Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My husband won't tell me who he voted for today?

339 replies

FreeFlowersForAll · 05/05/2022 23:25

AIBU?

I spoiled my ballot.

My husband won't tell me who he voted for, and he's annoyed that I keep asking? Surely this is the kind of info that should be shared between a man and wife?

OP posts:
lightisnotwhite · 06/05/2022 21:20

It’s interesting that the couples that must vote the same way or it’s a “dealbreaker” are all Labour supporters and the couples that aren’t fussed how the other votes have at least one Tory voter.

missmoon · 06/05/2022 18:35

My DH does this, it's very annoying, but I've just given up asking. He won't tell our children either. I can usually guess though.

peachgreen · 06/05/2022 18:24

Do children necessarily vote the same way as their parents? My parents have always openly and vehemently voted Tory, and maybe when I was 11 I would have done too but by the time I was old enough to vote I knew enough to know I’d rather stab myself in the eye. For me the main parties are ideologically divided enough that I’d find it odd if my my partner and children didn’t know who invited for, simply because my morals are so far apart from those of the Conservative party. But I guess knowing that and being told are two different things.

Abhannmor · 06/05/2022 18:02

Imagine not knowing what your partner earns. This is how they keep us down. An old boss once asked me not to tell ppl what I was paid. I said ' don't worry ; I'm just as ashamed of it as you are '. I soon moved on. Same with the voting . We mustn't discuss such matters. It might upset our betters.

Abraxan · 06/05/2022 17:17

neverbeenskiing · 06/05/2022 17:15

I don't really like the idea of children voting for the same party as their parents simply as it's what's done, without the child reading up and v]finding out more for themselves.

Me neither, but I think you can be open with your children about your politics and still encourage them to be curious, think critically and do their own research. My DF was very open about his own political views and who he voted for and I still grew up with different views and voted differently.

The problem is, is I often change who I vote for. I know dh has veered between parties too. We tend to look at what is happening and what is being said at the time. I don't believe in just choose one party to vote for and remaining loyal to them regardless of what they are saying or doing.

So, we discuss politics to an extent, we discuss our beliefs, thoughts and ideas about political events. But we don't just say 'I vote x because they will do xyz' - firstly, they rarely do what they say regardless of which party it is, and secondly what they say and do changes regularly.

neverbeenskiing · 06/05/2022 17:15

I don't really like the idea of children voting for the same party as their parents simply as it's what's done, without the child reading up and v]finding out more for themselves.

Me neither, but I think you can be open with your children about your politics and still encourage them to be curious, think critically and do their own research. My DF was very open about his own political views and who he voted for and I still grew up with different views and voted differently.

Abraxan · 06/05/2022 17:08

MorrisZapp · 05/05/2022 23:40

Blimey. How the other half live. I grew up knowing not only who my parents voted for but exactly why. We cracked champagne on Portillo night, it was the first GE I'd voted in. We had posters on the walls and in the windows. Both parents wore badges too 😂

Obviously the ballot box is private but it's your husband, not the greengrocer. I'd feel really weird if DP didn't tell me who he voted for.

Don't people usually just chat about this stuff?

This is one reason why we don't share who we vote for. We never wanted to feel,like we would be pushing dd one way or the other. Instead we talked about different parties and their general approach, she was shown and we looked at the different pledges put forward, etc. I'm sure dd probably has an inkling, but as it's likely me and dh vote differently, I don't feel she has any undue bias in any direction.

Before voting this time she read key summaries of each party. I don't know who she voted for and won't be asking.

I don't really like the idea of children voting for the same party as their parents simply as it's what's done, without the child reading up and v]finding out more for themselves.

donttalkaboutbookclub · 06/05/2022 17:06

neverbeenskiing · 06/05/2022 16:15

It depends entirely on the marriage. It's clear from this thread that in some relationships this would be fine, but in my marriage if one of us refused to tell the other who we voted for it would definitely spell trouble. Partly because it would be out of character for us to be secretive about anything, so the other one would naturally find it odd. But mostly because we're both very political, it's something we talk about a lot and our shared values are one of the things that bind us together. How anyone can say that the political beliefs and values of your own spouse are "none of your business" is beyond me! But I appreciate every marriage is different.

The only possible reason for my DH not to want to discuss his vote with me would be if he had voted for a right wing candidate. This would mean a fundamental shift had occurred in his core values, priorities and personal ethics which would essentially mean he wasn't the same man I married. To me, that's a very big deal.

Exactly the same here, @neverbeenskiing . I'm really surprised by this thread. Learn something every day on MN.

Abraxan · 06/05/2022 17:04

It's his decision and he is entitled to not share it with anyone, including you.

I would never ask dh (or dd) who he voted for during any election. I can hazard a guess generally. We don't always vote alike, based on what I know without asking, but I never ask to clarify or not. It's nothing to do with me how he votes, nor how dd votes. He never asks me either.

oioimatey · 06/05/2022 17:03

VOTE* not work. Although I won't disclose that either!

oioimatey · 06/05/2022 17:03

I never disclose who I work for, just like I never disclose my real name on this site Grin

OneTC · 06/05/2022 16:57

The %age that are already disenfranchised or disinterested enough not to vote should be sending a message already really, but none of them seem to care

They definitely don't care if you drew a winky on your paper

pinacolada321 · 06/05/2022 16:56

No one knows who anyone votes for that's the whole point, you could lie and tell your partner you're going to vote for a particular party then vote for a different party when you're in there. I never tell anyone who i have voted for because i have the right to vote with anonymity

OneTC · 06/05/2022 16:54

Ballot spoiling, if it was ever going to be an effective protest would have to be organised and widespread enough that it could be deployed tactically, 0.whatever % of people doing it, when a significant number of them will also be made up by people who just couldn't fill it in properly, isn't exactly a coherent message

Shinyandnew1 · 06/05/2022 16:52

Spoiling your ballot achieves nothing though. It may make you feel like you’re protesting, but the outcome is no different to not turning up. If you spoil your ballot-nobody knows, nobody cares. The person with the most votes wins.

GirlSYML · 06/05/2022 16:48

peachgreen · 06/05/2022 16:45

Spoiling your ballot is a form of protest & it should not be confused with not voting.

Sure. Whatever helps you sleep at night.

Well with that well reasoned response I guess there’s nothing left to say 🙄

peachgreen · 06/05/2022 16:45

Spoiling your ballot is a form of protest & it should not be confused with not voting.

Sure. Whatever helps you sleep at night.

GirlSYML · 06/05/2022 16:38

@peachgreen sorry you specifically said, and I quote gender critical feminism has done more to embolden right wing misogyny than anything nice to blame women for daring to have opinions.

Also, spoiling your vote is using your vote. It shouldn’t be done lightly but no one is obliged to vote for the ‘least worst candidate’ and no one should be cursed at like you have done to me for not doing what you want with my vote - voting for a candidate simply to have voted for someone isn’t a responsible use of your vote. Spoiling your ballot is a form of protest & it should not be confused with not voting.

Discovereads · 06/05/2022 16:33

It’s not really a valid political statement to spoil your vote because nobody in power cares. The number of spoilt ballots in the U.K. has never risen above 1% in any election ever. Nobody ever reads them or looks at them. The parties are told simply that 0.2% or whatever of votes were spoilt.

And in the same breath they are told the % of voters who refused to vote at all. The 2019 general election had 32.7% of voters not vote. Did that send a signal? Did that get any party to change and try and attract more voters? Fuck no. That’s about the average we roll at as 2017 wasn’t much different at 31.2% of voters not voting.

So I have to wonder at the sanity of people suggesting that spoiling your vote is going to send a message, get parties and candidates to engage more with their constituencies, and so on.

Spoiling your vote accomplishes nothing. It is the same as not voting only you’re cheekily and selfishly creating more work and headaches for the volunteers who count votes at the polling stations.

iheartmybeachhut · 06/05/2022 16:25

If my dh asked me who I voted for and kept asking he would be told quite firmly to jog off and mind his own business. Spoiling your vote is a bit twattish imo but there you have it.

peachgreen · 06/05/2022 16:19

You're putting words into my mouth that bear absolutely no resemblance to my posts. I literally just said that you should kick up a stink about it if you want to. Have all the opinions you like! Just don't waste your fucking vote. Not over anything. Because there is ALWAYS a less worse option. And by not voting for that less worse option, you are essentially voting for the worst one.

LakieLady · 06/05/2022 16:17

Dguu6u · 06/05/2022 10:06

Yes, I’d expect my husband to want to share this with me. But actually, if you have a close relationship, you should already know or be able to guess. Why would you not discuss politics with your other half? Do people not talk about things with their partners anymore? Why would anyone want to keep secrets from each other in a healthy relationship?

I don't get how people don't discuss politics with their partners, either, even if it's just a passing comment on whichever MP is on the box being particularly twattish, obviously lying etc.

I'm not suggesting people should be glued to the news channel and parliament channel all day and night, but surely there are political items on the news that would provoke anyone to have a view and express it?

GirlSYML · 06/05/2022 16:16

@peachgreen ah ok so those pesky gender critical women need to shut up and not have an opinion as they are ‘emboldening right wing misogyny’ 🙄🙄🙄

You’ve heard it now ladies. Be nice, be kind, vote quietly and don’t express any opinions as you’re making people more prejudiced against women. It’s all your fault.

peachgreen · 06/05/2022 16:15

How does wasting your vote show that you care about women? Please, enlighten me. Do you think allowing the Tories to continue forcing more and more single mothers into poverty is helping women?

If there are no gender critical candidates in your area to vote for, then vote for the candidate who is most likely to do good in other areas you care about, and then go and kick up a stink with them about gender critical issues all you like. That's what I mean by it being "one issue". It is not worth wasting your vote over.

neverbeenskiing · 06/05/2022 16:15

It depends entirely on the marriage. It's clear from this thread that in some relationships this would be fine, but in my marriage if one of us refused to tell the other who we voted for it would definitely spell trouble. Partly because it would be out of character for us to be secretive about anything, so the other one would naturally find it odd. But mostly because we're both very political, it's something we talk about a lot and our shared values are one of the things that bind us together. How anyone can say that the political beliefs and values of your own spouse are "none of your business" is beyond me! But I appreciate every marriage is different.

The only possible reason for my DH not to want to discuss his vote with me would be if he had voted for a right wing candidate. This would mean a fundamental shift had occurred in his core values, priorities and personal ethics which would essentially mean he wasn't the same man I married. To me, that's a very big deal.