Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to dread telling my DD no

208 replies

Funkyslippers · 06/05/2022 11:45

DD (13) has got it in her head that she'd like to be homeschooled. She says she hates getting up early for school, being around people she doesn't like (most of the other pupils!), wasting time in lessons and not really learning anything (hard for me to comment on that as we haven't even had a parents' evening yet this year). After much persuasion on her part, I said I couldn't make a decision until I'd done some research. Well now I have and I've decided it won't work for her, for many reasons, mainly because she'd be on her own all day and is not particularly motivated and really quite lazy and there'd be noone to support her learning or check any gaps. Also she would have very little social interaction. I've already made these points to her but she had an answer for both but I've still made up my mind.

But she's set her heart on this and is absolutely convinced it's the right thing for her. I'm dreading going home later as she will start on at me again and I know once I've said no she will be heartbroken and angry. I hate to think of her unhappy at school but I'm not really sure she is, well no more than the average kid. I know school can be a bit of a chore but we all have to go through it and come out the other side.

I know I need to grow some but I just don't know how to handle this sensitively but getting my point across without an argument.

OP posts:
Copperpottle · 06/05/2022 12:46

Funkyslippers · 06/05/2022 12:09

Well it would be possible technically, if I was to get all the resources ready for her say on a weekly basis, then check what she's done when I get home, and it doesn't have to be 9-3 5 days a week, so she could do a couple of hours when i get home or at the weekend, but that would still leave several hours of the day when she's on her own unsupervised, and she says she would learn Spanish, do PE, go to the library etc but I know her and if there's an option to laze around she's likely to take it!

I have done alot of research on it and it really won't work for her - or me

That's not home schooling. That's leaving your kid at home all day with a book. Literally no one 'homeschools' that way. That's just neglect.

Honestly the weird thing here is not the kid talking bollocks, as kids do, it's you thinking that your daughter deserves nothing better than being stuck at home alone with a textbook and a Bitesize worksheet.

You need to mature fast or she'll be running rings around you.

Undecidedandtorn · 06/05/2022 12:45

I think the only way this would work would be paying for an online school and if she was very motivated- neither of which seem viable/true.

Quartz2208 · 06/05/2022 12:43

Yes homeschooling isnt lockdown learning - it would need to be properly structured and working towards exam.

She sounds disengaged though from school - has she made friends?

Copperpottle · 06/05/2022 12:42

She's being ridiculous, as are you for entertaining the idea. Unless you're going to give up your life tutor her, she just wants to sit at home all day. That's dropping out, she isn't going to suddenly become academic, and you risk trouble with the authorities when they realise she's not being educated at all.

Get her off bloody YouTube. She clearly isn't mature enough to discern realistic situations from utter guff.

And you need to get tougher. You're not her friend. When she demands utter nonsense, you say no, you don't convince her she's got a chance.

Bibbetybobbity · 06/05/2022 12:42

I agree with @Clymene and I can’t understand PP’s suggesting that your dd could demonstrate how it would work etc. some things with teens are a discussion and a negotiation, this isn’t and it’s much kinder to be clear with her and stick to that.

Summerholidayorcovidagain · 06/05/2022 12:42

Suggests giving up your job would enable you to home school her. Is she prepared to accept the financial repercussions of that? No Sky /no car /no lifts /no allowance /no holidays.

Mariposista · 06/05/2022 12:41

ImNotBeingFunnyBut123 · 06/05/2022 11:59

Tough. When she enters the working world she'll probably have to do things she doesn't want and deal with people she doesn't like. Life's a bitch. Sooner she accepts it the better.

Couldn't have put it better myself

amicissimma · 06/05/2022 12:37

I think I'd expect her to demonstrate that she can learn well in any circumstances, including a school setting, and can find a way to get a long with a variety of people, before I'd even slightly consider a change in her educational arrangements.

I'd have no reason to suppose she would learn well when mostly alone and learn to get along with all sorts when largely avoiding them, unless she demonstrated excellent progress at school, although she considers it sub-optimal, for several years.

savoycabbage · 06/05/2022 12:37

There is absolute no way she can teach herself the core GCSE subjects from resources you 'get ready for her'. 🤯

Fairislefandango · 06/05/2022 12:31

Your mistake was letting her think it was viable at all.

^This.
Also, while I'm very much in favour of picking your battles as a parent, dreading saying no to your child is not a good sign. You need to be able to calmly and confidently give a hard no when you need to, without fearing your child's reaction.

OneCup · 06/05/2022 12:23

So you would be printed out a few worksheets for her to do during day time? This is not homeschooling! She needs someone to properly facilitate her learning: someone available and knowledgeable. It's a recipe for trouble!
The fact that she thinks she can teach herself Spanish also made me smile.

MrsSkylerWhite · 06/05/2022 12:23

Sounds like a disaster waiting to happen.

a firm no. She’ll get over it.

Zippy1510 · 06/05/2022 12:21

Leaving her at home by herself throughout the day then checking in isn’t homeschooling. You would need to be there, all day to act as her teacher.

Pieceofpurplesky · 06/05/2022 12:21

You are not planning on a home learning structure though. You are basically planning a drop out of school plan. Don't let her have her way.

Clymene · 06/05/2022 12:19

Your mistake was letting her think it was viable at all. You work so it's not possible. End of discussion.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 06/05/2022 12:17

Tell her
Homeschooling is not the same as self learning. She is too young to self learn and you won't be able to teach her

Lockdown showed she was not engaged with the process anyway

TeeBee · 06/05/2022 12:17

My youngest DS was the same (and is also pretty lazy if allowed to be). It was always a flat no from me. It wouldn't be good for him, he's very close with his school friends and I don't have time, money or motivation to sacrifice my own career to home school someone. I'd go round the bend. He's still not keen on going in because people tire him out. Tough shit, we all have to deal with people, whether we like it or not. I stated my reasons and explained that was my final decision and wouldn't be discussing it again. He decided to stay on at Sixth form and we're currently looking at uni open days, so it couldn't have been too damaging.

I know two children who were home schooled and left to their own devices (with online tutors). Both spent most the days playing PlayStation and both came out with one GCSE each.

AlternativePerspective · 06/05/2022 12:16

And I disagree with those saying she should put a case forward. That way she is going to believe there’s a chance, when there isn’t.

And it’s not home schooling if there’s no-one at home, it’s taking the piss.

MargaretThursday · 06/05/2022 12:16

I think leaving her on her own all day and calling it homeschooling would go down very badly if that was discovered.

I was talking a couple of days ago with dh, and we commented that all the dc would have loved homeschooling, and for all it would have been a bad decision for them in the long term.
DD1 probably wouldn't have been too bad academically, but socially would have been unhelpful.
The other two would never have done any work in subjects they didn't like, and only lackadaisical work in the ones they liked.
They'd have built fantastic Minecraft worlds and had great ambitions to do some proper work... tomorrow though.

But also: We're two well educated parents in different subject and a reasonable knowledge of between us of a good amount of other subjects. We still wouldn't feel up to teaching to GCSE level in the majority of subjects because teaching is more than just knowing the subject.
Yes, you can get tutors in. But they will be expensive (£40 an hour type range) and I'll bet that neither my younger pair would have enjoyed that any more than school!

DisappearingGirl · 06/05/2022 12:13

I absolutely agree with you OP! If there's no-one at home to teach her, she wouldn't be home schooling, she'd just be sat on her arse or wandering round town.

Lockdown taught me that there's no way I could homeschool my own kids, even if I wasn't also working. They are normally good kids and fairly bright. But the amount of shouting and howling when I asked them to write a paragraph. The amount of grumbling and procrastinating if I suggested a nature walk. No way. At school they just get on with it.

I would just tell her. Yes she will be cross, but tough. Teens get cross about a lot of things they can't have. When she argues I would just keep repeating the same reasons, broken record style. To be honest I wouldn't get into how it could work (as a poster suggested) because I think you are correct that it would absolutely not work!!

Funkyslippers · 06/05/2022 12:12

RJnomore1 1st lockdown - a few tasks sent home by the primary school but as it wasn't compulsory, she either did the bare minimum or nothing. I was working from home and tearing my hair out trying to keep her occupied and off her phone. 2nd lockdown, yr 7 - she attended live lessons and completed homework but again, it was few and far between and she completed it as quickly as possible then went back to lazing around (as much as I would let her)

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 06/05/2022 12:10

If she’s into YouTube/Instagram then would missing out things like prom make her think.

AlternativePerspective · 06/05/2022 12:10

It would be a hard no from me. Not negotiable.

Sometimes we have to do things we don’t want, and for her this includes going to school. Such is life.

Funkyslippers · 06/05/2022 12:09

Well it would be possible technically, if I was to get all the resources ready for her say on a weekly basis, then check what she's done when I get home, and it doesn't have to be 9-3 5 days a week, so she could do a couple of hours when i get home or at the weekend, but that would still leave several hours of the day when she's on her own unsupervised, and she says she would learn Spanish, do PE, go to the library etc but I know her and if there's an option to laze around she's likely to take it!

I have done alot of research on it and it really won't work for her - or me

OP posts:
Perfumelover18 · 06/05/2022 12:07

Unfortunately, at 13, she is not mature enough to make this decision, it's for parents to decide.

Homeschooling can work but the dynamics need to be right, with an adult on hand to supervise the process, even if tutors are used.

You could point out to her that tutoring is expensive, and she would still need to work hard to pass her exams.

If you are working then there won't be anyone to supervise her studies. It really isn't feasible. She needs to go to school.

As for how you can tell her, just gently ask her how she thinks homeschooling could work. She might be able to see the problems for herself.