Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there are two kinds of people when splitting the bill

166 replies

WoodenClock · 06/05/2022 11:50

And people seem to have friends that are either one if the other, never a mix?

I have a fairly wide circle and go out to eat/drink quite often with various different groups, from well off to really quite hard up. Without exception, any "argument" about money will be because someone wants to be over generous/buy an extra round/pay more than their share. As groups, a non drinker will never get stitched up for a share of the drinks bill and heavy drinkers recognise that and volunteer to pay extra, they never need to be asked.

But there are so many threads on here where people haven't paid their share or where there's awkwardness about asking them to do so. I don't meet those people.

Why is that?

OP posts:
Housetreecar · 06/05/2022 16:26

the only time people pay their own share is with work. Any other time without exception we split equally

Alwayspaintyournails · 06/05/2022 16:26

The groups I socialise with tend to split the bill evenly but always note if someone is not drinking and reduce their share (unless it’s cheeky tee total friend who said ‘I don’t drink’ but had a Mocktail on every round that cost more than a beer or a plain g&t etc) 🙄

burnoutbabe · 06/05/2022 16:25

also the sort of person who says "olves for the table" generally means - I WANT OLIVES AND I WILL EAT MOST. And generally they are not asking for approval for the purchase (i mean who would say NO), just telling everyone they are ordering them on everyone's behalf. if you want them, you pay.

My boss does this. but then he pays for it all :D

Norush4 · 06/05/2022 16:25

OfstedOffred · 06/05/2022 12:35

People who "just pay for what they had" are always the ones who forget the service, or dont realise the bread & olives were £5 a pop, and lo and behold there's a gap totting up the bill.

Good point. Do you mean friend or aquitances OP?

There's also those people that pretend to get the bill or deliberately stall knowing someone else will pay. It boils down to personality and morals because I would always pay my way and I'm happy to go half's on the bill with my friend. I think going through the bill looks a but tight and picking out what you have had unless there's considerable difference.

Perhaps your assertive or tight yourself OP so you won't get the short straw!

Oblomov22 · 06/05/2022 16:22

Never experienced a problem. Ever. Those that drink a lot are made to pay, those that drink little less. Only on MN is this a problem, not in RL.

linerforlife · 06/05/2022 16:19

@rookiemere one person other than me brought a card and gift. I don't usually go out with her group of friends so I don't know if they always go out. Birthday meals have been a bit limited in the last 2 years though... but pre covid when I've been out with people we've always covered the birthday girl!

linerforlife · 06/05/2022 16:17

@burnoutbabe trust me I realise my asking made it awkward - but I've genuinely never been out for someone's birthday and not split the cost of their meal between everyone. 3 courses for £40 is a pretty cheap night out (that included wine for some who weren't drinking), and I was shocked people wouldn't put less than a £5 in for her meal and the tip.

montysma1 · 06/05/2022 16:16

No they aren't always the ones who forget the olives🙄.
But of a generalisation there.

Why on earth should I pay for what other people eat? I choose what I want to eat and what I can afford to eat and that's what I pay for. I also dont drink so why should I pay for table wine?

I would however pay my share for "olives" (if I had any) and my portion of the service charge.

WinterDeWinter · 06/05/2022 16:14

I also could never ever be attracted to a man who was mean in company. It's excruciating and repulsive. I quite admire general male thriftiness in other circumstances though - my ideal combo is thrifty/not many wants, but doesn't mind spending good money on 'quality' 😀and believes I generally deserve a treat.

WinterDeWinter · 06/05/2022 16:10

I think if you're well-off and either always have been well-off, or are a bit thoughtless generally, you might not consider that others are strapped - not because you're a bad person, exactly, but.. maybe a bit entitled/self-involved/lacking imagination/delete as appropriate.

There are quite a number of people who fall into this group I think - they might offer to pay for it all, or a good share of it, if they're feeling generous/wanting to play mein host/need the validation, but on another day they might just as easily order from the middle-top of the wine list and completely miss the panic on others' faces.

If you're well-off and thoughtful (or anxious, maybe), you will already have done the thinking as part of your general scanning/empathy/anxiety about doing the wrong thing.

If you're poor and either anxious or proud, you'll put in more than your fair share and not eat for the next week for fear of being judged tight or worse, a CF.

in the past I've often paid for things I can't afford, either because I am pathologically afraid of being judged tight or exploitative, or because I know that other people are also struggling (weird). But I also hate the feeling of being taken advantage of and get all indignant and churned up if I think that's happened. I also sometimes drink too much and only afterwards realise that I've really had more than my fair share. Nightmare combo 😀I have got much better at being honest about my circumstances though so it's all less fraught these days, on the few occasions that I go out ...

Inyourhonor · 06/05/2022 16:07

ZealAndArdour · 06/05/2022 16:06

Did you split the bill equally though?

Quick thinking there 😂

NashvilleQueen · 06/05/2022 16:07

We are all over payers. It's exhausting. We always end up with about fifty quid over and then have to give it back to people.

rookiemere · 06/05/2022 16:06

@linerforlife - do you go out for every friends birthday? Had she had any gifts from the attendees?

I think it's much fairer to buy gifts and split the bill amongst all attendees unless it's a regular occurrence for everyone's birthday.

Plus as the person who sometimes has do do the Maths on the bill ( another reason why I'm glad when Accountant friend comes out) it's a pain in the rear end and there's always someone complaining about something. Worst was when I'd carefully split into wine drinkers share versus soft drink drinkers and then in a drunken haze I spotted the lady at the end who'd only had coffee and a cake not a meal. Of course she'd not said anything- nor had anyone else - so I had to recalculate, which is hard when drunk.

ZealAndArdour · 06/05/2022 16:06

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Did you split the bill equally though?

Nh1203 · 06/05/2022 16:05

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

burnoutbabe · 06/05/2022 16:05

linerforlife · 06/05/2022 15:57

I went out for a friends birthday meal recently. Everyone who attended was fairly well off - like enough that they don't need to worry where every fiver is going. When it came to paying the bill we split it equally, and I asked "I'm presuming that includes covering the birthday girl"? And the person who had divided the bill said no, and everyone else looked really awkward and mumbled about paying for themselves. It would have been an extra fiver on a cheap meal out (under £40 each for 3 courses). I couldn't get my head around her having to pay for her own meal!!!

well you made it awkward?

its fair enough if its ALWAYS the same group going out and birthday person never pays. But often its different groups and it doesn't even up. And going out for someone's birthday in my circles is more "its time for us to go out - x's birthday soon so good excuse to meet up". Some birthdays celebrated with a dinner and others not.

Chanel05 · 06/05/2022 16:02

I am a pay for what you had kind of person. I don't drink and don't see why I should cover the cost of alcohol for others.

At a pre wedding meal (I got married abroad) there were 8 of us ladies and only 2 drinking. The 2 drinkers ordered a huge, expensive bottle of champagne and then at the end were the first ones to suggest "splitting the bill". Uh no.

ParisNoir · 06/05/2022 15:59

PleasantBirthday · 06/05/2022 15:51

It would be, yes. I can't say though I've ever seen a situation where anyone has gone so far beyond what everyone else is having. I can't remember a meal where someone has had a starter or dessert, for example, if most people aren't having it, or who are drinking champagne while everyone else is having tap water. I think that's quite unusual behaviour.

I have seen this before. When I was a student and lots of my friends had quite well paid jobs in the city. I dont think they meant to be mean, its just that some people who are well paid tend to forget that others arent and especially if youve been drinking a lot of alcohol during a meal it just slips your mind and seems easier to work out. I'm not excusing it as it IS selfish but I think it tends to happen more when you've got large groups of people out for a meal and lots of drinks flowing.

WhoppingBigBackside · 06/05/2022 15:57

I find that there are three types.

There's the well-paid one who orders more food and drink and more expensive items than anyone else and wants the bill to be divided equally

There's the one who doesn't drink and eat like a sparrow and is on a limited budget and doesn't want to pay 5 times the value of what he or she had

There's the comfortably off ones who order sensibly and will be happy to split equally but throw in an extra note or two to even out the disparity between meal/drinks values and for a tip

linerforlife · 06/05/2022 15:57

I went out for a friends birthday meal recently. Everyone who attended was fairly well off - like enough that they don't need to worry where every fiver is going. When it came to paying the bill we split it equally, and I asked "I'm presuming that includes covering the birthday girl"? And the person who had divided the bill said no, and everyone else looked really awkward and mumbled about paying for themselves. It would have been an extra fiver on a cheap meal out (under £40 each for 3 courses). I couldn't get my head around her having to pay for her own meal!!!

DentonsFringeArnottsWaistcoat · 06/05/2022 15:56

OP, had exactly this experience yesterday lunch time - were you out with me? 😂 At one point I thought we were actually going to end up paying the restaurant more then we actually owed them 😂

PleasantBirthday · 06/05/2022 15:53

but by us asking for a split, we are often doing on behalf of those who won't (like the juniors at a work night out)

I'm thinking strictly friendship groups, the bill shouldn't be split evenly among work groups for any reason.

rookiemere · 06/05/2022 15:53

@burnoutbabe - my friend is an accountant. I love going on holiday with her as - before splitwise- she'd maintain a spreadsheet of checks and balances. For some reason my head doesn't work at all with that sort of thing so really helpful to have her keeping us all right !

PleasantBirthday · 06/05/2022 15:51

SirChenjins · 06/05/2022 15:44

I think it's just the sense that someone wouldn't go a penny beyond the technical, absolute total of what they ate and drank. I mean, if it's a significant difference, obviously, but if it's the case that someone is saying, "mine is 28.80, here's 2.88 as a 10% tip", it feels a bit pinchy

How often does that actually happen though? The vast majority would just say 'here's £3 for the tip. Otoh, it's really* pinchy to say 'I know I had £50 worth of food and drink but I'm only putting in £30 because that's the amount owed when the bill is shared equally'. So grubby.

It would be, yes. I can't say though I've ever seen a situation where anyone has gone so far beyond what everyone else is having. I can't remember a meal where someone has had a starter or dessert, for example, if most people aren't having it, or who are drinking champagne while everyone else is having tap water. I think that's quite unusual behaviour.

ZealAndArdour · 06/05/2022 15:50

I think I am both people in different groups of friends. If it’s a small group and we’ve very close I’m more than happy busy to split it evenly between us, even if I’ve not had as much as everyone else. But if it’s a larger group and I’m not that close or we’ll acquainted with them then I might put my head above the parapet and pay only for what I’ve had, especially so if I’ve had much less than everyone else.

If I’m out with just one friend or family member, then I’m more likely to just pay the whole bill, or halve it, if they insist, than I am to quibble over individual orders/costs.