Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not know how jury is supposed to weigh up evidence?

60 replies

JetTail · 06/05/2022 08:48

I'm thinking specifically about JD's defamation trial. I've seen some of AH's testimony and if true, he's a c u next tuesday.
My question is, what if you don't believe her?
Are you supposed to come to a decision based on the assumption that everything you hear from a witness is true (as they are under oath) or are you supposed to consider credibility?
And what if there are conflicting accounts from opposing sides and you believe both accounts?
Mind a bit boggled today lol

OP posts:
DameHelena · 06/05/2022 09:16

You have to decide which evidence is the most compelling.

I think expert and/or witness evidence is more trustworthy than testimony from the main players. In this case we have their former marriage counsellor saying she considered their marriage to involve 'mutual abuse' and that AH had bruises. And audio recordings of AH admitting to hitting JD.
I don't know what terms they use in the US system, but in English courts, IME as a jury member, we were told we had to be 'sure' the defendant was guilty.
I suppose that doesn't necessarily mean the claimant has to be NOT guilty of that or another crime, but they're not the one on trial.

JetTail · 06/05/2022 09:14

To put it in plainer language.
Is a juror instructed to take all sworn testimony as fact? Or are they instructed to draw their own conclusions as to the authenticity of the sworn testimony?

OP posts:
JetTail · 06/05/2022 09:12

I mean that I've listened to a lot of his testimony and hers. I find him to be believable but I also found her dramatics believable when she described the cavity search. By that I mean that I wouldn't believe a word out of her mouth, based on the testimony against her, however, she acted fairly plausibly to an innocent observer. In my own experience, the last place that you will get emotional about something extremely hurtful or painful to recall is in public. That is something you do alone and it is something that you will probably only do after months of therapy when you feel like you can trust the therapist to not exploit your vulnerability. I felt personally that she was acting out how she believed a sufferer of abuse would act. I.e. the tears.

OP posts:
DaisyStPatience · 06/05/2022 09:11

Not sure if it's different in the US but in the UK at least, I believe juries are only meant to reach a guilty verdict if they believe the crime has been proved "beyond all reasonable doubt". In practice I doubt many of them actually think about what that means and follows it. We can all reach our own private judgement on whether the dependent is guilty or not, but to believe objectively that there's no reasonable doubt is surely very difficult much of the time? So people probably take it as a yes/no choice instead.

BaaMoon · 06/05/2022 09:08

Its up to the jury to decide. That's why there's a jury and not just one person.

roosnunlilei · 06/05/2022 09:07

And what if there are conflicting accounts from opposing sides and you believe both accounts?

If you believe both accounts then she is guilty of exactly what he is suing her for, surely?

Copperpottle · 06/05/2022 09:06

What, your question is you don't understand how people make decisions or reach conclusions?

Don't you do this like... literally every day?

chisanunian · 06/05/2022 09:05

based on the assumption

I don't think you are meant to assume anything. You are supposed to question and examine all the evidence. Because, as we all know, people don't necessarily tell the truth.

JetTail · 06/05/2022 09:04

Thanks for the explanation but that doesn't really answer my question?

OP posts:
TheOriginalChatelaine · 06/05/2022 08:58

Once the defence & prosecution have finished the Judge gives their summing up which is directed to the jury. This is guidance on what to consider in the case and a reminder on what to disregard & points of law. A Foreman is appointed & during the deliberation they can ask the judge for clarification.