Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents not wanting to do childcare...

485 replies

Chewchewaboogiw · 04/05/2022 23:32

Have been thinking about several people I know whose planned retirememt or part time work has been changed as they have been asked to do childcare for their dgc and now they are doing chikdcare say 3 days a week instead of their plan to travel. And not massively happy about it ( in one case another.baby due also)..I have seen a post response recently that said that they take dgc out but they are not there for childcare. If you dont do childcare for your dgc how did you say no?( I am not in that position at present but i can imagine it would be hard work ..) I would imagine / fear adult ds would be hurt if they were told no dont want to do chikdcare and cant imagine how it would be phrased in a positive way.. anyone said no and is it bu to say you dont want to ... or is it now expected. I know that all families.different, am just asking about families who are comfortable in saying no .

OP posts:
Purplepot290 · 05/05/2022 07:33

My mum said that she didn’t want to do childcare as she didn’t want seeing them to become a chore. She also loved her freedom after years of raising children and didn’t want to lose that. I completely see her side of it and there is no resentment there at all! I had never expected her to provide childcare anyway. It was only once I had dc1 and started going to groups that I realized how many grandparents do. My mum has her busy own life which she very much enjoys, I’d hate her to feel she had to give up her free time to become childcare. She will babysit very happily when we ask and loves visiting. I’m glad she was able to be honest with me.

Meadmaiden · 05/05/2022 07:33

Mine offered, but were clear what their boundaries were, which I accepted.

In many societies, extended families helping each other out is the norm,. It's sad that doesn't generally happen in our society.

It's your right to say you won't help out at all with childcare (but wouldn't you at least help in an emergency?) but don't be surprised if your children aren't keen to help should you become frail and need help.

Snowiscold · 05/05/2022 07:31

Surely most grandparents are at work themselves and aren’t available for childcare. Retirement age is 67. And surely most people don’t live anywhere near grandparents for them to help out this way. My DC’s grandparents are all over 200 miles away. Both DH and I aren’t likely to live long enough to be grandparents.

nearlyspringyay · 05/05/2022 07:28

I was very lucky in that mine offered. Mum and mil did a day a week each. I would never have asked or expected it though and dts were registered at daycare.

It's a fine line though, they can be over involved, at some points I wished they had just gone to nursery.

MajorCarolDanvers · 05/05/2022 07:27

I never asked. But when my mum retired she offered one day a week which we were pleased to accept.

Sally872 · 05/05/2022 07:27

The polite way to say no is "I am not available for regular childcare but I will be happy to help in a more ad hoc way for you and partner to have a night out or a rest. I just can't commit to set days per week"

DangerNoodles · 05/05/2022 07:27

My DM made it clear long before we had children that she would not provide any childcare for any DGC. It's helpful that she managed expectations early on.

I don't feel entitled to childcare, however when we were young DM sent us to our DGM every day after school as well as sleepovers on a regular basis. Looking back she took advantage and being brutally honest a small part of me feels resentful that she hasn't paid it forward at all. She also hasn't made any plans for her future care and has made numerous poor financial decisions which means we will be responsible for her later on.

DMIL on the other hand has offered to have the DCs one day a week, they go to paid childcare on our other days and when DMIL is on holiday. They sometimes go to her on other days if I'm offered an extra shift on any day other than her hobby day. They have a much closer bond with DMIL and my DM gets very jealous and resentful that they do. We make an effort to see DM but it's only natural that they are closer.

When deciding to refuse childcare it's good to consider what parental help you had when your DCs are young. Your care arrangements for later and whether you can cope with your DGC being closer to the other set of GPs.

Hesma · 05/05/2022 07:26

Just say no, you value being able to spend time with dgc but don’t want the commitment. Your kids shouldn’t be expecting it from you anyway

PetersRabbitt · 05/05/2022 07:24

Childcare and babysitting are different. I’d do baby sitting…I find parents find that more valuable actually.

Whooshaagh · 05/05/2022 07:23

I looked after dgs 1 day a week until he was 3.
10 years later I have a new dgc and just feel too old to do childcare anymore.
Luckily we don't live nearby.
I have offered to help out financially with childcare to compensate. It's not expected but I feel happier being fair.

PaddlingLikeADuck · 05/05/2022 07:19

10 years ago my sister had a child (unplanned) and when she returned to work when the baby was 7 months old, our mom had to help out with childcare as my sister couldn’t afford FT nursery placement.

My mum was still working full time and so she had to change her hours so she worked 30 hours over 3 days between Mon-Fri (to provide childcare on the other 2 days) and then work 7.5 hours on a Saturday. She was exhausted! My sister didn’t appear to have any problem with this and it carried on for a few years when my sister then announced she was pregnant again - which again was unplanned.

My mum told my sister that if she thought my mom was going to be childcare for both children then she was mistaken! Between working full time and having a 3 year old for 12 hours, two days a week, she was drained - never mind adding in a 6 month old baby to the mix.

But despite her protests, she did end up having both children because she knew my sister couldn’t afford childcare.

This arrangement went on for years, and when they were both in school my mum then had to do before and after school childcare too.

Even now, 10 years down the line my mum still does childcare. My mum has retired now due to ill health and so in the school holidays she has the 11 year old every day.

It’s madness.

I have got two children, aged 8 and 5 and have never asked my mum for regular childcare and never would do.

My parents and my PIL will do emergency childcare if we need it, but we don’t ask unless there’s no other option.

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 05/05/2022 07:18

Lots of my friends use their parents as childcare, I don’t mean use in a horrible way. The parents look exhausted and overwhelmed… mine collect my son from school once a week for 2 hours which is helpful and then if they are away a friend helps.

icecreamcart · 05/05/2022 07:14

My parents said no. They just made it clear.

Fizbosshoes · 05/05/2022 07:12

My DM offered that they would consider having DD 1 day a week if I wanted to return to work. (Which I combined with a childminder) When DS was born they didn't offer and as they hadn't I took that to mean they didn't want to do the same again which was fine. They saw us every week still but didn't have childcare responsibility. DH parents lived too far to do any regular childcare but a few times when the DC were older they had them for a few days at a time in the holidays.

Change123today · 05/05/2022 07:11

We don’t live near any of the grandparents so logistically they wouldn’t be able to help weekly childcare. I know my step Mil & FiL would have helped more if the could. But my Dad & Mil have helped out where they could.

My Mum isnt maternal, she has looked after my eldest probably twice for a day and never my youngest, but I know she just isn’t comfortable doing it so I haven’t asked & she hasn’t offered!!

i don’t expect it from them. Though oddily I would be more than happy to help my girls out with their children when the time comes.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 05/05/2022 07:09

People need to learn to say no.

We don't have DC but my in-laws look after our dog for a few hours a day while we work as he has terrible separation anxiety and is really distressed to be left for too long.

We were going to put him in daycare but FIL offered to have him on a trial basis, and now he complains when we don't send him Grin

He doesn't walk him though, so by "looks after" I really mean "provides a sofa for naps and some head rubs" lol. They're both great company for the other and the dog adores FIL so it works out really well.

I think it's just down to each individual family, the children involved and the health and age of the grandparents. My IL's wouldn't be able to run about after a toddler but are quite happy to have an adult dog in the house who just snoozes and asks for food occasionally Wink

NotYourOscarSpeech · 05/05/2022 07:04

Well my parents moved abroad a couple of years before DS1 was born… so I guess that settled it!

mynameisnotmichaelcaine · 05/05/2022 07:00

Yanbu to not want to do this.

I wonder if some people's expectations are based on their own experiences. DD didn't have grandparents who provided childcare when we were working, although they were all very involved and she has great relationships with them. Her partner on the other hand - both of his parents worked full-time and his mum's parents provided all of the childcare. I will definitely not be doing this and have already told DD this.

I was a SAHM when mine were very little, but it was hard work in my 20s and I'm certainly not doing it again in my later years. Even one day a week restricts your ability to travel. I missed out on a lot when I had my kids young, and will be making the most out of my retirement, God willing.

MeanderingGently · 05/05/2022 06:59

When my children were young (a long time ago!) I never dreamed of expecting my parents/their grandparents to do any childcare. They still had a lovely relationship with my children even though we lived about 2 hours drive away. As the children got older, we moved house and were much nearer so saw them much more often. My teenage son would sometimes go to stay overnight but by then he could look after himself and didn't need watching or "caring" for.

I'm now grandparent age myself. Currently none of my children have kids of their own but if/when they do, neither are they under any illusion that I could be called upon to look after them. I can't see why it's a complicated conversation. I have just said, Don't expect me to do any childcare if you ever have children. I've already had mine and don't intend to be looking after anyone else's, grandchildren or otherwise. Why would I want to anyway?

It's fair, I think; I don't have the strength nor the stamina these days for small (or even bigger) kids, and besides, I've done my bit and have other things in life to be doing. Also, I agree with pp about choice....I chose to have my children but other people's choices mean they are responsible for their little people, not me. I'm on the brink of retiring, something I've looked forward to all my life.....I don't intend to retire and then be tied down by someone else's kids!!

rookiemere · 05/05/2022 06:58

My DM very kindly did one day a fortnight when the CM wasn't working. It felt like the right frequency for her and for us.

I feel sorry for my SIL they are looking after their DGD 2 days a week and the other GPs do the other two days. She is paying for a playgroup from her own pocket to get a break I think.

DGD is delightful and I think they enjoy looking after her but as she is nearly 3 it feels like it could be ramping down a bit, however the DPs are talking about having another baby- I do wonder if they've considered that GPs will be older and may not be willing or particularly able to provide that level of care for longer and for 2 DC.

ChocolateHippo · 05/05/2022 06:58

Chooksnroses · 05/05/2022 06:47

I was a childminder when my first grandchild was born. I simply said I didn't want her to be just another child amongst the others, I wanted our time together to be special. My son and daughter in law accepted that.
I often see grandparents looking after children and wonder how they cope. I simply don't have the energy to care for my grandchildren now in a way that I think is enough. I could put them in front of the TV, take them to the park for a while, and keep them safe
but I'd be doing a disservice to them if I took on their care now.

I wouldn't want my DP/PIL caring on a regular basis for my DC for this reason. It is hard, physical work looking after young children and many GPs could do without having to do this day in, day out.

As it is, my DM/PIL do provide ad hoc occasional care for my DC and will take them swimming, to the beach, the playground and run about after them in the garden. But those visits take their toll, and my DM often jokes to me on the phone after having DC for a couple of days that she'll need a few days to 'recover'. If my DC went to GPs on a regular basis, I think they'd be 'kept safe', but there would be a lot of screen-time and treats and much less active interaction, just because GPS wouldn't have the energy for it. Nursery is much better imo as regular childcare.

daffodilandtulip · 05/05/2022 06:57

When I left my abusive husband, after the "what will I tell people" comments; I got "I won't be doing any childcare for you so you'd better be sure you want to leave him." I worked shifts at the time so got a new job.

ememem84 · 05/05/2022 06:53

Dparents have the dc one day a week at the moment. They offered when I had ds and found out how much nursery would be.

dm has said that when the dc start school/preschool and go term time that she will help us out over the holidays but categorically has stated they will not do more than one day a week.

Sharrowgirl · 05/05/2022 06:53

I’m sad for your friends who can’t say no to their children. They need to speak up!

afinethingindeed · 05/05/2022 06:52

My MIL asked/told me she wanted to look after DD one day a week. Otherwise it never occurred to me that she'd provide childcare. (Other grandparents not able to for health reasons).
We're thinking about having another child and I certainly do not expect her to be looking after two children! I also appreciate she may change her mind at some point in future too.
I can't believe how expectant some people are. Why have children and expect your parents to look after them?!?