Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents not wanting to do childcare...

485 replies

Chewchewaboogiw · 04/05/2022 23:32

Have been thinking about several people I know whose planned retirememt or part time work has been changed as they have been asked to do childcare for their dgc and now they are doing chikdcare say 3 days a week instead of their plan to travel. And not massively happy about it ( in one case another.baby due also)..I have seen a post response recently that said that they take dgc out but they are not there for childcare. If you dont do childcare for your dgc how did you say no?( I am not in that position at present but i can imagine it would be hard work ..) I would imagine / fear adult ds would be hurt if they were told no dont want to do chikdcare and cant imagine how it would be phrased in a positive way.. anyone said no and is it bu to say you dont want to ... or is it now expected. I know that all families.different, am just asking about families who are comfortable in saying no .

OP posts:
LuckySantangelo35 · 07/05/2022 09:44

BossyFlossie76 · 07/05/2022 00:46

Quite the opposite of transactional in my view…we like looking after each other and being with each other! That translates into childcare in the sense that it frees me up several days of the week. I find it enriching for all involved.

[NB: I could cope without any help from family, I work nights, have a Husband, and also have full time paid childcare provision…there is a boring reason I have that perk- I’m just demonstrating that it’s a choice for us to trust our children to our parents a regularly].

I was making a link between feeling like you’re too busy/uninterested to look after your family, don’t then expect hands on care if and you need it, surely? If the caregiving/receiving relationship ends with childhood!?

It’s my opinion that we are all committed to each other in a lifelong way, and if one party checks out of that- doesn’t it break down? That’s totally fine if that’s the dynamic, there is one grandparent not involved for this very reason.

I appreciate there may be practical barriers to grandparents providing childcare, and that it could never work for all- but I don’t quite understand how the desire wouldn’t be there. I hope I get to help raise (or co-raise as I think you put it) my grand babies one day.

So in your view when you become a mother you literally sign up to caring for children forever more or less then? You care for your own kids and then you have to devote yourselves to your grandkids. Until you become too infirm/unwell to do anything anymore. And they you may MAY be looked after by your son/daughter if they deemed you selfless and giving enough (but no guarantee)

At what point in that trajectory do someone have time to dedicate to themselves?? To go travelling on a whim for weeks on end, maybe live abroad for a bit, or have holiday home, to take up new hobbies, classses, whatever. Not when they have their own kids, not when they have grandkids, not when they’re too old to look after grankids cos they’re be too infirm then - so when??!

so basically you have to sacrifice your entire life when you become a mother is what you’re saying??

Snowiscold · 07/05/2022 09:17

@Robinni
I did read the OP’s post. She said the grandparents are close and they have a good relationship. She didn’t say that they live close by. That’s maybe what was meant, but that is not what I understood.

Arthursmom · 07/05/2022 08:57

@Snowiscold in my situation they are all retired and have decent disposable income. We see them every week anyways sometimes twice a week. We live within 40 miles of one another and i do make that trip with a toddler in tow (who hates the car) at least once a week so they can see him. No one is even thinking of going back to work. They are literally doing nothing most of the time and want to see him! They just want me to run around after him while they see him. No, I wouldn't expect them to give anything up or work etc if they needed the income but they don't. But yes, broadly speaking, I think families should help each other out where they can. All families are different. My nana had all 12 of her grandchildren well into their teens and when she became infirm all 12 of those grandchildren took on care and visitation responsibilities gladly-including the ones who were still teenagers. At 12 when my grandfather started with dementia I would go places with him to make sure he got home. It wasn't a burden, they were my grandparents and we were so close because of all the time they had me growing up. I'd like that with my grandchildren. You are right, you shouldn't expect it but it would be nice.

@Dinoteeth I think that's it. They are just a little bit too old now. When he's a little older I think they will take him more / feel more confident.

Robinni · 07/05/2022 08:55

@Snowiscold did you read @Arthursmom’s post?

  • Grandparents live close.
  • There is disparity in terms of care provision - GP is taking nephew 2 days per week and one overnight. Doing nothing for @Arthursmom this is favouring one C/GC over the other. Not cool.
  • They are in an emergency situation due to covid reducing child care availability.
We had to rely on family - not GP - through covid as DC not able to go to childcare (CV/SEN) I’ve had to switch to WFH now but am hoping the single GP we have will be able to cover a few afternoons per wk to help support DC and allow me to go back to work properly, if child care was an option I’d take it.
Dinoteeth · 07/05/2022 08:32

@Mamanyt thats just being awkward, if you don't want to babysit just be honest.

@Arthursmom that just seems so unfair from the ILs but they maybe don't feel as fit as they were. Does your mum help you?

@Nanof8 sorry to hear about your DD. But you sound a fab Nan.

Snowiscold · 07/05/2022 08:26

Even a day every 2 weeks would help.

Another one! A day every two weeks would be a lot. You would expect grandparents to travel maybe hundreds of miles to help with childcare? You would expect them to cut their hours at work and go part-time?

Arthursmom · 07/05/2022 08:15

This is very interesting. I guess you just say no. If it was me I'd want to spend as much time with my grandchildren as is humanly possible and if it helped my kids, all the better. That said, I have traveled extensively and, to me, no pyramid or sea view has every compared to a day with my son. Each to their own. We have no help from GPs on a regular basis but they do come visit and we visit them. They are very close. It's a lovely relationship. I won't lie though! We are surrounded by people with tons of support and I am jealous. Even a day every 2 weeks would help. I will say that it breeds resentment if there are different situations between families also-ILs had SILs children for 20 years every week day and many weekends. My own mother has my nephew 2 days and one overnight a week. It feels unfair but hey ho. Probably wouldn't feel so bad if we could get him into nursery but we've been on the waiting lists over a year now and it's still a years wait (covid baby boom in out city means they are struggling for childcare places and school places).

WalkingOnTheCracks · 07/05/2022 08:09

LuckySantangelo35 · 06/05/2022 20:42

“I can think of very little I'd rather do with my retirement than spend a fair amount of it looking after my grandchildren.
I just wish my married son didn't live so far away.”

i think you need to broaden your horizons and use your imagination!

There’s loads you could do!

Go travelling, take up a hobby, spend more time friends, go to exercise classes, etc etc

It’s very kind of you to suggest those things.

If i were to list all the things I’ve done in the last sixty years - which I won’t - you would see, I think, why - for me - retirement isn’t about expanding horizons and embracing long-delayed interests. It’s about cutting back involvements, disengaging from activities and focussing only the two or three things that I most want to do.

And, looking back, the most enjoyable, worthwhile and rewarding thing I did was bring up kids. Which is why I’d love to give some time to being part of that now.

Mamanyt · 07/05/2022 06:48

Probably the best way to keep from being the "go-to" option in child care is, barring real emergency, give a qualified "no" the first time you are asked. "I'm sorry, that isn't convenient, but I can certainly do it Monday or Tuesday of next week! Then sprinkle those "noes" in until the thinking is "Gran will do it if she isn't busy" instead of, "Well, of course Gran will drop everything and do it!"

Nanof8 · 07/05/2022 02:28

I think just depends on your family and how close (distance) you are. My parents lived a 6-7 hour drive away. My older kids would go there for school holidays. 2 months in summer a week or so at Christmas and during spring break.

For my younger one they lived in the same town and looked after my son 4-5 days a week while I worked.

When they went somewhere I had alternate care. Now I am retired and my daughter just had her first and I'm looking forward to being her daycare next year. But I also have full guardianship of my 2 year-old grandson (his mother passed away) so having another little around won't be much different than usual.

Dinoteeth · 07/05/2022 01:56

Family support in old age is very important that I totally agree. Even actually getting carers organised etc. Attending frequent hospital visits etc.

I know I'd be more willing to reduce my working hours to support the people who supported me than to support people who didn't.

Robinni · 07/05/2022 01:35

@echt

Maybe they'll see any lack of support in their age as not part of the social contract and leave you out of the will.

Too late by this point; have seen people get cross that they aren’t getting the attention they feel they deserve and try and change the will at eleventh hour - family has a strong case they are of diminished responsibility or under undue influence so original will stands.

@Dinoteeth correct care home you are talking £40-50k per year fees, most cannot afford it - even on great pensions - without dipping into savings, selling home or getting family to pay. Several ways to avoid and prevent the stress but too off topic.

@BossyFlossie76 you are right - the ones who have family support have nice meals made for them, days out, company, chat and vibrancy. The ones without get a brief carer visit are provided with a microwave meal, cup of tea, toilet break and a 2 minute conversation because that’s all that is there - and that is for people with high needs!! Until they go into a home and either isolate in room or have to sit in enforced socialisation or activities. I know which I would prefer for myself and my family.

Longleggedgiraffe · 07/05/2022 01:22

Sorry, but they're your children and the buck stops with you. By all means ask if they' can babysit, but be prepared for a refusal. I'm sure they'd be more than
happy to help in an emergency but they've done their bit raising you.

Dinoteeth · 07/05/2022 01:10

echt · 07/05/2022 01:02

Think about yet another way.

Maybe they'll see any lack of support in their age as not part of the social contract and leave you out of the will.

If they needed a care home they'll not be much to be left to leave in a will anyway.

BossyFlossie76 · 07/05/2022 01:05

Onlyforcake · 06/05/2022 16:29

Its so important to maintain good boundaries. I work in care, its never ideal when families are involved in the hands on stuff. That works for children and the elderly. I will always a avoid GPs being responsible for my children for any amount of time AND thankfully my parents are very responsible and can afford their future care needs.

Sorry that you don't believe care workers actually care and are worth looking after your family members, be sure to get yourself trained up.

Obviously a slight tangent from the thread- I have to respectfully disagree, in my (significant) professional experience- family/informal carers are worth their weight in gold. I recommend a peek at Triangle of Care training, for some info on their value.

I’ve mentioned in my other comments, I have full time paid childcare as an option- I still choose our parents. Additionally, our parents are well able to cover any paid care needed- but you can bet your bottom dollar that I will be taking the lead, and that in doing so I will achieve the best possible care for them.

echt · 07/05/2022 01:02

Dinoteeth · 07/05/2022 00:43

Think about it a different way.

With little family support it isn't worthwhile me working full time and paying extra tax and childcare.
At some point as my kids get bigger and age out of childcare i may well decide that if makes financial sense for me to return to fulltime work and try to save for my old age, get more money into my pension. I don't really want to work to 67.

At some point the parents are going to need support. Not just yet but it will happen.

What comes first, topping up my own savings, with the hope that i get to retire at some point or supporting the people who retired at 60, and had multiple holidays per year and were too busy holidaying to help when our kids were really little?

Think about yet another way.

Maybe they'll see any lack of support in their age as not part of the social contract and leave you out of the will.

Robinni · 07/05/2022 00:52

LuckySantangelo35 · 07/05/2022 00:19

@Robinni

Of course, it’s a perfectly valid choice for a man or woman to make.

All I’m saying is that it should be just that - a choice made by the grandparents.

Not an expectation or pressure on them by their sons/daughters as often seems to be the case.

You hear tales of that all the time on here - sons/daughters withholding access to grandchildren if grandparents do not do exactly as they wish or threatening to abandon them in old age if they don’t sacrifice all their time and energy to providing childcare so that the kids parents can go to work.

So long as it’s a choice that’s fine, if someone feels undress or emotionally blackmailed or whatever - not fine

I don’t think there should be an expectation about providing childcare. But a discussion about what is reasonable and practically possible prior to birth of children.

I find a lot of these comments bizarre about never seeing grandchildren and people being very disconnected from family. But there may be regional differences across the U.K. in terms of how close knit families are and differences of cultural values.

As I said before, sacrificing all free time and being held hostage as the only childcare provider is completely unreasonable unless expressly wished for.

But equally, disconnecting yourself from family, making no effort to have a relationship with grandchildren, contributing nothing to the family as a whole so that you can go off and have a second teenagehood in old age without a care in the world…. Well it’s a bit cold.

To then expect family - including grandchildren you have no relationship with - to pick up the pieces whenever ill health and frailty sets in is unreasonable…. No matter how much money someone has, unless they die suddenly, there will be help required, this can be intensive during the transitional period - when in and out of hospital/trying to remain at home/waiting for a home place. And remains persistant even when they’re in the home - errands continue, organising their house etc, bills, dealing with care home, personal care etc etc….

Sooo for someone to bugger off essentially from the family for 20-30 years on a pleasure cruise of life and then expect highly intensive care such as this is extremely entitled…. Taking care of and organising provision for a fully grown adult is very much more labour intensive and difficult by comparison to a few kids for a few hours a week - imagine your toddler having a tantrum were 5ft8 and 12 stone…

BossyFlossie76 · 07/05/2022 00:46

Quite the opposite of transactional in my view…we like looking after each other and being with each other! That translates into childcare in the sense that it frees me up several days of the week. I find it enriching for all involved.

[NB: I could cope without any help from family, I work nights, have a Husband, and also have full time paid childcare provision…there is a boring reason I have that perk- I’m just demonstrating that it’s a choice for us to trust our children to our parents a regularly].

I was making a link between feeling like you’re too busy/uninterested to look after your family, don’t then expect hands on care if and you need it, surely? If the caregiving/receiving relationship ends with childhood!?

It’s my opinion that we are all committed to each other in a lifelong way, and if one party checks out of that- doesn’t it break down? That’s totally fine if that’s the dynamic, there is one grandparent not involved for this very reason.

I appreciate there may be practical barriers to grandparents providing childcare, and that it could never work for all- but I don’t quite understand how the desire wouldn’t be there. I hope I get to help raise (or co-raise as I think you put it) my grand babies one day.

Dinoteeth · 07/05/2022 00:43

Think about it a different way.

With little family support it isn't worthwhile me working full time and paying extra tax and childcare.
At some point as my kids get bigger and age out of childcare i may well decide that if makes financial sense for me to return to fulltime work and try to save for my old age, get more money into my pension. I don't really want to work to 67.

At some point the parents are going to need support. Not just yet but it will happen.

What comes first, topping up my own savings, with the hope that i get to retire at some point or supporting the people who retired at 60, and had multiple holidays per year and were too busy holidaying to help when our kids were really little?

LuckySantangelo35 · 07/05/2022 00:22

BossyFlossie76 · 07/05/2022 00:02

Super surprised by some of the attitudes, didn’t realise our situation was so pleasant!

I struggle to fit in all the grandparents and aunties that want to care for my children…to the point that I’ve had to earmark Fridays as “my” day with them!

My in laws moved to our village to help us.

I will of course care for these relatives in their old age, and I hope a lot of these family members [commenting they’ve no interest in caring for people that aren’t their children] are prepared to throw themselves at the mercy of paid for care when the time comes…

@BossyFlossie76

Dont see what the connection is between providing childcare for your grandchildren and using paid care when older, can you elaborate?

providing free childcare for your grankids is no guarantee that their parents will care for you in their old age.

Also, if your parents gave you a good enough, loving upbringing isn’t that enough?! Or do they have to co-bring up your kids for you in order to earn some regard when they are older?! Sounds so cold and transactional

LuckySantangelo35 · 07/05/2022 00:19

@Robinni

Of course, it’s a perfectly valid choice for a man or woman to make.

All I’m saying is that it should be just that - a choice made by the grandparents.

Not an expectation or pressure on them by their sons/daughters as often seems to be the case.

You hear tales of that all the time on here - sons/daughters withholding access to grandchildren if grandparents do not do exactly as they wish or threatening to abandon them in old age if they don’t sacrifice all their time and energy to providing childcare so that the kids parents can go to work.

So long as it’s a choice that’s fine, if someone feels undress or emotionally blackmailed or whatever - not fine

LuckySantangelo35 · 07/05/2022 00:15

Autienotnaughtie · 06/05/2022 22:15

@LuckySantangelo35 love your name. Great books 👍

@Autienotnaughtie

Thank you! They sure are 😀

BossyFlossie76 · 07/05/2022 00:02

Super surprised by some of the attitudes, didn’t realise our situation was so pleasant!

I struggle to fit in all the grandparents and aunties that want to care for my children…to the point that I’ve had to earmark Fridays as “my” day with them!

My in laws moved to our village to help us.

I will of course care for these relatives in their old age, and I hope a lot of these family members [commenting they’ve no interest in caring for people that aren’t their children] are prepared to throw themselves at the mercy of paid for care when the time comes…

Doje · 06/05/2022 22:32

My parents always made it clear that they would not be there for regular childcare. It just came up in conversation. Tbf I would never have expected it, but mum would always say 'I'm going to be 'fun' nanny. Not for regular stuff'. And she's been true to her word. Again, anything we get is a bonus, but they're great at taking the DC's for a couple of days during the school holidays. They kids love it. They get chocolate in bed and full on fun days out.

Justrestingmyeyes1 · 06/05/2022 22:24

Husband took early retirement last month and I will do the same next summer. We planned to sell and move to the coast (having been looking at houses) Our first grandchild is due in 6 weeks so mum will return to work next summer. They are looking to buy their first home and with the cost of properties, there is no way they can realistically afford childcare too so we have changed our plans and will stay here to look after the baby. We’re happy to do it as we are still only mid 50s so still have time to do what we want in a few years.

Swipe left for the next trending thread