Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents not wanting to do childcare...

485 replies

Chewchewaboogiw · 04/05/2022 23:32

Have been thinking about several people I know whose planned retirememt or part time work has been changed as they have been asked to do childcare for their dgc and now they are doing chikdcare say 3 days a week instead of their plan to travel. And not massively happy about it ( in one case another.baby due also)..I have seen a post response recently that said that they take dgc out but they are not there for childcare. If you dont do childcare for your dgc how did you say no?( I am not in that position at present but i can imagine it would be hard work ..) I would imagine / fear adult ds would be hurt if they were told no dont want to do chikdcare and cant imagine how it would be phrased in a positive way.. anyone said no and is it bu to say you dont want to ... or is it now expected. I know that all families.different, am just asking about families who are comfortable in saying no .

OP posts:
OfstedOffred · 05/05/2022 06:06

My mum always made clear that while she would try to help me in emergencies/odd sick day etc, she would not be committing to a regular childcare slot.

But then I come from the sort of family where financial planning has always been emphasized, my siblings and I all knew the importance of understanding the costs etc before having a baby.

SickAndTiredAgain · 05/05/2022 06:02

I can't imagine ever expecting that level of childcare from grandparents, and I don't think most people do expect it. I think most people are grateful for any help offered and wouldn't get arsey about not being offered more.

DD went to nursery full time for about a year, and then MIL retired and was desperate to look after her. She offered two days a week but we went with one and even that I feel guilty about.

Autienotnaughtie · 05/05/2022 05:58

I had my eldest whe my parents with in their fifties, working etc they said no to helping out before dc was born which was fine. Ex Mil had her 3/4 days a week , she voluntarily gave up work and we paid her the difference. When youngest was born my parents were in their seventies and retired, they did half a day for me, pil who were in their fifties were both working still, when fil took early retirement he took over the half day as dm health was declining. The other days dc went to nursery.

voxnihili · 05/05/2022 05:55

We don’t have any regular grandparent help - we never asked as DP’s parents are elderly and mine are young so still at work. My mum does however cover things like INSET days which she enjoys as she gets time with DD but it’s not a regular commitment.

My mum often tells me about her friends and how much some of them resent the loss of their retirement. They all love their grandchildren but lots of them had great plans which now haven’t happened. I think some of them are annoyed that their children keep having more children knowing they can’t afford childcare because they expect the grandparents to carry on looking after them.

whiteroseredrose · 05/05/2022 05:51

It is much easier if you have more than 1 DC. If you over commit to the first you won't have time to help with any others.

My lovely Step mum had 4 DC so she wouldn't commit to anything regular for her first grandchild because it wouldn't be fair if she couldn't do the same for any others. Made sense.

My DM only had me, but would have wanted more DC herself. She was desperate to be a grandmother. When DS came along she went part time so that she could look after him 2 days per week. She was 55 and it was entirely her offering. We did not ask. She did the same for DD 4 years later until I became a SAHM.

But it is horses for courses. DH agrees that it is now only fair that we stay in this area while DM and DStepF are alive so that we can help them as they are getting older and more infirm. DM didn't ask, we offered.

dalmatianmad · 05/05/2022 05:42

It makes me so sad reading some of the replies!

I am currently cradling my 6 month old DGS because he's got a high temperature (waiting for the Calpol and Nurofen to kick in).

I work full time as an A+E Sister (x3 12 hour night shifts a week) and have baby DGS for 3 days and 2 nights a week whilst my DD is at work (also a Nurse). Her Husband walked out when baby was a few weeks old.
This is completely my choice to look after him. I've changed my shift pattern to have him, have a very good Matron that supports me.

I had no help with my DC, my mum had no interest in them. I was a single Mum at Uni doing my Nursing with a 1 year old and a 3 year old. Shes didn't help once.

I vowed when my DD announced she was pregnant I would help as much as I could.
Sally she's gone back to work early because of the situation she's in.

I bloody adore him and this set up works for us.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 05/05/2022 05:38

My mum was 44 when I had DS, she works full time in a hospital so she has never been able to do much childcare. She'll have him overnight on a weekend if there's something I really want to do but I don't ask often. She's senior in the NHS so gets a lot of annual leave and she does take a week off every summer holiday to do childcare for me which I'm grateful for. She can't do regular childcare though.

I plan to do some travelling in future, I was young when DS was born so I'll be 40 when he's an adult. If he decides to have children I wouldn't commit to 3 days a week childcare! Although I'll still be working full time myself anyway.

TeddyisMydog · 05/05/2022 05:37

Just to add, she wouldn't need to do a school run or anything. She would literally have to sit in mine until my DP came home. She would also be paid for it (something she agreed herself she would need as she doesn't work)

I was sent to my nan's for a week every single holiday, my nan was also there 2 days a week for me and my siblings.
It's crazy to see how hands off my own mum is compared to how much time I spent with my nan

doingitforthegirls · 05/05/2022 05:33

My mother helped with my first as childcare costs are huge - we agreed as soon as money was freed up once we'd sold car, paid some bills etc we'd start scaling it back and all our annual leave was used so that she didn't come every week. Had twins next and obviously couldn't expect her to help out the same way - they did help arrange a loan though which we are paying over 10 years but will cover childcare until twins get 30 hours

DH parents not involved at all, never once offered, nothing. They watched my mother travel over to us weekly to help but never said a word

Honestly I didn't have kids myself to set them adrift in their adult years when they might need me. I'd be really upset if none of them had children of their own anyway and would hope they I'll be able to offer childcare of future grandchildren one day if circumstances allow. Fostering a good relationship with my grandchildren is more important that travelling or long lunches

TeddyisMydog · 05/05/2022 05:33

Just do as my mum has done. No.
I was due to return back after mat leave, I asked her to watch 3 of my children for me 4 days a week for 3 hours(first time I have ever asked her in all my years of working). She said no
She doesn't work, doesn't have other commitments (such as looking after a siblings child or animals left alone)
She doesn't spend any other time with my children.
I understand she has done her share of parenting, that she is free to say no and live her life how she now wants but in the same breath she complains that she doesn't see the children much 🤷‍♂️

110APiccadilly · 05/05/2022 05:31

I don't expect my parents to do childcare on the regular, though they're happy to help as one offs - DM is actually doing it tomorrow as I'm having some pregnancy complications which mean I need to go to the big hospital three hours away for an appointment. I'm grateful she's happy to do that.

We weren't looked after by our grandparents regularly so from that point of view I suppose the expectation isn't there. I think it's good to be clear about what you're happy to do, and what you aren't, preferably before the children are on the scene (takes the emotion out of it a bit).

workwoes123 · 05/05/2022 05:26

We didn’t have any choice really as we moved abroad before DC were born so no childcare from any grandparents, but I remember my mum saying years before “don’t expect me to be one of those grand mothers that does loads of free childcare”. So I never assumed she’d have any interest in doing so. Having said that, I think she mellowed over the years - if we’d lived closer I’m sure she would have done a day a week.

Passanotherjaffacake · 05/05/2022 05:23

My mum was always clear she wanted to be free and not shackled down by childcare. She moved to an area just far enough away that visiting is most of a day. She will do an evening babysit if we all go to her house and we put DC down for bed before we go out and she will come to cover hospital appts etc if they fall on a day nursery is closed (like, maybe once a year). DC loves nursery and gets loads out of it so I’m good with this arrangement. Nursery is more reliable then grandparents (generally). If DC is sick my husband and I cover it and we take the hit at work.

My aunt is the total opposite and spends so, so much time doing childcare for her 5DGC - she lives near to them, it always there for them and is fully part of their lives, providing top up childcare to help her daughters budget and covering all emergencies and illness. She is tired and my mum complains about her nieces not understanding that. My aunts grandchildren adore her though and my aunt leads a happy, full and busy life with them.

However my mum is quite unhappy about how infrequently she sees her (one) DGC (another on the way) as she loves her DGC. She finds the journey here tricky and has a residual fear of getting sick from a toddler cold - frequent with nursery - so we see her quite rarely. She is quite isolated where she is and has had a tough few years. She voices regrets about her decisions - it sounds cold, but she made them and they were her choices which I have always respected and never questioned. Mum had a shock at the last visit when it took my DC a while to warm up to her as it had been so long.

Just a note of caution OP - my mum has everything she asked for and her wishes totally respected but it hasn’t turned out entirely as she wanted.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 05/05/2022 05:08

Dil not did !

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 05/05/2022 05:08

I've just agreed to have my youngest gc one day a week when did goes back to work but its only for 3 months until she goes on mat leave again.

There's no way I could have both the young dc every week , maybe because I've still got primary school age dc myself

I've had all of them Iver night occasionally and have the littlest for a few hours here and there if did has appointments etc

BuffyFanForever · 05/05/2022 04:56

My mum stated forever that she couldn’t wait to look after my future children daily just as her Mum looked after me as a young child right up till she passed away. However as soon as children were actually born she made it clear the idea was lovely but she would never actually do it. She just says she is “not able” and that’s that. She won’t do it. No big conversation just a refusal. I personally would have actually never expected the daily childcare she always said she’d “love” but would have been really great full for someone to have them just when needed eg medical appointments etc. It’s also massively affected their bond. My Inlaws love having the children, again nothing like daily but have had them for whole days and have bits and bobs for them at their house. As a result the children really get excited to see them. Sadly as my Mum won’t really “deal” with them in anyway they aren’t very excited to see her...

DockOTheBay · 05/05/2022 04:54

they have been asked to do childcare for their dgc and now they are doing chikdcare say 3 days a week instead of their plan to travel. And not massively happy about it

People need to learn how to say "no". Its their own fault really. Three days a week is a huge ask.

Brightonbelly · 05/05/2022 04:51

My parents made it clear early on they would help with emergencies and treats. They have been hugely helpful to me and actually spend quite a lot of time with dc, especially now they are older but without committing to regular childcare.

SinaraSmith · 05/05/2022 04:50

You raised your kids. This is only a problem when there’s an expectation to do it. If you raise your kids to not expect everyone else to change their lives because they are changing theirs, it shouldn’t be a problem.

It would be a simple and easy conversation.

runnerswimmer · 05/05/2022 04:39

My MIL looks after DD2 one day a week, and picks up DD1 from school that day, we never asked but she offered, they also look after them if we go away for the weekend (which is max 5x a year). We made it clear to them we can find alternative arrangements if they want to go on holiday / have a bowls tournament etc but just gives us a heads up. We always invite MIL to stay for dinner as a thank you. We do not take the piss though, if we go out for the evening we pay for a babysitter because we do not want to burden them, they already do enough.

Our girls are and will be her only grandchildren and that is part of the reason why MIL looks after them, she loves spending time with them and she wants to make the most of her only grandchildren (she said this), and given she had sons I secretly think she does enjoy doing stuff that she wanted to do if she had a daughter (not saying she would love her grandsons any less but it is an added benefit).

starrynight21 · 05/05/2022 04:35

I'm a grandmother - before the children were born I made it quite clear that while I would love to see lots of the DGC and have days out, etc, I just wouldn't be available for regular child care since I planned to be travelling for several years. That's exactly how it turned out - we travelled for many years and we saw the grandchildren a lot but not as regular child care. You have to make it very clear before the children are born, so the parents have no illusions about what is on offer.

Womanface · 05/05/2022 04:31

No bloody way

watching my own mim, she just get taken for granted and it eats away at her

as on another thread she just wants to feel valued as a human not mere staff

the obligation changes the whole dynamic and spoils the joy IME

FirstFormAtMalloryTowers · 05/05/2022 04:28

Tell them the moment the first pregnancy is announced! My parents did and it managed everyone’s expectations. They travelled extensively and I am so glad they did. 20
years I already plan on doing the same.

Jenasaurus · 05/05/2022 04:20

My Adult DS, fiancé recently shared with me, that my DS is planning to build a granny annexe on their next home so I can help when they have DC. It didn't worry me as I am sure I would love to be there for them but I do have 2 other DC that live in this country, so I couldn't just up sticks and move away as then I wouldn't be able to help with their DC when/if they have them.

Vikinga · 05/05/2022 03:52

My parents live in a different country so never did childcare. My exes mum looked after my exes eldest quite a lot but then refused to officially look after our child. So we paid for full time nursery but she would have him once a week. It meant she had a choice and I understand that.

I think when my kids have kids, if I can I will have them so that they can go out and may have them say a day a week or do school pick ups or take to clubs. But it will depend on a lot of things. whether I am retired or working, how tired I am, now much enjoyment etc