Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents not wanting to do childcare...

485 replies

Chewchewaboogiw · 04/05/2022 23:32

Have been thinking about several people I know whose planned retirememt or part time work has been changed as they have been asked to do childcare for their dgc and now they are doing chikdcare say 3 days a week instead of their plan to travel. And not massively happy about it ( in one case another.baby due also)..I have seen a post response recently that said that they take dgc out but they are not there for childcare. If you dont do childcare for your dgc how did you say no?( I am not in that position at present but i can imagine it would be hard work ..) I would imagine / fear adult ds would be hurt if they were told no dont want to do chikdcare and cant imagine how it would be phrased in a positive way.. anyone said no and is it bu to say you dont want to ... or is it now expected. I know that all families.different, am just asking about families who are comfortable in saying no .

OP posts:
WildCoasts · 08/05/2022 00:22

Robinni · 07/05/2022 12:36

@LuckySantangelo35

Most extra help with kids is in the early years. By the time they are about 7 not much is required. Most kids are born within a few years of each other and most people have no more than 2-3 kids.

Are you seriously saying most people couldn’t do an afternoon or a day a week to spend time with their grandchildren, and to support their offspring to further their career? I would want my child to lose out, to have less of a pension etc because I wanted to go and get nails done.

Old age goes on a hell of a lot longer than the few years grandparents generally help out.

I see in my social circle people who have grandparents on board are jumping far ahead of others - better career, nicer house, nicer cars. More stability for the family as a whole - that includes the grandparents who may need them to pay for things in the long run (even with nice cushy pension and savings).

I perceive I will have quite a few years to “prioritise myself” but I don’t want to do that to the exclusion of supporting my family….

I guess we have to agree that we have different priorities.

But you might not have quite a few years. I'm not even 50 and two of my friends have died from illnesses and I've seen that disabiliity, that stops people doing all the things they have put off, can stop those delayed plans. I've seen other people I know more casually retire only to have their partner die within a year. Cancer in each case. Time is not a given for any of us. We don't know how much time we have and shouldn't take it for granted. You can't count on being able bodied or even alive for as long as you think. This is something life has taught me that wouldn't have crossed my mind when my family was young. I am very aware of the need to do things now or maybe never do them at all.

I think the comment that GPs that don't watch their children are doing things like getting their nails done says it all. I'm out in the forest looking after my physical and mental health, so hopefully I'll stay healthier longer. I'm caring for teenagers. I'm making sure my dogs are walked, because they need that and I'm responsible for their needs. I chose to have them, so they are my responsibility. I'm going to the occasional social event which I couldn't do when I was raising mine.

Not do those things so that someone can advance their career? No thanks. They chose their career and to have children. I delayed my career to care for my children, I chose to SAH because that's what I valued and I had the choice. If I couldn't have afforded that I'd have delayed children till such a time as I could. We're all responsible for our own choices. If you want kids and career, pay for childcare. Did your parents get any say into whether you conceived a baby? I doubt it. If it was going too affect their life so much, they should get a say into whether it happens.

I'm not saying I wouldn't do childcare but I don't feel it is an obligation. In the end, I value family most and that is where my priorities lie. But I matter too.

I think it is shocking that someone thinks they can decide to have children and expect me to adjust my life to meet their needs. If someone has those kind of expectations and can't do it without me, they need to talk to me before those children are conceived instead of making decisions for my life on my behalf. The expectation that your parents should alter their life to serve your family choices and material needs is very entitled.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 08/05/2022 00:01

I know a couple in their 70's who have been roped in to go and pick kids up from home, drop at school, pick up after school, take them to the playground as parents working from home and drop them off at a given time. Every single day!
They resent this but said they felt they couldn't say no as they might then not get to see the grandkids. Absolutely selfish of their daughter imo.

Autienotnaughtie · 07/05/2022 13:45

@Robinni completely true I found myself in the position of caring for my terminally ill dm , my dgf who was end of life whilst raising a toddler. In the end I had to give up work to manage it all. I don't regret it because families should support one another. I will help with any gc I am blessed with to make life easier for my children.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 07/05/2022 13:42

Arthursmom · 07/05/2022 08:15

This is very interesting. I guess you just say no. If it was me I'd want to spend as much time with my grandchildren as is humanly possible and if it helped my kids, all the better. That said, I have traveled extensively and, to me, no pyramid or sea view has every compared to a day with my son. Each to their own. We have no help from GPs on a regular basis but they do come visit and we visit them. They are very close. It's a lovely relationship. I won't lie though! We are surrounded by people with tons of support and I am jealous. Even a day every 2 weeks would help. I will say that it breeds resentment if there are different situations between families also-ILs had SILs children for 20 years every week day and many weekends. My own mother has my nephew 2 days and one overnight a week. It feels unfair but hey ho. Probably wouldn't feel so bad if we could get him into nursery but we've been on the waiting lists over a year now and it's still a years wait (covid baby boom in out city means they are struggling for childcare places and school places).

Phew. Not just me then.

RachaelN · 07/05/2022 13:17

My parents helped a little when mine were small ISH. But once in school nothing regular. Occasionally we ask for the odd night so we can out to a comedy show or do. We always expect the answer no though as we never see it as a right.

Mamanyt · 07/05/2022 13:10

@Dinoteeth It shouldn't be, and you may be fine with babysitting, but NOT want to become the fallback position and feel obligated. My suggestion simply puts it on "I'll babysit when it is convenient" terms.

Robinni · 07/05/2022 12:36

LuckySantangelo35 · 07/05/2022 12:06

But why should people have to commit to regular childcare so that parents don’t have to pay for it?

you can still help out and have a good relationship with your family including grandparents and not have to commit to a
day a week childcare whilst parents work.

is there really no point in life as a parent where you can prioritise yourself for a few years?

@LuckySantangelo35

Most extra help with kids is in the early years. By the time they are about 7 not much is required. Most kids are born within a few years of each other and most people have no more than 2-3 kids.

Are you seriously saying most people couldn’t do an afternoon or a day a week to spend time with their grandchildren, and to support their offspring to further their career? I would want my child to lose out, to have less of a pension etc because I wanted to go and get nails done.

Old age goes on a hell of a lot longer than the few years grandparents generally help out.

I see in my social circle people who have grandparents on board are jumping far ahead of others - better career, nicer house, nicer cars. More stability for the family as a whole - that includes the grandparents who may need them to pay for things in the long run (even with nice cushy pension and savings).

I perceive I will have quite a few years to “prioritise myself” but I don’t want to do that to the exclusion of supporting my family….

I guess we have to agree that we have different priorities.

TrippinEdBalls · 07/05/2022 12:18

LuckySantangelo35 · 07/05/2022 11:12

@Robinni

so what are you saying exactly then?

That people can only expect any form of support in old age if they provided extensive childcare for the grandkids to the extent that their parents didn’t have to rely on paid childcare solely? Lots of people simply don’t want that level of commitment in their older years!

Does that entitle people to the mentality ‘oh my parents didn’t look after my kids so I could go to work, so now they need help - fuck them!”

if that was the attitude then grandparents would be more than justified in leaving all their inheritance elsewhere- fuck them. Works both ways!

I don’t know when it didn’t become good enough to provide your kids with a good childhood - now you have to do it all over again for the grandkids or risk being disregarded as if you were a piece of rubbish. Very entitled generation.

But I think all of those things are optional:
Grandparents providing childcare
Adult children providing care for elderly parents
Parents leaving inheritance to non-dependent children

The only thing that is compulsory - and indeed mandated by law - is ensuring that the needs of your own children are met while they're dependents. Everything beyond that is good will, and no one is owed anything for fulfilling that obligation.

In practice of course most families do much more than that, and mine certainly does. But it is normally, and should be, give and take once everyone's adults. I would never have considered that if my parents hadn't offered childcare that would have meant I would have then not helped them as they aged - I love them. But then the fact they did offer, willingly and happily, feels like a general reflection of a relationship where we help each other and support each other as we can, and it's that that I want to continue and reciprocate as they age and need me more.

I know people whose parents have a 'I've done my time so I now owe you nothing' attitude and it's the attitude, not the specifics of what they do or don't offer in terms of childcare, that would make me feel reluctant to put myself out for them in return if that was how my parents felt (though I do find it hard to imagine my parents being like that, so perhaps I'm wrong about how I'd feel in return).

LuckySantangelo35 · 07/05/2022 12:06

But why should people have to commit to regular childcare so that parents don’t have to pay for it?

you can still help out and have a good relationship with your family including grandparents and not have to commit to a
day a week childcare whilst parents work.

is there really no point in life as a parent where you can prioritise yourself for a few years?

Robinni · 07/05/2022 11:58

LuckySantangelo35 · 07/05/2022 11:12

@Robinni

so what are you saying exactly then?

That people can only expect any form of support in old age if they provided extensive childcare for the grandkids to the extent that their parents didn’t have to rely on paid childcare solely? Lots of people simply don’t want that level of commitment in their older years!

Does that entitle people to the mentality ‘oh my parents didn’t look after my kids so I could go to work, so now they need help - fuck them!”

if that was the attitude then grandparents would be more than justified in leaving all their inheritance elsewhere- fuck them. Works both ways!

I don’t know when it didn’t become good enough to provide your kids with a good childhood - now you have to do it all over again for the grandkids or risk being disregarded as if you were a piece of rubbish. Very entitled generation.

@LuckySantangelo35

Personal and professional observation has been that those who maintained close family ties tended to have a much greater level of family support.

That’s all I am saying.

People need to be aware that if they do not maintain a relationship and provide zero support there is less chance that children/grandchildren will be there day in day out to cope in the end. It’s very hard work.

As I said before by the time people realise they are getting their just desserts and try to change their will they find they can’t because family will argue undue influence and incapable.

Never said childcare should be extensive, but that saying “I won’t help you ever” while perfectly fit and well, is a bit selfish.

It’s like that friend who never makes an effort, never sees you and is generally unpleasant… you aren’t going to be arsed going out of your way for them.

Robinni · 07/05/2022 11:44

LuckySantangelo35 · 07/05/2022 10:47

Lol I don’t peel and part boil potatoes for my own dinner! You can buy them ready made.

organising carers isn’t something so massive and time consuming that it should only be done if your parents provided loads of childcare for the grandparents , ffs

@LuckySantangelo35

How many people with cancer have you had in your life? How many with dementia? Osteoporosis? Heart disease? Infirm?

How many assessments have you gone through? How many attendance allowance forms? How about arguments with utility companies, rates, sorting gardeners, cleaners, hairdressers and of course additional carers when you would like to sleep through the night and get peace.

What about a weekly shop to buy these ready made potatoes you speak of. How about having to call by their home a few times a day to check on them, give them an extra toilet break and deliver their groceries - they won’t remember everything by the way so you’ll have to be at shop at least 3x a week. How about having to go buy extra clothes for them as they keep spilling their dinner and soiling themselves.

How about counselling them repeatedly because they don’t like the carers or because the carers are changed so frequently they get upset. Never mind all the other times they get upset because they are losing their independence.

Oh and then there’s the hospital appointments, the late night ambulance calls etc etc.….

Organising a persons life and care is enormously time consuming when they are 5-7 years off death. Often you have several relatives at once to deal with too….

dottiedodah · 07/05/2022 11:44

CinnamonjellyBeans Why if you didnt travel when younger does it mean you wont start now FFS! More people aged 65 plus are going for their holiday of a lifetime! We have been to US when younger, and hope to again.I have always decorated Cakes, and seen friends for lunch (still do) Many people are working still ,and cant get 3 or 4 weeks plus to travel. Hence waiting until retired, when they have free time . Why do women who are Grandmas have to be expected to provide childcare for life ? Why cant they have a life of their own ?

LuckySantangelo35 · 07/05/2022 11:12

Robinni · 07/05/2022 11:03

@LuckySantangelo35

i think you are assuming that all people desperately want to be cared for by family when infirm. Lots don’t, they don’t want their family witness to their indignity etc and wouldn’t want that burden on their family so would actually prefer care form NHS/paid care.
**
also what is so wrong about going on a “pleasure cruise of life”?! Isn’t that what life is for? To enjoy when you can? If your parents gave you a great childhood would you really begrudge them going on cruises and that kind of when they were retired rather than look after your kids for you?!

With respect you are being incredibly naive regarding care in old age via private or NHS.

Everyone and I mean EVERYONE I have cared for in a personal and professional capacity has required family support during the transition from able bodied to infirm in a care home. Everyone.

Prior to going into a home paying a care assistant/PA you are talking £15-£20 per hour minimum which is fine if you have it - however carers are not available - it is a poorly paid profession and there is a staffing crisis.

None of the people I have cared for personally or professionally wanted to have family involved, but they needed family involved because they could not cope and care is not available instantly.

I don’t know how I can make it any clearer. People are waiting up to a year to get into a home because somebody else has to die for a place to be available.

To qualify to get in your needs have to be assessed - you have to qualify to be there - which means you go through a period of gradual deterioration at home first. Only those with high needs (usually wheelchair bound) qualify for 5 visits a day - this is 15-20 mins 3x a day and two other visits for toileting/check maybe 5 mins…. They have serious falls and there are a lot of accidents as they can’t wait long enough for the carer to arrive to take them to the loo.

It does not matter how much money you have. How intent you are to be independent. How tremendously capable you have been through life. Without family around to help you the existence is utterly miserable.

Carers don’t want it that way but the system is massively under funded and slow and paperwork heavy.

@Robinni

so what are you saying exactly then?

That people can only expect any form of support in old age if they provided extensive childcare for the grandkids to the extent that their parents didn’t have to rely on paid childcare solely? Lots of people simply don’t want that level of commitment in their older years!

Does that entitle people to the mentality ‘oh my parents didn’t look after my kids so I could go to work, so now they need help - fuck them!”

if that was the attitude then grandparents would be more than justified in leaving all their inheritance elsewhere- fuck them. Works both ways!

I don’t know when it didn’t become good enough to provide your kids with a good childhood - now you have to do it all over again for the grandkids or risk being disregarded as if you were a piece of rubbish. Very entitled generation.

Robinni · 07/05/2022 11:10

@LuckySantangelo35

appears to be a glitch on formatting in my previous post….

All this oh your parents gave you a great life so they should F off, never see you and lounge about.

I’m sorry but my Grandparents went to various clubs, had active social lives, they went on several holidays a year. My parent is away a few times a month…. They felt/feel that helping out enriched/es their lives and they want/ed to build a relationship with Grandchildren. I don’t know why people are arguing so strongly against normal human interaction and support of family members. I am looking forward to myself.

Having a life and pursuing interests in retirement should not mean that you have to forget about being part of your family and caring. Some will do so more than others.

Robinni · 07/05/2022 11:03

@LuckySantangelo35

i think you are assuming that all people desperately want to be cared for by family when infirm. Lots don’t, they don’t want their family witness to their indignity etc and wouldn’t want that burden on their family so would actually prefer care form NHS/paid care.
**
also what is so wrong about going on a “pleasure cruise of life”?! Isn’t that what life is for? To enjoy when you can? If your parents gave you a great childhood would you really begrudge them going on cruises and that kind of when they were retired rather than look after your kids for you?!

With respect you are being incredibly naive regarding care in old age via private or NHS.

Everyone and I mean EVERYONE I have cared for in a personal and professional capacity has required family support during the transition from able bodied to infirm in a care home. Everyone.

Prior to going into a home paying a care assistant/PA you are talking £15-£20 per hour minimum which is fine if you have it - however carers are not available - it is a poorly paid profession and there is a staffing crisis.

None of the people I have cared for personally or professionally wanted to have family involved, but they needed family involved because they could not cope and care is not available instantly.

I don’t know how I can make it any clearer. People are waiting up to a year to get into a home because somebody else has to die for a place to be available.

To qualify to get in your needs have to be assessed - you have to qualify to be there - which means you go through a period of gradual deterioration at home first. Only those with high needs (usually wheelchair bound) qualify for 5 visits a day - this is 15-20 mins 3x a day and two other visits for toileting/check maybe 5 mins…. They have serious falls and there are a lot of accidents as they can’t wait long enough for the carer to arrive to take them to the loo.

It does not matter how much money you have. How intent you are to be independent. How tremendously capable you have been through life. Without family around to help you the existence is utterly miserable.

Carers don’t want it that way but the system is massively under funded and slow and paperwork heavy.

LuckySantangelo35 · 07/05/2022 10:59

Dinoteeth · 07/05/2022 10:21

I do get it when age plays a part in what childcare grandparents can offer. But i really don't agree with giving your all to one child and little to the other.

That just breeds resentment

Agree on that point

Rincewind1213 · 07/05/2022 10:59

Curious. Of the grandparents here, did your parents look after your own children when you were a parent yourself. Has that altered your perspective on how you contribute to supporting your own children with their childcare? I only ask because my mother relied heavily on my grandparents for childcare when I was little. However when my son was little she announced that she would not become childcare for me (I didn’t ask.) Whilst I was totally fine with that (it’s her life) it did few a little hypocritical. She often talked about how she wouldn’t have got by without my grandparents help yet made it very clear that no such help would be forthcoming for me. I wasn’t expecting help anyway but it did feel a little jarring.

LuckySantangelo35 · 07/05/2022 10:57

echt · 07/05/2022 01:02

Think about yet another way.

Maybe they'll see any lack of support in their age as not part of the social contract and leave you out of the will.

Very true!

LuckySantangelo35 · 07/05/2022 10:47

Dinoteeth · 07/05/2022 10:29

@LuckySantangelo35 who organises the care for elderly frail people. Very often its family or friends who actually have to recognise the need and organise getting carers in.
Council carers might do 3x 10min visits to sort food, who's actually doing the shopping, peeling the potatos, part boiling them, so they can be plonked on a plate in less than 10mins.

Lol I don’t peel and part boil potatoes for my own dinner! You can buy them ready made.

organising carers isn’t something so massive and time consuming that it should only be done if your parents provided loads of childcare for the grandparents , ffs

SunSparkle · 07/05/2022 10:45

The best thing you can do is make it clear. We told both sets of grandparents we had no expectations of childcare from them. One of the grannies said she wanted to do one day a week. For months we said are you sure etc etc it’s hard work, a long day, baby likes to be out and about etc. She kept saying yes that’s fine I want to do it. And then at the last second pulled out saying she thought it was too much work, too long a day, didn’t want to leave the dog, leaving us scrambling to find a nursery that could do the extra days. It was stressful and totally avoidable. We went into having a child budgeting for the childcare we needed and had planned accordingly. Also our daughter has a weird relationship with those grandparents - they don’t seem to settle in each others company - I’m glad it worked out that they weren’t doing a day a week in the end. I think it would have come to a swift end quite quickly leaving us on a sticky situation trying to get another day care.

OutsideLookingOut · 07/05/2022 10:45

LuckySantangelo35 · 07/05/2022 09:44

So in your view when you become a mother you literally sign up to caring for children forever more or less then? You care for your own kids and then you have to devote yourselves to your grandkids. Until you become too infirm/unwell to do anything anymore. And they you may MAY be looked after by your son/daughter if they deemed you selfless and giving enough (but no guarantee)

At what point in that trajectory do someone have time to dedicate to themselves?? To go travelling on a whim for weeks on end, maybe live abroad for a bit, or have holiday home, to take up new hobbies, classses, whatever. Not when they have their own kids, not when they have grandkids, not when they’re too old to look after grankids cos they’re be too infirm then - so when??!

so basically you have to sacrifice your entire life when you become a mother is what you’re saying??

Sadly it seems this is what many people think. There is a story about a grandmother like this in the book Honeycomb. Really made me think.

Dinoteeth · 07/05/2022 10:29

@LuckySantangelo35 who organises the care for elderly frail people. Very often its family or friends who actually have to recognise the need and organise getting carers in.
Council carers might do 3x 10min visits to sort food, who's actually doing the shopping, peeling the potatos, part boiling them, so they can be plonked on a plate in less than 10mins.

Dinoteeth · 07/05/2022 10:21

I do get it when age plays a part in what childcare grandparents can offer. But i really don't agree with giving your all to one child and little to the other.

That just breeds resentment

LuckySantangelo35 · 07/05/2022 10:13

Robinni · 07/05/2022 00:52

I don’t think there should be an expectation about providing childcare. But a discussion about what is reasonable and practically possible prior to birth of children.

I find a lot of these comments bizarre about never seeing grandchildren and people being very disconnected from family. But there may be regional differences across the U.K. in terms of how close knit families are and differences of cultural values.

As I said before, sacrificing all free time and being held hostage as the only childcare provider is completely unreasonable unless expressly wished for.

But equally, disconnecting yourself from family, making no effort to have a relationship with grandchildren, contributing nothing to the family as a whole so that you can go off and have a second teenagehood in old age without a care in the world…. Well it’s a bit cold.

To then expect family - including grandchildren you have no relationship with - to pick up the pieces whenever ill health and frailty sets in is unreasonable…. No matter how much money someone has, unless they die suddenly, there will be help required, this can be intensive during the transitional period - when in and out of hospital/trying to remain at home/waiting for a home place. And remains persistant even when they’re in the home - errands continue, organising their house etc, bills, dealing with care home, personal care etc etc….

Sooo for someone to bugger off essentially from the family for 20-30 years on a pleasure cruise of life and then expect highly intensive care such as this is extremely entitled…. Taking care of and organising provision for a fully grown adult is very much more labour intensive and difficult by comparison to a few kids for a few hours a week - imagine your toddler having a tantrum were 5ft8 and 12 stone…

@Robinni

i think you are assuming that all people desperately want to be cared for by family when infirm. Lots don’t, they don’t want their family witness to their indignity etc and wouldn’t want that burden on their family so would actually prefer care form NHS/paid care.

also what is so wrong about going on a “pleasure cruise of life”?! Isn’t that what life is for? To enjoy when you can? If your parents gave you a great childhood would you really begrudge them going on cruises and that kind of when they were retired rather than look after your kids for you?!

Robinni · 07/05/2022 09:44

@Snowiscold

All this hysteria, cutting work hours, driving 100s of miles… dramarama…

The couple in question live a 30-40 min drive away (I wonder how long it takes them to drive to tesco? 🤔), are fully retired with ample income.

They are providing a lot of care for another grandchild while not supporting @Arthursmom which is favouritism and disadvantaging one of their children over the other breeding resentment and family discord..

Even old people can be dicks sometimes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread