Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not know how jury is supposed to weigh up evidence?

60 replies

JetTail · 06/05/2022 08:48

I'm thinking specifically about JD's defamation trial. I've seen some of AH's testimony and if true, he's a c u next tuesday.
My question is, what if you don't believe her?
Are you supposed to come to a decision based on the assumption that everything you hear from a witness is true (as they are under oath) or are you supposed to consider credibility?
And what if there are conflicting accounts from opposing sides and you believe both accounts?
Mind a bit boggled today lol

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Crazykatie · 06/05/2022 21:08

If it’s a criminal case the standard is “Beyond reasonable doubt”
If it’s a civil case it’s the “Balance of probabilities”.

A H is portraying herself as the victim, juries are always biased in favoring of the victim, which gives her an advantage.

I was obviously a toxic relationship how on earth you decide how much is true from both sides I have no idea, I would bet that JD looses.

JetTail · 06/05/2022 20:45

I would not be remotely surprised that if he wins the case, she will be extremely vulnerable mentally. Potentially fatally. No winners in this.

OP posts:
JetTail · 06/05/2022 20:42

I genuinely did not intend to be nasty about AH. My default position would be to believe her rather than him. I was just wondering really. How the hell do you decide? I wonder what the fucking point is of being 'under oath', when at least one fucker is bound to be lying lol. I genuinely get the impression that she has been deeply hurt by him but my irrelevant opinion is that she is not telling the truth and it has all snow-balled so that she's too far in to back out. I also think that this is probably destroying her mental health.

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 06/05/2022 15:08

It's also a matter of corroborating evidence. I.e. two people saying one thing as opposed to just 1 person saying the opposite. Exactly why rape cases are hard to prove as it's just 1 person against another.

It's why the barristers/lawyers try to either prove their client's version of events or disprove the other person's version of events, but introducing other evidence.

itsmeagainlol · 06/05/2022 14:44

Of course people lie, but it's who you believe.

itsmeagainlol · 06/05/2022 14:43

The jury hear the evidence from both parties and their witnesses. They listen to the cross examination which is designed to test the evidence. Basically to see if either side may be lying. At the end of the trial the judge sums up the evidence and advises the jury on points of the law. So they are not interested in some of the testimony, but rather whether it is an issue in law. Juries shouldn't be looking at press coverage but judging for themselves whose evidence is most compelling. This is why people testify, so that juries can assess their honesty. Murderers tend not to testify as they will be torn to shreds by the prosecution.

It is on the balance of probabilities rather than beyond all reasonable doubt, so the bar is lower and it's who the jury believes backed up by the evidence of their legal team.

Minfilia · 06/05/2022 14:27

Think about it logically.

Of course you can’t be expected to take what everyone says under oath as automatically true.

If one person is arguing that the sky is red, and the other that the sky is yellow, they can’t both be right!

donquixotedelamancha · 06/05/2022 13:46

This is how a rather large proportion of people do conduct themselves when on jury service, it’s horrifying.

Is it? Could you explain how you know that?

I didn't find anyone doing that when I did it, everyone too the responsibility very seriously. In the vast bulk of cases you wouldn't be able to anyway because you don't know anything about the case in advance.

RunIsAFourLetterWord · 06/05/2022 13:38

So you're not really asking the question at all, are you? This is just another AH is a cunt thread? If that's what you want to say, just say it, dressing it up in faux wide-eyed naivety is disingenuous and bloody annoying.

Traumdeuter · 06/05/2022 13:31

KrisAkabusi · 06/05/2022 13:16

I don't believe her at all. I simply don't believe a word out of her mouth.
He suffered financial damage and it was as a result of her claims in that article.

You would be terrible on a jury because you've made up your mind before you've heard all the evidence, nevermind waiting for deliberations to begin!

This is how a rather large proportion of people do conduct themselves when on jury service, it’s horrifying.

Bobbybobbins · 06/05/2022 13:25

As people have said, you have to use your judgement purely based on the evidence before you and accept that others may reach a different conclusion. I was the foreman on a case which was, like this, one person's word against another's. We could not reach a big enough majority so were a hung jury.

KrisAkabusi · 06/05/2022 13:16

I don't believe her at all. I simply don't believe a word out of her mouth.
He suffered financial damage and it was as a result of her claims in that article.

You would be terrible on a jury because you've made up your mind before you've heard all the evidence, nevermind waiting for deliberations to begin!

Badbadbunny · 06/05/2022 13:04

JetTail · 06/05/2022 09:14

To put it in plainer language.
Is a juror instructed to take all sworn testimony as fact? Or are they instructed to draw their own conclusions as to the authenticity of the sworn testimony?

Of course not. If that was the case, all an accused would ever have to do was swear he was innocent and the jury would have to acquit him!

The juries have to weigh up all the evidence and form their own opinions as to who's lying.

saveforthat · 06/05/2022 12:58

Op, if you ever do jury service I pity the poor buggar on trial. You would convict if someone juts out their chin. What if their eyes are too close together?

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 06/05/2022 12:38

Oh. So you weren't really asking?!?!

JetTail · 06/05/2022 11:44

I'm not a body language expert but she juts her chin out a lot. I can't think of a better way to describe it. It's like she is in fight mode. Here - take me on muddafuccka! I'm gonna fuckin kill you!!!
Then she cries apparently. Every move and facial expression is fake imo. Mind you, HE, sticks on sunglasses a lot. Probably to hide the rolling eyes.

I don't believe her at all. I simply don't believe a word out of her mouth.
He suffered financial damage and it was as a result of her claims in that article.
BTW why do all of the fucking witnesses sound like they're on weed or something? Or chill pills?

OP posts:
JetTail · 06/05/2022 11:39

Oh gosh. My brain is not capable of understanding your answers!
He is suing for defamation.
I am not sure that some of you understand that?
For defamation to be proven, as far as I know, it has to be untrue and it has to have caused damage to a reputation (financially).
It's clear that he has suffered financial damage and reputational damage. What is not clear is whether what she wrote in the article was true.

I am very swayed by his demeanour and testimony. Her? No. I actually do not believe a word she says.

OP posts:
Daenerys77 · 06/05/2022 11:26

You can't safely assume that everything a witness says is true just because the witness is on oath. People can and do lie on oath.

The jury needs to assess the credibility of the witnesses individually but also the evidence as a whole i.e. are witnesses on the same side of the case consistent with each other? Minor inconsistencies are common, but if a party calls several witnesses and they all give very different accounts of the same event, it undermines that party's credibility.

However, if witnesses on different sides of a case give different accounts, that is what you would expect, because if there is a trial, the facts are usually in dispute.

donquixotedelamancha · 06/05/2022 10:56

that’s really interesting- I thought it would be US specific.

I should qualify that IANAL, let alone a US one; but that is my understanding from reading around US libel. I haven't followed this case but I'm pretty sure such a case would not commonly get this far, simply because it's not usually worth it.

As I said above, given that two years ago he was perceived as a one sidedly abusive partner and that the PR battle seems to be going more his way now, I wonder whether this is as lose-lose a situation as it looks like from the outside?

Hollywood has a very high tolerance for unpleasent people- perhaps he only needs to detoxify himself a bit for this to be a victory?

Also worth noting that jurors can discuss trials, after the event, in the US; so losing on the law but making the narative that she was lying might be enough.

CounsellorTroi · 06/05/2022 10:53

DaisyStPatience · 06/05/2022 09:11

Not sure if it's different in the US but in the UK at least, I believe juries are only meant to reach a guilty verdict if they believe the crime has been proved "beyond all reasonable doubt". In practice I doubt many of them actually think about what that means and follows it. We can all reach our own private judgement on whether the dependent is guilty or not, but to believe objectively that there's no reasonable doubt is surely very difficult much of the time? So people probably take it as a yes/no choice instead.

This is a civil case not a criminal trial. In the UK at least , in civil cases the standard of proof isn’t “beyond all reasonable doubt”, it’s “on the balance of probability”, though in the US it may be a higher standard of proof.

Thatswhyimacat · 06/05/2022 10:52

Lawyers are there to specifically guide you through the process. You aren't supposed to consider anything outside of what is presented to you. Say you hear testimony, you are initially to assume the witness is telling the truth. However, lawyers can cross examine or provide additional evidence that calls the witness credibility into question, which you are then allowed to sway your opinion towards them and then decide you don't believe.

If you believe both, then you only consider whether the person on trial is guilty of what they are guilty of. If the other person's guilt means that the dependent isn't responsible in law for their actions, a judge would guide you on this, likewise if it's irrelevant. If the other person is also guilty creating mitigating circumstances, then that is for the judge to consider when sentencing.

This is a civil case, so it goes on balance of probabilities vs reasonable doubt, which is why character witnesses etc are being used a lot more, and evidence that doesn't definitely prove anything. E.g. 'Johnny Depp is an alcoholic and sent awful messages to his wife'. OK, that doesn't prove he hit her, but it makes it more likely. 'Amber Heard sent messages saying she would ruin his career', ok, also doesn't prove he didn't hit her, but calls her credibility into question.

Leftbutcameback · 06/05/2022 10:45

@donquixotedelamancha that’s really interesting- I thought it would be US specific.

donquixotedelamancha · 06/05/2022 10:36

Here in the UK it's said that levels of proof required are lower but I don't know if that's true in the US.

It's not the level of proof that's lower, it's what constitutes libel. US free speech protection is very high so anything that is opinion, even if forseeably causing harm, is likely to be protected.

If they feel that she just has a different view of events to him, or they believe parts of her story, then he loses.

MadKittenWoman · 06/05/2022 10:34

We work on the basis of ‘ innocent until proven guilty’. Guilt has to be proven. It comes down to who you believe the most. If you are not sure, you have to give a ‘not guilty’ verdict. Both cases I have been involved in resulted in a retrial. In the first, I would have convicted but the judge stopped it as the accused changed his story and started saying things which the prosecution had no knowledge of. In the second, we deliberated. We were one jury member down at the last minute due to personal circumstances, so there were only 11 of us. As it was a serious case, the judge wanted a unanimous verdict. We very quickly decided 9-2 ‘not guilty’. We asked the judge for guidance, and he came back with 10-1. Nobody wanted to change their minds; the foreman, who thought something ‘may’ have happened wanted to convict, as did another member who was under the impression that it was ‘guilty until proven innocent’. The rest of us did not believe the ‘victim’ or any of his witnesses, and found the accused more believable, so could not give a guilty verdict. As in England we don’t have the third option the Scots have of ‘not proven’, we had to vote innocent. The judge would not accept 9-2, so we were discharged and it went to another trial.

Pluvia · 06/05/2022 10:28

Just a reminder that this is a civil case, not a criminal one, in a US court and so we can't go applying UK expectations to it. Civil courts are used to sort out disputes where no crime has been committed. Here in the UK it's said that levels of proof required are lower but I don't know if that's true in the US.

As for how you reach a decision, you listen as carefully as you can and try to use your head to work out whether there are holes in one side's argument or the other. At the end of the evidence you listen carefully to what the judge has to say and then you discuss things with your fellow jurors and (hopefully) try to make a decision based on the facts, discarding as many prejudices and as much emotion as you can. You try to come to an agreement and if you can't you call for guidance from the court officials or the judge.

Swipe left for the next trending thread