Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents not wanting to do childcare...

485 replies

Chewchewaboogiw · 04/05/2022 23:32

Have been thinking about several people I know whose planned retirememt or part time work has been changed as they have been asked to do childcare for their dgc and now they are doing chikdcare say 3 days a week instead of their plan to travel. And not massively happy about it ( in one case another.baby due also)..I have seen a post response recently that said that they take dgc out but they are not there for childcare. If you dont do childcare for your dgc how did you say no?( I am not in that position at present but i can imagine it would be hard work ..) I would imagine / fear adult ds would be hurt if they were told no dont want to do chikdcare and cant imagine how it would be phrased in a positive way.. anyone said no and is it bu to say you dont want to ... or is it now expected. I know that all families.different, am just asking about families who are comfortable in saying no .

OP posts:
SockFluffInTheBath · 05/05/2022 09:22

MigsandTiggs · 05/05/2022 08:47

If you didn't travel, write books, decorate cakes and lunch with your friends in the early decades of your life, you are not going to start when you're 65.
While this may be true for some, as a generalisation it is totally inaccurate. Surely it depends on the person's mindset and ability. Retirement also gives you more time to spend on existing interests and hobbies.

Agree with the reply. I spent my early 20s in uni then caring for a terminally ill relative then had DC1. I will be 46 when the youngest goes to uni and I fully intend to make up for ‘lost’ time.

JKRowlingDevilWoman · 05/05/2022 09:22

My mum always had my children for a day. We had a conversation about it and she was happy to do it. Now they are both at school she has them overnight one night a week and takes them to school the following day. I've always made it clear that if/when it becomes too much for her she needs to let us know. My mum travels and has an active social life. If she has plans, or is going away the kids don't go to Grandma's. When they were little we could usually put them into nursery for an extra day or I'd take a holiday day to cover it. It has never been a problem, but my Mum wanted to do it. If you don't want to, then that's fair enough, but if you do there are ways to accommodate travel and having a life. My kids are incredibly close to my Mum and I'm incredibly grateful to her as she is their only grandparent.

Montague22 · 05/05/2022 09:21

It shouldn’t be expected.
My in laws on announcing DC1 badgered us to do childcare straight away. I wasn’t that keen.
Then with DC2 when we said I was expecting they barely said Congratulations and began a long rang about how they couldn’t do childcare again. We didn’t expect it and it was actually quite offensive.

So I would discuss ahead of time. Don’t assume they’ll want help though as I hadn’t but they insisted first time.

WildCoasts · 05/05/2022 09:18

I've had a conversation with my daughter that I'm happy to support if she has a child but no more than two days a week (emergencies excepted), she needs to have a back up plan for if I am sick or have something else urgent or want to go away, and not to count on any of it because, while I'm under 50 and can do it now, who knows what happens in future with my health or life? I think we just take it as it comes but everyone has to appreciate that I am important too and my wants and needs matter when negotiating anything.

NessieMcNessface · 05/05/2022 09:17

I do a lot of childcare and it is exhausting beyond words. Can’t give more info as too outing but if I described how much and for how many children, I think people would probably say I was giving up too much of my life to it. Positives are that I feel genuinely and truly appreciated and this is demonstrated to me every day of my life; I also have a brilliant relationship with my grandchildren who I absolutely adore. Would I do it all again? Absolutely, but it has felt too much at times and it does certainly limit travel possibilities. If I were to advise others I would say help out whenever needed if you are happy to do so, but don’t commit to regular childcare unless you’ve really considered all the factors involved.

Jalepenojello · 05/05/2022 09:16

I do find the responses interesting. It doesn’t really tie in with what I see on school pick ups, which is definitely around 50/50 parents/grandparents.

I agree you have to make it clear before the kids are even here so avoid any awkward conversations.

babysitting is great but regular childcare is a real commitment and it can turn into a chore. I am lucky that my own parents have helped me here, far beyond what I hoped or expected but bottom line is no one owes you childcare.

WhatHaveIFound · 05/05/2022 09:16

I think it depends what kind of relationship you want with your grandchildren.

We were very lucky that DH's parents offered to have DD one day a week from when she was a few months old. A few years later they took DS on too. Both of them have a fantastic relationship with their grandmother as sadly my lovely FIL died several years ago. Even now DD will call her from university for a catch up.

Thankfully I'm self employed so I could adapt my working hours around their holidays so it was never a problem when they were away, nor did we expect them to drop everything for us. I'd like to think that's how it would work for us if/when we eventually have GC.

My own parents made no effort when DD & DS were little and make even less now that they're older. They don't even call them on their birthdays and have no real relationship at all. It makes me sad that they're missing out but I don't force things. My mum wasn't great at mothering and she obviously hasn't changed over the years.

WildCoasts · 05/05/2022 09:13

Rrrunrunrunrunrun · 05/05/2022 09:06

My parents removed their offer of childcare and left us stuffed. We had twins and are struggling financially to pay for childcare. Oh but both sets of GPs want to visit at weekends and do outings with us. I’ve started saying no sometimes. I accept they don’t want to commit to regular childcare, but I will choose how we spend our spare time. (Yes I sound bitter, I am sad that GPs took early retirement 5 years ago and we are really struggling with paying for childcare/ keeping on top of life with no support)

I think most young families have financial struggles, no doubt your parents did too. They do have as much right to say no to childcare as you do to say no to weekend visits. In the end, the twins aren't their responsibility to provide for.

LondonJax · 05/05/2022 09:12

I think it's a conversation to have before even trying to have children. It's a bit much to do, like an acquaintance of mine. She and her DH had one child, her parents stepped up and looked after the DC when she returned to work.

His parents did 2 days a week, her parents did 3 days. They saved a mint on childcare. Her mum still worked part time so part of her time off was spent looking after the GC. Her dad was retired. Her DH's parents were both retired. Having saved a fortune they didn't even give the GP spending money to help to take the child out - that was GP choice. And, of course, they spent out on trips. So for four/five years they carried on. She got annoyed when one of the set decided to go on holiday 'outside' a time that suited her and her DH - couldn't get time off work so had to pay someone as the other set couldn't step up.

Her mum then retired and she and her husband decided they'd like to spend a bit more time on weeks away, days out during the week now they had their time back. The GC was now at school and went to a friend's house three times a week after school so, apart from holidays, their time was their own.

Lo and behold DD announced she was expecting and got really nasty when the GP announced they'd help for a couple of weeks in the summer and other holidays and once a fortnight for a couple of days a week. The expectation was 'you helped doing x hours with the first so you help with the subsequent'. No conversation before TTC. Forgetting that the GP were now 5 years older, both retired so less commitments (apart from the babysitting which was over to a large extent with DC at school) and had done their stint by raising her, her siblings and their first GC.

Don't assume GP are going to be there for you. Lives change. My mum developed Alzheimer's when DS was 6 years old. Health can change dramatically for anyone and, sometimes, retired people go back to work part time to help with bills etc. GP should be back up, plan B. Not the basis on which you decide to start a family. Because they may not always be there for many reasons.

MrsBlaue · 05/05/2022 09:09

My child spends every single weekend with either grandparent, and sometimes weeknights.
I would love to have a grandchild to look after when I retire. I will feel blessed.

Bearsan · 05/05/2022 09:09

We have very young gc parents are doing childcare themselves. We will be away too much to help regularly. I'd be happy to do some babysitting, after school and summer holidays when we aren't away if we are still able by then but imagine if you end up with 6 or more gdc it would be pretty exhausting to help with them all.
I couldn't do all day, except in an emergency or full time, I might as well have stayed at work.

wonkygorgeous · 05/05/2022 09:08

I can see this unfolding for us too.

I've decided that I'll be available on the understanding that we will be travelling. I will try to give them two weeks to sort out child care when we are planning to be away.

I'm happy to be a back up but as we are planning to travel we l when the mood takes us it might not be practical.

I'll always do school pick ups when we are home.

My parents did school pick ups and it was appreciated.

Fintytint · 05/05/2022 09:06

Just say no, simple as that. And as for other people expecting grandparents to rearrange their lives to watch a child they didn't carry, give birth to etc is just really self serving and really selfish.

I often wonder if people discuss introducing another human being into the world with grandparents (who they expect to baby sit their kids so they can go to work) just to see how it would disrupt the grandparents lives. Or do they just have the kid and just expect it then throw a wobbler and call the grandparents selfish etc.

If they choose to have children then it is their responsibility to adjust and change their work life etc to care for the child. You've done your child rearing, why should you take on someone elses responsibility. Watching little kids is mentally, emotionally and physically draining. Put yourself, your life and needs first.

CharSiu · 05/05/2022 09:06

Culturally there has always been multi generational living on my side of the family and DH was brought up with a housekeeper and a Nanny so opposite ends historically.

Personally I would like to help look after any grandchildren but we have one DS so there will never be a huge amount of GC if we have any. My sister had three children and two lots have had children so she has ended up looking after four GC plus due to the large age gap as her DS had children in his thirties whereas her DD was in early twenties those years stretched out a lot. She was resentful but she did almost FT childcare for four GC. I will happily have GC a full day a week and then some weekend evenings so they can have some time together. But I will make it clear that if we will be off on hols and we do plan to leave during Jan and Feb each year that’s what we are offering.

MintyCedricRidesAgain · 05/05/2022 09:06

I was lucky that both sets of grandparents helped out when DD was small, however...

  • Mine were retired and didn't travel
  • ILs were retired/flexible working
  • I worked part-time and now XH worked a rolling shift pattern so the GPs were just filling in the gaps, although still a commitment which I'm grateful for.

DD is now in her late teens and is very career minded...I have been informed that the only grandkids I will be getting will be furry ones! However, should that change (and I kinda hope it does many, many years down the road) we have the kind of relationship where we could be very honest with each other about needs and expectations.

Personally I probably wouldn't do regular GC care if I was still working, even part-time. I'd be happy to chip if in I was retired but would only offer what I knew I could manage...maybe 2 or 3 half days a week.

Of course if (God forbid) DD found herself in a difficult position relationship or health wise I'd drop everything to help her out however I could.

Rrrunrunrunrunrun · 05/05/2022 09:06

My parents removed their offer of childcare and left us stuffed. We had twins and are struggling financially to pay for childcare. Oh but both sets of GPs want to visit at weekends and do outings with us. I’ve started saying no sometimes. I accept they don’t want to commit to regular childcare, but I will choose how we spend our spare time. (Yes I sound bitter, I am sad that GPs took early retirement 5 years ago and we are really struggling with paying for childcare/ keeping on top of life with no support)

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 05/05/2022 09:05

I would suggest if a hypothetical situation is making you anxious then you have a conversation with your children now - tell them you're looking forward to your retirement when you can travel and do whatever you want on a whim.

And frankly, your son can be hurt but that doesn't mean you're obliged to change your mind. Did you never say no to him as a child?

EmilyBolton · 05/05/2022 09:04

I do also think that unless you’ve had children young, and your parents did too, that basing childcare plans on parents or PIL is a bit risky. Sure, if they offer then you can make use of that help while available, but financially you need a back up plan absolutely for paid care . Typically with women being in 30s when they have children , grandmothers are at least early sixties. Many of them will still be working to 67 now, and many of them have elderly parents to care for too. It’s just not viable to rely on them 100% .

PurassicJark · 05/05/2022 09:03

I wouldn't expect my parents or my partners parents to give regular childcare even if they tried insisting on doing even one day. It's just not fair on them, what if they are ill that day? Or end up with plans that can only work on that day? That then means we'd have to fix childcare for that day which can be quite difficult if you've already told the other childcare provider that it will only be set days, they might not take on extra days at short notice. I'd rather they just spent time together on weekends, makes it easier all round.

Should never go into having a child with the expectation someone else will do the work for you for free. Never take someone's word at that. It's naive at best.

RowanAlong · 05/05/2022 09:02

I think just be clear with what you are up for. I feel exhausted at 42 looking after my two, and already I feel that there is no way in future I’d commit to regular childcare as a grandparent. Happy to be nearby to help out as and when, but not a regular commitment. I don’t think that’s unreasonable, and I don’t think you should worry about it - just define your boundaries early on.

EmilyBolton · 05/05/2022 08:58

I would point out that I had severe post natal depression and therefore am not comfortable with caring for a baby. I struggled with my own and would not trust myself with caring for someone else’s.
hopefully that will set the precedent that means I don’t get asked as they get older. I do want to be more involved than my mum, but actually doubt that will happen as they both live a long way from me now due to work etc. and I certainly ain’t moving now.

YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp · 05/05/2022 08:57

My mother told me never to ask her for help with anything because I wouldn’t get it; she later had my sisters children very frequently, overnight and by day.
ok, that was her choice but that was followed by frequently moaning that she never saw them. I always had to drive to my parents, in 22 years living 6 miles away they came to our house three times (easy drive, both drivers), and only to our present house only if we fetched them.
For my DGCs I happily went over 100 miles by train to help out whenever I could, I loved doing it. It’s only ill health that’s curtailed it, but they’re older now so it’s easier for my DS and DDIL to arrange. Even so, I would do whatever I could if necessary.
There’s a very big difference if there are expectations that grandparents will commit to childcare regardless.

Apple42 · 05/05/2022 08:57

My in-laws look after my sil childrens 7 and 3 and it’s too much for them, they are in there early 70s now It’s only 1 day a week but 7.30 am am-6pm . Eldest one taken and picked up from school 5 miles away and entertaining younger one all day who no longer naps. Then in the holidays they have them both but two days a week. They are exhausted, mine own two 14 and 12 get a phone call in the holidays to come over to play . To Give the in-laws a much needed rest. Yes more kids in the house but all playing together so they say it feel like less work and more eyes on what younger ones are doing.

Hallibob · 05/05/2022 08:57

I made it clear I never expected help from my parents or in laws, but my parents insisted despite still working and had my DC 1 day a week when I went back to work, and offer to take him fairly often for full weekends now he is older.

My sister also changed her hours at work to have a regular day off without me asking her to and she had him a day a week as well. I look after my baby nephew on my day off so my SIL can work.

So we help each other out, and everyone still has time to themselves. It's lovely 😊

ancientgran · 05/05/2022 08:56

Just thinking about it after reading posts I realise I'm in a different position to lots of grandparents as I'm my DHs carer, have been for over 30 years, so going off travelling isn't really an option so that isn't a consideration for me.