Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Did your DC decide not to go to University because of their GF/BF

38 replies

Loomingdoom · 05/05/2022 17:16

DS (17) has always wanted to go to university to do a course which is very worthwhile and would definitely lead to employment in a well paid field. He is very academic and it would be a natural next step after A’levels.
He has been going out with a lovely girl for approximately 6 months and it’s pretty serious. She doesn’t want to go to university and instead wants to work in an area she enjoys that doesn’t require higher education. DS is now wavering about going to university, although he’s not sure what he’d do instead. I don’t want him to go and be unhappy and subsequently drop out but I can’t help but feel he’d be making a big mistake not going when all his friends do (I know he can always go later, but it would be much easier to get help from college for applications etc). I don’t really know the best approach to take with him. I know it’s his life and up to him but I don’t want him to throw away opportunities or not reach his potential and be unfulfilled ultimately. I’d be interested to hear from anyone with experience of this.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Aria2015 · 05/05/2022 19:46

It crossed my mind not to go but my mum basically said, if I didn't go then I'd had to get a job and would be expected to pay my way (not very appealing). I think the main thing that helped was that she didn't try and down play our relationship. She validated my feelings but she'd reason that a strong relationship could survive some distance and she encouraged me to think of ways to make it work so that I could have both a degree and my relationship. She also said if I went and was miserable I could always quit. Ultimately I went and although I desperately missed my boyfriend initially, I grew to love uni and my boyfriend and I maintained our relationship for almost the full 3 years.

I'm really glad I went, I would of 100% regretted not going.

ZenNudist · 05/05/2022 19:42

Personally I would be insisting on higher education.

NerrSnerr · 05/05/2022 19:33

MarJau26 · 05/05/2022 17:37

At 17 he knows absolutely nothing about life, he shouldn't be making big decisions such as skipping university for a teenage relationship. He isn't an adult and I think you need to step in and give him quite a reality check here. He could change gf many times before he is 20 but he will regret not having a qualification at 20. Sorry but I would be very angry with my ds if he decided to make a foolish decision based on a girl.

Although it's true that 17 year olds often make unwise decisions he'll be 18 when it's time to actually go to university and you can't force an 18 year old to undertake a degree against their will!!

I would advise him to apply to university but potentially defer the year and then after the year he can decide whether staying at home and working is for him or if he'd prefer to go.

Loomingdoom · 05/05/2022 19:24

Thanks for the replies. I have made it clear to DS that he should going to university and if his relationship is meant to be it will survive.
@LillyBugg I agree with you though and don’t want to push him away so am trying to be understanding (even though it’s hard)!

OP posts:
SkoolShoes · 05/05/2022 19:13

Get him to ask his college if they will support him applying once he is left (I work in a Sixth Form College and we still help with applying/references etc even if they left a few years back).

If they don't, do as PP say - apply and he can always defer.

darlingdodo · 05/05/2022 18:44

He needs to go through the processes of application - I'd be pointing out:

The relationship may not survive if he goes to uni - equally it may not survive if he stays at home.

What are his plans if he doesn't go to uni, because you'll not be supporting him to sit on his tush.

What are his shirt term, medium and long term goals? Where does he see himself in 5/10/20 years time?

If the relationship does survive him going away to university he will be in a much better position to progress the relationship if he has a good degree and subsequently a good job - they'll be able to travel, get on the housing ladder, plan a family of that's what they want.

_nellie_ · 05/05/2022 18:34

He'll regret it and resent her in the future if he doesn't go. My partner went to university 5 hours away and I stayed in London, we made it work. 7 years later we're happier than ever. Plus I liked going up to visit him, like a mini holiday and he liked coming home for the break. Christmas and Easter break is a month long too, summer break is about 3-4 months.

dimples76 · 05/05/2022 18:33

As he looked into degree apprenticeships? That would mean that he could start earning straight away and still get a degree.

I know I would be worried in your shoes but it is more common (I am a university lecturer) for people to come to university at different points in their life and make significant career changes so a lot of opportunities will still be out there.

Swayingpalmtrees · 05/05/2022 18:31

Consequently i’ve never had a “career” in a field I enjoy

Well at least you had a career, dropping out is almost certainly going to lead to very little opportunity and options.
He can apply for the uni in the closest city if he must, but simply dropping out because of a six month teenage romance would be robustly but kindly challenged in this family.

TooManyPJs · 05/05/2022 18:27

My DS was wavering more about where to go that whether to go at all. But I told him categorically that he should not be making life decisions based on a relationship at this age. They are too young, have so much growing to do as people and it's extremely unlikely this person is the one they will spend the rest of their life with. Definitely not something to base huge life decisions on. However strong his current feelings are.

Thankfully he's always taken my advice seriously as that relationship has since broken down. He's now with someone else that is much better for him and does not regret his uni decision.

Reallyreallyborednow · 05/05/2022 18:26

I wouldn't be taking no for an answer in short, and if I had to steamroll, I would. He is not an adult and is not going to uni is not an option, or wouldn't be for us

my parents did this to me. Big mistake. Wrong course, wrong career, and I could never afford to retrain. Consequently i’ve never had a “career” in a field I enjoy.

my mum is very proud of my degree though 🙄.

o/p I’d tell him to apply. Apply for the course and uni he wants, plus one nearer home. He can defer a year if he wants to hang around and see how the relationship goes. But he needs to get a job.

i’d also focus on “if it’s meant to be, it’ll survive 3 years at uni”. She can visit, so can he. It’s only 10 weeks apart at a time. Try and make him see that going after what he wants can help the relationship- he’ll be in a better place after etc to support an adult relationship.

Booboobagins · 05/05/2022 18:25

Not quite the same but my DS didn't finish her quals because of a BF. They finished 12m later and she never went back to finish. She's now in her 50's and earns £30k pa.

Personally I think he should go and experience uni now, I kniw he can go later, but getting on the career ladder early is def the best option in my experience.

If he can go close to home, he can still see his GF. Most people I know who had DPs St home and went to uni weren't together for very long.

We all know what that first love feels like and maybe tge relationship will survive, better to test it now rather than later when he's working and may not want to go to uni.

YANBU

Barton10 · 05/05/2022 18:24

I didn’t go because of my bf at the time. I really regret it as the relationship didn’t last and I am stuck in a dead end job now.

Crunchycrouton · 05/05/2022 18:22

I skipped uni for that reason.

I went back and did a law degree at 22 and by 30 I was on a good salary as a qualified lawyer, by 35 I was earning the same as if I’d gone at 18.

Another friend of mine went to uni and dropped out after her first year. She did something she wanted to do at 21, and got her degree at 24.

Its not ideal; but it can work out. With hindsight I wasn’t ready for uni at 18, but I was a few years later.

Autienotnaughtie · 05/05/2022 18:20

I didn't go to uni as bf didn't want me to. Massively regretted it, got my degree at 35. He could go to uni closer to home to be near gf or defer his place for a year and work a year see how he feels. But he needs to do what's best for him in long run.

LillyBugg · 05/05/2022 18:18

met my bf at 16 and he was a year older. He went to uni and I followed him to the same one much to my mothers horror. I know it's not quite the same. But she didn't support me at all and made life difficult. I moved in with him at 18. I married him at 24, that was ten years ago and we've got two DC. I also have no contact with my mother.

I think mine is just a tale of caution OP. It's okay to advise but be kind and be supportive whatever he decides to do. A good job isn't everything.

GarlandsinGreece · 05/05/2022 18:17

Not quite the same, but after earning AAB in my A-levels (back in the Dark Ages) I chose to go to a subpar ex-poly, because that’s where my boyfriend was going.

To this day, I wish to god my parents had put their feet down and saved me from such a shitty decision.

springsmiles · 05/05/2022 18:17

I met my BF in the april before Uni. I did go to Uni and BF was working. I was surprised but it did work out. Although I went to a uni only 1 he from home, so he could come see me in the week and I would go home weekends.

Honestly I regret being with him for the whole of my 3 years as I don't feel I really had the chance to bond with my house mates or make as many new friends, but we did get married and are still together 20 yrs on

themosttiptoptopcat · 05/05/2022 18:11

I went to Uni at 18, my boyfriend of 2 years stayed home and got a full time job, he would visit me every/every other weekend or I would go home for the weekend occasionally. 11 years on and we’ve been married for nearly 3 years.

Swayingpalmtrees · 05/05/2022 18:06

I wouldn't be taking no for an answer in short, and if I had to steamroll, I would. He is not an adult and is not going to uni is not an option, or wouldn't be for us.

Swayingpalmtrees · 05/05/2022 18:04

I second pp that say he is just 17 and is relying on you to guide him - even if he doesn't know it! Make sure he applies and you go to the open days, and start the process regardless.
In your position we would talk out the advantages, I would be making a very strong case for university and would tell him that if he really wants to ensure his gf is happy in the future, then a good job and financial security are imperative. List the reasons why she might also enjoy higher living standards etc, new cars, holidays, buying a home etc all costs money.

I would point out that she could always move close to the uni, and that is an option. The holidays are very very long and so he would see plenty of her, and she can come and stay with him at weekends. It will give him the chance to fulfil his potential and ambitions, it is not like he has a list of alternatives. I would also point out she could finish the relationship in the near future, and he has thrown away his chance. Despite what others are saying starting in your 20's is not very common at all. Above all, if it is meant to last, then it will.

That is option A, and option B is basically to remind him that you can't support him unless he goes to uni, so he will need to get a job as nighttime shelf stacker now.

I would not be happy with the idea of him not going for this reason, and would move heaven and earth to convince him otherwise.

Ponderingwindow · 05/05/2022 17:51

My job as a parent is to support my child in full time education.

if he wants to skip university, it’s time for him to support himself financially. As soon as he finishes school, he needs to get a full time job and start paying rent.

SecondhandTable · 05/05/2022 17:50

I'd encourage him to go but try not to be too pushy, maybe make suggestions about how the relationship can continue to work even with him at uni. E.g. a) long distance (we did this for the first year of uni, it was fine, we met up every couple of months or so and we are still together, and I know a few people who did it all the way through uni and sometimes even beyond and are also still together years later). B) uni in home city or commuting to a nearby uni. C) Girlfriend moves to his uni city and pursues her career/job there.

bigbluebus · 05/05/2022 17:49

I wouldn't have allowed my DS to not go to Uni based on a 6mth relationship with a girl. If they really are serious then they will survive him being away and she can visit/he can pop home some weekends. He would be throwing away the opportunity to experience life away from home and gaining a degree and career for a relationship which may or may not survive.
My DNephew had a gf at school. They both went to different Unis and visited each other at weekends. Now DN is doing a post grad and GF has moved to the same city and got a job. They still don't live together - she shares with her friends and he with his. They're both 24 now.

amusedbush · 05/05/2022 17:46

CHOSE*

You'll be glad to hear that I don't teach English Blush