Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents not wanting to do childcare...

485 replies

Chewchewaboogiw · 04/05/2022 23:32

Have been thinking about several people I know whose planned retirememt or part time work has been changed as they have been asked to do childcare for their dgc and now they are doing chikdcare say 3 days a week instead of their plan to travel. And not massively happy about it ( in one case another.baby due also)..I have seen a post response recently that said that they take dgc out but they are not there for childcare. If you dont do childcare for your dgc how did you say no?( I am not in that position at present but i can imagine it would be hard work ..) I would imagine / fear adult ds would be hurt if they were told no dont want to do chikdcare and cant imagine how it would be phrased in a positive way.. anyone said no and is it bu to say you dont want to ... or is it now expected. I know that all families.different, am just asking about families who are comfortable in saying no .

OP posts:
woodpecker2 · 05/05/2022 08:21

on the other side my mum was so desperate for gran children when I didn’t really want kids so I expected some help. I have been left high and dry and resent both of them.

FirewomanSam · 05/05/2022 08:20

I didn’t have any grandparents growing up and I had no idea grandparents doing regular childcare was a thing, until I went to uni and had a couple of friends who were really close to their grandparents. I remember my friend telling me about how her nan used to look after her every day after school and how she used to spend whole weekends with them. It suddenly made sense to me why my mum would always complain about not having any family nearby to help her out!

I watched Motherland recently and was really shocked at the whole premise (the main character suddenly needing childcare because her mum refuses to do it any more) because it’s so alien to me that people have that expectation to begin with.

I think it’s a wonderful thing when grandparents are able to offer regular help and be really involved in their grandchildren’s lives because I never had that as a child, but I don’t think there should ever be an assumption that grandparents (and let’s be honest, it’s mainly grandmas we’re talking about) put their own life plans on hold to provide unpaid childcare indefinitely.

ResidentHortensia · 05/05/2022 08:16

CinnamonJellyBeans · 05/05/2022 07:59

Evidence suggests that we have evolved to live in family groups, where females enjoy a relatively long lifespan after their reproductive years in order to the survival of their own daughters' offspring (grandmother hypothesis).

Of course this doesn't mean that you have to follow your nature and nurture your own family. This is the 21st century dammit. Don't be a mammal; choose to be reptiles, lay your eggs and bugger off. It's sad that so many women are determined to avoid their own descendants. Be honest with yourselves: If you didn't travel, write books, decorate cakes and lunch with your friends in the early decades of your life, you are not going to start when you're 65.

What's the point of having decades of experience and wisdom in raising children and then not using these skills? You know what is best and (perhaps more importantly) what not to do. Children are joyful and wonderful. If you can spare some energy and time, why not help raise your family?

What a load of claptrap. Women do raise their children. They don't give birth and bugger off (if anyone buggers off it's generally the father). And as for living longer to raise the grandchildren, we don't live in caves anymore, there aren't bears outside, but there are nurseries childminders and after school clubs. Most older women are out working now too!

And if you read these boards regularly, you'll see that the "wisdom" of older women when it comes to childcare is generally not welcome. Things are done very differently now, as I see posted often.

This idea that a woman's sole purpose is to serve others needs to stop.

Flatandhappy · 05/05/2022 08:14

We have 20 month old DGD one day a week, have done since she was 6 months, I thought carefully about what I was prepared to commit to and that is what I offered. Ongoing medication post cancer means that I get tired easily and tbh on days when DD or DH aren’t around to help I do find it exhausting. She is gorgeous though and lots of fun and I want to be part of her life although I have been clear that apart from emergencies when of course I would help, one regular day is my limit. Now we can travel again if we can’t have her because we will be away we pay for the extra nursery day so as not to leave DS and DIL in the lurch. We had three kids with no family around so I know the importance of childcare being reliable.

Peony26 · 05/05/2022 08:13

We have never had help with childcare from grandparents, our eldest is now 16. Although I really don’t expect it they’re our children and our choice, there have been times when it’s been a struggle and I feel a little resentful as our grandparents had us supporting them a lot growing up, my nan and grandad had me all the time, and my husband was practically raised by his grandma, even all his holidays etc were with her. But we never get a break, let alone regular work related childcare! My mom will randomly have 1 or 2 of our 3 children for a sleepover or a day out once in a blue moon which they love and have a great relationship with her. I just think when my time comes although I will want my freedom I know how difficult it can be so I would like to help out too

LowlandLucky · 05/05/2022 08:10

I love all of Grandchildren, they are the best part of being a parent. My contribution to childcare is visiting each family once a year for a week and enabling the parents to have a weekend away child free, i also have all of my Grandchildren at the same time to stay with me for a fortnight in the summer. They get to spend fun times with their Cousins, they camp on the beach with their Granda, they walk the hills and they spend hours running wild. Once they get to teenage years the plan is to have them for the usual fortnight and also to take each one away on their own for a few days. Other than that unless it is an emergency or Mum is going into hospital to have another baby, i don't do childcare and my children always knew that would be the case.

Snowiscold · 05/05/2022 08:09

CinnamonJellyBeans · 05/05/2022 07:59

Evidence suggests that we have evolved to live in family groups, where females enjoy a relatively long lifespan after their reproductive years in order to the survival of their own daughters' offspring (grandmother hypothesis).

Of course this doesn't mean that you have to follow your nature and nurture your own family. This is the 21st century dammit. Don't be a mammal; choose to be reptiles, lay your eggs and bugger off. It's sad that so many women are determined to avoid their own descendants. Be honest with yourselves: If you didn't travel, write books, decorate cakes and lunch with your friends in the early decades of your life, you are not going to start when you're 65.

What's the point of having decades of experience and wisdom in raising children and then not using these skills? You know what is best and (perhaps more importantly) what not to do. Children are joyful and wonderful. If you can spare some energy and time, why not help raise your family?

Because grandparents are at work aged 65. Because grandparents need to live close to their work, which might not be near their adult offspring. By the time they do retire, many will have health problems themselves and some will be caring for their own elderly parents. The concept of the fit, active, retired grandparent is over for most people. Cost of living and growing poverty is damaging health and lifespans of grandparents, never mind the wallet.

SockQueen · 05/05/2022 08:08

Sally872 · 05/05/2022 07:27

The polite way to say no is "I am not available for regular childcare but I will be happy to help in a more ad hoc way for you and partner to have a night out or a rest. I just can't commit to set days per week"

This is pretty much exactly what my parents said. And we weren't expecting anything else - they live 2 hours away and are in their early 70s so we would never have dreamed of a weekly commitment. My PiL never said anything and we never asked. We did have a similar sort of arrangement with them pre-Covid, but they have become much more cautious and withdrawn in the last two years so sadly we see them less.

It's wonderful knowing that they're able to help with school holidays, or on the rare occasions DH and I have clashing work commitments, but most of the time it's nice just to enjoy time with all of us! Also, while they're not in bad shape for their ages, having two energetic boys (5&2) for long periods is very tiring for them (it's tiring for me!) so I wouldn't want it to become a chore. I think some grandparents agree when the DGC are cute babies who just feed, sleep and cuddle, and then struggle more when they become rampaging toddlers, or when siblings come along.

Fml1980 · 05/05/2022 08:06

No none of the grandparents has looked after my children regularly (one has about 5 times in 21 years just for a couple of hours so dh and I could have a meal).
Even if I had the best relationship with my parents they're to physical disabled to be able to have my children anyway.
I don't think it is up to the grandparents to facilitate working but I would like to think if I could I would help my children out if I could.

FlamingoQueen · 05/05/2022 08:03

My DF said to me - I don’t really want to do childcare, but obviously if there is an emergency I will be straight there! It was a bit random though that he said this, because I had never even mentioned childcare! (My DM is no longer with us).

TeddyisMydog · 05/05/2022 08:01

Sidisawetlettuce · 05/05/2022 07:57

That's an awful lot of time for your mum to commit to though - no wonder she said no.

Frustratingly she said yes to begin with so I accepted the job offer then she said no so I had to go back and apologise etc.
I'd like to think if I was sat at home with nobody to talk to, nothing else to do and nowhere else to go that I would say yes to my children but I guess that's where me and her differ

CinnamonJellyBeans · 05/05/2022 07:59

Evidence suggests that we have evolved to live in family groups, where females enjoy a relatively long lifespan after their reproductive years in order to the survival of their own daughters' offspring (grandmother hypothesis).

Of course this doesn't mean that you have to follow your nature and nurture your own family. This is the 21st century dammit. Don't be a mammal; choose to be reptiles, lay your eggs and bugger off. It's sad that so many women are determined to avoid their own descendants. Be honest with yourselves: If you didn't travel, write books, decorate cakes and lunch with your friends in the early decades of your life, you are not going to start when you're 65.

What's the point of having decades of experience and wisdom in raising children and then not using these skills? You know what is best and (perhaps more importantly) what not to do. Children are joyful and wonderful. If you can spare some energy and time, why not help raise your family?

Sidisawetlettuce · 05/05/2022 07:57

TeddyisMydog · 05/05/2022 05:33

Just do as my mum has done. No.
I was due to return back after mat leave, I asked her to watch 3 of my children for me 4 days a week for 3 hours(first time I have ever asked her in all my years of working). She said no
She doesn't work, doesn't have other commitments (such as looking after a siblings child or animals left alone)
She doesn't spend any other time with my children.
I understand she has done her share of parenting, that she is free to say no and live her life how she now wants but in the same breath she complains that she doesn't see the children much 🤷‍♂️

That's an awful lot of time for your mum to commit to though - no wonder she said no.

Hiphophippityskip1 · 05/05/2022 07:56

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Noisyprat · 05/05/2022 07:54

My parents, well my Mother, made it very clear that she didn't believe in childcare, nurseries etc, and clearly believed I should just give up my career. Tbh I never expected regular help, I don't feel they would have given the type of childcare I wanted and I appreciated the benefits if a nursery. They did have young dc for sleepovers but clearly found it exhausting.

I do think that there should be some childcare planning before having a child and it's important GPS are upfront about whether and how much they can commit. I always think that once something becomes a regular, set commitment then it can become a chore. DC can become too reliant and any request to change dates causes issues and can cause resentment on both sides. I do think this situation is especially difficult for Mums if girls because they know the burden will fall to their girls regardless of how strong a woman she is so there is a tendency to want to support.

Dinoteeth · 05/05/2022 07:53

My MIL made it clear she wasn't doing regular childcare but then decided to offer to babysit on my day off (I still can't work out the logic).
My Mum does what she can.

Men's time is much more important, a woman's time is for others to fill

Haha, MIL was too busy to babysit when we had a sick child. But hearing her darling son would need to take a day off to watch his own child she was down here faster than Nigel Manson

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 05/05/2022 07:50

My poor Mum (widowed) does all the childcare for my Sister's children. Her in-laws (pair of them) spend all their time being too busy playing bridge and having lunch.

I think my sister takes the piss a bit that's up to my Mum. The upside is that both GC have a close relationship with my Mum.

SockFluffInTheBath · 05/05/2022 07:50

I think in most societies it is pretty normal for all the family to help with childcare if they can. Our society is so disparate from that. I guess people have evolved in our society to be, well quite selfish I suppose, other than to care for own children there doesn't seem to be much other responsibilities felt such as for care of our elderly and extended family.

I don’t think it’s evolved to be selfish, it’s evolved to women realising they don’t have to spend their entire existence wiping someone else’s bum.

JenniferAlisonPhilipaSue · 05/05/2022 07:46

DM looked after DD until I started WFH permanently 3 years ago (pre covid). She looked after DD from 5 months old, and then before and after nursery and school. She did this even whilst being a full time carer for my gran. DM insisted, even though it was hard and DF useless but it saved us a shitload of money and DM did not want a stranger looking after her GC. DM did resent my ILs though who were happy to look after DN but not my DD. It was like pulling teeth getting ILs to do any babysitting. DM was not working through, which made a difference. ILs were working for the first few years of DDs life but not intersted thereafter. If I was working when DD has children, I'd try to help my DD evenings, weekends and my days off. I'd try to support with financing childcare too.

carefullycourageous · 05/05/2022 07:46

I never had any childcare from either set of parents, partly circs and partly the way they are. We were fortunate not to really need it.

I would personally offer to my children if I could but a) not too much, b) not if I needed to work or had bad health and c) not if there would be drama.

Obviously I have no idea if I will have grandchildren but if I did personally I would like to do some childcare as it helps the parents and will hopefully give a really good chance to get to know the grandkids properly.

caramac04 · 05/05/2022 07:42

I’m the grandparent and have done/do a lot of childcare. I’ve enjoyed/enjoy it but it does restrict me. I accept that and love seeing dgc. However, I rarely have them overnight or for their dp’s social events. Sometimes it’s a responsibility rather than fun times iyswim and I wonder if that is a slight negative.
I think expectations need to be discussed prior to pregnancy if possible by simply asking DP’s how they feel but also perhaps be mindful an eager DGP might wish for more than they can actually cope with or enjoy. Contingency plans need to be in place for if illness should occur preventing DGP continuing childcare.

Hankunamatata · 05/05/2022 07:38

I was never entitled enough to ask relations to childcare. We paid for childcare. Which means now relations are happy to offer sleepovers, emergency childcare etc as they don't feel burdened or put upon.

WhiskeyAndGinger · 05/05/2022 07:37

A more realistic title for this thread should really be "Grandmothers not wanting to do childcare...."

It's always women expected to put others first. Men are far too busy doing important things. Often the grandmother doing free childcare is also looking after an elderly parent, even her inlaws, because God forbid their own sons should step up. Men's time is much more important, a woman's time is for others to fill.

onlywork55 · 05/05/2022 07:35

My parents did what others have suggested upthread, and gave examples of the situations their friends were in looking after GC x days a week. Then made it clear that wasn’t something they were able to do.

It does make me a bit sad as a lot (most?) of my friends/colleagues have help with childcare from family. But I do understand it’s their choice and to be fair they already have caring responsibilities for my elderly grandfather and my disabled sister so it’s not like they haven’t already got their hands full!

One thing to bear in mind is that when we moved house a few years ago we chose the location purely based on proximity to work and not in the most convenient location for travelling to family. It wasn’t to be spiteful but just because we had to put work/childcare arrangements above anything else as that has to be our priority since we have no help with it. I think my DM is a bit sad that we didn’t move closer to them like some of her friends’ DC did but it just wouldn’t have made sense.

StillMedusa · 05/05/2022 07:34

I do granny care for my 1 yr old grandson. I work 3 days a week and have him whichever other days are needed..so it can be anything between once and 4 days a week depending on my DD2 and SILs nursing shifts... because of their jobs it would be impossible for them otherwise and financially crippling.

I won't lie, on the 'full' weeks I'm knackered and go to work for a rest Grin but the upside is I have a wonderful relationship with him, they feel completely secure knowing he is happy and my home is his home too. I'm mid 50s and still fit, but I can't imagine doing it in 10 years time..for later born children I will have to play it by ear. Luckily DD2 doesn't want another one for a few years so hopefully no 1 will be in nursery/school by then!

My other children live much further away so it won't be logistically possible to help, and I hope the other nearby grandparents will step in if they have children.

I know if I said 'I can't do this anymore' my lovely DD2 would understand but I can't imagine not wanting to help... I never realised how much I would adore my grandchild until he arrived!!!