Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to dread telling my DD no

208 replies

Funkyslippers · 06/05/2022 11:45

DD (13) has got it in her head that she'd like to be homeschooled. She says she hates getting up early for school, being around people she doesn't like (most of the other pupils!), wasting time in lessons and not really learning anything (hard for me to comment on that as we haven't even had a parents' evening yet this year). After much persuasion on her part, I said I couldn't make a decision until I'd done some research. Well now I have and I've decided it won't work for her, for many reasons, mainly because she'd be on her own all day and is not particularly motivated and really quite lazy and there'd be noone to support her learning or check any gaps. Also she would have very little social interaction. I've already made these points to her but she had an answer for both but I've still made up my mind.

But she's set her heart on this and is absolutely convinced it's the right thing for her. I'm dreading going home later as she will start on at me again and I know once I've said no she will be heartbroken and angry. I hate to think of her unhappy at school but I'm not really sure she is, well no more than the average kid. I know school can be a bit of a chore but we all have to go through it and come out the other side.

I know I need to grow some but I just don't know how to handle this sensitively but getting my point across without an argument.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Clymene · 08/05/2022 14:09

Yay! Smile

She might have secretly been slightly relieved. It would be really lonely to be home so on her own for that long.

3luckystars · 08/05/2022 14:00

Good!

Funkyslippers · 08/05/2022 13:45

Clymene typical. I worried about it all day at work then she barely mentioned it when I got home. She did throw it into conversation eg. "When I'm homeschooled...." so I took the opportunity to say" I'm sorry honey but I've had a think and it just won't work for us". She then screwed her face up and looked like she was trying to force some tears out! She then made a recording on her phone for me and OH to listen to and she called it Homeschooling Frequently Asked Questions!!!! I had a listen (fair play to her, she'd pretty much covered all bases!!!) but still told her it wouldn't work and I'm not changing my mind. That was Fri night and she hadn't mentioned it since. I think the reason I'm feeling more confident about it is because I am 100% sure that we are not doing it and I will not change my mind. I have all you lovely Mnetters to thank for giving me confidence in my decision. Thank you!!!!

OP posts:
Blondeshavemorefun · 08/05/2022 09:42

Home schooling needs an adult to do the schooling! It isn't just being left at home alone.

THIS. you work. Snr be at home. Tell her no.

Luculentus · 08/05/2022 09:31

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

No, I am not wrong. Read the statute. The case you refer to (R (Goodred) ve Portsmouth City Council and the Secretary of State for Education) reinforces that, and so far as I am aware the decision hasn't been appealed. The findings of the court are very clear. How on earth can campaign group information outweigh that?

I didn't suggest that there is a compulsory register, and I don't doubt that it can be difficult for local authorities to find every child who is being home educated. I equally don't doubt that different areas have different approaches, not least because some LAs have chosen to save money that way. None of that changes the clear terms of the law.

Clymene · 08/05/2022 09:26

How did the conversation with your daughter go @Funkyslippers?

Mischance · 08/05/2022 09:22

Catcrisis · 08/05/2022 03:05

Seeing as you can't spell 'a lot' correctly it's probably best you're not her teacher 🤓

Now don't get me started on the number of misspelt comments etc I received from my DDs' teachers - and even wrong corrections when the child was right!

Funkyslippers · 08/05/2022 09:06

Catcrisis well now that you've corrected me and I know how to spell it, I feel totally qualified to teach any age, any subject as that was obviously all that was needed

OP posts:
Catcrisis · 08/05/2022 03:05

Seeing as you can't spell 'a lot' correctly it's probably best you're not her teacher 🤓

UndertheCedartree · 07/05/2022 22:37

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Yes, I have. I was responding to the comment that 18% of people think it is fine to just leave a 13 year old at home 5 days a week. But my point was they are responding to the idea of home education rather that 'leaving your child at home'. After all that was what OP suggested - home education. Yes, we have lots of resources and my DC gets himself there himself. People that don't home educate would have no idea, though.

lameasahorse · 07/05/2022 22:32

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

lameasahorse · 07/05/2022 22:28

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Luculentus · 07/05/2022 22:03

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

I know "otherwise" means home education (amongst other possibilities such as PRUs and hospital schools). The significant word is "suitable". Local authorities have a duty to check that all children are registered in schools or are receiving suitable education by other means,

It may well be that your council isn't complying with its duties as regards home schooled children. That doesn't mean, as you claimed, that I was incorrect in saying that they have that duty.

UndertheCedartree · 07/05/2022 21:15

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

But 13 yo home ed kids do not stay at home 5 days a week. My son was going to classes 2 days a week at that age, then had another day he was out at groups etc. He was only with me 2 days a week if that.

Mischance · 07/05/2022 20:55

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Yes I hear what you are saying - I was just trying to illustrate that the stuff we learn at school is not always stuff we will use - I know that education is more than that, but for lots of children, especially those who struggle with learning, having to swallow lots of facts or processes that they will never use is a bit of a put-off, and can leave them feeling worthless and bottom of the heap, Under our current system it is hard to be flexible as the curriculum is so rigid.

I am the SEND governor at a primary school and am very conscious that teachers have to "bend the rules" of the curriculum in order to make some of the learning appropriate to the child - I do not think they should be in that uncomfortable position. Their professional skills should be valued. And as for the whole SATS thing - don't get me started on that!!

I absolutely agree that it is important that parents and children make the decision about home education based on the right facts, including being clear about what state education has to offer that is positive. This is why I am suggesting that the OP gets up to the school and examines what is really going wrong for her DD. At the very least it puts her and DD on the same "side" and helps the DD to feel she is being taken seriously.

It may of course be that her DD is looking for a way to be bone idle!! - but I am sure OP can disabuse her of that idea by presenting her with a sample learning schedule from a home education website!

lameasahorse · 07/05/2022 20:37

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 07/05/2022 20:06

I wouldn't have done even a cursory bit of research. I don't want to do it, my child is not struggling at school, and quite frankly, I already have a full time job and don't want another one.

I would tell her that you've looked into it, it's not feasible and you will not discuss it again, it's not going to happen. I would point out to her that you can't even rely on her to complete <insert menial task that she regularly doesn't do> so you think she has neither the drive nor the maturity to work all day on her own waiting for you to come home. I'd also point out that there is a huge social aspect to school she'd miss out on, and that it's all very lovely for the Fizz Family to be going out to farms and theatres and whatever else they do, but they clearly have a vastly different set up.

I'd probably try and soften the message Wink but like fuck would I be pandering to her!

Mischance · 07/05/2022 19:56

The option to laze if there is no motivation will increase the further she advances into the teenage years. But lazing around is not always a bad thing - it is part of what teenagers do. I can remember doing it at every opportunity!

I am a great believer in home education because I am very aware that the school system is micro-managed by central government to its detriment; and that school simply does not suit some young people and they never really settle. A lot of what they learn represents a throw back to the public school system that spawned our current rulers, and is pretty irrelevant. I left school knowing how translate Latin text, but having not the faintest clue how to change a plug.

I am not of the opinion that it is just something children have to grit their teeth and get on with - how very soul-destroying - and what a waste of youth and childhood, which they will never get back again.

But home education only works if the parent/s are 100% committed to it, are at home a large amount of the time and care deeply about the philosophy behind it. They also need to have masses of time to research, to make contacts with other home educators and be there to set the structure of the day and to monitor this.

I would ask her to list in a systematic way all the things that she dislikes so much about school. She needs to know that you are taking that seriously - because it is serious that she is spending the majority of her life unhappy. Discuss what might be changed to help her settle. Say that you are willing to go and talk with the school about every point - no need to wait for the parents' evening - she needs to know that you are prepared to be proactive on her behalf.

And are there other schools nearby with different philosophies? - Steiner? Montessori?

I do not think that you can possibly home educate and be out at work - the two do not go together, especially if self-motivation is not her skill. She needs to know that the family she saw will have had one parent at home to organise the education day.

But she does need tangible evidence that you are on her side; that you get it; that you care about this. You can't do home education in your circumstances but you might be able to help her feel that you want to find some other way of sorting this.

Blooming Youtube!!

lameasahorse · 07/05/2022 19:37

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Luculentus · 07/05/2022 19:25

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Section 436A Education Act 1996:

(1) A local authority must make arrangements to enable them to establish (so far as it is possible to do so) the identities of children in their area who are of compulsory school age but—

(a) are not registered pupils at a school, and

(b) are not receiving suitable education otherwise than at a school.

(2) In exercising their functions under this section a local authority must have regard to any guidance given from time to time by the Secretary of State.

(3) In this Chapter, “suitable education”, in relation to a child, means efficient full-time education suitable to his age, ability and aptitude and to any special educational needs he may have

Section 437:

If it appears to a local authority that a child of compulsory school age in their area is not receiving suitable education, either by regular attendance at school or otherwise, they shall serve a notice in writing on the parent requiring him to satisfy them within the period specified in the notice that the child is receiving such education.

... and then there's lots more about enforcing those orders. And the guidance referred to puts quite a lot more flesh on the bones.

safclass · 07/05/2022 19:16

Gonna admit I've not looked into it, but I think if you are home schooling then you would be expected to be there and teaching her, not just leaving work to be completed.
That would be the arguement I'd use as well! If you work how can you home school?

Knifer · 07/05/2022 18:32

I homeschooled my 11YO DD for a year and it was a nightmare. She was so so lazy, refusing to do the work, it was a constant battle, I was in tears every night, we never got a break from one another, I couldn't find enough social opportunities for her. It was a horrible time and I do not look back fondly on it.

Don't do it

aSofaNearYou · 07/05/2022 18:14

She is just being idealistic because she doesn't want to go to school, and yes she just needs to suck it up.

Given how she was during lockdown, where she was essentially being homeschooled, I think you made a mistake not just saying no straight away and reminding her that she did not engage with you homeschooling her then. But if she kicks off I think it's important you remind her of this now.

lameasahorse · 07/05/2022 18:02

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

lameasahorse · 07/05/2022 18:01

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn