Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Excess buying from grandparents

43 replies

excessmess · 06/05/2022 10:03

I know this will be polarising, and it is not intended to be in-law bashing, I'm just trying to establish a way to manage this.

My in-laws love our DC dearly, they are their only grandkids. They are very generous towards them, and this is where we are struggling slightly. Every time we see them they buy the DC gifts, every Christmas, birthday and easter they shower them with lots of presents and in-between time they sometimes just send gifts in the post too.

I feel absolutely unreasonable and ungrateful BUT we have found this difficult. Firstly, it's just wasteful (it's stuff they don't need / often duplicates of things), secondly, I don't think it sends a great message to the kids to spoil them to this degree and thirdly, we live in a small home which doesn't have much space. For every thing they buy the kids I have to get rid of something else. The kids are at that age where they get attached to everything, so this process of constantly rotating stuff in and out of the house isn't easy and we come out as the bad guys. I also find it means we have to pare down what we buy for the children ourselves because we know the tidal wave which will come from them. This is fine, but sometimes I would love to be able to treat my own kids.

We have spoken to them about it several times (trying not to be ungrateful but asking them to reign it in for all of the reasons given above). We have suggested gifts stay at their house (doesn't work as they just forget and leave it to us to tear the things out of the kids hands as we leave which makes us the bad guy, so we gave up). We suggested that they buy other gifts for christmas / birthdays (e.g. a trip out) which doesn't work as they just by this as well as other gifts. We have explained the reasons and tried to express gratitude but it doesn't work, the stuff stops for one visit and then resumes again.

I recognise that we have a difference in values and it's a grandparents prerogative to spoil the grandkids. I'm just finding it hard because their values are intruding on our home if that makes sense. So AIBU and how can I deal with it?!

OP posts:
Pandoracharm · 06/05/2022 11:37

I can be a bit like this with my grandchildren! I have got better & now will give/send clothes instead of toys. Maybe ask for them to send vouchers for days out instead? I know when my kids were younger I couldn't afford to buy them treats, out of birthdays/ Christmas, as always on a tight budget. So is nice to be able to do it now.

ancientgran · 06/05/2022 11:33

My husband threatened to buy his mother an elephant (a real one) if all the stuff she was buying didn't stop. I'm not sure if it would work with everyone but I think it worried her a bit and she did stop.

He is probably a bit unusual as I wouldn't put it past him.

Dixiechickonhols · 06/05/2022 11:28

If you have a garden would outdoor equipment or toys be an idea - playhouse, bike etc.

Dixiechickonhols · 06/05/2022 11:23

I was going to suggest them paying for outings but see you’ve tried that. Would something expensive like a zoo pass maybe mean they don’t buy as much stuff. Show tickets they could enjoy with the children. Pay for a hobby and kit to go with it? Clothes/uniform/shoes.
All you can do is explain politely. It’s lovely you want to buy them things but house bursting at seams.
Savings for Uni is sensible - I bet they have no idea they won’t be able to borrow enough.

AuntieJoyce · 06/05/2022 11:15

If you are prepared to shift your mindset mentally so that it doesn’t matter who buys things for the children, you just then need to provide GPs with a list of things that the children need or want and you save your money.
So for her birthday DCs maybe get one nice present from you and then the rest of the parents are paid for by the GPs. The children won’t care who buys if they still get what they want

Curiosity101 · 06/05/2022 11:12

Could you buy a large toy box to keep at their house? Explain to the kids that this is so some of their toys can live at their grandparents house. Then they always have to tidy up and put their toys away at the end of a visit (including any new ones). It also might make it easier to shuffle stuff to your in-laws house as you can 'Take some toys to play with' but then tidy then away into the PILs toy box before leaving for home.

I do think finding a route for most of the toys etc to end up back at your in-laws is probably best. It's just a case of finding a way that they kids are happy to help/know it will happen. And tbh if your in-laws don't want the stuff back then I'd be tempted to let it fall on deaf ears, just as they have with buying it in the first place.

hoomaeyy · 06/05/2022 11:11

My MIL is the same.
She buys soooo much for my 2 girls.

Birthdays she must spend about £100 each and I would say about £200 + each at Xmas. Turns up with 2 Xmas sacks each and more.
Most visits she has something. Clothes/sweets etc.

It used to really annoy me but I gave up and just accepted it as it wasn't worth me feeling pissed off all the time.

In terms of toys etc, one of her friends sent a load of second hand toys over and I just said could we tell them we don't need any more toys next time, in the nicest possible way. No toys from anyone since!

I know it comes from a good place so I would say just let it go and don't stress over it.

MinorWomensWhiplash1 · 06/05/2022 11:09

Same problem, I have tried everything but like a pp I have now given up. For the postal stuff I prescreen and some goes straight to charity. It’s mostly cheap stuff that breaks after a few plays so a bit easier to get rid of (though I despair of the waste). Don’t let it stop you getting stuff for the children yourself though, you are the parent. I find I have to pre-empt it and say “don’t buy this, I have already bought it”. Doesn’t always work, like the time when a whole trampoline showed up on the doorstep without prior warning 🙄

Ponoka7 · 06/05/2022 11:05

My DD keeps me upto date with what clothes they might need and send me links. I pay for the school uniform. I take them for that, so it's a day out. I also started to volunteer to pay towards things, like passports , school trips etc. My eldest GC likes to go on holiday for their birthday. I paid for flights and hotel one year. This year I've paid towards the accommodation and a few activities. If you have a car and are by zoos/safari parks/NT/ swimming a membership is a good idea. You can now get gift vouchers for everywhere, soft play etc. Your DP should have a word. Activities are much better than stuff.

TheKeatingFive · 06/05/2022 10:59

If you can't nudge them towards more experiential things, I'd just be sending stuff off to charity shops at regular intervals.

Their priorities are different to yours. It's annoying, but very much a first world problem.

sandalsinbohemia · 06/05/2022 10:55

I would be incredibly frustrated just at the fact that they are ignoring your requests. Can your DH say something?

That said, if they can't actually be stopped can you request consumable gifts/ gifts with a short shelf life (not sure how old they are but things like sticker books, colouring books etc which get used and then binned, or even sweet treats if you're not against those)

Ferngreen · 06/05/2022 10:51

Saving for university? - pointing out how much that costs might make them see sense.

PlanBea · 06/05/2022 10:43

"oh, that's great, you can keep this at granny's house to play with here!" Is a good one, it makes them think twice about the giant plastic monstrosity they want to install into your living room.

GodspeedJune · 06/05/2022 10:31

Agree with PP that although they may love buying for the children, part of the appeal is their own enjoyment of seeing the children’s reaction.

I’m afraid I would intercept the postal gifts and pass on straight to charity. If you have a small home (as I do) it’s better not to bring unnecessary stuff in, in the first place. Just makes the place cluttered and claustrophobic.

Could you ask them to buy gifts you actually need like shoes or clothes, instead of more toys?

PinkSyCo · 06/05/2022 10:24

It’s funny isn’t it? Some parents would kill to have this problem. I totally understand why it is a problem though and, as much as I love to spoil my grandchildren myself, I would be getting annoyed with the PIL’s at this stage because they are continuously ignoring what you’ve told them. Tell them one last time that you simply don’t have the space for anymore toys so any presents-outside of the expected birthday and Christmas ones-from them would be donated to the children’s ward at the hospital or some other charity.

HistoricMoment · 06/05/2022 10:17

I have a similar problem with my parents and I've just given up. I've accepted that this is what they're like, they just love buying stuff and nothing is going to stop them. It does annoy me because I sometimes have to give up on buying things I would have liked to buy myself for the DC but I remind myself that it's a first world problem.
I regularly get the kids to choose things to give to charity. I've found that they are very willing to give away things if they know where they are going to (eg Ukrainian children who have fled their country without taking any toys with them).

Rainbowqueeen · 06/05/2022 10:16

Savings account is a good shout.

Also consumable items eg tickets for days out
Books are also good because they take up less space

Maytodecember · 06/05/2022 10:13

Suggest a savings account instead that they open and put present money into that? Don’t think this will work as they probably like the instant gratification of seeing the kids love a present. They’re doing it more for themselves than the children.
You could try you’re banning plastic toys for environmental reasons……… No new toys, only secondhand for same reason ( this makes it a bit harder for them to source stuff so might reduce it)

Swipe left for the next trending thread