takes the piss. One person I used to work with would always ask before he ordered whether we were splitting the bill or paying separately. If we were splitting it he would order 3 courses (even if other people were not having starters etc) including an expensive main. If we were paying separately he would just have an inexpensive main and badger everyone to agree to shared dishes as well, which he then ate most of but insisted the cost should be shared equally.

shrunkenhead · 06/05/2022 14:06

I once went out with a group of friends and one women got out her phone/calculator and added up EXACTLY what she'd had so knew what to pay for her share! If that was me I'd be mortified. If I can't afford a night out I just say! If, for example 5 of us go out and bill comes to £200 that's £40 each - simple. I don't hang around with CFs as a rule and we all enjoy a drink so it's always fair to split equally. I'm veggie (and on some occasions friends have insisted I pay less as I'm a cheap date) but I don't expect to pay less. I honestly think it leaves a horrible end to what was possibly a great night when people start quibbling over the bill. It's just not classy.

Glitterspy · 06/05/2022 14:03

Saying that back in the day we had a friend whose dad was super wealthy and obviously gave her a generous allowance, she and her husband grew up to be incredibly tight fisted, never buy a drink in a pub, always wait until someone offers to buy a round (my husband and I call him “mine’s a pint Joe”) and they are the sort of people that will pay to the penny (with coins on the table) for exactly what they ate, “accidentally” forgetting to pay for their drinks or contribute to the tip, and then leave early so they don’t have to pay extra for a late taxi. The way I see it, their behaviour is just so totally appallingly selfish. If they were skint I’d understand and actually would offer to pay for them, but these are wealthy people who just want to get away with it. We don’t see them any more.

FirewomanSam · 06/05/2022 14:03

I’m of the opinion that everyone should keep a very rough track of what they’ve had compared to everyone else. I don’t mean item for item, but you usually know if you’ve had cocktails while everyone else has water, or if you’re the only one who had dessert, or if you’ve had steak while everyone else is veggie.

Then when the bill comes, if I know I’m one of the big spenders I’ll always try to grab it first and say very clearly ‘we owe more than you so please don’t split it’. Sometimes people will really insist on splitting and that’s lovely but I’ll normally just try to figure out roughly how much extra we owe and then suggest that we pay, say, £20 more than our dining companions.

If I know I’ve had less than others (which is sometimes the case as I don’t drink) then I’m always grateful if someone does the above but I generally tend to say I’m fine to split it unless the difference is really, really big. Usually it’s only a few quid difference really, especially if I’ve had mocktails or a dessert in place of not drinking, and I figure it all comes out in the wash anyway.

If I’d been on water all night while everyone else was on champagne then I’d be quite miffed if someone asked me to split but that’s thankfully never happened, because my friends are considerate enough to realise that that wouldn’t be very cool!

Glitterspy · 06/05/2022 13:58

Oh god yes this is a proper friendship ender! With my friends (the ones I actually look forward to seeing), either one person picks up the whole bill and we take it in turns for next time, or we split the whole bill, tip included, evenly.

It makes me cringe and actually feel quite cross when people start asking for the menu back and drunkenly working out to the penny how much everyone should pay! One “friend” absolutely ruined another friend’s hen do dinner by doing this and then arguing about how much everyone needed to pay. In my opinion the bill should just be equally split and that’s that. I don’t care if you’ve drunk slightly less or didn’t choose to order a starter, I don’t care if you drank 3 bottles of wine to yourself and are chateaubriand, we will be splitting the bill evenly because we are friends and this is a NICE DINNER!!!

Bimster · 06/05/2022 13:57

We just split everything equally. If someone is not drinking or had fewer courses we might suggest they pay less but they always insist on paying the same as the rest. This is based on-

  • a 30 year friendship so it all comes out in the wash (maybe X is pregnant and not drinking today but Y was pregnant and not drinking last year and Z the year before that etc)
  • everyone's quite well off so no one is too worried about cash flow
  • no one is taking the piss.
I'd hate to be friends with someone who took the piss. I think I'd just find it so embarrassing to have to deal with someone wiggling their way out of paying their share.
storminabuttercup · 06/05/2022 13:49

PlacidPenelope · 06/05/2022 13:42

Now we go out and 9/10 they will say oh you pay and we will transfer later then ask my what they owe, never a huge difference, two kids, theirs is younger so eats from children menu. I've started giving them the bill and saying work it out when you get home as I can't be watching them sit and work it out on a calculator. They never tip either that's usually me.
Then I end up reminding them to transfer. They are higher earners than us, I'm not tight but I also don't like being taken for a mug.

I don't know why you still go out with them but next time you do just hand them the bill and say You pay and we'll transfer our share later (make sure you know exactly what your share is), or make life even easier and ask for separate bills when ordering and leave them to sort themselves out when it comes to paying.

You're right, I think separate bills is the way forward. We prob go out 4 times a year as a family group, it's much better when it's just me and my friend not her husband (he's the calculator weirdo)

Swingsandroundabouts123 · 06/05/2022 13:47

When we were recently graduated and just started earning money my group of friends and I would go for boozy Sunday roasts most weekends. We started to notice that one friend would always want to pay last when the bill came. We worked out that she was counting on us all being tipsy and over paying what we owed. Any extra should have gone towards a generous tip only she would swoop in at the end, discreetly pay whatever small amount was left to cover the food and drinks and we’d all be scrambling for change! We’re still friends. She must be feeling more financially secure as she’s far more generous these days.

LauraNicolaides · 06/05/2022 13:46

Quibbling, penny-counting diners who want the menu back at the end of the meal so that they can get their calculator out and work out their personal liability, including an apportionment for the fact that the bread was charged extra and they only had one of the seven pieces are fabulous humans. But I sure as hell don't eat out with them twice!

(And they tend to be the ones who think that rounding up their £22.85 share to £23 is more than enough tip.)

PlacidPenelope · 06/05/2022 13:42

Now we go out and 9/10 they will say oh you pay and we will transfer later then ask my what they owe, never a huge difference, two kids, theirs is younger so eats from children menu. I've started giving them the bill and saying work it out when you get home as I can't be watching them sit and work it out on a calculator. They never tip either that's usually me.
Then I end up reminding them to transfer. They are higher earners than us, I'm not tight but I also don't like being taken for a mug.

I don't know why you still go out with them but next time you do just hand them the bill and say You pay and we'll transfer our share later (make sure you know exactly what your share is), or make life even easier and ask for separate bills when ordering and leave them to sort themselves out when it comes to paying.

littlemisslozza · 06/05/2022 13:41

My worst friend for this is a vegetarian and her food is always a bit cheaper, however she's a really heavy wine drinker and forgets about the people driving who've not had any alcohol! She's known for being very tight and always argues about it because she's drunk too!

IsitFridayyet21 · 06/05/2022 13:38

alltheteeshirts · 06/05/2022 12:31

Actually, I think there are three types of people.

  1. The type of people who want to only pay for exactly what they've consumed
  2. The type of people who prefer to just split the bill (on the assumption everyone's consumed a similar amount)
  3. CFers who always want to take advantage no matter which method is used

I think the people in 1) are usually on a tight budget, so a difference of a couple of quid can add up fast.

The people in 2) are financially comfortable, so are happy to potentially pay a couple of quid extra for the ease of being able to just pay the bill without someone whipping out a calculator.

The people in 3) are people I do not want to eat with. They're the ones who will have everyone else pay first, then use other people's tips to make up their share of exactly what they've consumed, or they'll suggest splitting the bill evenly when they know they've had much more expensive stuff than everyone else (typically the steak and wine brigade).

Absolutely this. And I really hate the people who say "let's split" with no awareness that the people watching their pennies have not had all 3 courses and drinks BECAUSE they're watching their pennies.

So I'd say there's a group 4 too. The oblivious "let's split" who don't mean to be CF's but haven't paid attention. Probably because they have enough money not to.

burnoutbabe · 06/05/2022 13:36

If I am in a group where we normally split if k know I am eating much less expensive (Ie veggie versus steaks) I will also order a dessert to make up. Or another side.

If I am not drinking that is usually taken into account in any split. But now I often have low alcohol cocktails which are around same price so happy to split.

storminabuttercup · 06/05/2022 13:27

We have friends who have been to ours for many meals over the years, we stopped it as it was costing he every time and they never repaid the invite. Now we go out and 9/10 they will say oh you pay and we will transfer later then ask my what they owe, never a huge difference, two kids, theirs is younger so eats from children menu. I've started giving them the bill and saying work it out when you get home as I can't be watching them sit and work it out on a calculator. They never tip either that's usually me.
Then I end up reminding them to transfer. They are higher earners than us, I'm not tight but I also don't like being taken for a mug.

On the other hand we have friends we've gone out with with DS they have adult DCs and insist on just splitting the bill down the middle. Which is kind but makes me feel guilty. But then we'd be the same if things were reversed.

bumblingbovine49 · 06/05/2022 13:24

OfstedOffred · 06/05/2022 12:35

People who "just pay for what they had" are always the ones who forget the service, or dont realise the bread & olives were £5 a pop, and lo and behold there's a gap totting up the bill.

This. In my experience, people who add up from the menu what they ordered often forget these things so like this. Particularly when there is an order shared things such as sparkling water and bread etc. So what happens is everyone puts down the money for what they ordered and without fail, the total is never enough to cover the bill, let alone a tip/ service charge. Then the more 'generous natured or those better off invariably end up paying the difference. There are there are always a few who insist they have left money for what they had and/or have left early leaving 'not quite enough' to cover their share.

Generally though I tend not to go for meals where everyone pays only exactly for what they ordered because working that out accurately so that the bill is actually fully covered on a meal for more than 2-3 people is often much too much hassle

SockFluffInTheBath · 06/05/2022 13:19

alltheteeshirts · 06/05/2022 12:31

Actually, I think there are three types of people.

  1. The type of people who want to only pay for exactly what they've consumed
  2. The type of people who prefer to just split the bill (on the assumption everyone's consumed a similar amount)
  3. CFers who always want to take advantage no matter which method is used

I think the people in 1) are usually on a tight budget, so a difference of a couple of quid can add up fast.

The people in 2) are financially comfortable, so are happy to potentially pay a couple of quid extra for the ease of being able to just pay the bill without someone whipping out a calculator.

The people in 3) are people I do not want to eat with. They're the ones who will have everyone else pay first, then use other people's tips to make up their share of exactly what they've consumed, or they'll suggest splitting the bill evenly when they know they've had much more expensive stuff than everyone else (typically the steak and wine brigade).

Agree with this except my personal experience is the 1s are affluent and just like to embarrass themselves.

Crankley · 06/05/2022 13:17

If people have had similar food/drink, I prefer to split the bill. I hate adding up what everyone owes individually. It's obviously different if one had fillet steak and a couple of bottles of wine and the other had an omelette and a glass of wine.

I can't stand mean people. An EX-friend of mine insisted on adding her items individually when we were in a teashop because mine cane to 24p more than hers.