Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My husband won't tell me who he voted for today?

339 replies

FreeFlowersForAll · 05/05/2022 23:25

AIBU?

I spoiled my ballot.

My husband won't tell me who he voted for, and he's annoyed that I keep asking? Surely this is the kind of info that should be shared between a man and wife?

OP posts:
Cornettoninja · 06/05/2022 12:14

I would respect the fact they don't want to tell me, because it is a secret ballot and that is very important.
But I would find them personally pompous and annoying

….and they very well may be. Or, perhaps you (a theoretical you since I know nothing about you!!) are politically dogmatic and unpleasant to engage with unless their views align with your own.

Rather than lying for the sake of a quiet life it’s a way of shutting down conversation without giving someone anything to feed off. A vote was cast and that’s all that’s known so someone doesn’t have to compromise their own beliefs or get into a conversation they know isn’t going anywhere.

RuthW · 06/05/2022 12:13

It's none of your business.

BlossomWind · 06/05/2022 12:08

BaaMoon · 06/05/2022 08:49

But what I'd they don't want to tell you? What should they say? "I don't want to share that?"

I would respect the fact they don't want to tell me, because it is a secret ballot and that is very important.
But I would find them personally pompous and annoying.
Like I respect that people have the right to ask me to take my shoes off when I enter their house, and I will follow their wishes, and I won't huff. But I find them annoying for doing so.

Labscollie · 06/05/2022 12:06

jcyclops · 06/05/2022 11:49

Maybe he voted Tory and is ashamed to admit so.
Maybe he voted Labour, and as a Jew, he is ashamed to have done so.
Maybe he spoiled his paper because he couldn't vote Tory but refused to vote for one of the numerous non-Tory parties with no policies.
Maybe he closed his eyes and placed his cross randomly and doesn't actually know who he voted for.
Maybe he voted for the candidate with whom he is having a secret affair.
Maybe he has decided that any argument with you over how he voted would be much worse than the argument caused by not telling you.

Or maybe he knows his wife is on MN, and knows the amount of shaming, ironically on AIBU threads, that is carried out. Jumping on somebody for their vote choice is playground bullying.

HiJenny35 · 06/05/2022 12:03

If he doesn't want to say then he voted tory. Surely you have talked about the current situations and know if he would be willing to vote tory after what they've done recently? For me I couldn't be with someone with such different opinions and can't understand why you would keep it secret when who you vote for is so important why you wouldn't be able to state who and why if its your belief that its the correct thing to do.

Cornettoninja · 06/05/2022 12:00

I find it weird when people think you should keep it private: if you believe in it enough to vote for it, why are you hiding it?

The privacy and anonymity of every vote is the default position, if a person chooses to continue that with their friends, family, acquaintances that’s their right. It’s not weird, it’s a layer of protection to ensure that the individuals vote is influenced by them alone. ‘Nothing to hide, nothing to fear’ is a sinister notion in the context of elections.

I agree it implies various things about a relationship if people feel they can’t openly discuss their political views especially in a scenario when it would be easy enough to lie and just say something to stop being badgered. If that were me I’d take the hint that no matter how strongly I felt about a particular issue my partner didn’t appreciate being dragged into debates that they fundamentally don’t agree with or don’t care about. It’s a very personal reaction as to where that would take me/the relationship.

Sirzy · 06/05/2022 11:58

Take the hint he doesn’t want to tell you. Call it a joke as much as you like there is a fine line between that and pestering! How often is bullying excused as “banter”

and just like not voting spoiling your paper is just like a vote for the worst option!

jcyclops · 06/05/2022 11:49

Maybe he voted Tory and is ashamed to admit so.
Maybe he voted Labour, and as a Jew, he is ashamed to have done so.
Maybe he spoiled his paper because he couldn't vote Tory but refused to vote for one of the numerous non-Tory parties with no policies.
Maybe he closed his eyes and placed his cross randomly and doesn't actually know who he voted for.
Maybe he voted for the candidate with whom he is having a secret affair.
Maybe he has decided that any argument with you over how he voted would be much worse than the argument caused by not telling you.

emmajane90 · 06/05/2022 11:49

YABU. It's absolutely none of your business who he, or anyone else, voted for.

housemaus · 06/05/2022 11:42

MorrisZapp · 05/05/2022 23:40

Blimey. How the other half live. I grew up knowing not only who my parents voted for but exactly why. We cracked champagne on Portillo night, it was the first GE I'd voted in. We had posters on the walls and in the windows. Both parents wore badges too 😂

Obviously the ballot box is private but it's your husband, not the greengrocer. I'd feel really weird if DP didn't tell me who he voted for.

Don't people usually just chat about this stuff?

Same - I can't imagine marrying someone without knowing their political views, I wouldn't get past casual dating with someone if we weren't on the same page!

DH and I talked about politics on our first date - not in a 'interviewing each other' kind of way, but we're both quite political and it came up in conversation and we spent the next hour talking about it Grin. In fact, I only have a couple of friends who I don't know their voting choices - almost everyone I know is quite open about it.

I find it weird when people think you should keep it private: if you believe in it enough to vote for it, why are you hiding it?

amusedbush · 06/05/2022 11:38

I voted in the morning, DH went after work and then we shared exactly how we ranked each option on our ballots. Turns out we voted almost identically, just two parties were inverted.

I'd find it weird if he didn't tell me but as others have said, it's his business. We are both pretty political and well-aligned in that respect, though.

Tilltheend99 · 06/05/2022 11:36

*Were

Tilltheend99 · 06/05/2022 11:36

FreeFlowersForAll · 06/05/2022 11:13

I spoiled my ballot because, as a feminist, I have nobody to vote for. However, I would like my vote counted. Being counted in the "spoiled" pile is better than not voting for me.

I'm not pestering my husband. I asked him at first, and he wouldn't tell me, and it became a bit of a joke throughout the day. He's not telling me to wind me up, I think.

Did all of your local candidates express anti feminist views? Where there not enough women on the ballot? Was there no one running as an independent? If you feel that strongly maybe you should run for local council.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 06/05/2022 11:35

Judging by some on this thread, there are MNers who’d like to go back to the bad old days when voting (if you did have a vote) was anything but private, so that anyone who voted the ‘wrong’ way could be hanged by their entrails from the nearest lamppost - or at the very least, ostracised.

On a previous GE day, a party worker came to the door asking how I’d voted. I said politely that it was a private matter. Dh didn’t mind telling them, but then he chats to Jehovah’s Witnesses, too, rather than telling them rather more politely to sod off.

Tilltheend99 · 06/05/2022 11:31

It’s a bit rich to complain that he won’t tell you considering you didn’t even vote for a councillor. (You vote for a local councillor to represent the interests of your area on the local council at local elections not a party although you can vote along party lines if you like. All of your local candidates must have been pretty dire for you to spoil your ballot as it’s not really the same as ‘sending a message’ in a general election imo.)

Lbushsgkm · 06/05/2022 11:31

Aha just read your update above. Fair enough!

Lbushsgkm · 06/05/2022 11:30

Reading between the lines OP, you’re a conservative voter who’s boycotting the current government but couldn’t bring yourself to vote labour. You think DH has either voted labour or conservative and are pissed off about it.

PeacockPartyTime · 06/05/2022 11:26

You sound controlling, let the man have some privacy. And why spoil your ballot? Are you trying to be some 'cool' rebel because all you're doing is causing people more work. Stay away from the station if you're just going to act like a twat.

DressingGownofDoom · 06/05/2022 11:22

Labscollie · 06/05/2022 09:55

For those saying he no doubt voted Tory, you're the reason why people keep their votes secret. Aside from it being nobody else's business, it is HIS choice, not yours.

I'd keep it quiet too if I'd voted for Senator Palpatine.

RoostasTowel · 06/05/2022 11:13

Are you sure he voted? Maybe he's embarrassed to tell you he forgot it was election day.

FreeFlowersForAll · 06/05/2022 11:13

I spoiled my ballot because, as a feminist, I have nobody to vote for. However, I would like my vote counted. Being counted in the "spoiled" pile is better than not voting for me.

I'm not pestering my husband. I asked him at first, and he wouldn't tell me, and it became a bit of a joke throughout the day. He's not telling me to wind me up, I think.

OP posts:
HectorGloop · 06/05/2022 11:10

my DH believes that you should never say who you voted for. I don’t know who he has voted for in any election ever. That’s his right.

I’m happy to tell him who I voted for if he asks. Sometimes he does, sometimes he doesn’t.

we are grown up enough to discuss politics and elections and general social issues. Sometimes we agree, often we don’t. If I had to guess, I would say he generally votes differently to me. But that’s fine, because we are allowed to disagree.

doesn’t mean our relationship is unequal in any way, just that we respect each other’s boundaries.

Malbecfan · 06/05/2022 11:09

It's my 25th wedding anniversary later this month. In all that time, we have both voted in every possible election. One year, I had to vote by proxy for DH and it is the only time I have ever known who he voted for. As it happened, he asked me to select the candidate I would have chosen myself anyway.

I now have adult DDs. I have a strong suspicion of how they have voted, but unless they share it with me, I don't know for certain. We are quite politically engaged; I work in state education and the DDs are students, so our natural inclinations are broadly aligned. We discuss politics at the table and are mostly in agreement as a family. In our constituency, tactical voting is the best way to get rid of the incumbent and we have discussed it many times. That does not mean that I know how any of them actually voted on the day.

Crinklecuts · 06/05/2022 10:58

I think you were unreasonable to spoil your ballot. Why would you waste your time going to vote ?

JudgeJ · 06/05/2022 10:57

If someone refuses to tell you who they voted for - well, it's pretty obvious they have a very different opinion...

A simpleton's conclusion, we never in 50+ years discussed our voting habits, we were not so controlling of each other. Anyone demanding to be told would be a 'red flag' to me!