Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents not wanting to do childcare...

485 replies

Chewchewaboogiw · 04/05/2022 23:32

Have been thinking about several people I know whose planned retirememt or part time work has been changed as they have been asked to do childcare for their dgc and now they are doing chikdcare say 3 days a week instead of their plan to travel. And not massively happy about it ( in one case another.baby due also)..I have seen a post response recently that said that they take dgc out but they are not there for childcare. If you dont do childcare for your dgc how did you say no?( I am not in that position at present but i can imagine it would be hard work ..) I would imagine / fear adult ds would be hurt if they were told no dont want to do chikdcare and cant imagine how it would be phrased in a positive way.. anyone said no and is it bu to say you dont want to ... or is it now expected. I know that all families.different, am just asking about families who are comfortable in saying no .

OP posts:
Latecomer131 · 05/05/2022 10:09

@WildCoasts I agree that in an ideal world people wouldn't need to bring it up before their DC had kids. However, if OP doesn't bring it up beforehand, there's a small risk that if she has to refuse once DGC arrive, then the request might be peppered with an implicit threat of not getting to see the DGC if she says no.

If OP makes it crystal clear before DGC are on the cards that she'd never do regular childcare, it could save her a lot of potential future awkwardness and falling out with her DC and/or their partners. Her DC and their partners are less likely to try and guilt trip her into regular childcare if she's already left no room for doubt that there's not a hope in hell of her spending her retirement in that way.

user1471538283 · 05/05/2022 10:07

My DM never looked after my DS once. My DF helped significantly (took him to kindergarten, had him if I had to work and my DS was poorly) but I never expected him to do it all. Even with my limited income then I paid for childcare.

I will help should I ever have grandchildren but I am not providing it week in and week out. Also I will probably be working until I am very old. I've been clear to my DS from the get go, I will babysit but not raise as I want the same relationship he had with his DGF.

throwa · 05/05/2022 10:06

My retired mum made it very clear that she was not going to take part in regular childcare - she'd seen her neighbours packing their bags and driving 2 hours away to stay for 3 nights to help out their 3x daughters, every single week. This went on for 10 years and they had had enough by the end of it! What she did say however was that she was very happy to have them for a week in school holidays, which we were very grateful for once they were in school and we were trying to juggle holiday cover between us. She is very engaged with them, we see each other once a month or so (we're 1.5 hours drive away) and they love spending time with her.

My MIL on the other hand isn't as interested nor as physically able (about 5 years older than my mum), so hasn't done any form of childcare for us at all.

Both of these approaches are fine by me - the grandchildren aren't their kids and they don't 'owe' us childcare in any form! But, this was all clear and agreed right at the start of when we had the first baby, they haven't said yes, and then changed their minds and said no etc, and we all fully understand everyone else's position on it.

But, we were also in the position where we could afford nursery and the bills when we had our children. If we had been in the position where one of us was only earning enough to cover the nursery fees, and it would have made a real financial difference for a grandparent to do the childcare, then I'm not sure what the response would have been.

Springsunshine1 · 05/05/2022 10:05

I’m coming at this from a totally different position. DM wanted to do childcare (paid as a childminder) and has found it very difficult to deal with the fact that this has now stopped. Pandemic was the first reason and then the second is that my youngest is 11 and we are now mostly WFH.
It has created a huge amount of anger and resentment from DM who feels ‘used’
Obviously I know this is unreasonable as she was paid but her hurt is still real and this has had a very negative impact on our relationship.

A friend with children only slightly younger DC is finding it impossible to back out of the arrangement she has with her parents. Luckily she is very well off so the money is of little consequence to her but it’s not ideal.

Grandparents childminding when it’s a favour and maybe not a permanent arrangement can work well but I think that a more permanent, paid, full time arrangement can be difficult to back out of.

Snowiscold · 05/05/2022 10:02

I suspect there will be an increasing number of people whose parents will have died or become seriously ill by the time they have children. I know lots of people who died in their 50s or very early 60s - from cancer, heart attacks, Alzheimer’s, strokes, brain aneurysms, accidents, even suicide. Others became seriously suddenly disabled - such as blindness. Many people my DC’s age have never ever known their grandparents because they died. Both DH and I won’t live long enough to see our own late teens/early 20s children have their own children.

noblegreenk · 05/05/2022 10:01

You just say no. I'd make it very clear before the event of being asked that it's not something you'd consider doing.
I think a lot of parents are very entitled when it comes to GPs being free childcare. I have a 3yo and have never expected her GPs to perform day to day childcare for us. As far as I'm concerned our child is not their responsibility. They did their parenting years ago when bringing up their own children. Looking after children is bloody hard work and not something I'd want to be doing at their age. I think it's fine for them to have GC on an ad hoc basis (e.g. overnight, for a weekend or in emergency situation) but for daily childcare it really isn't fair for it to be expected.

Soontobe60 · 05/05/2022 10:00

When my dd was pregnant with her first, I was still working full time, but planning to drop 1 day. As it turns out, I dropped 2 days and once she went back from Mat leave I looked after my dgc 1 day a week. I still do, now there’s 2, and dgc1 will start school in September. My dd knows that there may be times when I can’t do a day, we arrange it well in advance so she can make alternative arrangements.
it’s hard work physically, but I absolutely love it!

CounsellorTroi · 05/05/2022 09:57

WildCoasts · 05/05/2022 09:51

Have you asked her to take your DD for a few hours? In the nicest way, you do know her best after all, but parents aren't mind readers and might not know you could use that break.

That's a good example of a time I'd love to help out my child.

This, some people do like to be asked, rather than being expected to offer.

StopStartStop · 05/05/2022 09:55

You could make your expectations clear from the off...'When you're ready, I'd love to babysit occasionally. Apart from that, keep busy. Be on holiday, or involved in group activities you can't miss. Be unavailable, so that people can't form expectations of you.

I'm the other way - some people might think me a 'professional doormat'. But my greatest pleasure comes from supporting those people who matter to me. I'm not well enough to work and what I can do in the family is really appreciated. They support me, too.

Find your own path, OP. Don't let societal expectations trap you into - or deny you - extra responsibilities.

Courante · 05/05/2022 09:55

whatstheteamarie · 05/05/2022 08:42

I think where resentment is often found is where GPS either remove their offers of help or there's disparity amongst how much help they offer their different DC.

For example, my PIL took SIL DC to school, picked them up afterwards, cooked meals etc for them, despite my BIL being unemployed.

We both worked FT and got the occasional overnight childcare when we were stuck. We were very grateful for this, however when our couple of days help per year (at times of real need) was rejected, in favour of helping SIL, that's when the rot set in.

Also SIL was free to come and go as she pleased as GP had spent time with the DGC in the week, however my PIL expected to come on holidays and weekends away with us as they "wanted time with the GC".

We were seen as selfish for wanting a holiday as a nuclear family, but SIL was encouraged to go away with her DC as it gave my PIL a break.

If you want to offer help then do so and if you don't, then don't- it really shouldn't be expected of you. But please treat your DC (& DGC) equally or it can lead to a real fracturing of your relationship if you don't.

Very much agree with @whatstheteamarie .

There was a massive difference between what PIL (my parents were deceased by this point) offered to do and what they really wanted to do. They very much wanted to give the impression of hands on grandparents - I'm not even sure they could admit to themselves that they didn't really want to do it.

They offered and agreed to do things but when it came to it communicated that they didn't really want to do it by PA means: complaining to us about 'all the help' they gave to SIL with her DC and how they couldn't say no to it (SIL had a full-time nanny and they were never asked to regular childcare) but it was too much; being very difficult about arrangements; breaking/damaging things in our home what we honestly think was deliberately (this was MIL alone); lying to SIL about not being able to help her as they were helping us with our DC (SIL then rang our house at the alleged time to speak to MIL - and was surprised to hear me answering the phone) and so on...

The behaviour above (and other similar things not just above childcare) has very much damaged relationships and it is really sad looking back - no one has benefitted.

WildCoasts · 05/05/2022 09:51

naomi81 · 05/05/2022 09:48

@wildcoasts great example, I've been quite poorly recently and on antibiotics etc nothing contagious but could do with abit of a rest, our dog has been really poorly so OH has had to spend a lot of time at the vets etc this weekend. I know she has been on her own all bank holiday weekend, not working and maybe a few personal commitments. She hasn't even offered to have DD3 (who is in good health atm) for 2/3 hours to give me a break, she isn't interested!

Have you asked her to take your DD for a few hours? In the nicest way, you do know her best after all, but parents aren't mind readers and might not know you could use that break.

That's a good example of a time I'd love to help out my child.

naomi81 · 05/05/2022 09:48

@wildcoasts great example, I've been quite poorly recently and on antibiotics etc nothing contagious but could do with abit of a rest, our dog has been really poorly so OH has had to spend a lot of time at the vets etc this weekend. I know she has been on her own all bank holiday weekend, not working and maybe a few personal commitments. She hasn't even offered to have DD3 (who is in good health atm) for 2/3 hours to give me a break, she isn't interested!

elephantbreathing · 05/05/2022 09:44

I look after my GC for 2 days with an overnight stay. We have great fun and are close. Wouldn't have it any other way.
Totally understand people not wanting to do it but for me it's a joy and a privilege to be part of GC upbringing.

Bluevelvetsofa · 05/05/2022 09:43

I babysat quite frequently for mine and did some childcare too, but I was working full time, so couldn’t do care during the day. When I worked part time, I did some collecting from school and looking after until my DiL was home. They’re young adults now, so not needed.

I know of someone whose daughter expects childcare daily. She’s a single parent and works irregular hours, so there are often overnight stays.

WildCoasts · 05/05/2022 09:42

Brainwave89 · 05/05/2022 09:35

My parents had passed on by the time I had kids, and my in laws never looked after them at all (took them out twice in total). No big deal really, I never expected any childcare. I do come across mothers though who do. One mum in our group saying very clearly that if the DGPs were not willing to look after the DC for two days a week she would not be bringing them round at weekends. I think this line of thinking is sadly more common than we would like to think.

What an entitled woman.

WildCoasts · 05/05/2022 09:40

Latecomer131 · 05/05/2022 09:34

It helps if you live reasonably far away from your DC. My parents are a 1 hour and 45 min drive from me, so them offering regular childcare would never have been feasible.

However, even if they did live near me, I wouldn't dream of asking for a regular childcare arrangement of x days a week. I would just be hoping (but not expecting) that they would help us out with maybe a couple of child free evenings a month (but only if/when it didn't conflict with their own plans).

I think I agree with other PPs, who have said that you need to make it clear before grandchildren are on the cards that you won't be offering free regular childcare. I have seen quite a few entitled posts on MN from people who never discussed the issue with their own parents or in-laws before they had kids. They are then shocked to learn that their parents (or in-laws) don't want to sacrifice their hard-earned, relaxing retirement to become unpaid nannies for x days a week.

You don't want a situation where your children and their partners are mistakenly assuming that you will regularly do x days a week of unpaid childcare for them, when they are factoring in whether kids are feasible. Make it clear that it's never going to be an option. It's far less likely to cause offence if you do it before you actually have grandchildren.

While paying for full-time childcare is very expensive, I actually prefer this set up. I have seen from the dynamics with extended family, that when grandparents offer regular childcare, they tend to take over and get overly involved in parenting decisions. My DH has described regular grandparent childcare as a "Faustian bargain"!

I don't think there's any onus on the potential grandparents to address childcare ahead of time. It's on children thinking of having a child and wanting that care to ask if it's a possibility. If they are presumptuous about it and get a no, that's on them.

Aquamarine1029 · 05/05/2022 09:39

My children are adults, no children of their own yet, but they know already that I will not be providing regular childcare for when they work. I will love them, love to take them out on occasion, have them stay over on occasion, but I will not be a regular babysitter. I've done my job raising kids.

Brainwave89 · 05/05/2022 09:35

My parents had passed on by the time I had kids, and my in laws never looked after them at all (took them out twice in total). No big deal really, I never expected any childcare. I do come across mothers though who do. One mum in our group saying very clearly that if the DGPs were not willing to look after the DC for two days a week she would not be bringing them round at weekends. I think this line of thinking is sadly more common than we would like to think.

Latecomer131 · 05/05/2022 09:34

It helps if you live reasonably far away from your DC. My parents are a 1 hour and 45 min drive from me, so them offering regular childcare would never have been feasible.

However, even if they did live near me, I wouldn't dream of asking for a regular childcare arrangement of x days a week. I would just be hoping (but not expecting) that they would help us out with maybe a couple of child free evenings a month (but only if/when it didn't conflict with their own plans).

I think I agree with other PPs, who have said that you need to make it clear before grandchildren are on the cards that you won't be offering free regular childcare. I have seen quite a few entitled posts on MN from people who never discussed the issue with their own parents or in-laws before they had kids. They are then shocked to learn that their parents (or in-laws) don't want to sacrifice their hard-earned, relaxing retirement to become unpaid nannies for x days a week.

You don't want a situation where your children and their partners are mistakenly assuming that you will regularly do x days a week of unpaid childcare for them, when they are factoring in whether kids are feasible. Make it clear that it's never going to be an option. It's far less likely to cause offence if you do it before you actually have grandchildren.

While paying for full-time childcare is very expensive, I actually prefer this set up. I have seen from the dynamics with extended family, that when grandparents offer regular childcare, they tend to take over and get overly involved in parenting decisions. My DH has described regular grandparent childcare as a "Faustian bargain"!

Astrabees · 05/05/2022 09:34

Where I work it seems very common for grandparents to be involved in child care, though usually only one day a week. I think that works quite well as it seems to mean both sets of grandparents have the child for one day and then any other working days are covered by a nursery. I'm not a grandmother yet but I'd be happy to do one day.

naomi81 · 05/05/2022 09:31

@wildcoasts nah she's just no interested at the end if the day. Even if she didn't work she wouldn't be interested. She would make out to everyone else that she would be interested but ultimately not do anything.

PaperMonster · 05/05/2022 09:30

I never expected my parents to do any childcare. However, they were desperate to and offered! OH’s parents were already looking after other grandchildren and I think felt a bit put upon with them tbh. They did help with emergencies but my parents are more hands on.

WildCoasts · 05/05/2022 09:27

naomi81 · 05/05/2022 09:25

My mum has always told me she will never do child care from an early age, and she would just say no if I ever asked her. Even if my child was sick she just doesn't want to know. I do find it abit sad but it's her choice at the end if the day, surprisingly we are not close.

Is she worried a sick grandchild might make her sick? You don't always get over things as easily when older and, if she works or has other commitments, it would interfere with that.

naomi81 · 05/05/2022 09:25

My mum has always told me she will never do child care from an early age, and she would just say no if I ever asked her. Even if my child was sick she just doesn't want to know. I do find it abit sad but it's her choice at the end if the day, surprisingly we are not close.

Luckywithchildcare · 05/05/2022 09:25

I’m fortunate, both my PIL and my mum actively wanted to do childcare so it’s been more of a balancing act to make things fair. But I have regular conversations about whether it is too much and let them know I am very willing to make other arrangements if they can’t manage. On the other hand, I’ve always known my dad and stepmother have no interest in doing it, despite my dad offering in a fit of new grandparent enthusiasm. I’m sure they would in an emergency, but it wouldn’t fit with their lifestyle and interests, so I knew, and am perfectly content that, it wasn’t an offer on the table.