Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents not wanting to do childcare...

485 replies

Chewchewaboogiw · 04/05/2022 23:32

Have been thinking about several people I know whose planned retirememt or part time work has been changed as they have been asked to do childcare for their dgc and now they are doing chikdcare say 3 days a week instead of their plan to travel. And not massively happy about it ( in one case another.baby due also)..I have seen a post response recently that said that they take dgc out but they are not there for childcare. If you dont do childcare for your dgc how did you say no?( I am not in that position at present but i can imagine it would be hard work ..) I would imagine / fear adult ds would be hurt if they were told no dont want to do chikdcare and cant imagine how it would be phrased in a positive way.. anyone said no and is it bu to say you dont want to ... or is it now expected. I know that all families.different, am just asking about families who are comfortable in saying no .

OP posts:
Robinni · 08/05/2022 08:51

WildCoasts · 08/05/2022 00:22

But you might not have quite a few years. I'm not even 50 and two of my friends have died from illnesses and I've seen that disabiliity, that stops people doing all the things they have put off, can stop those delayed plans. I've seen other people I know more casually retire only to have their partner die within a year. Cancer in each case. Time is not a given for any of us. We don't know how much time we have and shouldn't take it for granted. You can't count on being able bodied or even alive for as long as you think. This is something life has taught me that wouldn't have crossed my mind when my family was young. I am very aware of the need to do things now or maybe never do them at all.

I think the comment that GPs that don't watch their children are doing things like getting their nails done says it all. I'm out in the forest looking after my physical and mental health, so hopefully I'll stay healthier longer. I'm caring for teenagers. I'm making sure my dogs are walked, because they need that and I'm responsible for their needs. I chose to have them, so they are my responsibility. I'm going to the occasional social event which I couldn't do when I was raising mine.

Not do those things so that someone can advance their career? No thanks. They chose their career and to have children. I delayed my career to care for my children, I chose to SAH because that's what I valued and I had the choice. If I couldn't have afforded that I'd have delayed children till such a time as I could. We're all responsible for our own choices. If you want kids and career, pay for childcare. Did your parents get any say into whether you conceived a baby? I doubt it. If it was going too affect their life so much, they should get a say into whether it happens.

I'm not saying I wouldn't do childcare but I don't feel it is an obligation. In the end, I value family most and that is where my priorities lie. But I matter too.

I think it is shocking that someone thinks they can decide to have children and expect me to adjust my life to meet their needs. If someone has those kind of expectations and can't do it without me, they need to talk to me before those children are conceived instead of making decisions for my life on my behalf. The expectation that your parents should alter their life to serve your family choices and material needs is very entitled.

Dear God…

@WildCoasts

I am disabled. My DS is disabled. Some of my friends have been diagnosed with cancer in their teens. Some have died in their 20s and 30s. It crossed my mind at a very early age that I should not put things off and delay plans. That I should try and enjoy my life. Older people do not have a monopoly on death and disablement such that they can use it to be totally selfish.

My friends with disabilities/impending death did not run around with a “it’s all about me” agenda, nor have I - I have still cared for several people and developed relationships because I love my family and it gives me fulfilment to contribute to others. That is ok.

All of this focus on plans is coming from people who have spent their whole life being entitled and now have ample pensions to facilitate said plans - some of your contemporaries are still working into their 70s and 80s.

I'm making sure my dogs are walked, because they need that and I'm responsible for their needs. I chose to have them, so they are my responsibility.

How you feel about your dogs is how I feel about my DC and potential grandchildren.

I want my DC and GC to be successful and happy and anything I can do, while not compromising my own health and well being, I will do. If I found myself unable to physically help I might consider contributing towards childcare costs, many GP do this too and that is ok too.

My parents were very involved with my choice to have children and very supportive as they had seen me go through several operations, have to accept disability and have several miscarriages. Most daughters will discuss their hopes for a family with one or both parents. I know people who have promised the world and done nothing, and others who have promised nothing but then moved into the house to help in the first 6wks as daughter had a caesarean.

I don’t think anyone truly knows what is possible until the children are born, no matter how much planning they do. I don’t think anyone should be entitled to childcare or expect anything. However, for a GP to purposefully avoid helping out at all, ever -when they are fit and able - seems the exception and not the rule.

Good luck to you and the dogs.

WildCoasts · 08/05/2022 08:29

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 08/05/2022 08:23

I struggle with the other extreme albeit with after school care for older children but too young to have a door key and a weekly early morning so 7-9am.

MIL is adamant she wants to do it, has a fit at any suggestion of an au pair or other carer but is clearly resentful of the tie on her time particularly if arrangements change. She is massively passive aggressive about it and it's doing my head in.

My parents were always very clear there was no way they were getting involved like this.

MIL has no business having a fit about whatever arrangements you want to make. You are the parents, it's your choice.

DurhamDurham · 08/05/2022 08:28

Our youngest daughter was pregnant in her final year at uni, luckily we had just downsized and paid off the mortgage so both me and her dad were able to drop a day at work to help with childcare. We all helped out until she finished uni and her student placements, we looked after our granddaughter from her being a few weeks old. Our daughter didn't want to have to defer (is that the right term?) so went back to uni weeks after giving birth and we all pitched in.

Our granddaughter is almost four now and I've looked after her one day a week (I work the other four) every week, we do more when we can and often have her for sleepovers. My husband does the same, he has her on a different day. She goes to nursery twice a week, our daughter works a four day week too, although she does long days.
Our granddaughter is going to school in September and we're all having a rethink to make sure we can cover drops offs and pick ups.

I honestly wouldn't change a thing, it's been an absolute joy to be part of her life and to spend quality time with her. I also enjoy going to work and having a life outside of being a grandparent so I think I've got the best of both worlds.

I do wonder about young women who don't have help and support, our daughter would likely not have finished uni if she hadn't had hands on help, as well as financial support. She may have ended up on benefits, instead she has a job she enjoys and a life outside of being a mum.

WildCoasts · 08/05/2022 08:27

HistoricMoment · 08/05/2022 05:31

Whyall the hyperbole? Looking after a child one day a week is not going to stop any grandparent from going out to lunch, doing a hobby, going out in the evenings, or even travelling. It's literally 10 hours or less out of the 148 hours of one week.

One day a week is one thing, a lot of posts are talking about more, sometimes much more. I would love to look after a GC one day a week. I can take the to the zoo, to the park, lots of things. I'd love it. That would be my choice and not an obligation though. I'd also expect that if I want to go for a three month cruise (not my thing, just hypothetical) that I would be able to do that and the child's parents would make other arrangements for that time. I could resume when I get back, if the parents want that.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 08/05/2022 08:23

I struggle with the other extreme albeit with after school care for older children but too young to have a door key and a weekly early morning so 7-9am.

MIL is adamant she wants to do it, has a fit at any suggestion of an au pair or other carer but is clearly resentful of the tie on her time particularly if arrangements change. She is massively passive aggressive about it and it's doing my head in.

My parents were always very clear there was no way they were getting involved like this.

Momicrone · 08/05/2022 08:10

Plenty of people hire total strangers, what's wrong with that?

BestDove · 08/05/2022 08:04

Posts like this make me so sad. We get zero grandparent help.

My mum died when I was younger. My dad makes precisely zero effort and then complains when my DC don't want to engage in a monthly FaceTime call with him.

I remember asking him desperately if he'd please watch my 11 month baby for 4 hours so I could go to a job interview I needed. He said no "they [him and step mother] don't do childcare". It's a total lie. They don't do regular childcare as they go on holiday every 6-8 weeks (no exaggeration), but she's got 5 kids herself and countless grandchildren and they are always there for school drop off/pick up/tea/sleepovers!!! I then called him a couple of days after that conversation and begged him to please help me. The answer was still no. I ended up hiring a total stranger from a babysitting agency, so dbs checked etc, but a total random person. I took the babysitter and my baby to the office building where my interview was. I gave her money for a coffee and asked her to walk around the area and meet me back at the reception in an hour. I got the job and it was a godsend.

My heart still breaks whenever I think of that situation though. I never asked for help before and I haven't asked since.

My dear mum would be absolutely furious with him. He's a shit dad since she died and a total irrelevant, non-existent grandparent.

BestDove · 08/05/2022 07:53

@dalmatianmad 💐 you sound absolutely lovely. Made me quite emotional reading how you support your DD

ZigZagIntoTheBlue · 08/05/2022 06:48

My mum was always clear about not offering regular childcare, but she has gone above and beyond when we were in a tight spot and needed help in emergencies. If I get sick in traffic and won't make after school club I know she'll go get them for me.
I think any hurt feelings would come from mismanaged expectations - I knew from the start she didn't want to, if she had spent a year saying she did want to then suddenly said no it might've felt hurtful. Also, I knew she wouldn't respect our decisions as parents with respect to limiting sugar in a toddler etc so was personally happier paying for childcare.

MumsGoneToIceland · 08/05/2022 05:51

My parents made it clear way before I was thinking of children (I think when I was still living at home) that they wouldn’t do childcare, that they had done their time. MIL offered to do it after I had my first dd and I politely declined on the grounds that I wanted them to have a proper grandparent/grandchild relationship whereas if they cared for them the relationship would inevitably be different

SonicWomb · 08/05/2022 05:40

I do feel like some posters think the only role of older women is to facilitate their lives.

Or to some extent - everyone’s lives?? Expected to look after older parents, and GC, and the house and husband, maybe volunteer as well.

HistoricMoment · 08/05/2022 05:31

dottiedodah · 07/05/2022 11:44

CinnamonjellyBeans Why if you didnt travel when younger does it mean you wont start now FFS! More people aged 65 plus are going for their holiday of a lifetime! We have been to US when younger, and hope to again.I have always decorated Cakes, and seen friends for lunch (still do) Many people are working still ,and cant get 3 or 4 weeks plus to travel. Hence waiting until retired, when they have free time . Why do women who are Grandmas have to be expected to provide childcare for life ? Why cant they have a life of their own ?

Whyall the hyperbole? Looking after a child one day a week is not going to stop any grandparent from going out to lunch, doing a hobby, going out in the evenings, or even travelling. It's literally 10 hours or less out of the 148 hours of one week.

OutsideLookingOut · 08/05/2022 05:22

WildCoasts · 08/05/2022 00:22

But you might not have quite a few years. I'm not even 50 and two of my friends have died from illnesses and I've seen that disabiliity, that stops people doing all the things they have put off, can stop those delayed plans. I've seen other people I know more casually retire only to have their partner die within a year. Cancer in each case. Time is not a given for any of us. We don't know how much time we have and shouldn't take it for granted. You can't count on being able bodied or even alive for as long as you think. This is something life has taught me that wouldn't have crossed my mind when my family was young. I am very aware of the need to do things now or maybe never do them at all.

I think the comment that GPs that don't watch their children are doing things like getting their nails done says it all. I'm out in the forest looking after my physical and mental health, so hopefully I'll stay healthier longer. I'm caring for teenagers. I'm making sure my dogs are walked, because they need that and I'm responsible for their needs. I chose to have them, so they are my responsibility. I'm going to the occasional social event which I couldn't do when I was raising mine.

Not do those things so that someone can advance their career? No thanks. They chose their career and to have children. I delayed my career to care for my children, I chose to SAH because that's what I valued and I had the choice. If I couldn't have afforded that I'd have delayed children till such a time as I could. We're all responsible for our own choices. If you want kids and career, pay for childcare. Did your parents get any say into whether you conceived a baby? I doubt it. If it was going too affect their life so much, they should get a say into whether it happens.

I'm not saying I wouldn't do childcare but I don't feel it is an obligation. In the end, I value family most and that is where my priorities lie. But I matter too.

I think it is shocking that someone thinks they can decide to have children and expect me to adjust my life to meet their needs. If someone has those kind of expectations and can't do it without me, they need to talk to me before those children are conceived instead of making decisions for my life on my behalf. The expectation that your parents should alter their life to serve your family choices and material needs is very entitled.

This is true, a long life isn’t a guarantee. My dad died at 50. The thought that I am entitled to the last few years of good health to raise children I decided to have doesn’t sit right with me unless that is something the GPs themselves want.

we have come to expect that younger women get to make choices about how they live their lives. One day I hope we will expect the same for older women, I do feel like some posters think the only role of older women is to facilitate their lives.

SonicWomb · 08/05/2022 05:05

@bozna I know it’s common, I’ve done it and it was awful. A million times harder in my case than looking after children.

HandlebarLadyTash · 08/05/2022 04:35

Grandparents on all sides have never done childcare. The ones that live in the same town were clear it would not be happening. Totally respect their decision. We just paid for nurserys/clubs.

bozna · 08/05/2022 04:17

@SonicWomb I think it probably quite common. Women struggle juggling work and babies, but it never ends the different family needs, as on the older generation need help. I can't respect my mum more for stepping up and looking after my grandma when she needed her..

Namechange303333311 · 08/05/2022 04:13

My mum made it clear she wouldn’t be providing childcare years before I had a child. I’ll be doing the same.

SonicWomb · 08/05/2022 04:10

@bozna that sounds really difficult for your mum. It makes you realise how lucky we are to have so many generally excellent choices available by comparison when it comes to caring for children but so few options and so little support (even less good quality support) to look after elderly relatives. When it comes to children it “takes a village”. When it comes to elders, you’re on your own.

bozna · 08/05/2022 03:50

My kids grandparents will always be there when we need them, but my mum has to prioritise looking after her very elsderly parents now, as she has become the main carer, so really hard for her to find time, it's so difficult

iRun2eatCake · 08/05/2022 03:38

My parents made it clear that they wouldn't do childcare to enable me to work .... we lived too far away anyway.

However, when we got really stuck financially they did step in one day a week and DH dropped off and collected DS as he was then commuting to their area for work. Once we got sorted again and could afford nursery we put DS back in for the 2 days..... much to my DP upset as they'd enjoyed it afterall!

WildCoasts · 08/05/2022 03:05

@saltinesandcoffeecups I am in my late 40s. I didn't have GPs I ever knew. I didn't have aunts or uncles or cousins that I knew either. My parents worked full time and were there in real emergencies, but never really offered to babysit. They don't live local to me anymore. I am used to going it alone. I will be more available to my own children if they are local to me, but I will also be living my own life and meeting other responsibilities. I work part-time.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 08/05/2022 02:41

I really have no horse in this race, but would have found the discussion to be interesting if everyone weighing in started with their age and the time period their parents and grandparents did or did not help. I think that has a lot do with where the person is coming from.

for instance, those who spent loads of time with their GP or whose parents provided a lot of childcare, what was their situation? Did the GM work outside the home? Did/does the current set of GPs work outside the home? there is a lot that can change in a generation. It may have been a very natural pivot from being a SAHM/housewife to a care providing GP. But the transition from being a working mum to retired to full time/part time childcarer is totally different IMHO.

I’m in my mid 40s, my mother worked full time from the time I was 3, her mother (my GM) worked full time until I was about 8-10. So yeah, I get where both were very clear about not being able raise any more children. I think my mother finally fully retired at about 70 after years of being semi-retired but working full time hours) No way would she be willing to take on essentially a part time (or full time job).

the GPs of today have had children, careers, cared for or are still caring for their own parents, that’s a lot!

Hey, if it works out than it’s a great thing for kids to be raised by extended family, but I also think people need to extend some grace for when it doesn’t.

WildCoasts · 08/05/2022 02:22

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

I apologise for my off the cuff response. I would be involved with my GC and happy to do limited care. My D has health concerns and I've already told her I would be happy to take the baby for a couple of nights or help out with what is needed, if that helps her. That is because I want to make myself available though. We can work together. If she doesn't want that care given, good too. It's not what I pictured as a GP but it's about responding to the situation as it is. I have cautioned her though that she needs to consider the possibility that I could have an unexpected turn of health in future that might limit my ability to help. I've seen that happen to other people. I will manage to meet my own goals still. I also don't expect or want any help in my old age. I hope they will be available to chat sometimes.

WildCoasts · 08/05/2022 00:46

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Vikinga · 08/05/2022 00:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread